| Literature DB >> 34472659 |
Jatinder Singh1,2,3, Evamaria Lanzarini4, Nardo Nardocci5, Paramala Santosh1,2,3.
Abstract
AIM: This systematic review identified and thematically appraised clinical evidence of movement disorders in patients with Rett syndrome (RTT).Entities:
Keywords: Rett syndrome; dystonia; movement disorders; mutations; stereotypies
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34472659 PMCID: PMC9298304 DOI: 10.1111/pcn.13299
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Psychiatry Clin Neurosci ISSN: 1323-1316 Impact factor: 12.145
Summarized information from the eligible studies
| Source | Demographics | Clinical characteristics | Assessment methods | Relevant movement impairment evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
Females with RTT (1074) from the RTT Natural History Study Patients with classical RTT comprised the largest group ( |
All study participants had a confirmed clinical diagnosis and/or mutation in Of the 1074 patients with RTT, 922 had classical RTT, 75 had atypical severe RTT, and 77 had atypical mild RTT Patients with classical RTT were followed for an average of 4.22 years | Standardized assessments (CSS and MBA) at baseline and analyses of longitudinal data |
Hand stereotypies were reported in all (100%) patients with classical RTT, in 97.3% with atypical severe RTT, and in 96.1% with atypical mild RTT Hand mouthing and clapping/tapping was more commonly reported than hand wringing/washing Clinical severity was found to be worse with decreased hand function, and while hand use lowered over time, the frequency of hand stereotypies was noted to remain unchanged, i.e. remained unchanged and was elevated In the majority of patients, regression appeared before hand stereotypies but one‐third appeared with early onset Increases in bradykinesia and hypertonia were suggested to play a role in hand functioning |
|
| Females (≥14 years) were split into three age groups (14–20 years, 21–29 years, and >29 years) |
Questionnaire sent to members of the Italian Association for RTT The Kerr score was used to evaluate disease severity | Questionnaire study |
Stereotypies (hand) were present in nearly all patients (98%), while only 20% could independently walk Nearly all (96%) patients had musculoskeletal problems, with scoliosis (83%) being the most frequent followed by spasticity (51%) and joint deformities (36%). Joint deformities also appeared to become worse over time In terms of movement problems, the study findings indicated that stereotypies and hand functioning remained stable over time. Musculoskeletal problems worsened and continued into adulthood In the sample, older patients with some specific mutations (R294X and R133C) and C‐terminal deletions were clinically less severe |
|
| Cohort ( | Patients were categorized according to genotype | Video data |
The findings showed that nearly all patients had hand stereotypies (94.4%) Among the 15 categories evaluated, midline wringing was noted in 60% of cases In patients younger than 8 years, clapping and mouthing was more frequent, while in patients older than 19 years, wringing was more common In the 15 categories explored, the study indicated that there was no obvious relationship between hand stereotypies and genotype |
|
| Fifty‐one patients ranging from 2 years 5 months to 54 years of age |
Patients who were included were Classification was also based on mutation type (truncating [ | Rigidity was assessed using the RTT rigidity distribution score |
The study showed that rigidity was observed in 84.3% of patients (43 of 51). The onset was rapid, appearing at 3 years and tended to increase with age The topography began with ankle, legs, arms neck, and face No statistically significant difference in rigidity score was seen between those with truncating and missense mutations Patients who could walk had lower rigidity scores when compared with those who were less able to walk The authors suggested that Parkinsonian‐like rigidity is common in RTT |
|
| Fourteen females with RTT aged (±SD) 9.2 ± 5.4 years |
Each participant had a confirmed diagnosis according to Neul All patients were ambulatory | Videotape observations during overground and treadmill walking |
Freezing of gait appeared to be the most frequently occurring behavior and was deemed to be an important characteristic of walking in patients with RTT Video together with overground and treadmill observation can be useful to assess ataxic gait in patients with RTT who are ambulatory Stereotypic behaviors were not observed in patients during freezing of gait and could suggest independent neural mechanisms This information can be useful for clinicians to assess the individual's gait regression over time and can provide further understanding of gross motor dysfunction in these patients |
|
|
Study participants ( Average age was 6 years 4 months |
All study participants met the diagnostic criteria for RTT Assessments were done before administration of active agent or placebo | Clinical assessment and video recording |
