| Literature DB >> 34531202 |
Vanessa Place1, Benjamin Nabb2, Ester Gubi2, Karima Assel2,3, Johan Åhlén2, Ana Hagström2, Sofie Bäärnhielm3, Christina Dalman2, Anna-Clara Hollander2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To develop conceptual understanding of perceived barriers to seeking care for migrant children and young people (aged 0-25 years) with mental health problems and/or neurodevelopmental differences in high-income countries.Entities:
Keywords: child & adolescent psychiatry; public health; qualitative research
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34531202 PMCID: PMC8449985 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-045923
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 3.006
Figure 1A conceptual framework of patient-centred access to healthcare. Adapted from Levesque et al.15
Figure 2Determining how studies are related to one another using mind-mapping: a worked example.
Figure 3Study selection. HIC, high-income country.
Quality criteria and results
| Question | Yes | No | Unclear |
| Is this study qualitative research? | 28 | 0 | 2 |
| Are the research questions clearly stated? | 24 | 6 | 0 |
| Is the qualitative approach clearly justified? | 20 | 7 | 3 |
| Is the approach appropriate for the research question? | 28 | 0 | 2 |
| Is the study context clearly described? | 27 | 2 | 1 |
| Is the role of the researcher clearly described? | 13 | 15 | 2 |
| Is the sampling method clearly described? | 27 | 1 | 2 |
| Is the sampling strategy appropriate for the research question? | 29 | 0 | 1 |
| Is the method of data collection clearly described? | 28 | 1 | 1 |
| Is the data collection method appropriate to the research question? | 26 | 1 | 3 |
| Is the method of analysis clearly described? | 25 | 4 | 1 |
| Is the analysis appropriate for the research question? | 27 | 2 | 1 |
| Are the claims made supported by sufficient evidence? | 27 | 1 | 2 |
Adapted version of the CASP quality assessment tool, taken from Atkins et al.54
CASP, Critical Appraisal Skills Programme.
Characteristics of included studies
| Study | Country | Type (no and gender) participants | Participant background (no) | Data collection method; dates | Method of analysis | Study focus |
| Arora and Algios | USA | Adolescents aged 14–20 years (33, 14 male and 19 female) | First-generation and second-generation Asian-American | FGD; dates not reported | Grounded theory approach | To obtain information on Asian-American immigrant youth’s perceptions of SBMH services and recommendations to address the mental health needs of this group |
| Bradby | Scotland, UK | Parents (35, 5 male and 30 female), service users aged 6–14 years (7, 3 male and 4 female) and/or their parents (8, 2 male and 6 female), healthcare professionals (7, gender not stated), and carers (8, 1 male and 7 female) of children aged 5–13 years who had not been referred to CAMHS despite having suitable problems | South Asia | FGD and semistructured interviews; September 2003–March 2005 | Thematic analysis | To explore attitudes to and experiences of CAMHS among families of South Asian origin who were underrepresented as service-users |
| Guzder | Canada | Parents (20, gender not stated) of children aged 7–12 years who attended a psychiatric day hospital for significant behaviour impairment | Immigrant (10) and native-born Canadian (10) | In-depth, semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Grounded theory approach | To identify similarities and differences in perceptions of mental health problems and help seeking experiences between native-born and immigrant parents |
| Islam | Canada | Youth aged 15–23 years (10, 2 male and 8 female) | First- and second-generation South Asian | In-depth, semistructured interviews; March–July 2015 | Thematic analysis | To understand the mental health challenges and service access barriers experienced by South Asian youth populations |
| Posselt | Australia | Youth aged 12–25 years (15, 6 male and 9 female) and service providers (15, gender not stated): social workers, psychologists, and mental health nurses/nurse practitioners | Refugee youth from Afghan (9), African (4) and Bhutanese backgrounds (2); service providers background not stated | Semistructured interviews; 2013–2014 | Thematic analysis | To determine the barriers and facilitators to effective, culturally responsive service provision for young people of refugee background with comorbid mental health and AOD problems |
| de Anstiss and Ziaian | Australia | Adolescents aged 13–17 years (85, 44 male and 41 female) | Refugee (various backgrounds) | FGD; dates not reported | Thematic analysis | To fill gaps in knowledge of rates and patterns of service utilisation across service sectors, use of informal supports, and actual and perceived barriers to mental health services among refugee adolescents |
| Gonçalves and Moleiro | Portugal | Adolescents aged 12–17 (16, 11 male and 5 female), mothers (6), teachers and health professionals (17, 5 male and 12 female) | First-generation and second-generation immigrant adolescents and first-generation immigrant mothers (various backgrounds), teachers and health professionals background not stated | FGD; dates not reported | Content analysis | To shed light on the family-school-primary care triangle and the access to mental healthcare for migrant and ethnic minority families |
