Maurice Retout1, Ivan Jabin2, Gilles Bruylants1. 1. Engineering of Molecular NanoSystems, Ecole Polytechnique de Bruxelles, Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Avenue F. D. Roosevelt 50, CP165/64, B-1050 Brussels, Belgium. 2. Laboratoire de Chimie Organique, Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Avenue F. D. Roosevelt 50, CP160/06, B-1050 Brussels, Belgium.
Abstract
Compared to gold nanoparticles, silver nanoparticles are largely underexploited for the development of plasmonic nanosensors. This is mainly due to their easy chemical degradation through oxidation, poor colloidal stability, and usually broad size distribution after synthesis, which leads to broad localized surface plasmon resonance bands. Coatings based on polymers such as poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) or poly(vinylpyrrolidone) (PVP) and plant extracts have been used for the stabilization of AgNPs; however, these thick coatings are not suitable for sensing applications as they isolate the metallic core. The examples of stable AgNPs coated with a thin organic layer remain scarce in comparison to their gold counterparts. In this work, we present a convenient one-step synthesis strategy that allows to obtain unique gold, silver, and bimetallic NPs that combine all of the properties required for biosensing applications. The NPs are stabilized by a tunable calix[4]arene-based monolayer obtained through the reduction of calix[4]arene-tetradiazonium salts. These multidentate ligands are of particular interest as (i) they provide excellent colloidal and chemical stabilities to the particles thanks to their anchoring to the surface via multiple chemical bonds, (ii) they allow the subsequent (bio)conjugation of (bio)molecules under mild conditions, and (iii) they allow a control over the composition of mixed coating layers. Ag and Ag_Au nanoparticles of a high stability are obtained, opening perspectives for development of numerous biosensing applications.
Compared to gold nanoparticles, silver nanoparticles are largely underexploited for the development of plasmonic nanosensors. This is mainly due to their easy chemical degradation through oxidation, poor colloidal stability, and usually broad size distribution after synthesis, which leads to broad localized surface plasmon resonance bands. Coatings based on polymers such as poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) or poly(vinylpyrrolidone) (PVP) and plant extracts have been used for the stabilization of AgNPs; however, these thick coatings are not suitable for sensing applications as they isolate the metallic core. The examples of stable AgNPs coated with a thin organic layer remain scarce in comparison to their gold counterparts. In this work, we present a convenient one-step synthesis strategy that allows to obtain unique gold, silver, and bimetallic NPs that combine all of the properties required for biosensing applications. The NPs are stabilized by a tunable calix[4]arene-based monolayer obtained through the reduction of calix[4]arene-tetradiazonium salts. These multidentate ligands are of particular interest as (i) they provide excellent colloidal and chemical stabilities to the particles thanks to their anchoring to the surface via multiple chemical bonds, (ii) they allow the subsequent (bio)conjugation of (bio)molecules under mild conditions, and (iii) they allow a control over the composition of mixed coating layers. Ag and Ag_Au nanoparticles of a high stability are obtained, opening perspectives for development of numerous biosensing applications.
Metal-based nanomaterials
can find many applications due to their
remarkable catalytic,[1,2] electronic,[3,4] magnetic,[5,6] optical,[7,8] and mechanical[9] properties. These properties depend strongly on the way these nanomaterials
are synthesized as it will dictate their final shape, size, composition,
and colloidal stability. Gold and silver nanomaterials are extensively
studied in the biomedical field thanks to their optical properties.[10−12] Indeed, these nanomaterials exhibit a localized surface plasmon
resonance (LSPR) band in the visible region, which strongly depends
on their size, shape, and dielectric properties of the local environment.[13,14] Their extinction coefficient is at least three to four orders of
magnitude higher than that of any organic molecule.[15,16] Therefore, these nanomaterials constitute attractive transducers
for the development of colorimetric biosensors. For now, gold nanoparticles
(AuNPs) are the most widely used thanks to their well-mastered synthesis,
high chemical stability, and biocompatibility.[17] However, in comparison with AuNPs, AgNPs of the same size
exhibit a much higher extinction coefficient and their use could thus
greatly improve the biosensor sensitivity.[18] So far, the great potential of silver nanoparticles is underexploited
mainly because of their easy chemical degradation through oxidation
and their usual poor colloidal stability in the absence of a thick
organic coating. In particular, the covalent immobilization of organic
molecules at their surface is extremely difficult, as the particles
usually aggregate or are degraded upon addition of the functionalization
reagents.[17] Consequently, if the synthesis
of AgNPs of various sizes is well reported in the presence of citrate
as capping agent,[19] their applications
in the biosensing field are rather limited[20] and these particles are thus mostly exploited for their antimicrobial
properties.[21] Coatings based on polymers
such as poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)[22−24] or poly(vinylpyrrolidone)
(PVP)[25] and plant extracts[26,27] have been used for the stabilization of AgNPs (the thinnest coating
commercially available is based on a PEG molecule of 3000 Da). These
thick coatings are however not suitable for sensing applications as
they isolate the metallic core from its environment, which prevents
the LSPR band shifts that are usually exploited to detect the presence
of an analyte. Moreover, the use of plant extracts leads to AgNPs
coated with unknown biomolecules and with nonhomogeneous size distribution
or shape.[28] In this context, the development
of a new method for the synthesis of highly stable AgNPs covered with
a thin organic layer that would both provide strong chemical and colloidal
stabilities to the particles and allow the covalent immobilization
of biomolecules would therefore represent a major breakthrough in
the field.In this work, we report on the use of calix[4]arene-tetradiazoniumsalt, a preorganized rigid molecular platform decorated with multiple
anchoring points,[29−31] as the capping agent. It has indeed already been
shown that the reduction of their four aryl diazonium groups into
the corresponding aryl radicals leads to their strong and irreversible
grafting via the surface multiple links.[32] This method of surface functionalization has been applied with success
to a broad range of materials (Au, Ge, carbon, polymers, glass, etc.)