The study indicated that hand stereotypies in patients with RTT are heterogenous and more robust objective measures are needed such as actigraphy It was also suggested that machine learning could also be able to classify movement patterns regarding abnormal movements in RTT |
|
| Ten individuals aged between 5 and 32 years (median: 12.5 years) | Of the 10 patients, nine had classical RTT and one had atypical RTT | Questionnaire assessment and video observational data from parents, teachers, and carers |
Self‐injury occurred in six of the patients (five with classical and one with atypical) Environment was considered to be important in modifying the behavior of patients with RTT, especially for self‐injury but not for hand stereotypies |
|
| Study of five female patients with RTT (mean age: 17.8 years [range: 4 to 47 years]) | All patients had a clinical diagnosis of classical RTT according to Neul | Behavioral observations using video |
The study indicated that there were no observed differences in stereotyped hand behaviors during the high and low stress conditions for any of the patients More negative signs were seen during high stress conditions as indicated by differences in the domains of face, vocalize, and tremble |
|
| Case study of five patients with RTT ranging from 3 to 9 years of age | Five females with RTT and unilateral repetitive hand movements were noted from a sample of 64 patients with 24‐h video‐EEG recordings | Video‐EEG recording |
This study identified a unique set of unilateral hand movements that was associated with centrotemporal spikes on EEG This behavior was not thought to be epileptic but rather the EEG spikes were caused by either somatosensory or motor potentials most likely originating from the somatosensory, motor cortex, or subcortical areas of the brain in patients with RTT |
|
| The study included 20 patients with RTT (mean age: 60 months [range: 36 to 96 months]) and 20 individuals with ASD (mean age: 68 months [range: 33 to 98 months]) |
Patients met the RTT diagnostic criteria Patients with ASD had a preschool diagnosis based on | Video observations |
Behavioral hand stereotypies could be distinguished between children with RTT when compared with those with ASD In RTT, the hand stereotypies were said to be complex and localized to the body midline and involved mouthing. In comparison, in children with ASD, the hand stereotypies were said to be simple and intermittent and usually included objects It was suggested that there could be abnormal basal ganglia circuitry involvement together with impaired thalamic motor input |
|
|
Patients with RTT ( Median age of group I ( |
Patients were diagnosed according to clinical criteria (Hagberg Patients had either the classical (58.6%) or variant form (41.4%) Of the 59 patients with a molecular diagnosis (group I), 26 had missense mutations and 33 had truncating mutations |
Video analysis and observation by a pediatric neurologist Blood samples for genomic DNA extraction X‐chromosome inactivation assays |
Ataxia, number of stereotypies per patient, rigidity, and ataxic gait were statistically significant in group I when compared with group II. Dystonia was more frequent for patients in group II but was not significant ( In patients with a confirmed molecular diagnosis (group I), rigidity and dystonia were more common in those with truncating mutations. There was, however, no obvious difference in the number of stereotypies in patients with either missense or truncating mutations Perinatal data showed that patients in group I presented with a higher frequency of abnormal delivery (28.8%) when compared with group 2 (21.4%). Moreover, there was a higher frequency of abnormal delivery in patients with truncating (33.3%) compared with those with missense (23.1%) mutations. Neither of these findings reached statistical significance The authors suggest that organic features of impaired movement disorders are driven by changes in brainstem and cerebellar structures that could explain the differences in the phenotypic picture |
|
|
Cross‐sectional study comprising 144 females with RTT from the ARSD Mean age: 14 years 10 months (range: 2–31 years 10 months) |
All patients had a clinical diagnosis of RTT Of the 144 females, 110 were found to have an | Video observations and parent‐reported data together with modified Kerr scores, WeeFIM, ambulation status, and number of hand stereotypies |
It was indicated that patients with the p.R168X mutation in comparison to those with p.R133C or p.R294X mutations had the worst hand function Patients older than 19 years had worse hand function than those younger than 8 years When controlling for age and mutation, there was a significant association between mobility and hand function Positive environmental reinforcement could play a role in managing hand stereotypies |
|
| Ten females with RTT aged between 5 and 26 years | All patients had a diagnosis of RTT and analyses of their | Assessment scales and video recording of the overselectivity test |
Females tended to learn more quickly when their stereotypies were contained compared with those whose stereotypies were not contained Stereotypies can be reduced when sensory stimulation is present |
|