| Colucci | Australia | Service providers (115, 30 male and 85 female) from agencies that support refugee youth: mental health services, community support organisations, health services, schools, the state government health department, and a refugee resettlement agency | Not stated | FGD and semistructured interviews; April 2010–November 2011 | Thematic analysis | To explore the perspectives of experienced service providers on barriers and facilitators to engaging refugee-background young people with mental health services |
| Wang | USA | Adolescents (55, 10 male and 45 female) aged 11–19 years | First-generation and second-generation Latinx- (25) and Asian-American (27), and biracial (Asian and Latinx, n=3) | Semistructured interviews; 2014–2015 academic year | Descriptive thematic analysis | To explore Asian– and Latinx–American adolescents’ perceptions of seeking help for mental health concerns at middle or high schools |
| Forrest-Bank | USA | Service providers (14, 2 male and 12 female) from organisations serving refugee youth: community non-profit organisations, public schools, healthcare agencies, local government, an advocacy group, and a church. | Caucasian (12), not stated (2) | Semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Inductive thematic analysis | To gain the perspectives of service providers about the strengths and barriers to mental health services addressing the needs of resettled refugee youth |
| Flink | The Netherlands | Mothers (41) of daughters aged 10–20 years | First-generation Moroccan (13) and Turkish (17), and Dutch (11) | FGD; dates not reported | Content analysis | To examine how mothers with different ethnic backgrounds perceive the issue of help-seeking for internalising problems experienced by adolescent girls |
| Ellis | USA | Adolescents aged 11–20 years (30, 10 male and 20 female) | First-generation Somali or Somali-Bantu | FGD and in-depth interviews; January 2004–June 2006 | Thematic analysis | To examine the utility of the Gateway Provider Model in understanding service utilisation and pathways to help for Somali refugee adolescents |
| McCann | Australia | Youth aged 16–25 years (28, 18 male and 10 female), parents and community leaders (41, 24 male and 17 female) | Sub-Saharan African youth, first-generation sub-Saharan African parents, and community leaders | FGD and semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Inductive thematic analysis | To explore the stigma experience with mental illness and/or substance misuse among sub-Saharan African immigrants, and to examine the implications of this for help seeking for young people and parents from these communities |
| Valibhoy | Australia | Youth aged 18–25 years who had received services from a mental health professional in Australia (16, 7 male and 9 female) | Refugee (various backgrounds) | In-depth interviews; March 2012–January 2013 | Thematic analysis | To document the perspectives of youth from refugee backgrounds on their experience of accessing mental health services |
| McCann | Australia | Youth aged 16–25 years (28, 18 male and 10 female), parents and community leaders (41, 24 male and 17 female) | Sub-Saharan African youth, first-generation sub-Saharan African parents, and community leaders | FGD and semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Inductive thematic analysis | To identify the help-seeking barriers and facilitators for anxiety, depression and alcohol and drug use problems in young people from recently established sub-Saharan African migrant communities |
| Gerdes | USA | Parents (73, 25 male and 46 female, 2 not stated) of children aged 5–12 years | Latino | Problem recognition questionnaire for ADHD; dates not reported | Grounded theory | To better understand the help seeking process that occurs within Latino families when a child is exhibiting behaviours consistent with ADHD |
| Chapman and Stein | USA | Parents (16, 1 male and 15 female) of newly immigrated youth aged 12–18 years | First-generation Latino | Semistructured interviews; August 2004–March 2006 | Narrative analysis | To examine parental perceptions of mental health and to determine patterns of help seeking and service use |
| Kang-Yi | USA | Church leaders (9, 7 male and 2 female) and early childcare workers (4, 1 male and 3 female) | First-generation Korean-American | Semistructured interviews; September 2013–August 2014 | Grounded theory approach | To understand Korean immigrant families’ and professionals’ beliefs and attitudes towards autism and other developmental disorders |
| Shor | Israel and Russia | Parents in Israel (100, 21 male and 79 female) and Russia (100, 24 male and 76 female) of children under 18 years of age | Jewish immigrant parents from the Former Soviet Union (living in Israel) and Jewish parents living in Russia | Interviews; dates not reported | Content analysis | To differentiate between culturally based help-seeking patterns of immigrant parents and those resulting from their new social context |
| AlAzzam and Daack-Hirsch | USA | Mothers (16) of children aged 5–12 years | First-generation Arab Muslim | Semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Content analysis | To elicit Arab immigrant Muslim mothers’ perceptions of and responses to behavioural problems in children (especially those associated with ADHD) |
| Wang | USA | Parents (19, 2 male and 17 female) of children aged 12–18 years | First-generation Asian | In-depth, semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Thematic analysis | To investigate Asian immigrant parents’ perception of barriers for seeking SBMHS for their adolescents |