over the past decade.[33−36] Moreover, in contrast to what is generally observed with simple
aryl diazonium compounds,[37] the unique
macrocyclic structure of calix[4]arenes prevents their polymerization
at the surface of the material. Thin monolayers of calix[4]arenes
are thus typically obtained. Once grafted, the calixarene-based platforms
can serve to the covalent immobilization of organic molecules or biomolecules
(postfunctionalization step) under mild conditions. This general surface
modification strategy has been recently used for the synthesis of
robust calixarene-coated AuNPs (AuNPs-calix) through a ligand-exchange
procedure from citrate-stabilized AuNPs.[38−40] We thus envisioned
that the calix[4]arene-based coating could be a tool of choice for
the stabilization of AgNPs. However, as already mentioned, citrate-stabilized
AgNP colloids are poorly stable and the particles usually aggregate
upon addition of chemicals. In addition, the removal of all of the
citrate ligands remains a challenge and the residual citrate molecules
at the surface of the nanomaterial may disturb the subsequent postfunctionalization
step.[41] For all of these reasons, we investigated
the development of a procedure for the in situ synthesis of citrate-free
silver or gold NPs by mixing the metallic and calixarene-diazonium
salts in the presence of a reducing agent.Herein, we report
on the development of a general procedure for
the in situ synthesis of highly stable silver, gold, and bimetallic
silver/gold nanoparticles in the presence of calix[4]arene-diazonium
salts. The possibility to engineer the composition of the calix[4]arene
layer using mixtures of calix[4]arenes and to conjugate organic molecules
is also described, opening interesting perspectives in the field of
biosensing.
Results and Discussion
Development of an Optimized Procedure for
the In Situ Synthesis
of Calixarene-Coated Gold and Silver Nanoparticles
Two calix[4]arene-diazonium
salts (i.e., C1 and C2) differing in the nature of their substituents
on their small rim were chosen for the study (Scheme ). Calixarene C1 displays four carboxyl groups
on its small rim, that can be used for the subsequent covalent (bio)conjugation
of (bio)molecules, while calixareneC2 bears four PEG chains ended
by a methoxy group. It is noteworthy that an attempt to prepare AgNPs-C1
from AgNPs-citrate according to the ligand-exchange procedure that
was previously reported on AuNPs-citrate[38−40] led, unsurprisingly,
to an irreversible aggregation of the silver particles when the calix[4]arene-diazoniumsalt C1 and the reducing agent (i.e., NaBH4) were added
to the colloidal suspension.
Scheme 1
In Situ Synthesis of Calixarene-Coated
Silver or Gold Nanoparticles
According to the Optimized Procedure
Note that the schematic
representation
of the grafted calixarenes does not necessarily imply that their four
aryl units are linked to the surface.
In Situ Synthesis of Calixarene-Coated
Silver or Gold Nanoparticles
According to the Optimized Procedure
Note that the schematic
representation
of the grafted calixarenes does not necessarily imply that their four
aryl units are linked to the surface.Various
reaction conditions (time, temperature, pH, order of addition
of the reactants) and reducing agents were screened for the in situ
synthesis of calixarene-capped silver (see Table S1) and gold (see Table S2) nanoparticles
and the reactions were monitored by UV–vis spectroscopy. Optimal
results were obtained by first mixing gold or silver salts with the
calix[4]arene-diazonium salt (C1 or C2) at pH between 7 and 9, then
adding sodium ascorbate as the reducing agent, and finally stirring
the solutions at 60 °C for 16 h (Scheme ). The resulting calix[4]arene-coated gold
or silver nanoparticles were purified from the unreacted reagents
by several centrifugation steps and replacement of the supernatant
by pure water. The size homogeneity of the obtained nanoparticles
was assessed by characterizing the LSPR band, and the density of the
organic coating, by monitoring the stability of the suspensions upon
pH variations and KF exposure. It is worth mentioning that the optimal
synthesis conditions are found for a narrow range of experimental
parameters and that conditions differing slightly from the optimal
ones lead to either aggregated, polydisperse, or poorly coated particles.