| Study cohort consisted of 12 patients with RTT with a mean age of 18.6 years (range: 14–31 years) | The cohort was selected from 30 patients 14 years and older and | Parental interviews, video observations, and review of clinical information |
In the 12 patients, the mean onset age of stereotypies was 19.4 months and were maintained during disease progression across the lifespan In nine of 12 patients, hand functioning was lost a few months after onset of stereotypies Hand stereotypies did not occur during sleep but were constant during the daytime All patients presented with motor stereotypies ranging from mouthing (six of 12 patients), pill rolling and twisting of two or three fingers (six of 12), bruxism (six of 12) and orofacial movements (five of 12), leg involvement (two of 12) and whole‐body stereotypy (one of 12), and tremor and myoclonus (four of 12). The myoclonus was not of epileptiform origin It was suggested that reduction of the caudate heads of thalami and presynaptic abnormalities in the nigrostriatal pathway could account for the movement abnormalities seen in patients with RTT |
|
|
Eighty‐eight patients met the revised diagnostic criteria, and, of these, 60 had an Median age of 60 patients: 7.0 years (range: 5.0–13.5) |
The cohort only included patients with The type of mutation and its location was recorded Patients with RTT included those with the classical form (60.7%) and variant (39.3%) | Assessment scales, video observations, and genotyping |
Stereotypies were noted in 95% of patients and the most common was bruxism (found in 80% of patients). Dystonia was present in 63.3% of patients, and scoliosis likely caused by truncal dystonia was noted in 71.7% of all cases. Bruxism was frequent during awake periods and did not occur at night When looking at dystonia, the study showed that focal dystonia was more common in patients with missense mutations ( Tremor was observed in 48.3% of all cases and were noted to be predominantly kinetic in patients with missense mutations and postural in patients with truncating mutations The study showed that movement disorders in RTT are associated with the severity and advancement of the disease. Patients with truncating mutations were shown to have a higher rate of dystonia and rigid‐akinetic syndrome It was stated that stereotypies decrease with age and become less complex and slower |
|
| Data were analyzed from 99 females with a median age of 14.1 years (range: 1.5–27.9 years) | Of the 96 individuals who had a genetic test, a confirmed | Video observations alongside parent‐reported checklist |
The study showed that mobility of patients decreased with age and motor scores were worse in those patients having had surgery for scoliosis Patients with the genotypes R133C, p.R294X, p.R306C, or C‐terminal deletion were said to have better mobility and complex motor skills ≥13 years and better complex motor skills <13 years of age. The development of motor skills was not impacted by behavioral hand stereotypies It was suggested that overall, motor skills—especially complex ones—were determined by the mutational profile of the patient The study also highlighted the problems associated with dyspraxia, indicating that dyspraxia is hindered by poor muscle tone and becomes more prominent when complex tasks such as transitions are performed |
|
|
Data were collected from 83 patients with RTT, of which 53 were Mean age of 83 patients: 10.0 years (range: 1 to 31 years) | Among the cases, 60.2% had classical RTT and 39.8% had variant RTT | Video observation in |
Both groups had hand stereotypies that manifested at a mean age of 22.3 months for group 1 and 25.4 months for group 2. Midline hand wringing and washing‐like movements was the most common hand movement The second most common stereotypy with hand movements was bruxism The stereotypies of hair pulling, bruxism, and cervical retropulsion was more common in group 1 (mutation positive) It was also indicated that mutation‐positive patients had more varied stereotypies and these tended to reduce after 10 years of age |
|
| Video analysis of 22 cases |
All 22 cases had classical RTT Twelve cases were mutation positive | Motor and behavior milestones using video observations during first 6 months |
All cases presented with abnormal movements (100%) followed by tongue protrusion (62%), postural stiffness (58%), and tremor (28%) Other stereotypies included hand stereotypies (42%) and stereotyped body movements (15%) The authors suggested brainstem dysfunction during neurodevelopment |
|
| Eight patients with RTT aged between 13 and 17 years | All study participants had a clinically confirmed diagnosis of classical RTT | Video observations of stereotypic hand movements |
Stereotypic hand movements were found to occur in the majority of individuals The study showed that environmental modifications had limited impact on the behaviors of hand stereotypies |
|
| Nine females with RTT aged between 3 and 15 years |
All patients were in the postregression phase and without speech All patients could walk, albeit with impediments None of the patients were taking AEDs | Video observations was used to define the stereotypies |
