Literature DB >> 34285056

Interventions to improve the well-being of medical learners in Canada: a scoping review.

Stephana J Moss1, Krista Wollny2, Mungunzul Amarbayan2, Diane L Lorenzetti2, Aliya Kassam2.   

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Medical education affects learner well-being. We explored the breadth and depth of interventions to improve the well-being of medical learners in Canada.
METHODS: We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL and PsycINFO from inception to July 11, 2020, using the Arksey-O'Malley, 5-stage, scoping review method. We included interventions to improve well-being across 5 wellness domains (i.e., social, mental, physical, intellectual, occupational) for medical learners in Canada, grouped as undergraduate or graduate nonmedical (i.e., health sciences) students, undergraduate medical students or postgraduate medical students (i.e., residents). We categorized interventions as targeting the individual (learner), program (i.e., in which learners are enrolled) or system (i.e., higher education or health care) levels.
RESULTS: Of 1753 studies identified, we included 65 interventions that aimed to improve well-being in 10 202 medical learners, published from 1972 through 2020; 52 (80%) were uncontrolled trials. The median year for intervention implementation was 2010 (range 1971-2018) and the median length was 3 months (range 1 h-48 mo). Most (n = 34, 52%) interventions were implemented with undergraduate medical students. Two interventions included only undergraduate, nonmedical students; none included graduate nonmedical students. Most studies (n = 51, 78%) targeted intellectual well-being, followed by occupational (n = 32, 49%) and social (n = 17, 26%) well-being. Among 19 interventions implemented for individuals, 14 (74%) were for medical students; of the 27 program-level interventions, 17 (63%) were for resident physicians. Most (n = 58, 89%) interventions reported positive well-being outcomes.
INTERPRETATION: Many Canadian medical schools address intellectual, occupational and social well-being by targeting interventions at medical learners. Important emphasis on the mental and physical well-being of medical learners in Canada warrants further exploration.
© 2021 CMA Joule Inc. or its licensors.

Entities:  

Year:  2021        PMID: 34285056      PMCID: PMC8313096          DOI: 10.9778/cmajo.20200236

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  CMAJ Open        ISSN: 2291-0026


Concerns exist about the impact of medical education on learner well-being.1–4 Programs housed within medical schools often address intellectual and occupational well-being, focusing specifically on skills related to learning and working;5,6 however, well-being is a multidimensional construct. Social, mental, and physical well-being have been shown to be negatively affected during undergraduate medical education,7 with increased prevalence of burnout in residency.8,9 Poor well-being can affect medical learners across the spectrum of programs, including undergraduate health sciences.10 The Canadian Federation of Medical Students aims to “train healthier physicians to maximize the productivity and quality of health care services for Canadians.”11 Their strategic directions for 2020–2022 include developing health promoting communities, promoting a positive culture in medical education that prioritizes learner well-being, increasing collaboration within the medical community and optimizing student resources. Despite the growing literature as universities implement services to address the well-being of medical learners, earlier reviews on this topic have not evaluated interventions in Canadian medical schools and have found it difficult to define medical learner well-being.12,13 The Wellness Innovation Scholarship for Health Professions Education and Health Sciences (WISHES) laboratory at the University of Calgary is taking a holistic approach to medical learner well-being.14 Based on Nussbaum’s human capabilities approach15 and acknowledging that well-being is multidimensional, 16 WISHES focuses on measurable outcomes within the domains of mental, physical, occupational, social, and intellectual well-being for individual learners and teachers, health professions education and training programs, and the intersection of the higher education system and the health care system.17 We conducted a scoping review that builds on previous literature and uses the WISHES holistic approach to well-being to explore the breadth and depth of interventions that aim to ultimately improve well-being among medical learners in Canada.

Methods

Study design

Based on Joanna Briggs Institute’s Review Manual18 and the Arksey–O’Malley methodological framework,19 we used 5 steps for our review: identifying the research question, identifying relevant studies, study selection, charting the data, and collating, summarizing and reporting results.

Identifying the research question

Our primary research question was “What is the breadth and depth of interventions aimed to improve well-being among Canadian medical learners?” We included any intervention that aimed to improve well-being of medical learners in Canada, with any comparator or outcome.