This process must result in a delicate balance between the activation
of the diazonium groups, reduction of the metallic salts, formation
of the metallic cores, grafting of the calixarenes on the NP surface,
and their polymerization in solution. The interplay between these
different processes and the influence of each parameter (pH, T, or
concentrations of different reactants) on several of them leads to
a complex synthesis for which only a narrow range of parameters provide
monodispersed and well-coated particles. Detailed synthetic and cleaning
procedures of the particles can be found in the Experimental
Section.
Characterization of NPs-C1 and NPs-C2
AuNPs and AgNPs
synthesized in the presence of either C1 (AuNPs-C1 and AgNPs-C1) or
C2 (AuNPs-C2 and AgNPs-C2) were characterized by UV–vis and
infrared (IR) spectroscopies as well as transmission electron microscopy
(TEM) and dynamic light scattering (DLS).The UV–vis
spectra of AgNPs-C1, AgNPs-C2, AuNPs-C1, and AuNPs-C2 showed a sharp
and intense LSPR band with a maximum of absorbance at 418, 421, 525,
and 538 nm, respectively (Figure a–d), with resulting suspensions displaying
a bright yellow (AgNPs) or deep red (AuNPs) color (Figure , insets). The colloidal stability
of AgNPs-C1 and AuNPs-C1 is due to the electrostatic repulsion between
particles because of the carboxylate groups at their surface; the
protonation of these groups in acidic conditions led to an aggregation
of the particles and thus to a strong modification of their LSPR bands
(Figure a,c, spectra
in red). However, this aggregation is fully reversible. Indeed, both
sets of particles can be fully redispersed by increasing the pH, as
shown by the restoration of their LSPR band to their initial wavelengths
(Figure a,c, spectra
in blue). In contrast, AgNPs-C2 and AuNPs-C2 are sterically stabilized
thanks to the dense and thicker PEG coating, and are thus not sensitive
to pH variations (Figure b,d, spectra in red and blue). TEM analysis of the particles
revealed a spherical shape and core sizes of 18 ± 3 and 15 ±
2 nm for AgNPs-C1 and AuNPs-C1, respectively. Smaller core sizes of
11 ± 2 and 12 ± 2 nm were observed for AgNPs-C2 and AuNPs-C2,
respectively (Figure e–h). Additional TEM images of AgNPs-C1 and AuNPs-C1 can be
found in the Supporting Information Figures S1 and S2. IR analyses of the particles confirmed the presence
of the calix[4]arene-based coating, as the typical bands of C1 (C=O
stretching around 1600 cm–1) or C2 (asymmetric C–O–C
stretching from the PEG chains around 1100 cm–1)
could be observed in NPs-C1 and NPs-C2 spectra, respectively (Figure ), in addition to
the Car–Car stretching band that is present
at 1458 cm–1 in all batches. DLS measurements revealed
average hydrodynamic diameters of 37 and 32 nm for AgNPs-C1 and AuNPs-C1,
respectively, which correspond to a thin layer around the particles
(Figure S3). Hydrodynamic diameters of
46 and 50 nm were measured for AuNPs-C2 and AgNPs-C2 (Figure S4), respectively. These values are in
good agreement with those previously reported for a monolayer of C1
or C2 grafted through a ligand-exchange process onto 20 nm citrate-capped
AuNPs.[4]Arenes
Revealed by Infrared Spectroscopy. Langmuir. 2017 ">39,40]
Figure 1
UV–vis spectra of (a) AgNPs-C1, (b) AgNPs-C2,
(c) AuNPs-C1,
and (d) AuNPs-C2 suspended in water at pH 7 (black dashed line), pH
3 (red plain line), and pH 9 (plain blue line). Insets show pictures
of the suspensions at pH 7. TEM images of (e) AgNPs-C1, (f) AgNPs-C2,
(g) AuNPs-C1, and (h) AuNPs-C2 with corresponding histograms based
on the measurement of >100 NPs.
Figure 2
Attenuated
total reflection Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR)
spectra of (a) calixarene C1, AgNPs-C1, and AuNPs-C1 and (b) calixarene
C2, AgNPs-C2, and AuNPs-C2.