The findings from the study indicated that eye movements can influence the onset of stereotypic characteristics in patients with RTT and provide further understanding into the disease post‐regression |
|
| Thirty‐two patients aged between 30 months and 28 years |
Forty‐one patients were seen and data were available for 32 patients Patients also met the diagnostic criteria for RTT | Video observations and MBA |
The most frequent motor abnormalities noted in this cohort were stereotypies and gait abnormalities Bruxism, abnormal eye movements, and dystonia were also observed Drooling was also common (seen in 75% of patients) Young patients were noted to have more hyperkinetic movements than older patients |
|
| Study information was obtained from 216 patients with RTT (age range: 3 to 53 years) | A questionnaire was sent to 1016 special needs education schools and 204 facilities in Japan | The questionnaire comprised 17 headings to assess hand stereotypies and purposeful hand behaviors |
The questionnaire study showed that emotions such as displeasure (63.8%) or pleasure (48.5%) were the main factors that led to increased stereotypical hand movements Factors that decreased stereotypies were somnolence (43.5%), pleasure (30%), concentration (29.4%), and food (24.1%) It was suggested that factors that reduce behavioral stereotypies could be useful to reduce the incidence of secondary disabilities such as skin issues and joint contractures |
|
|
A total of 58 patients (55 females and three males) were used for analyses Typical individuals with RTT ( |
Cross‐sectional study Patients were diagnosed by two neurologists based on diagnostic criteria and genetic information | Questionnaire evaluation |
Of the abnormal movements, stereotypies were present in all cases—both typical and atypical (100%)—as was tremor (69%), dystonia (63.8%) agitation (62.1%), and self‐injuries (37.9%) Of the stereotypies in the 58 cases, bruxism was the most common (63.8%), followed by shifting weight from one leg to the other (63.8%), while wringing was the most common (58.6%) hand stereotypy Scoliosis caused by truncal dystonia occurred in 72.4% of cases and increased with age There were differences in the typical and atypical RTT groups. In typical RTT, shifting weight from one leg to the other (58.1%), hand wringing (58.1%), and bruxism (53.5%) were the most common stereotypies. In atypical RTT, the most common stereotypies were bruxism (93.3%), lip protrusion (93.3%), and shifting weight from one leg to the other (80%) It was suggested that basal ganglia together with cortico‐basal ganglia‐thalamo‐cortical loop involvement may play a role in the evolution of abnormal movements in patients with RTT |
|
|
The study comprised 909 cases (InterRett Mean age: 28.6 years (range: 14.1–44.0 years) |
Cases were obtained from InterRett and the ARSD All cases either had an | Clinical information based on questionnaire data |
Stereotypies were found in the majority (95.1%) of cases at a mean age of 27.4 months There was also an earlier diagnosis in those patients who developed stereotypies when compared with those who did not Those patients with the p.R255X and p.R168X mutations were diagnosed at a younger age (43.7 and 43.5 months, respectively) |
|
|
The study consisted of 91 females with RTT Mean age: 20.5 years (range: 4 to 47 years) |
Study participants were recruited from the British Isles Rett Syndrome Survey Of the 91 females, 69 were diagnosed as having classical RTT, 19 with atypical RTT, and 3 with another | Questionnaire packs (GDQ, health questionnaire NCCPC‐R, severity scores, VABS) |
The study showed that patients with truncating mutations or large deletions had greater severity Patients diagnosed with classical RTT had a higher degree of health‐related problems when compared with those with atypical RTT Stereotypies were reported in 90 of 91 (98.9%) cases and bruxism in 57.1% Frequent comorbidities in the 91 cases were epilepsy, weight, gastrointestinal, and bowel issues |
|
| Case study of two girls (12 and 17 years of age) with RTT | Patients had a diagnosis at 24 and 18 months of age | Microswitch‐based method using touch and optic sensors |
The study showed that a microswitch‐based program could assist in managing adaptive behaviors in these individuals Improving environmental stimulation can be a positive way to manage self‐stimulation such as stereotypic behaviors, and it was suggested that this could also lower caregiver burden There was a positive impact on participants’ mood during the intervention phase; however, environmental stimuli need to be adapted accordingly to avoid sensory overload |
|
| Twenty‐three patients aged between 2 and 21 years | Confirmation of RTT in the 23 individuals was based on diagnostic criteria | Retrospective chart review of clinical data |
In this retrospective chart review, there was no association between age of onset and severity of motor impairment All patients were noted to have been hypotonic during the first year postbirth Ataxia was noted in 73% of cases and 47% were ambulatory |
|
| The study cohort comprised 87 females with RTT with an age range from 2 years 1 month to 44 years 10 months | Of the 87 patients, 76 met the criteria for classical RTT and 11 met the criteria for variant or atypical RTT |
