| Literature DB >> 34285056 |
Stephana J Moss1, Krista Wollny2, Mungunzul Amarbayan2, Diane L Lorenzetti2, Aliya Kassam2.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Medical education affects learner well-being. We explored the breadth and depth of interventions to improve the well-being of medical learners in Canada.Entities:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34285056 PMCID: PMC8313096 DOI: 10.9778/cmajo.20200236
Source DB: PubMed Journal: CMAJ Open ISSN: 2291-0026
Categorization of well-being domains21
| Well-being domain | Description | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Social | State of well-being in which individuals and communities feel they understand, are a part of, and are accepted by their social environment, and are comfortable expressing their feelings, needs, identities and opinions. | Isolation, imposterism, equity, diversity, discrimination, race, religion, ethnicity, family support |
| Mental | State of well-being in which every individual realizes his or her own potential, can cope with the normal stresses of life, can work productively and fruitfully, and is able to make a contribution to her or his community. | Mindfulness, mental health, mental illness or disorder, anger, sadness, emotions |
| Physical | Perception and expectation of well-being of an individual’s body, including the active and continuous effort to maintain optimum levels of physical activity and focus on nutrition, as well as self-care and maintenance of a healthy lifestyle. | Exercise, physical activity, physical health, nutrition, symptoms of burnout |
| Intellectual | State of well-being in which individuals are enabled to pursue creative, mentally stimulating activities that expand their knowledge, develop skills, and foster life-long learning and teaching, toward a goal of self-actualization. | Learning, tools, outcomes, teaching, goals, learning needs |
| Occupational | Protection and promotion of workers or learners by preventing and controlling occupational diseases and accidents, and by elimination of conditions hazardous to health and safety at work or school, and the development and promotion of healthy and safe work or learning, work or learning environments and organizations. | Work, (resident) rotation, job, laboratory, research (assistantship or similar) |
Figure 1:Study flow diagram.
Figure 2:Medical schools and learners represented among included studies.
Figure 3:Cumulative number of published studies on interventions for medical learner well-being.
Figure 4:Number of studies that reported significantly positive effects of well-being interventions by well-being domain, level of intervention and type of learner. Note: One level of intervention was recorded from each included study. More than one well-being domain could be recorded from a single study.
Summary of findings from qualitative studies1,2*
| Study | Well-being domain | Level | No. and type of students | Intervention | Analysis | Themes or theory | Author findings from original study |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brown et al., 2018 | Intellectual, occupational | Individual | 123; first-year undergraduate medical students | Program for Improvement in Medical Education for engagement in quality improvement training | Thematic | Continuous support; genuine interest in improving medical education; team-based learning and problem solving; regular project feedback; access to education resources for quality improvement | Medical education is an appropriate setting to teach preclerkship medical students about quality improvement, which might lead to increased knowledge of quality improvement. |
| Byszewski et al., 2017 | Intellectual, occupational | Individual | 93; undergraduate medical students | Multimedia podcast resource on what a geriatric specialty entails | Thematic | Students found the podcast a creative method to present a specialty and suggested creating podcasts for other medical fields; students provided suggestions for including patient testimonials and “A day in the life of …” | A multimedia podcast for medical students can raise awareness of geriatric medicine as a potential career choice and can be used as a novel multimedia approach for a variety of career options when considering residency programs. |
| Cadieux et al., 2017 | Intellectual, occupational | System | 62; first-year undergraduate medical students | Leadership course grounded in business pedagogy | Thematic | Understanding change; effective teamwork; leading in patient safety; leadership in action | Leadership in medical education should be applicable to the learner’s stage of training and may be better supported if leadership is framed as a competency throughout their career. |
| Chew et al., 2012 | Intellectual, occupational | Individual | 18; second-year undergraduate medical students | Preclerkship HIV elective | Thematic | Enthusiasm for small group sessions; clinical observerships; community agency placements; diversity of topics covered | Student-run initiatives can supplement medical curriculum content and promote student leadership and interest, community partnerships, and faculty mentorship. |