UV–vis spectra of (a) AgNPs-C1, (b) AgNPs-C2,
(c) AuNPs-C1,
and (d) AuNPs-C2 suspended in water at pH 7 (black dashed line), pH
3 (red plain line), and pH 9 (plain blue line). Insets show pictures
of the suspensions at pH 7. TEM images of (e) AgNPs-C1, (f) AgNPs-C2,
(g) AuNPs-C1, and (h) AuNPs-C2 with corresponding histograms based
on the measurement of >100 NPs.Attenuated
total reflection Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR)
spectra of (a) calixarene C1, AgNPs-C1, and AuNPs-C1 and (b) calixareneC2, AgNPs-C2, and AuNPs-C2.It is worth mentioning that using a stronger reducing agent than
sodium ascorbate, such as sodium borohydride (NaBH4), allows
the synthesis of smaller nanoparticles (i.e., approximately 6 ±
2 nm). As an example, TEM images as well as UV–vis and IR spectra
of 6 nm AgNPs-C1 can be seen in Figures S5 and S6, respectively.
Stability and Handling of Calixarene-Coated
Silver Nanoparticles
As mentioned above, the use of silver
nanoparticles for the development
of biosensors is highly challenging because of their very low stability.
The silver nanoparticles synthesized in this study were expected to
possess higher chemical and colloidal stabilities than the commonly
commercially available ones thanks to the multidentate calix[4]arene
coating. The stability of the calix[4]arene-coated AgNPs was evaluated
and compared with two types of standard commercial AgNPs of similar
size (i.e., 20 nm): citrate-capped silver nanoparticles (AgNPs-citrate)
and silver nanoparticles coated with a thiolated PEG (3000 Da) (AgNPs-S-PEG3000).Figure shows the
LSPR bands of AgNPs-citrate, AgNPs-S-PEG3000, and AgNPs-C1 after several
stability tests. As reported in the literature, AgNPs-citrate are
poorly stable. They cannot be centrifuged or exposed to pH variations
or agents such as potassium fluoride (KF) without aggregating or degrading
almost instantaneously (Figure a). In contrast, AgNPs-S-PEG3000 can be centrifuged or exposed
to pH variations without any loss of particles or variations of their
LSPR band thanks to the thick PEG coating that protects the particles
(Figure b). However,
when exposed to KF for 30 min, a loss of approximately 40% of the
particles was observed, indicating that the PEG layer does not efficiently
protect the metallic core from the action of fluoride. This moderate
stabilization ensured by the thick PEG coating has dramatic consequences
on the particle lifetime. After 6 months of storage at 4 °C in
the dark, 90% of the particles indeed stuck to the wall of the vial,
while the remaining 10% in solution was aggregated. As mentioned previously,
calix[4]arene-coated silver nanoparticles AgNPs-C1 and AgNPs-C2 can
endure multiple pH variations without degradation (Figure ). They can also resist to
numerous centrifugation cycles without any loss of particles or modification
of their LSPR band. When exposed to KF, only a loss of 5% of the particles
was observed after 30 min (Figure c). Exposure to an oxidizing agent, H2O2, has also been investigated. It has been observed that 1.5
× 10–3% of H2O2 completely
dissolves AgNPs-citrate, while even 3 × 10–2% dissolves only 50% of AgNPs-C1 (see Figure S7).
Figure 3
(a) UV–vis spectra of AgNPs-citrate suspended in water (black)
after two centrifugation cycles (red), after exposure to pH 3 and
then 9 (blue), or after exposure to 150 mM KF for 30 min (pink). (b)
UV–vis spectra of AgNPs-S-PEG3000 suspended in water (black)
after exposure to pH 3 and then 9 (blue), exposure to 150 mM KF for
30 min (pink), or after 6 months (red). The inset shows a picture
of the sample containing 6-month-old AgNPS-S-PEG3000. (c) UV–vis
spectra of AgNPs-C1 after exposure to 150 mM KF for 30 min (pink)
and after 36 months. Inset shows a picture of the sample containing
36-month-old AgNPS-C1.
