| Literature DB >> 34336757 |
Linda Schultz1, Julie Ruel-Bergeron1.
Abstract
School health and nutrition (SHN) interventions are among the most ubiquitous public health investments and comprise a key mechanism for reaching populations that are otherwise difficult to reach through the health system. Despite the critical role of monitoring these multisectoral programs to enable data-informed adaptive programming, information to guide program implementers is scant. This manuscript provides an overview of how monitoring indicators can be selected across a SHN program's logical framework, with specific examples across five SHN implementation models. Adaptation of SHN programs in times of school closures, such as those currently being experienced globally due to the emergence of COVID-19, is also addressed. Key aspects of SHN program monitoring are explored, including: (1) why monitor; (2) what to measure; (3) how to measure; and (4) who measures. In situations of school closures, strategies to shift both program activities and corresponding monitoring mechanisms are critical to understanding the rapidly evolving situation and subsequently guiding policy actions to protect vulnerable populations.Entities:
Keywords: adaptive programming; adolescent health; human capital; monitoring; multisector investments; school closure; school feeding; school health and nutrition
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34336757 PMCID: PMC8322578 DOI: 10.3389/fpubh.2021.645711
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Public Health ISSN: 2296-2565
Figure 1Information flow between schools and ministries by school health and nutrition delivery modality. The encircled cross icon represents the health sector and the pencil icon represents the education sector. Information for Malawi and Mozambique were contributed based on personal communication with World Bank staff. Sources for the summary on Maryland, United States: (9); Sources for the Netherlands: (3, 10–13); Sources for Tajikistan: (10, 13–15).
Monitoring considerations and methods for selecting ASHN interventions.
| Kenya | Following Deworming Days, schools send completed monitoring forms to their division/ward-level Area Education Officer, who then compiles and shares collated data with the Sub-County Directors of Education, who in turn, submits sub-county-level summaries to the Sub-County Medical Officers of Health and to the National Office for Data Analysis and Financial Management. Finally, school-based deworming data is captured within the HMIS ( |
| Bhutan | The Ministry of Education requests that schools submit regular reports on the delivery of IFA supplementation to adolescent girls and boys. Teachers provide a report to the principal, who in turn collates the school's data and shares it with the District Health Officer, the District Education Officer, the School Health Program at the MOH, the Food and Nutrition Program at the MOH, as well as with the Comprehensive School Health Division at the MOE ( |
| Ecuador | Ecuador has an information management system that provides real-time information to the national program on the number of breakfasts and snacks delivered and school children reached. School Food Program officials use this system to monitor program implementation and to intervene when programs are underperforming. In addition, the national budget includes a line item specifically for monitoring school feeding implementation ( |
| Tanzania | The Tanzania Education Management Information System (EMIS) includes metrics related to school feeding ( |
| Lao PDR | The National School Health Policy (NSHP) spans five components: personal health and life skills, healthy school environment, health and nutrition services, control and prevention of common diseases, and school and community partnership. Province and district educational offices monitor and report on the implementation of the NSHP to the Ministry of Education and Sports ( |
| Pakistan | Pakistan conducts school-based vision screening with support from Sightsavers International. Trained teachers in participating schools conduct vision screening of all school-attending children and other teachers, document screening results in a standardized form, and submit forms to the school principal. Principals collate and submit school-wide forms to the Designated Education Officer at the Local Education Department, who in turn, submits district-level data to the Health Department indicating where follow-up is needed. In parallel, participating hospitals accept referrals from the school vision screening program and submit monthly status reports to the National Program for Prevention and Control of Blindness as well as with the Sightsavers Pakistan Country Office. Sightsavers consolidates all programmatic data and submits quarterly reports to the Federal Directorate of Education at the Ministry of Education. |
Information for vision screening was collected through personal communication with Sightsavers International.
Figure 2Illustrative logical framework for adolescent school health and nutrition interventions.
Examples of school health and nutrition indicators by intervention.
| Vision screening | National poverty reduction strategy, human capital strategy, or other relevant strategy includes disability prevention | Number of primary and secondary schools that screen students for vision problems | % of students identified to have correctable vision loss that received readymade or low-cost spectacles |
| HPV vaccination | National vaccination program includes HPV vaccination for girls age 9–14 years, with a recommendation for school-based delivery | Number of participating schools that deliver two doses of the HPV vaccine to 80% of targeted female students | % increase of adolescent girls vaccinated with 2 doses of HPV vaccine by age 15 years |
| Intermittent iron and folic acid supplementation | National nutrition guidelines include a specific recommendation for school-based delivery of weekly IFA supplementation | Proportion of schools delivering weekly IFA supplementation to adolescent girls | % of adolescent girls aged 11–19 who received IFA supplements in the project area |
| School feeding | School feeding is included within the national poverty reduction strategy, human capital strategy, or equivalent strategy | Number of students attending schools which implement the health and nutrition program are fed one hot meal and one snack daily 190 days per year | % increase in number of school feeding days as percentage of actual school days in prior term |
| Deworming | Inclusion of helminth and schistosome control commodities in the basic package of school health interventions | Number of school-age children receiving anti-helminth treatment | % reduction in anemia and severe anemia among adolescents aged 10–19 years |
| Nutrition education and health promotion | National policies on the nutritional standards of food and beverages sold in school canteens are published | Number of schools with a safe and clean space that can be used for recess, sports, physical education, or other physical activity | % increase in number of adolescents participating in at least 60 min of physical activity per day during the past 7 days compared to baseline |
| Comprehensive sexuality education | Ministerial Order allowing adolescent girls to remain enrolled in school in the event of pregnancy or marriage | Percentage of secondary schools offering sexual and reproductive health services (information and/or contraceptive methods) | Number of additional institutions that have teachers trained to teach comprehensive sexuality education 2 years after baseline |
| Menstrual health and hygiene | National policies guarantee the provision of facilities and materials for adolescent girls and female teachers to manage menstrual health and hygiene safely and with dignity at school | Number of primary and secondary schools with separate latrines for girls to use | Number of districts (or other appropriate administrative unit) where 90 percent of public schools have access to safe water and sanitary facilities |
Most of the indicators included within this table are drawn from current and past World Bank projects as well as from the FRESH Monitoring and Evaluation Thematic Indicators (.
Figure 3Example of referral forms used in Liberia for school-based deworming and vision screening.