| Ling | USA | Service providers (16, 4 male and 12 female) who work with Asian-American youth: counsellors, social workers, psychologists, organisation leaders and programme coordinators, and an educator. | White (3), Korean (4) and Chinese (9) ethnicity | In-depth, semistructured interviews; March–June 2012 | Consensual Qualitative Research method | To explore the perceived mental health needs of urban Asian-American adolescents and barriers to meeting their needs from the perspective of social service providers |
| Messent and Murrel | UK | Parents (7, 3 male and 4 female) who were attending or had attended CAMHS with their children, and social workers (4, 2 male and 2 female) | Bangladesh | Group meetings with semistructured interview guide; dates not reported | None | To examine the accessibility of a child and adolescent mental health service to ethnic minority populations |
| Iqbal Kaur | Canada | Parents (4, 1 male and 3 female) of children aged 9–20 years, young adults aged 19–22 years (4, 1 male and 3 female), therapists and medical professionals (2 female), and a community leader (1 male) | First-generation Punjabi Sikh parents, second-generation Punjabi Sikh young adults, South-Asian mental health and medical professionals, and a Punjabi Sikh community leader | Semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Content analysis | To describe the beliefs held by first-generation Canadian Punjabi Sikh parents about adolescent suicide and suicide-related behaviours |
| Choummanivong | New Zealand | Adolescents aged 13–18 years (53, 25 male and 28 female) and mental health service providers (20, 4 male and 16 female): psychologists, social workers, general practitioners, and school guidance counsellors | Refugee adolescents and health service providers from various backgrounds | FGD and semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Thematic analysis | To provide more information about stressors impacting on refugee youth, their coping strategies, and their experience of mental health services in New Zealand |
| Nguyen | USA | Mothers (4) of children aged 3–12 years who had or were currently using mental health services | First-generation Vietnamese American | Semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Content analysis (consistent with the multiple case study design) | To describe how Vietnamese American families that have used mental health services perceive and incorporate children’s mental health into their lives |
| Jacobs | USA | Mental health and human service providers who had experience working with Somali youth (8, 1 male and 7 female) | Somali (5) and Caucasian (3) | Semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Content analysis | To explore how human service personnel view the barriers to services faced by Somali youth and how those barriers can be overcome |
| Zuckerman | USA | Parents (30, 7 male and 23 female) of typically developing children aged 2–10 years | First-generation and second-generation Latino | FGD and semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Thematic analysis | To assess the understanding and conceptualisation of ASD in the Latino community in order to understand potential community barriers to early diagnosis |
| Araujo | USA | Caregivers (13, 1 male and 12 female) of children aged 7–10 years with ADHD symptoms that were receiving the Collaborative Life Skills programme in school | Latino | Semistructured interviews; dates not reported | Thematic analysis | To explore emotional, social, and cultural experiences of Latino youth with ADHD symptoms and their families |
| Smith | USA | Community members that provide services within communities with elevated rates of at-risk Latinx youth (11, 2 male and 1 female) | USA (9), Mexico (1) and Germany (1) | Qualitative interviews; December 2014–March 2016 | Grounded theory | To explore stressors and barriers to care in the Latinx youth community through a community-based participatory research framework |
Note that the language used to describe participants was taken directly from included studies.
ADHD, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder; AOD, alcohol and other drugs; ASD, autism spectrum disorders; CAMHS, Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services; FGD, focus group discussions; SBMHS, school-based mental health services.
Third-order constructs, in the form of themes, incorporated into a conceptual framework of patient-centred access to healthcare
| Determinants | Dimensions | Third-order constructs |
| Supply: dimensions of accessibility | Approachability | |
| Acceptability | Privacy and confidentiality concerns | |
| Fear and mistrust of services | ||
| Negative perceptions and prior experiences of services | ||
| Availability and accommodation | Logistical and structural barriers | |
| Lack of information on mental health | ||
| Affordability | Associated costs deter help-seeking | |
| Appropriateness | Lack of information and services in other languages | |
| Service providers lack cultural responsiveness | ||
| Demand: dimensions of ability | Ability to perceive a need for care | Alternative explanatory models |
| Ability to seek | Stigma | |
| Preference for self-support | ||
| Cultural values deter help-seeking | ||
| Ability to reach | Immigration and legal status | |
| Limited knowledge of services | ||
| Lack of familial support | ||
| Ability to pay | ||
| Ability to engage | Language and communication barriers |
Adapted from Levesque et al.15
Figure 4A conceptual framework of patient-centred access to mental healthcare for migrant children and young people. Adapted from Levesque et al.15