(a) UV–vis spectra of AgNPs-citrate suspended in water (black)
after two centrifugation cycles (red), after exposure to pH 3 and
then 9 (blue), or after exposure to 150 mM KF for 30 min (pink). (b)
UV–vis spectra of AgNPs-S-PEG3000 suspended in water (black)
after exposure to pH 3 and then 9 (blue), exposure to 150 mM KF for
30 min (pink), or after 6 months (red). The inset shows a picture
of the sample containing 6-month-old AgNPS-S-PEG3000. (c) UV–vis
spectra of AgNPs-C1 after exposure to 150 mM KF for 30 min (pink)
and after 36 months. Inset shows a picture of the sample containing
36-month-old AgNPS-C1.All of these data indicate
that the silver core is remarkably protected
from chemical stresses thanks to the calix[4]arene layer. This high
stability was illustrated by their extremely long lifetime as no variation
of the LSPR band could be observed after 36 months of storage on the
bench and in pure water (no reducing or stabilizing agent was added
to the suspension). Such a high stability of calix[4]arene-coated
AgNPs allows to handle them under conditions that are crucial for
the development of biosensing applications. As an example, it is possible
to suspend AgNPs-C1 in human serum for 1 h without noticeable loss
of particles (Figure a), which is not possible with the other AgNPs tested (see Figure S8). It is particularly interesting for
in vitro diagnosis, as these kinds of applications require the detection
of analytes directly in biological samples. Even more remarkably,
it is also possible to dry AgNPs-C2 and resuspend them without any
loss (Figure b). Finally,
the carboxyl groups carried by AgNPs-C1 were used for the covalent
immobilization of amino-containing molecules through a peptide coupling
reaction. As a proof of concept, an amino-PEG derivative (i.e., H2N-PEG-OCH3, see the structure in Figure c) was conjugated to AgNPs-C1
via a classical 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide (EDC)/sulfo-NHS
procedure, leading to AgNPs-C1-PEG-OCH3 particles. The
choice of this PEG derivative was motivated by the characteristic
and distinct IR signals that it possesses compared to AgNPs-C1. Figure c shows the IR spectra
before and after the coupling reaction (the spectra were normalized
on the aromatic band at 1458 cm–1). The typical
band of the PEG chain at ca. 1100 cm–1 can clearly
be identified, confirming the presence of the PEG derivative onto
the particles. Furthermore, amide-I and -II bands at ca. 1650 and
1530 cm–1, respectively, were observed, indicating
the formation of amide bonds. Finally, the bioconjugation of biomolecules
such as peptides or proteins to AgNPs-C1 was also shown through covalent
immobilization of a human antibody via the EDC/sulfo-NHS procedure.
The presence of the antibody at the surface of the nanoparticles was
clearly observed by typical IR amide-I and -II bands at ca. 1650 and
1530 cm–1, respectively (Figure S9). This result highlights the remarkable properties of the
calixarene-coated AgNPs and constitutes a significant result in the
field of silver nanomaterials for biosensing applications.
Figure 4
(a) UV–vis
spectra of AgNPs-C1 suspended in water (black)
or in human serum for 1 h (blue), then centrifuged and resuspended
in water. This centrifugation/resuspension step was necessary due
to the large absorbance of human serum between 300 and 500 nm. (b)
UV–vis spectra of AgNPs-C1 suspended in water before (black)
and after drying at 70 °C for 4 h and resuspended in pure water
(green). Inset shows pictures of the AgNPs-C1 before drying, after
drying, and then resuspended. (c) ATR-FTIR spectra of AgNPs-C1 before
(black) and after (blue) conjugation of H2N-PEG-OCH3.
(a) UV–vis
spectra of AgNPs-C1 suspended in water (black)
or in human serum for 1 h (blue), then centrifuged and resuspended
in water. This centrifugation/resuspension step was necessary due
to the large absorbance of human serum between 300 and 500 nm. (b)
UV–vis spectra of AgNPs-C1 suspended in water before (black)
and after drying at 70 °C for 4 h and resuspended in pure water
(green). Inset shows pictures of the AgNPs-C1 before drying, after
drying, and then resuspended. (c) ATR-FTIR spectra of AgNPs-C1 before
(black) and after (blue) conjugation of H2N-PEG-OCH3.
Control over the Composition
of Calixarene-Based Mixed Layers
For biosensing applications,
control over the composition of mixed
monolayers of ligands is essential. Particularly, biosensors based
on the aggregation of NPs for the detection of biomolecules will operate
in the adequate dynamic range only if the number of recognition elements
matches the analyte concentration.[42,43] We thus evaluated
the possibility to control the formation of mixed layers of calixarenesC1 and C2 on silver and gold nanoparticles. Several batches of particles
were synthesized according to the optimized procedure (vide supra)
in the presence of different proportions of C1 and C2 (Figure a) and the resulting particles
AgNPs-C1/C2 or AuNPs-C1/C2 were characterized by IR spectroscopy (Figures S10 and S11). In all cases, the absorbance
intensities at 1600 cm–1 (C=O band typical
of C1) and 1100 cm–1 (C–O–C band typical
of C2) were compared to determine the composition of the mixed layer
at the NP surface. A linear relationship between the ratio of the
IR absorbance at 1600 and 1100 cm–1, indicative
of the composition of the calixarene coating, and the molar ratio
of C1 (%) used during the synthesis was observed (Figure b). As NPs-C1 are very sensitive
to pH variations, unlike NPs-C2 (vide supra), the pH sensitivity of
NPs-C1/C2 was thus studied by UV–vis spectroscopy to evaluate
the proportion of the two calixarenes at the surface (Figures S12 and S13). Figure c shows the LSPR shift of the different NP-C1/C2
batches when decreasing the pH from 7 to 3 as a function of the molar
ratio of C1 (%) used during the NP synthesis. A proportional relationship
between the λmax shift and the percentage of C1 can
be observed. All of these data clearly show that the composition of
the calixarene-based coating is directly proportional to the proportions
of C1 and C2 used during the nanoparticle synthesis. This finding
is of great interest as it means that it is possible to simply tune
the surface properties of the NPs as well as their bioconjugation
capacity. Indeed, increasing the proportion of C2 at the surface leads
to sterically stabilized NPs thanks to the increased density of PEG
chains, while increasing the proportion of C1 leads to a higher density
in bioconjugable carboxylate groups at the NP surface.