Identifying relevant studies

We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL and PsycINFO from inception to July 11, 2020. We developed search strategies with an experienced medical librarian (D.L.L.), which combined synonyms and subject headings from 3 concepts: medical learners in Canada, well-being and interventions. We also searched review databases to identify review articles to screen reference lists for studies missed in our initial search. One author (S.J.M.) conducted all searches and reviewed reference lists. The complete MEDLINE search strategy is provided in Appendix 1, Supplemental Table 1, available at www.cmajopen.ca/content/9/3/E765/suppl/DC1. Categorization of well-being domains21 Our inclusion criteria were that studies from any publication year be primary research of interventions (e.g., mentoring, or educational interventions) for medical learners in Canada that aimed to improve well-being. We excluded studies if they were not primary research (e.g., editorials) or did not report any outcome from an intervention aimed to improve well-being. We defined a medical learner as an individual registered in an academic institution whose program is housed in a Canadian medical school and pertains to research or treatment of diseases and injuries or relating to medicine (i.e., undergraduate medical student, postgraduate medical student [resident physician], undergraduate nonmedical [health sciences] student, graduate science [MSc or PhD] student).20 We defined an intervention as any randomized or nonrandomized experimental study. We included studies if well-being was 1 component of a multicomponent intervention (e.g., education intervention to address intellectual well-being, not just clinical skills). We selected domains of well-being (i.e., social, mental, physical, intellectual, occupational)14 for our scoping review based on a needs assessment performed among medical learners at a Canadian medical institution; we validated operational definitions for domains.21 We used broad inclusion criteria (inclusive of all medical learners) to explore the breadth and depth of well-being support among medical learners as they transition through their studies into a health care profession. Understanding the comprehensiveness of well-being support throughout the academic trajectory will benefit efforts to develop effective interventions for students as they transition through medical education.22

Study selection

Three authors (S.J.M., K.W., M.A.) reviewed titles and abstracts, independently and in duplicate, after achieving 100% agreement on a pilot test of 50 random studies. The same authors reviewed the full text of selected articles, independently and in duplicate; we included articles in the final review if both reviewers agreed on inclusion. A fourth author (A.K.) resolved disagreements.

Charting the data

Independently and in duplicate, we (S.J.M., K.W., M.A., A.K.) charted data for included studies using a data collection sheet that was developed and piloted by the review team, resolving discrepancies through discussion. We collected information on document characteristics (e.g., year, geographic location), study characteristics (e.g., medical school, time frame), learner group, intervention domains (i.e., social, mental, physical, intellectual, occupational), level of intervention (i.e., individual, program, system), outcomes (e.g., assessment measures, themes or theories), limitations and conclusions.

Data analysis

We synthesized findings descriptively (Table 1) and categorized the level of intervention as targeted to the individual (i.e., the individual learner or group of individual learners), program (i.e., the program in which the learner is enrolled) or system (i.e., the academic institution or health care system in which learners learn or work). We recorded the primary level for each intervention. We categorized outcomes within 5 validated domains of well-being21 that represent part of the multidimensional construct of well-being: social (e.g., equity, diversity), mental (e.g., mindfulness, emotions), physical (e.g., exercise, nutrition), intellectual (e.g., tools, education) and occupational (e.g., research, resident rotation). Multiple outcomes (within multiple domains) could be recorded for each intervention.
Table 1:

Categorization of well-being domains21

Well-being domainDescriptionExamples
SocialState of well-being in which individuals and communities feel they understand, are a part of, and are accepted by their social environment, and are comfortable expressing their feelings, needs, identities and opinions.16 This includes processes (methods) and outcomes (experiences) of social well-being.Isolation, imposterism, equity, diversity, discrimination, race, religion, ethnicity, family support
MentalState of well-being in which every individual realizes his or her own potential, can cope with the normal stresses of life, can work productively and fruitfully, and is able to make a contribution to her or his community.23Mindfulness, mental health, mental illness or disorder, anger, sadness, emotions
PhysicalPerception and expectation of well-being of an individual’s body, including the active and continuous effort to maintain optimum levels of physical activity and focus on nutrition, as well as self-care and maintenance of a healthy lifestyle.16 This acknowledges physical health and limitations can coexist in a healthy environment.Exercise, physical activity, physical health, nutrition, symptoms of burnout
IntellectualState of well-being in which individuals are enabled to pursue creative, mentally stimulating activities that expand their knowledge, develop skills, and foster life-long learning and teaching, toward a goal of self-actualization.16 This includes processes (how) and outcomes (deliverables) of intellectual well-being.Learning, tools, outcomes, teaching, goals, learning needs
OccupationalProtection and promotion of workers or learners by preventing and controlling occupational diseases and accidents, and by elimination of conditions hazardous to health and safety at work or school, and the development and promotion of healthy and safe work or learning, work or learning environments and organizations.24 This includes processes (responsibilities) and outcomes (trajectories) of occupational well-being.Work, (resident) rotation, job, laboratory, research (assistantship or similar)
We (S.J.M., K.W., M.A., A.K.) synthesized results from included qualitative studies using thematic synthesis for reviews on health research.23,24 We developed discrete themes that represented findings reported in primary studies, and considered these themes to generate new interpretive constructs, explanations or hypotheses.25 We integrated our qualitative and quantitative findings by using qualitative results to interrogate quantitative results, to identify research gaps and to synthesize lines of inquiry.26 We classified reported outcomes for each well-being domain as statistically significant if p < 0.05. We calculated descriptive statistics using STATA IC15 (StataCorp).

Ethics approval

We did not require ethics approval as all data were available in published records.

Results

Of 1753 relevant studies identified, we included 65 interventions that aimed to improved medical learner well-being (Figure 1). Characteristics of included studies are in Appendix 2, Supplemental Table 2, available at www.cmajopen.ca/content/9/3/E765/suppl/DC1.27–91
Figure 1:

Study flow diagram.

Study flow diagram. Summary of findings from qualitative studies1,2* Reported as per the Summary of Qualitative Findings Table structure.26 Well-being domains include social, mental, physical, intellectual or occupational well-being. Levels include individual, program or system level. The 65 included studies27–91 were published between 1973 and 2020, and were conducted most frequently at University of Toronto (n = 16, 25%) or McGill University (n = 8, 12%) with undergraduate (n = 34, 52%) or postgraduate medical education students (n = 31, 48%) (Figure 2). Figure 3 illustrates the cumulative number of published studies on interventions. Among 44 studies that reported implementation year, the median was 2010 (range 1971–2018). The median intervention duration, reported from 47 studies, was 3 months (range 1 h–48 mo). Most studies (n = 52, 80%) were uncontrolled trials, of which half were implemented with undergraduate medical students (n = 26). We included 16 qualitative studies; most (n = 9) were conducted with undergraduate medical students. Resident physicians were commonly from family medicine (n = 6) and pediatrics (n = 6), which included pediatric subspecialties (n = 2); generalist practice was more broadly defined (n = 4).
Figure 2:

Medical schools and learners represented among included studies.

Figure 3:

Cumulative number of published studies on interventions for medical learner well-being.

Medical schools and learners represented among included studies. Cumulative number of published studies on interventions for medical learner well-being. Fifty-one (78%) interventions targeted intellectual (e.g., clinical skills modules46) well-being and 32 (49%) targeted occupational well-being (e.g., resident rotation bundle47); 23 (35%) targeted both domains (e.g., specialty exploration and discovery programs92). Among 19 interventions for individuals, most (n = 14) were for medical students. Program interventions (n = 27) were primarily for resident physicians (n = 17). Medical students and residents were represented similarly in system interventions (undergraduate, n = 9; postgraduate, n = 10). Two system interventions were for undergraduate health sciences students. Few studies (n = 2) incorporated formal mentorship programs in their intervention as a method to promote learner well-being. Only 3 studies considered barriers or stigma among medical learners to accessing appropriate mental health services.

Quantitative studies

Quantitative outcomes are reported in Appendix 3, Supplemental Table 3, available at www.cmajopen.ca/content/9/3/E765/suppl/DC1. Statistical evaluation of interventions was explored extensively (n = 41, 63%), namely evaluating perceptions of well-being pre- and postintervention, satisfaction with the intervention, and determining attitudes and agreement regarding use of interventions. Figure 4 illustrates the number of studies that reported a significantly positive effect of interventions by well-being domain, level of intervention and learner group. In Appendix 4, available at www.cmajopen.ca/content/9/3/E765/suppl/DC1, we provide summaries on assessment tools used to measure outcomes within well-being domains, as well as a summary of statistical findings.
Figure 4:

Number of studies that reported significantly positive effects of well-being interventions by well-being domain, level of intervention and type of learner. Note: One level of intervention was recorded from each included study. More than one well-being domain could be recorded from a single study.