Assessment schedule to assess oromotor function, feeding issues, growth, and breathing Clinical assessments were also based on patients’ needs and related questions the parents and caregivers had answered |
The findings showed that there is poor growth, together with joint problems and scoliosis, that persists into adulthood Hypotonia was present in about half of the children older than 5 years but diminished after hypertonia and rigidity became established Hand stereotypies were described in 79 to 84 patients. Mouthing (45.1%) was the most common and plucking movements the least common (14.6%). Different ranges of hand use were seen among all ages In this series of patients, there was minimal change in mobility across the lifespan, and it was noted that half of the adults were mobile |
|
|
Seventeen females with RTT aged 15.30 ± 8.1 years Twenty‐six healthy controls (age‐ and sex‐matched) 16.21 ± 7.9 years |
All patients with RTT had confirmed Because of poor imaging quality, one patient with RTT and two healthy controls were excluded from the analyses |
Susceptibility‐weighted imaging methods RTT assessment scales for behavioral measurements and the Unified Dystonia Rating and Fahn–Marsden scales for dystonia assessment |
The study showed that iron accumulation in brain regions was associated with the severity of dystonia in patients with RTT Dystonia assessment scales indicated that the severity was more pronounced in patients older than 10 years It was suggested that the increased iron deposition in dopaminergic networks and gray matter could account for the age‐related changes in the severity of dystonia |
|
| One hundred females aged between 1 and 43 years (mean ± SD: 14.5 ± 11.2 years) |
Diagnosis was based on genetic and clinical diagnostic criteria Of the 100 patients, 86 had typical RTT and 14 had atypical RTT |
Clinical review of information from the Japanese RTT database Genetic testing including whole exome sequencing was performed in some patients |
The study showed that walking in all age groups was associated with the ability to form meaningful words In particular, the acquisition of words was associated with ambulatory ability after 10 years of age The authors concluded that patients who can walk can be predicted to form meaningful words |
|
|
Database study Age ranges were 7 to 12 years (15.3%), 13 to 19 years (40.7%), and 20 years and older (44.0%) |
Individuals had a confirmed Variables that were evaluated were demographic factors, | Review of data from InterRett including oral health variables, alongside mobility, frequency of seizures, gastric reflux, and sleep disturbances |
The response rate was 93.1% (216 families of 232 that responded) The study showed that patients with bruxism were more inclined to access dental services and those who were tube‐fed had less dental experience Maternal education was suggested to be a driver for increased focus to access dental services Some patients were also said to cope with more invasive procedures such as extractions without requiring sedation |
|
|
Database study of 242 females with RTT analyzed Age ranges were 6 to 20 years and older | All patients had a confirmed | Retrospective review of longitudinal data collected from the ARSD |
The study indicated that those with the most severe genotypes had worse oral health–related outcomes When adjusting for mutation, by about 3 years of age more than half of patients will have bruxism (58.74%); however, the predictive risk seems to decline with age, with 38.46% at 12 years and 16.49% at 30 years |
|
| Twenty‐three females with a mean age of 1.7 to 5.8 years |
All 23 females had a diagnosis of classical RTT and a positive test for Stages of the disorder were assessed by a pediatric neurologist | Dysphagia was assessed using videofluoroscopic methods |
Oral motility was affected by dystonic and dyskinetic movements. These movements occurred with oral apraxia during ingestion in 78% of patients There were also noticeable abnormalities in this group such as tongue retroflexion and altered (rocking and rolling) lingual patterns |
|
|
Participants with RTT (1052) from the RTT Natural History Study A total of 815 of 1052 patients had typical RTT, with an average age of 9.9 ± 8.9 years at enrollment A total of 148 of 1052 patients had atypical RTT with an average age of 9.1 ± 7.9 years at enrollment | Of the 1052 study participants, 963 met the diagnostic clinical criteria for either typical or atypical RTT | The clinical severity score was used to assess severity of study participants |
The study findings showed that the clinical severity increases with age Ambulation, hand function, and onset of stereotypies were also associated with disease severity; however, regardless of the initial severity, the progression of RTT becomes worse with age It was indicated that X‐chromosome inactivation does not fully account for the clinical severity seen in patients |
|
|
The study included 281 patients aged between 13 months and 27 years Group 1 consisted of patients with RTT ( |