Figure 5
(a) Scheme of Ag- or
AuNPs coated by a mixed layer of calixarenes
C1 and C2. (b) Normalized ratio of the IR absorbance at 1100 and 1600
cm–1 of AgNPs-C1/C2 (blue) and AuNPs-C1/C2 (red)
as a function of the molar ratio of C1 (%) used during the synthesis.
(c) Difference between the maximum of absorbance at pH 3 and 7 of
AgNPs-C1/C2 (blue) and AuNPs-C1/C2 (red) as a function of the molar
ratio of C1 (%) used during the synthesis.
(a) Scheme of Ag- or
AuNPs coated by a mixed layer of calixarenesC1 and C2. (b) Normalized ratio of the IR absorbance at 1100 and 1600
cm–1 of AgNPs-C1/C2 (blue) and AuNPs-C1/C2 (red)
as a function of the molar ratio of C1 (%) used during the synthesis.
(c) Difference between the maximum of absorbance at pH 3 and 7 of
AgNPs-C1/C2 (blue) and AuNPs-C1/C2 (red) as a function of the molar
ratio of C1 (%) used during the synthesis.
Control over the Optical Properties
The last challenge
was to produce bimetallic calixarene-coated nanoparticles. This kind
of particle shows great promise for biomedical imaging and sensing
or in catalysis as they offer a new degree of freedom to tune the
particle properties and combine the advantages of both metals in a
single nanostructure.[44,45] Coprecipitation of Ag and Au
has already been reported in the literature to produce alloyed nanoparticles
with a global composition matching that of the salt mixture used for
the preparation of the particles, although the distribution of the
two metals in the NP is not uniform.[45] Several
batches of nanoparticles were synthesized in the presence of a mixture
of silver and gold salts mixed with either C1 (Ag_AuNPs-C1) or C2
(Ag_AuNPs-C2) according to the optimized procedure (vide supra). Different
molar ratios of silver and gold salts were used, and the resulting
suspensions were characterized by UV–vis spectroscopy (Figure c,d). For all of
the samples, a strong and sharp LSPR band was observed with a maximum
of absorbance ranging from the one of pure silver nanoparticles to
that of pure gold nanoparticles, i.e., suspension colors from bright
yellow to bright red (Figure a,b). Most interestingly, a linear relationship between the
position of LSPR λmax and the proportion of the two
metal salts used for the NP synthesis was also observed (Figure c,d, insets). This
suggests that, as observed by Ristig et al., a control over the global
composition of the metallic core can be obtained.[45] TEM images showed that the size and shape of the bimetallic
nanoparticles were similar to those of pure gold or silver nanoparticles,
i.e., 13 ± 3 nm for alloys coated with C1 and 10 ± 3 nm
for alloys coated with C2 (Figures S14 and S15). Finally, all of the samples were characterized by IR spectroscopy
and typical bands of calixarenesC1 and C2 were observed on Ag_AuNPs-C1
and Ag_AuNPs-C2, respectively (Figure S16), confirming the presence of the calixarene layer.
Figure 6
Pictures of suspensions
of (a) Ag_AuNPs-C1 and (b) Ag_AuNPs-C2
produced with different molar ratios of AgNO3 (%) and HAuCl4 and (c and d) corresponding normalized UV–vis spectra.
Insets show the position of the maximum of absorbance as a function
of the molar ratio of AgNO3 (%) used during the synthesis.
Pictures of suspensions
of (a) Ag_AuNPs-C1 and (b) Ag_AuNPs-C2
produced with different molar ratios of AgNO3 (%) and HAuCl4 and (c and d) corresponding normalized UV–vis spectra.
Insets show the position of the maximum of absorbance as a function
of the molar ratio of AgNO3 (%) used during the synthesis.Finally, this versatile procedure was extended
to the production
of bimetallic nanoparticles coated with mixed layers of calix[4]arenes
(Figure a). These
sophisticated NPs possess the optical properties of alloyed particles
and colloidal properties that reflect the ratio of C1 and C2 in the
grafted calixarene layer. As an example, equimolar solutions of gold
and silver salts were mixed with mixtures of C1 and C2 containing
different molar ratios (%) C1/C2 of 100:0, 66:33, 33:66, and 0:100.
The resulting Ag(50%)_Au(50%)-C1/C2 particles were characterized by
UV–vis, IR, and TEM.
Figure 7
(a) Scheme of the synthesis of bimetallic Ag_Au
nanoparticles coated
with a mixed layer of calixarenes. (b) UV–vis and (c) ATR-FTIR
spectra of bimetallic nanoparticles synthesized in the presence of
a mixture of silver and gold salts and a mixture of C1 and C2.