Number of studies that reported significantly positive effects of well-being interventions by well-being domain, level of intervention and type of learner. Note: One level of intervention was recorded from each included study. More than one well-being domain could be recorded from a single study.

Qualitative studies

Sixteen studies explored well-being qualitatively. Most (n = 12) focused on promoting and understanding intellectual well-being in medical education (Table 2). Five qualitative studies reported favourable outcomes; 3 studies concluded that formal audit is needed34,79,77 and 2 studies uncovered shortcomings related to postgraduate education content (i.e., intellectual, occupational well-being)84 and undergraduate medical education leadership (i.e., social, intellectual well-being).33
Table 2:

Summary of findings from qualitative studies1,2*

StudyWell-being domainLevelNo. and type of studentsInterventionAnalysisThemes or theoryAuthor findings from original study
Undergraduate medical students
Brown et al., 201830Intellectual, occupationalIndividual123; first-year undergraduate medical studentsProgram for Improvement in Medical Education for engagement in quality improvement trainingThematicContinuous support; genuine interest in improving medical education; team-based learning and problem solving; regular project feedback; access to education resources for quality improvementMedical education is an appropriate setting to teach preclerkship medical students about quality improvement, which might lead to increased knowledge of quality improvement.
Byszewski et al., 201732Intellectual, occupationalIndividual93; undergraduate medical studentsMultimedia podcast resource on what a geriatric specialty entailsThematicStudents found the podcast a creative method to present a specialty and suggested creating podcasts for other medical fields; students provided suggestions for including patient testimonials and “A day in the life of …”A multimedia podcast for medical students can raise awareness of geriatric medicine as a potential career choice and can be used as a novel multimedia approach for a variety of career options when considering residency programs.
Cadieux et al., 201733Intellectual, occupationalSystem62; first-year undergraduate medical studentsLeadership course grounded in business pedagogyThematicUnderstanding change; effective teamwork; leading in patient safety; leadership in actionLeadership in medical education should be applicable to the learner’s stage of training and may be better supported if leadership is framed as a competency throughout their career.
Chew et al., 201236Intellectual, occupationalIndividual18; second-year undergraduate medical studentsPreclerkship HIV electiveThematicEnthusiasm for small group sessions; clinical observerships; community agency placements; diversity of topics coveredStudent-run initiatives can supplement medical curriculum content and promote student leadership and interest, community partnerships, and faculty mentorship.
Ellaway et al., 201445Social, intellectualSystem101; first-year undergraduate medical studentsMobile device programGrounded theoryMobile devices augment, but are not replacements for, laptop computers, and mobile devices in medical education are perceived as a tool and source of supportMedical learners use mobile devices depending on the learning culture and contexts of their specific medical programs and education ecologies.
Law et al., 201966Intellectual, occupationalIndividual17; undergraduate medical studentsComputer programming certificate courseThematicValue of the course; potential application of learningComputer science and medicine would benefit from enhanced 2-way communication when developing technology for use in medicine.
