John A Aitken1, Elisa M Torres1, Seth A Kaplan1, Deborah DiazGranados2, Lillian Su3, Sarah Henrickson Parker4. 1. Psychology Department, George Mason University, Fairfax, Virginia, USA. 2. School of Medicine and Evaluation and Team Science at the Wright Center for Clinical and Translational Research, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA, USA. 3. Division of Critical Care Medicine, Children's National Health System, Washington, District of Columbia, USA. 4. Human Factors Research, Virginia Tech Carilion School of Medicine and Research Institute, Roanoke, Virginia, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Simulation-based training (SBT) is often evaluated based on the transfer of specific knowledge and skills. In contrast, the degree to which reflective practice is inculcated by SBT is rarely considered. Because reflection is a pillar of adult learning theories, we sought to examine the degree to which participation in SBT was associated with increased reflective practice. METHOD: Eighty one healthcare professionals completed a survey which included the number of SBTs they participated in during the past two years, content- and administrative-related features of those SBTs, and a key aspect of reflective practice (i.e., self-appraisal). RESULTS: The number of SBTs healthcare professionals participated in during the past two years was positively associated with reflective self-appraisal. This relationship was not moderated by the inclusion of reflection components in SBTs nor by the voluntary/mandatory nature of participation in SBTs. Furthermore, the facilitator was ranked as the most important feature of the overall learning experience in SBTs. Also, no significant differences were found between the number of technical skills-based and non-technical skills-based SBTs. CONCLUSION: These findings demonstrate the importance (of evaluating) SBTs for facilitating reflective learning mindsets that healthcare practitioners can apply beyond the specific skills trained by SBTs.
BACKGROUND: Simulation-based training (SBT) is often evaluated based on the transfer of specific knowledge and skills. In contrast, the degree to which reflective practice is inculcated by SBT is rarely considered. Because reflection is a pillar of adult learning theories, we sought to examine the degree to which participation in SBT was associated with increased reflective practice. METHOD: Eighty one healthcare professionals completed a survey which included the number of SBTs they participated in during the past two years, content- and administrative-related features of those SBTs, and a key aspect of reflective practice (i.e., self-appraisal). RESULTS: The number of SBTs healthcare professionals participated in during the past two years was positively associated with reflective self-appraisal. This relationship was not moderated by the inclusion of reflection components in SBTs nor by the voluntary/mandatory nature of participation in SBTs. Furthermore, the facilitator was ranked as the most important feature of the overall learning experience in SBTs. Also, no significant differences were found between the number of technical skills-based and non-technical skills-based SBTs. CONCLUSION: These findings demonstrate the importance (of evaluating) SBTs for facilitating reflective learning mindsets that healthcare practitioners can apply beyond the specific skills trained by SBTs.
Entities:
Keywords:
Reflection; reflective practice; simulation-based training
Authors: David A Cook; Stanley J Hamstra; Ryan Brydges; Benjamin Zendejas; Jason H Szostek; Amy T Wang; Patricia J Erwin; Rose Hatala Journal: Med Teach Date: 2012-09-03 Impact factor: 3.650