(a) Scheme of the synthesis of bimetallic Ag_Au
nanoparticles coated
with a mixed layer of calixarenes. (b) UV–vis and (c) ATR-FTIR
spectra of bimetallic nanoparticles synthesized in the presence of
a mixture of silver and gold salts and a mixture of C1 and C2.UV–vis spectroscopy revealed a similar absorbance
maximum
for all of the suspensions (Figure b), which was expected, as the composition of the metallic
cores was kept constant. IR spectra revealed the obtention of mixed
layers of calixarenes with different C1 and C2 proportions on the
bimetallic particles as different IR signal intensities of C1 and
C2 were observed, as previously described (Figure c). Finally, TEM analysis of these particles
revealed a spherical shape with a size comprised between that of Ag(50%)_Au(50%)NPs-C1
and Ag(50%)_Au(50%)NPs-C2. As an example, the TEM picture of Ag(50%)_Au(50%)NPs-C1(50%)/C2(50%)
is reported in Figure S17 and shows a core
size of 13 ± 2 nm.These particles represent an important
step toward the development
of biomedical applications, as both their optical properties and organic
coating can be precisely tuned using this simple one-pot synthesis
procedure. As both the calixarene-coated pure AgNPs and AuNPs present
excellent stabilities and a tunable bioconjugation capacity depending
on the proportion of C1 in the organic layer, those alloyed NPs are
expected to be characterized by similar properties.
Conclusions
Herein, we report a versatile and very simple in situ synthesis
method to produce ultrastable Ag, Au, or Ag_Au nanoparticles. All
of these NPs are coated by a thin layer of calix[4]arenes. These molecular
platforms are of particular interest as NP coating ligands, since
they provide (i) high colloidal and chemical stabilities despite the
thinness of the organic layer and (ii) a bioconjugation capacity.
Furthermore, they can be functionalized at the level of their small
rim with a large variety of functional groups without affecting the
reactivity of the diazonium groups at their large rim (and the subsequent
grafting to the surface), allowing the grafting of mixed layers on
the NPs. With this NP synthesis method, mixed layers of C1 and C2
and/or Ag_Au bimetallic nanoparticles could be obtained by tuning
the proportions of C1 and C2 or of silver and gold salts, respectively,
before addition of the reducing agent. Therefore, it is possible to
control the composition of the calix[4]arene layer (and thus the surface
properties of the particles) as well as the optical properties of
the particles, paving the way for the synthesis of highly tunable
ultrastable gold, silver, and alloyed nanoparticles.We then
show that silver nanoparticles produced with this synthesis
possess a very high chemical stability despite the thinness of the
organic coating. Their stability encompasses by far the one of the
commercially available AgNPs, allowing their use in human serum, drying,
or covalent (bio)conjugation with amine-containing (bio)molecules
via a classical EDC/sulfo-NHS procedure. We think that this method
is of general interest in the field of metallic nanoparticle synthesis.
Indeed, highly stable nanoparticles coated with a thin engineered
organic layer are obtained in a simple one-step synthetic procedure
with (i) a control over the composition of the organic coating and
(ii) with tunable optical properties. It could significantly improve
the development of biosensors based on the use of plasmonic nanoparticles,
especially composed of silver. Efforts are ongoing to extend this
synthesis process to nanoparticles of other metals such as copper,
palladium, platinum, or even to magnetic nanoparticles.
Experimental
Section
General Materials
Tetrachloroauric(III) acid (HAuCl4) and sodium ascorbate citrate (C6H7NaO6) were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (Saint-Louis,
MO). Silver nitrate was purchased from VWR Chemical (Radnor, Pennsylvania).
All solutions were prepared with HPLC-grade water (Lichrosolv) and
all reagent solutions were aqueous unless otherwise noted. Calix[4]arenesC1 and C2 were purchased from X4C (Belgium). Before use, all glassware
and Teflon-coated stir bars were washed with aqua regia (3:1 volume
ratio of concentrated HCl and HNO3) and rinsed thoroughly
with water.Caution! Although we have not encountered any problem,
it is noted that diazonium salt derivatives are potentially explosive
and should be handled with appropriate precautions. Aqua regia is
highly toxic and corrosive and requires proper personal protective
equipment. Aqua regia should only be handled in a fume hood.
Nanoparticle
Synthesis
Typically, 150 μL of an
aqueous solution of AgNO3 (10 mM) or HAuCl4 (10
mM) or a mixture of both were mixed with 575 μL of lichrosolv
water and 360 μL of an aqueous solution of C1 (5 mM) or C2 (5
mM) or a mixture of both. As an example, Ag(50%)_Au(50%)NPs were synthesized
using a mixture solution containing 75 μL of the aqueous solution
of AgNO3 (10 mM) and 75 μL of the aqueous solution
of HAuCl4 (10 mM). NPs-C1(50%)/C2(50%) were synthesized
using a solution obtained by mixing 180 μL of the aqueous solution
of C1 (5 mM) and 180 μL of the aqueous solution of C2 (5 mM).