Group 1 consisted of 88 children with RTT (classical RTT Diagnosis of classic or variant RTT was based on revised clinical criteria | Exon analysis: point mutations or small intraexonic deletions |
Among the patients with classical RTT, there was a higher frequency of spasticity‐dystonia (46.4%) and tremor‐ataxia (64.3%) in patients who were mutation positive compared with those who were mutation negative (spasticity‐dystonia [16.7%]; tremor‐ataxia [33.3%]) The study showed that female patients who were |
|
|
The study consisted of 832 patients with age ranging from 8 months to 49 years Patients with C‐terminal deletions had a median age of 10 years (range: 1.3 to 43.5 years), while for patients with other | Of the study cohort, 79 had a deletion in the C‐terminal region and 753 had different |
The cohort was obtained from InterRett and ASRD Three severity scales were used to evaluate phenotypes |
The findings from the study showed that there was a lower severity in patients with C‐terminal deletions when compared with patients without C‐terminal deletions Cases with C‐terminal deletions were also noted as having normal head circumference and weight, and the onset of stereotypes tended to be later Patients with C‐terminal deletions were also more likely to have learned to walk earlier than those with other |
|
| Forty‐six females and one male patient | Patients were diagnosed according to RTT diagnostic criteria | Sequencing of the |
The study showed that truncating mutations were associated with greater disease severity than patients with missense mutations who had a milder course of the disease Significant differences were also noted in sitting unsupported, ambulation, and stereotypies between patients with missense and truncating mutations |
|
|
The study cohort comprised 974 patients, with a mean age of 11.53 years (range: 1 year 4 months to 49 years) The mean age of patients with a large deletion was 9.14 years |
Patients were classified per clinical criteria according to Hagberg Of the 974 individuals, 51 had a large deletion of |
Data were obtained from patients recruited from InterRett and ARSD Regression and survival analysis was used to assess clinical severity |
When compared with other mutations, those patients with a large deletion in Patients with large deletions also developed an earlier onset of hand stereotypies, epilepsy, and scoliosis The authors suggested that a less functional MECP2 protein could account for the clinical severity observed in muscle and motor tone phenotypes |
|
| Five study participants with an age range between 3.1 and 9.1 years | The patients had RTT (classical and atypical) and RTT‐related disorders ( | The study methodology utilized an interrupted time series design to assess the effects of Ayres Sensory Integration on functional reaching |
Preliminary findings showed that sensory integration might offer small improvements in functional hand grasping in children with RTT Motor control appeared to increase slightly after two months of intervention and could be down to neuroplastic changes responding to environmental stimuli |
|
| Case series of three female patients with RTT at ages 8.4, 9.2, and 10.5 years | All females had a diagnosis of RTT at 16, 20, and 18 months, respectively | PECS and VOCA interventions |
During the interventions period, the study findings noted a reduction in stereotypic behaviors in the three patients Fostering constructive engagement and promoting environmental outcomes was shown to have a positive effect on the management of stereotypic behaviors in these patients |
|
| Fifty females with RTT aged between 12 months and 14 years | Patients had classical RTT (predominantly at stages II and III) |
Clinical observations including EEG data Speech and motor disturbances were followed between 2 and 5 years |
The association between the severity of motor and speech functions and neurophysiological data study points towards a dysregulation of cortical structures As the disorder progresses further subcortical, cerebellar, and spinal cord involvement can result in ataxia, tremor, and losing the ability to walk |
|
|
Cross‐sectional and longitudinal (2‐year) QoL analyses of 260 individuals with classical RTT Mean age: 10 years | Data were obtained from the RTT Natural History Study | Clinical severity of patients was assessed using CSS and MBA scales |
The sample showed that individuals with worse clinical status seemed to have better psychosocial functioning, i.e. patients with worse motor function together with an earlier onset of stereotypies accounted for higher QoL scores There were no changes in QoL scores and clinical severity over the 2‐year duration |
|
| Case presentation of three patients with RTT aged 9, 13, and 20 years | Patients had ALTEs and patient #3 died before trihexyphenidyl could be used | Review of case histories |
ALTEs were nonepileptic in nature In two of the patients (patient 1 and 2), use of trihexyphenidyl reduced ALTEs caused by dystonia |
Neul JL, Kaufmann WE, Glaze DG, Christodoulou J, Clarke AJ, et al. RettSearch Consortium. Rett syndrome: revised diagnostic criteria and nomenclature. Ann Neurol. 2010; 68(6): 944–950.