| Ellaway et al., 2014 | Social, intellectual | System | 101; first-year undergraduate medical students | Mobile device program | Grounded theory | Mobile devices augment, but are not replacements for, laptop computers, and mobile devices in medical education are perceived as a tool and source of support | Medical learners use mobile devices depending on the learning culture and contexts of their specific medical programs and education ecologies. |
| Law et al., 2019 | Intellectual, occupational | Individual | 17; undergraduate medical students | Computer programming certificate course | Thematic | Value of the course; potential application of learning | Computer science and medicine would benefit from enhanced 2-way communication when developing technology for use in medicine. |
| Lynch et al., 2014 | Social, intellectual | Individual | 4; undergraduate medical students | Linking students from North America and Europe with a peer-to-peer learning approach | Thematic | Peer connection; trust in data veracity; aid to clinical learning process | Connecting students across continents in a community of peer-to-peer learning encourages peer cooperation with potential to disseminate key clinical learnings. |
| Welsher et al., 2018 | Intellectual | Individual | 23; preclerkship undergraduate medical students | Video-based observational practice communities that augment simulation-based skill education and connect geographically distributed learners | Thematic | Ease of use; technical knowledge; versatile and accessible; observational tools beneficial to learning; desire for more networked, observational learning activities | Video-based observational practice communities are feasible to support simulation-based learning of clinical skills in a distributed group of health professional trainees. |
| Yeung et al., 2017 | Social, intellectual | Individual | 20; second-year undergraduate medical students | Longitudinal Students as Teachers program | Thematic | Program increased perceived knowledge and provided students with opportunities to practice teaching and to provide and receive feedback, and to reflect on their practice | Early exposure to medical education theories allows opportunity to apply theories practically through ongoing teaching and feedback sessions that include reflective exercises. |
| Campagna-Vaillancourt et al., 2014 | Social | Program | 45; otolaryngology–head and neck surgery | Multiple Mini Interview (MMI) for the selection of applicants to residency | Thematic | Meet more staff; less stressful; multiple first impressions; different aspects of personality; objective and fair; team assessment | Using the MMI for admission to a residency program has good acceptability and reliability, and is feasible. |
| Malhotra et al., 2008 | Mental, intellectual | Program | 12; internal medicine | Mini Clinical Evaluation Exercise | Phenomenological | Education; assessment; exam preparation | The mini Clinical Evaluation Exercise is anxiety provoking at first, but may provide insight into clinical competence over time. |
| Myden et al., 2012 | Intellectual, occupational | Program | 6; orthopedics | Computer-assisted surgery simulations | Thematic | Confidence; awareness; deepening knowledge; changed perspectives | High-impact educational interventions endorsing cognitive flexibility increases confidence, changes awareness, and deepens knowledge and perspectives. |
| Sachedina et al., 2019 | Occupational | Individual | 17; cardiac critical care | Code Blue Simulation Program (CBSP) | Thematic | The CBSP is a useful tool to help prepare residents to serve as code blue learners and the authenticity of the CBSP cases was useful | The CBSP enhanced resident preparedness. Differences between simulated and real codes should be addressed to enhance fidelity. |
| Sukhera et al., 2018 | Mental | System | 10; psychiatry | Mental illness implicit association test | Grounded theory | Vulnerability provoked tension between personal and professional identities reconciled through striving for ideal while acknowledging the actual | Addressing implicit bias among health professionals is influenced by the process of recognizing and managing biases. |
| Tait et al., 2013 | Mental, intellectual, occupational | Individual | 7; family medicine, psychiatry | The Dignity Interview | Thematic | Experience of the interview; patient as teacher; residents reflecting on their own lives; resident reflections on palliative or end-of-life care education; physician role in conflict | Conversations with dying patients and soliciting a patient’s story are poorly taught and modelled in medical education. |
| Tan et al., 2013 | Social, occupational | Program | 130; family medicine | Online virtual patient clinical case in palliative care | Thematic | Useful content; beneficial teaching modality; realism of case; awkward navigation; worried about missing key points in the case | The online virtual patient case in palliative care is a useful teaching tool to address need for increased formal palliative care experience in medical education. |
Reported as per the Summary of Qualitative Findings Table structure.26
Well-being domains include social, mental, physical, intellectual or occupational well-being. Levels include individual, program or system level.