The pH was increased to a value comprised between 7 and 9 through
the addition of an appropriate volume of 1 M NaOH (typically between
10 and 20 μL depending on the metal salt or the calix[4]arene
used). Quickly after this, 410 μL of an aqueous solution of
sodium ascorbate (15 mM) was added and the resulting solution was
stirred for 16 h at 60 °C. After ca. 10 min, a change of color
of the solution can be clearly observed, becoming yellow for AgNPs,
red for AuNPs, and orange for Ag_AuNPs. At the end of the reaction,
the nanoparticles were washed by centrifugation. Briefly, the NPs
were centrifuged at 20 000g for 20 min, and
the supernatant was removed and replaced by 5 mM NaOH or 1% SDS (mass)
for particles synthesized in the presence of calix[4]arenes C1 or
C2, respectively. In the case of the mixture of C1 and C2, 1% SDS
was also used. This process was repeated two times, then two other
cycles were performed with replacement of the supernatant by pure
water. Four cycles were then performed to completely discard all of
the unreacted reagents as well as small and noncoated particles. It
is worth to mention that the first supernatant was colored due to
the presence of small particles that do not precipitate at this centrifugation
force. The concentration of AuNPs or AgNPs was determined by measuring
their diameter by TEM and recording their absorption spectra, using
the extinction coefficients of 8 × 108 or 6 ×
109 L·cm–1·mol–1, respectively, reported in the literature for particles of these
sizes.[15,16]
Conjugation of NPs-C1
Nanoparticles
were diluted in
MES buffer (20 mM, pH 5.5) to reach a nanoparticle concentration of
1 nM in a volume of 300 μL. To this dispersion, 20 μL
of an aqueous solution of 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide
(EDC, 6 mM) and 20 μL of an aqueous solution of N-hydroxysulfosuccinimide (sulfo-NHS, 10 mM) were added. The resulting
solution was stirred at room temperature for 1 h to activate the carboxyl
groups carried by the NPs. After 1 h, 1 mL of pure water was added,
and the particles were centrifuged at 20 000g for 20 min. The supernatant was then discarded and replaced by 450
μL of pure water. Ultrasonication was used when necessary to
resuspend the particles. Finally, an appropriate volume of molecules
containing an amino group was added to reach 10 000 equiv per
particle and the solution was stirred for 4 h at room temperature.
The particles were then cleaned from the excess of reagent and adsorbed
molecules via centrifugation cycles: two cycles involving replacement
of the supernatant with 1% SDS in mass to ensure the removal of adsorbed
molecules followed by two cycles with pure water to remove the SDS.
UV–Vis Spectroscopy
UV–vis absorption
spectra were recorded from 1000 to 300 nm at a 120 nm·min–1 scan speed with a UV–vis–NIR spectrophotometer
in disposable (poly(methyl methacrylate), PMMA) cuvettes with a 1
cm optical path length at room temperature.
Dynamic Light Scattering
Samples were characterized
by dynamic light scattering (DLS) with back scattering (NIBS 173°).
Measurements were performed at 25 °C using a refractive index
of 1.54 for the gold nanoparticles. AuNPs (20 μL, ∼16
nM) were dispersed in lichrosolv water to obtain 1 mL of AuNPs (∼0.16
nM) in disposable semi-microcuvettes (PMMA) and multiple DLS measurements
were performed. The reported values are the average hydrodynamic diameters
obtained from three independent measurements using the Z average as calculated by the Zetasizer software.
Attenuated
Total Reflection Fourier Transform Infrared
Attenuated total
reflection Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectra
were recorded at 22 °C on an FTIR spectrophotometer
equipped with a liquid-nitrogen-cooled mercury–cadmium–telluride
detector. The spectrophotometer was continuously purged with dried
air. The target chemicals were deposited in solution on a germanium
single-crystal internal reflection element (triangular prism of 6.8
mm × 45 mm, with an internal incidence angle of 45°), and
the solvent was removed with a flow of nitrogen gas. Bare germanium
was used for the background spectrum. Opus software (4.2.37) was used
to record 128 scans with a nominal resolution of 2 cm–1. Data were processed and analyzed using the home written Kinetics
package in Matlab R2013a by subtraction of water vapor, baseline correction,
and apodization at 10 cm–1.
Transmission Electron Microscopy
Images of the AuNPs
were obtained with a Philips CM20-UltraTWIN transmission electron
microscope (TEM) equipped with a lanthanum hexaboride (LaB6) crystal
at a 200 kV accelerating voltage. The average size and 95% confidence
interval were determined by measuring the size of more than 100 AuNPs.