| Literature DB >> 34383118 |
Anouk Schori1, Christian Jackowski2, Corinna A Schön2.
Abstract
A noteworthy number of people are interested in BDSM (bondage and discipline, dominance and submission, sadism, and masochism). Fatal outcomes while participating in BDSM activities occur. The aim of this literature review is to give a better insight into potential dangerous BDSM play by summarizing published data on BDSM fatalities. A literature search was conducted. It was searched for non-natural death related to BDSM activity. Seventeen cases were found. The age of the deceased ranged between 23 and 49 years (mean age 34.9 years). Strangulation in the course of erotic asphyxiation was the most common cause of death (88.2%). In 13 cases, a toxicology report for the deceased was mentioned, of which in eight cases (61.5%) toxicology analysis was positive. In four of these cases, the BDSM partner was also tested positive with the same substance. Drugs or alcohol was involved in 64.3% of fatal BDSM play. In nine cases, the level of experience in BDMS activity of the deceased and the partner was described, and in all of them, the deceased and the partner were not new to BDSM play. Fatal outcomes of BDSM plays are rarer than autoerotic fatalities and natural deaths related to sexual activities. Safeguards and education on medical aspects exist in the BDSM communities. If they are followed by the practitioners, the risks of BDMS play can be reduced. Cases of non-natural death connected to BDSM are rare incidents and can be prevented.Entities:
Keywords: Erotic asphyxiation; Masochism; Non-natural death; Sadism; Sexual activity; Strangulation
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34383118 PMCID: PMC8813685 DOI: 10.1007/s00414-021-02674-0
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Legal Med ISSN: 0937-9827 Impact factor: 2.686
Definitions of the different forms of asphyxia
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| Strangulation | Superordinate term for manual strangulation, ligature strangulation, and hanging |
| Manual strangulation | Form of strangulation: compression on the neck by hands, forearms, or other limbs |
| Ligature strangulation | Form of strangulation: pressure on the neck applied by a ligature tightened by a force other than the body weight |
| Hanging | Form of strangulation: compression on the neck applied by a ligature constricted by the gravitational weight of the body or part of the body |
| Suffocation | Broad term for different types of asphyxia such as smothering, choking, and confined spaces/entrapment/vitiated atmosphere associated with deprivation of oxygen |
| Smothering | Blockage of the air passages above the epiglottis, including the nose, mouth, and pharynx |
| Choking | Blockage of the air passages below the epiglottis |
| Confined spaces/entrapment/vitiated atmosphere | Asphyxia caused by an exposition to an inadequate atmosphere with reduction of oxygen or displacement of oxygen by other gases |
| Mechanical asphyxia | Superordinate term for traumatic asphyxia and positional asphyxia |
| Traumatic asphyxia | Asphyxia caused by the position of an individual which leads to the inability to breath |
| Positional asphyxia | Asphyxia caused by external chest compression by a heavy object |
| Drowning | Asphyxia by immersion in a liquid |
Reported cases associated with BDSM activities; F, female; M, male
| Case | Age | Sex | Cause of death | BDSM play | Experience in BDSM | Deceased’s relationship with partner | Toxicology | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 32 | M | Manual strangulation | Strangulation with the forearm of sexual partner | Not noted | Sexual partner (M) | Negative (deceased), partner not noted | Michalodimitrakis et al. [ |
| 2 | 25 | F | Ligature strangulation | Rope around the neck for a sexual partner to control, deceased’s arms and legs fixed, towel in the mouth with a ligature consisting of a scarf and belt | Not noted | Sexual partner (M) | Not noted | Baik and Uku [ |
| 3 | 30 | F | Manual strangulation | Strangulation with hands and manually closed respiratory orifices by the partner | Yes (both) | Sexual and BDSM partner (M) | Alcohol (both) | Oklota et al. [ |
| 4 | 41 | M | Ligature strangulation | Rope around the neck for a sexual partner to control, deceased’s arms and legs were tied | Deceased yes, partner not noted | Sexual partner (M) | Negative | Oklota et al. [ |
| 5 | 49 | M | Suffocation, oronasal occlusion | Mouth sealed with tape, arms and legs fixed, partner pressing hands on the mouth and nose | Deceased was a member of a BDMS community and has been known for participating in breath control plays, partner not new to breath control play | BDSM partner (F) | Negative | Madea and Hagemeier [ |
| 6 | 23 | F | Incomplete hanging | Shibari bondage practice, double hanging with rope at least twice around the neck of the deceased | Deceased and female partner had attended classes in BDSM, third partner (observer) experience in BDSM not noted | BDSM partner (F), observer (M), all three met online | Moderate quantity of alcohol and cannabinoids (both) | Roma et al. [ |
| 7 | 27 | F | Manual strangulation | Strangulation with hands by sexual partner | Not noted | Sexual partner (M) | Drugs (not clarified which substances), (both) | Sendler [ |
| 8 | 31 | F | Ligature strangulation | Throttling with belt | Not noted | Boyfriend | Alcohol (partner), deceased not noted | Sendler [ |
| 9 | 26 | F | Manual strangulation | Strangulation with hands, with a bag placed overhead | Deceased not noted, client not new to breath control play | Client (M) of sex worker | Rape pill substances (not clarified which substances) (deceased), partner not noted | Sendler [ |
| 10 | 30 | F | Manual strangulation | Strangulation with a hand and closing respiratory orifices with a cloth | Deceased participating in breath control plays for some years, partner has been involved in BDSM plays before, but new to breath control play | Sexual and BDSM partner (M) | Negative (both) | Sendler [ |
| 11 | 41 | M | Ligature strangulation | Rope around the neck for a sexual partner to control, deceased’s arms and legs fixed | Deceased interested in breath control plays for two years, partner not noted | Sexual partner (M) | Negative (both) | Sendler [ |
| 12 | Not noted | M | Ligature strangulation | Strangulation with a throttling device | Yes (both) | Not noted | Not noted | Bunzel et al. [ |
| 13 | Not noted | M | hanging | Strangulation with hanging | Yes (both) | Not noted | Not noted | Bunzel et al. [ |
| 14 | Not noted | F | Severe hemorrhage combined with alcohol intoxication | Vaginal insertion of foreign objects, one was an inflatable balloon pump | Yes (both) | Not noted | Alcohol (both) | Bunzel et al. [ |
| 15 | 46 | M | Ligature strangulation | Straightjacket and headgear with gag, tied to a wooden board with shoelaces fastened around neck or headgear | Yes (both) | Dominatrix (F) | Alcohol (deceased), cocaine (partner) | Bauer et al. [ |
| 16 | 49 | M | Strangulation, compatible with hanging | Incomplete hanging with collar and chain attached to the ceiling, whip play by partner | Deceased yes, partner not known | Sexual partner (M) | Cannabinoids (deceased), partner not noted | Bauer et al. [ |
| 17 | 38 | M | Strangulation compatible with hanging | Chain around the neck, tied to a column, dildo in mouth, electrical stimulation of genitals and nipples | Yes (both) | Dominatrix (F) | Acetone, 2-propanol (components of “poppers”) (deceased), partner negative | Bauer et al. [ |
Causes of death in fatal BDSM play
| Cause of death | |
|---|---|
| Strangulation | 15 |
| Manual | 5 |
| Strangulation with hands, respiratory orifices closed with cloth/hands | 2 |
| Strangulation with hands | 1 |
| Strangulation with hands and bag over head | 1 |
| Strangulation with forearm | 1 |
| Ligature | 6 |
| Controlling rope during sexual intercourse | 3 |
| Throttling | 2 |
| Tied to a wooden board with shoelaces around neck/headgear | 1 |
| Hanging | 4 |
| Incomplete hanging | 3 |
| Incomplete hanging, double hanging | 1 |
| Suffocation/oronasal occlusion | 1 |
| Hemorrhage combined with alcohol intoxication | 1 |
Diversity of BDSM activities—explanations (Taormino [14])
| Impact play | Spanking, caning, slapping, flogging, florentine flogging (two-handed style of flogging), whipping |
|---|---|
| Sensation play | Clips, clamps, pinching, hot wax, knife play, electricity play, tickle torture, cupping, fire cupping, fire play |
| Rough body play | Slapping face, hair pulling, spitting, punching, wrestling, biting, scratching |
| Genitals, sex, and bodily fluids | Vaginal fisting, anal fisting, rough sex, cock and ball play, genital play, genitorture, sounds, enema, watersports/golden showers (urine) |
| Sensory deprivation | Sight deprivation, sound deprivation, scent deprivation, gagging, mummification, breath control play |
| Bondage | Rope bondage, cuffs, metal bondage, Japanese bondage, suspension, chastity device, predicament bondage, mummification, confinement |
| Scene or relationship dynamics | Master/slave, domestic servitude, sexual service, personal service, 24/7 D/s (permanent dom/sub-role) |
| Role play and psychological play | Animal role play, age play, taboo play, psychological manipulation, interrogation, objectification, humiliation, kidnapping, orgasm control/denial, forced cross-dressing, medical play |
| Body modification | Play piercing/temporary piercing, suture play, stapling, saline inflation, permanent piercing, cutting, branding |