Hagberg B, Hanefeld F, Percy A, Skjeldal O. An update on clinically applicable diagnostic criteria in Rett syndrome. Comments to Rett Syndrome Clinical Criteria Consensus Panel Satellite to European Pediatric Neurology Society Meeting, Baden Baden, Germany, 11 September 2001. Eur J Paediatr Neurol. 2002; 6(5):293–297.
AED, antiepileptic drug; ALTE, acute life‐threatening episode; ARSD, Australian Rett Syndrome Database; ASD, autistic spectrum disorder; CDKL5, cyclin‐dependent kinase‐like 5; CSS, Clinical Severity Scale; DSM‐III‐R, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders–Third Edition Revised; EEG, electroencephalography; GDQ, Gastro‐esophageal Distress Questionnaire; InterRett, International Rett Syndrome Phenotype Database; MBA, Motor‐Behavioral Assessment; MECP2, methyl‐CpG binding protein 2; NCCPC‐R, Non‐communicating Children's Pain Checklist – Revised; PECS, Picture Exchange Communication System; QoL, quality of life; RCT, randomized controlled trial; RTT, Rett syndrome; VABS, Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale; VOCA, voice output communication aid; WeeFIM, Functional Independence Measure for Children.
Fig. 1Frequency of six identified themes. Key: , Theme 1: Clinical features of abnormal movement behaviors; , Theme 2: Mutational profile and its impact on movement disorders; , Theme 3: Symptoms and stressors that impact on movement disorders; , Theme 4: Possible underlying neurobiological mechanisms; , Theme 5: Quality of life and movement disorders; , Theme 6: Treatment of movement disorders.
Developmental trajectory of movement disorders in patients with RTT
|
|
Stage I (period of developmental stagnation) between 6 to 18 months of age. During the initial period there is hypotonia and this lessens after rigidity becomes established. Stage II (developmental regression phase) between 12 to 48 months. Parkinsonian‐like rigidity is common. It can appear early (3 years of age) and frequency increases with age. Nonambulatory patients are more severely affected. In the later parts of stage I and beginning of stage II, patients can present with bruxism. When adjusting for mutation type, bruxism declines with age. For the majority of patients, hand stereotypies appear during this stage, but hand stereotypes may also appear before regression in some patients. Hand function declines over time; however, the frequency of hand stereotypies remain stable and high across the lifespan. Stage III (pseudostationary stage) around ages 2 to 10 years. Dystonia and Parkinsonian‐like rigidity persists across the lifespan of the disorder and is usually stable. The severity and trajectory of dystonia, spasticity, and Parkinsonian‐like movement disorders are probably dependent on the genotype, especially in patients with truncating mutations or large deletions who have worse clinical symptoms and outcomes. Stage IV (motor regression) about 10 years of age. Patients enter into motor regression, which is primarily associated with a decline in gross motor function.
RTT, Rett syndrome.