Lynch et al., 201468Social, intellectualIndividual4; undergraduate medical studentsLinking students from North America and Europe with a peer-to-peer learning approachThematicPeer connection; trust in data veracity; aid to clinical learning processConnecting students across continents in a community of peer-to-peer learning encourages peer cooperation with potential to disseminate key clinical learnings.
Welsher et al., 201888IntellectualIndividual23; preclerkship undergraduate medical studentsVideo-based observational practice communities that augment simulation-based skill education and connect geographically distributed learnersThematicEase of use; technical knowledge; versatile and accessible; observational tools beneficial to learning; desire for more networked, observational learning activitiesVideo-based observational practice communities are feasible to support simulation-based learning of clinical skills in a distributed group of health professional trainees.
Yeung et al., 201790Social, intellectualIndividual20; second-year undergraduate medical studentsLongitudinal Students as Teachers programThematicProgram increased perceived knowledge and provided students with opportunities to practice teaching and to provide and receive feedback, and to reflect on their practiceEarly exposure to medical education theories allows opportunity to apply theories practically through ongoing teaching and feedback sessions that include reflective exercises.
Postgraduate medical students
Campagna-Vaillancourt et al., 201434SocialProgram45; otolaryngology–head and neck surgeryMultiple Mini Interview (MMI) for the selection of applicants to residencyThematicMeet more staff; less stressful; multiple first impressions; different aspects of personality; objective and fair; team assessmentUsing the MMI for admission to a residency program has good acceptability and reliability, and is feasible.
Malhotra et al., 200869Mental, intellectualProgram12; internal medicineMini Clinical Evaluation ExercisePhenomenologicalEducation; assessment; exam preparationThe mini Clinical Evaluation Exercise is anxiety provoking at first, but may provide insight into clinical competence over time.
Myden et al., 201274Intellectual, occupationalProgram6; orthopedicsComputer-assisted surgery simulationsThematicConfidence; awareness; deepening knowledge; changed perspectivesHigh-impact educational interventions endorsing cognitive flexibility increases confidence, changes awareness, and deepens knowledge and perspectives.
Sachedina et al., 201977OccupationalIndividual17; cardiac critical careCode Blue Simulation Program (CBSP)ThematicThe CBSP is a useful tool to help prepare residents to serve as code blue learners and the authenticity of the CBSP cases was usefulThe CBSP enhanced resident preparedness. Differences between simulated and real codes should be addressed to enhance fidelity.
Sukhera et al., 201883MentalSystem10; psychiatryMental illness implicit association testGrounded theoryVulnerability provoked tension between personal and professional identities reconciled through striving for ideal while acknowledging the actualAddressing implicit bias among health professionals is influenced by the process of recognizing and managing biases.
Tait et al., 201384Mental, intellectual, occupationalIndividual7; family medicine, psychiatryThe Dignity InterviewThematicExperience of the interview; patient as teacher; residents reflecting on their own lives; resident reflections on palliative or end-of-life care education; physician role in conflictConversations with dying patients and soliciting a patient’s story are poorly taught and modelled in medical education.
Tan et al., 201385Social, occupationalProgram130; family medicineOnline virtual patient clinical case in palliative careThematicUseful content; beneficial teaching modality; realism of case; awkward navigation; worried about missing key points in the caseThe online virtual patient case in palliative care is a useful teaching tool to address need for increased formal palliative care experience in medical education.

Reported as per the Summary of Qualitative Findings Table structure.26

Well-being domains include social, mental, physical, intellectual or occupational well-being. Levels include individual, program or system level.

A key finding was that well-being among learners is a multidimensional construct that includes 4 components: genuine sense of personal fulfillment and gratification in medical education, grounded understanding of requirements for medical education programs, enhanced peer cohesion and functionality, and promoting cognitive flexibility to strengthen knowledge for diverse perspectives. Three conditions were identified as predicting and promoting well-being: effective coping and emotional regulation through individual strategies, individual and program affirmation of the role of being a learner in a medical school, and systems that favour attributing meaning to being a learner. Qualitative studies provided insight into catalyzing the shift from reducing manifestations of distress to proactively optimizing well-being.

Interpretation

We conducted a scoping review of published interventions conducted in Canadian medical schools to improve the well-being of medical learners. Our review shows that many Canadian medical schools address intellectual, occupational and social well-being through interventions targeted to individual medical learners and their respective programs, within the medical education system. The well-being of graduate students in health sciences programs does not appear to have been addressed through targeted interventions. Across all medical learners in Canada, mental and physical well-being is an important area that requires further exploration. Few included studies used formal faculty adviser or mentor programs as a method to promote social well-being. Mentorship is an interactive process to encourage learning and development, grounded in social learning principles,93,94 that has been used extensively in medical schools in the United States.12 Academic mentors model the importance of key components of social well-being — inclusion, diversity and professionalism — in medical education.95 Formal mentorship programs that are integrated with curricular content can be used to offer career guidance to graduate science researchers, 96,97 or to develop clinical skills among medical students98 and resident physicians.99 Mentorship programs for social well-being report high satisfaction,100,101 career promotion,102 improved clinical performance103 and patient safety.104 We encourage Canadian medical schools to consider social well-being among their medical learners. Barriers to mental health treatment for medical learners are common105,106 and important to recognize for effective mental health interventions.107,108 Learners with mental health disorders and symptoms are often undiagnosed and undertreated. 109 We found a gap in increasing access and reducing stigma around mental health interventions within Canadian medical schools. In 2019, Wilkes and colleagues surveyed 69 undergraduate medical students and reported that 83% of students considered medical education a source of stress, and 70% met criteria for exhaustion; however, only 36% of students reported seeing a mental health professional to address mental health concerns.110 There is a need for formal programs focused on mental well-being, inclusive of increasing awareness, reducing stigma and improving access to mental health services. Although such programs are associated with lower depression and suicidal ideation rates in the United States, the effectiveness of this approach in Canadian medical schools is unknown.111 We found a scarcity of interventions aimed to improve the physical well-being of medical learners.112 Physical well-being does not have comparable widespread acceptance as an aspect of physician well-being.113,114 Adherence to various dimensions of physical well-being is low among undergraduate medical education students.115 In an online cross-sectional survey of fourth-year medical students at the University of British Columbia, Holtz and colleagues showed that those who perceived exercise counselling to be highly important to clinical practice participated in daily physical activity.116 Although it may be hubristic to suggest interventions to improve learner physical well-being will improve patient outcomes, 117 we contend that encouraging physical well-being should be a core component in developing competent and professional future physicians.118 Many interventions in Canadian medical schools promote collectives of learners to encourage a collaborative state of mind rather than peer-to-peer competition. All but 2 Canadian medical schools have adopted a pass/fail grading system for medical education.119 A pass/fail system has been shown to improve intellectual well-being,120 enhancing teamwork among learners121 without negative impact on academic performance.122 Pass/fail grading systems, complemented by standards-based evaluations, are a step along the continuum to recognizing learners as professionals, enhancing intellectual well-being and preparing medical students for life as enduring learners.123,124 Further, many studies reported that medical learners have higher satisfaction and greater achievement of knowledge-related outcomes when skills are taught in condensed workshops, ranging from 2 hours,59 to 5 days,41 to 2 weeks.51 More research is needed to understand massed versus dispersed learning to maximize intellectual well-being. Occupational well-being is an increasingly researched area in Canadian medical schools, particularly in resident trainees. 125 Compared with physicians, residents in Canada have a 48% increased risk of burnout, 95% increased risk of depression and 72% increased risk of suicidal thoughts.126 Residency programs play a predominant role in the occupational well-being of residents; medical leaders have stressed the need for universities to make occupational well-being a core competency of medicine by redesigning medical programs.127 We found many interventions that aimed to improve occupational well-being at the program and system level by addressing culture, learning and work environments; however, more research is needed to ensure that efficacious interventions are effectively implemented in a contextually adaptive manner to respond to individual learner needs. We suggest 3 key directions when considering future interventions. First, positive psychological outcomes are important,128 given that positive psychological adaptations evolve to meet the demands of stressful experiences.129,130 Highly resilient individuals are known to cultivate positive adaptations proactively;131,132 it is unknown whether or not positive psychological adaptations are by-products of interventions or whether they improve coping. Future interventions for improved mental well-being should consider the aggregate of negative and positive mental well-being outcomes. Second, the well-being of graduate science education students in Canada has not been considered widely. Scientific research is an important element in graduate science education programs, and learners conducting scientific research may face unique well-being challenges.133,134 In Canada, the integrative MD-PhD program is a popular approach for training physician-scientists,135 representing a substantial investment of institutional, federal and societal resources.136 Medical schools might consider interventions for all learners conducting scientific medical research to augment their success as future investigators. Lastly, process evaluation is needed to assess the implementation of interventions and outcomes over time. Though most studies reported positive improvements, it is possible that interventions were not reliably delivered or consistently adhered to.137 As others have mentioned,12 we suggest that intervention evaluations include the study of sequential phases of implementation to determine synergies among well-being domains associated with improvement in learner well-being. Interventions may have adverse effects that should be weighed against potential benefits,138 and success during one stage of training may not be helpful during the next stage of training.139

Limitations

The protocol for our review was not registered; we included only primary studies and did not search grey literature, which may fill gaps we identified or report interventions with negative outcomes. Our definition of medical learner is not a validated definition.20 We categorized studies based on 5 domains of well-being, but there may be other well-being domains related to medical learning (e.g., spirituality).140 We found authors nearly exclusively reported successes and few failures, which suggests positive publication bias. Given the multidimensional constructs of interventions, it was not possible to determine specific components of interventions associated with more favourable outcomes. The lack of a universal definition for learner well-being added complexity to study selection, but our broad inclusion criteria allowed us to produce a comprehensive summary of literature. Our review was limited to medical learners in Canada and the included studies did not report on subpopulations of learners (e.g., Indigenous students, international students). We were unable to comment on different race and ethnocultural factors influencing the learning experience.141

Conclusion

Interventions to improve the well-being of medical learners in Canadian medical schools vary. Many Canadian medical schools have addressed intellectual, occupational and social well-being through interventions targeted to individual medical learners, their medical learning programs or the educational or health care systems. The well-being of graduate students in health sciences programs does not appear to have been addressed through targeted interventions. Across all medical learners in Canada, mental and physical well-being is an important area for further exploration. Comprehensive and inclusive interventions aimed to improve well-being for medical learners in Canada are needed.
  129 in total

1.  Outcome measurement in postgraduate year one of graduates from a medical school with a pass/fail grading system.

Authors:  K L Vosti; C D Jacobs
Journal:  Acad Med       Date:  1999-05       Impact factor: 6.893

2.  Evidence-based strategies to improve immunization compliance of postgraduate medical trainees at large academic-medical facilities.

Authors:  Thirumagal Kanagasabai; Loreta Muharuma; Joy McGuire; Melanie Russell; Mary Vearncombe; Murray Urowitz
Journal:  Healthc Q       Date:  2007

3.  The Impact of Stigma and Personal Experiences on the Help-Seeking Behaviors of Medical Students With Burnout.

Authors:  Liselotte N Dyrbye; Anne Eacker; Steven J Durning; Chantal Brazeau; Christine Moutier; F Stanford Massie; Daniel Satele; Jeff A Sloan; Tait D Shanafelt
Journal:  Acad Med       Date:  2015-07       Impact factor: 6.893

4.  Partnership in fellowship: Comparative analysis of pediatric surgical training and evaluation of a fellow exchange between Canada and Kenya.

Authors:  Robert Baird; Dan Poenaru; Michael Ganey; Erik Hansen; Sherif Emil
Journal:  J Pediatr Surg       Date:  2016-06-13       Impact factor: 2.545

5.  Evidence for a mental health crisis in graduate education.

Authors:  Teresa M Evans; Lindsay Bira; Jazmin Beltran Gastelum; L Todd Weiss; Nathan L Vanderford
Journal:  Nat Biotechnol       Date:  2018-03-06       Impact factor: 54.908

6.  The effect of pass/fail grading and weekly quizzes on first-year students' performances and satisfaction.

Authors:  L S Robins; J C Fantone; M S Oh; G L Alexander; M Shlafer; W K Davis
Journal:  Acad Med       Date:  1995-04       Impact factor: 6.893

7.  Physician Burnout, Well-being, and Work Unit Safety Grades in Relationship to Reported Medical Errors.

Authors:  Daniel S Tawfik; Jochen Profit; Timothy I Morgenthaler; Daniel V Satele; Christine A Sinsky; Liselotte N Dyrbye; Michael A Tutty; Colin P West; Tait D Shanafelt
Journal:  Mayo Clin Proc       Date:  2018-07-09       Impact factor: 7.616

8.  Is Canadian surgical residency training stressful?

Authors:  Nasser Aminazadeh; Forough Farrokhyar; Amir Naeeni; Marjan Naeeni; Susan Reid; Arash Kashfi; Kamyar Kahnamoui
Journal:  Can J Surg       Date:  2012-08       Impact factor: 2.089

9.  Striving While Accepting: Exploring the Relationship Between Identity and Implicit Bias Recognition and Management.

Authors:  Javeed Sukhera; Michael Wodzinski; Pim W Teunissen; Lorelei Lingard; Chris Watling
Journal:  Acad Med       Date:  2018-11       Impact factor: 6.893

10.  Initiation of a multidisciplinary summer studentship in palliative and supportive care in oncology.

Authors:  Alysa Fairchild; Sharon Watanabe; Carole Chambers; Janice Yurick; Lisa Lem; Patty Tachynski
Journal:  J Multidiscip Healthc       Date:  2012-09-24
View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.