Literature DB >> 34320172

Perspective: When the cure might become the malady: the layering of multiple interventions with mandatory micronutrient fortification of foods in India.

Anura V Kurpad1,2, Santu Ghosh3, Tinku Thomas3, Sulagna Bandyopadhyay2, Ravinder Goswami4, Arun Gupta5, Piyush Gupta6, Anjaly T John2, Umesh Kapil7, Bharati Kulkarni8, Rebecca Kuriyan1,2, Jagmeet Madan9, Sanchit Makkar2, Krishnapillai M Nair10, Raghu Pullakhandam8, G Bhanuprakash Reddy8, Dheeraj Shah6, Harshpal S Sachdev11.   

Abstract

When public health programs with single nutrients are perceived to have a poor impact on the target health outcome, the policy response can be to supply more, by layering additional mandatory programs upon the extant programs. However, we argue for extreme caution, because nutrients (like medicines) are beneficial in the right dose, but potentially harmful when ingested in excess. Unnecessary motivations for the reactionary layering of multiple intervention programs emerge from incorrect measurements of the risk of nutrient inadequacy in the population, or incorrect biomarker cutoffs to evaluate the extent of nutrient deficiencies. The financial and social costs of additional layered programs are not trivial when traded off with other vital programs in a resource-poor economy, and when public health ethical dilemmas of autonomy, equity, and stigma are not addressed. An example of this conundrum in India is the perception of stagnancy in the response of the prevalence of anemia to the ongoing pharmacological iron supplementation program. The reaction has been a policy proposal to further increase iron intake through mandatory iron fortification of the rice provided in supplementary feeding programs like the Integrated Child Development Services and the School Mid-Day Meal. This is in addition to the ongoing pharmacological iron supplementation as well as other voluntary iron fortifications, such as those of salt and manufactured food products. However, before supplying more, it is vital to consider why the existing program is apparently not working, along with consideration of the potential for excess intake and related harms. This is relevant globally, particularly for countries contemplating multiple interventions to address micronutrient deficiencies. Supplying more by layering multiple nutrient interventions, instead of doing it right, without thoughtful considerations of social, biological, and ethics frameworks could be counterproductive. The cure, then, might well become the malady.
© The Author(s) 2021. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the American Society for Nutrition.

Entities:  

Keywords:  anemia; fortification; iron; mandatory; micronutrients; supplementation

Year:  2021        PMID: 34320172     DOI: 10.1093/ajcn/nqab245

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Am J Clin Nutr        ISSN: 0002-9165            Impact factor:   7.045


  5 in total

1.  Response to Comments from Brown et al. (ref: 2021EJCN0980RR).

Authors:  Raghu Pullakhandam; Santu Ghosh; Bharati Kulkarni; G Bhanuprakash Reddy; Hemalatha Rajkumar; Umesh Kapil; Anura V Kurpad; Harshpal S Sachdev
Journal:  Eur J Clin Nutr       Date:  2022-07-11       Impact factor: 4.884

2.  Precision in prescription: multiple micronutrient supplements in pregnancy.

Authors:  Anura V Kurpad; Harshpal Singh Sachdev
Journal:  Lancet Glob Health       Date:  2022-06       Impact factor: 38.927

3.  Platelet reactivity and platelet count in women with iron deficiency treated with intravenous iron.

Authors:  Benjamin K Elstrott; Hari H S Lakshmanan; Alexander R Melrose; Kelley R Jordan; Kylee L Martens; Chih-Jen Yang; Danielle F Peterson; Hannah Stowe McMurry; Corinne Lavasseur; Jamie O Lo; Sven R Olson; Thomas G DeLoughery; Joseph E Aslan; Joseph J Shatzel
Journal:  Res Pract Thromb Haemost       Date:  2022-03-23

4.  COVID-19 pandemic and vitamin D: rising trends in status and in daily amounts of vitamin D provided by supplements.

Authors:  Malachi J McKenna; Oonagh C Lyons; Mary At Flynn; Rachel K Crowley; Patrick J Twomey; Mark T Kilbane
Journal:  BMJ Open       Date:  2022-08-04       Impact factor: 3.006

5.  Sensory Trial of Quintuple Fortified Salt-Salt Fortified With Iodine, Iron, Folic Acid, Vitamin B12, and Zinc-Among Consumers in New Delhi, India.

Authors:  Seema Puri; Tejmeet Kaur Rekhi; Tinku Thomas; Meena Haribhau Jadhav; Venkatesh Mannar; Levente L Diosady
Journal:  Food Nutr Bull       Date:  2022-05-08       Impact factor: 2.244

  5 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.