Fig. 2Schematic of brain regions implicated in movement disorders and associated neurochemical pathways. Panel A: Cross‐section of the human brain showing different regions likely to be involved in movement disorders. Panel B: The array of neurochemical pathways associated with movement are complex with multiple interconnecting circuits that could be dysregulated in Rett syndrome (RTT). In our simplified adaptation of network schematics, , outputs from striatal medium spiny neurons project into the substantia nigra pars reticulata (SNpr) via the striatonigral pathway or into the globus pallidus (GP) via the striatopallidal pathway. These projections modulate thalamic activity and trigger or diminish motor activity through dopaminergic or GABAergic control. Impairments in dopaminergic or GABAergic circuits may give rise to the Parkinsonian‐like movement features or repetitive behaviors in RTT. , Striatal integrity may also be dependent on functional methyl‐CpG binding protein 2. More recent evidence in mice models further suggests that motor impairments in RTT could arise from altered cerebellar architecture. Evidence also indicates glutamate receptor dysregulation in the motor cortex of postmortem brain tissue in patients with RTT and this may affect neurotransmission into the thalamus. Aspects of network dysregulation that may influence movement disorders in RTT are shown.
Treatment of movement disorders – implications for the management of patients with RTT
| Movement disorder | Brain circuitry involved | Treatments | Considerations for patients with RTT |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hypertonia (dystonia/spasticity) | Cholinergic, dopaminergic, GABAergic, glutaminergic | Anticholinergics, baclofen, BDZ, dopaminergics, Botulinum toxin, α2‐Agonist, gabapentin |
Trihexyphenidyl is used to target dystonia. The most common side effects include a reduction in concentration and memory, which might not easily be detected in patients with RTT. Peripheral side effects can include dry mouth, urinary retention, constipation, and blurred vision. This could increase the risk of urinary tract infections and worsen preexistent gut dismotility. Sudden discontinuation can precipitate a change in mental state.
An analogue of GABA, it targets spasticity and dystonia. Oral baclofen can cause dose‐dependent side effects, which include sedation, hypoventilation, and increased seizures, thus possibly worsening preexisting breathing problems and/or epilepsy.
BDZs can be prescribed to target spasticity and dystonia. Their use should be avoided in patients with RTT because: (i) BDZ could induce respiratory depression for which patients with RTT already have a vulnerability; (ii) BDZ such as clonazepam can cause excess drooling, thus increasing the risk of aspiration pneumonia; and (iii) BDZ can cause paradoxical agitation in patients with neurodevelopmental disorders.
α2‐Agonists such as clonidine can assist in the management of secondary dystonia in other patient groups. Clonidine has the potential to increase adverse events. There are no published studies on the effectiveness of clonidine for treating movement disorders in patients with RTT.
It was shown to improve muscle tone in children with refractory dystonia. In patients with RTT, gabapentin must be used with caution given the lack of empirical evidence in RTT and the risk of multisystem side effects.
Carbidopa/levodopa can assist in the management of dystonia. An increase in nausea and worsening of constipation must be carefully monitored. Longer‐term treatment of dopamine could worsen bruxism.
Targets focal and segmental dystonia/spasticity by blocking acetylcholine release at the neuromuscular junction, thus inducing a transient muscle relaxation. Reinjection is necessary at 12–14 weeks. The injection site procedure is minimally invasive for superficial muscles but can require sedation, which has additional complications for patients with RTT. |
| Parkinsonian features | Cholinergic, dopaminergic, GABAergic, glutaminergic | Anticholinergics, dopaminergics, NMDA receptor antagonist |
Parkinsonian features in patients with RTT usually do not respond to levodopa or dopamine agonists, possibly because of a postsynaptic defect. |
| Abnormal gait (ataxic/dyspraxic) | Cerebellar networks | No medication has proved to be successful in improving gait abnormalities in patients with RTT. | |
| Stereotypies/bruxism | Limbic parts of basal ganglia networks | The efficacy of SSRIs for repetitive movements has not been demonstrated; however, when prescribed to target anxiety, there could be a secondary behavioral improvement. |
There is basal ganglia involvement; however, the neuropathology of stereotypies remains incomplete and is likely to involve other branches of cholinergic and dopaminergic pathways.
BDZ, benzodiazepine; GABA, γ‐aminobutyric acid; NMDA, N‐methyl‐d‐aspartate; RTT, Rett syndrome; SSRIs, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors.