| Literature DB >> 34267494 |
Paulina S Sockolow1, Kathryn H Bowles2,3, Carl Pankok1, Yingjie Zhou2, Sheryl Potashnik1, Ellen J Bass1,1.
Abstract
During home health care (HHC) admissions, nurses provide input into decisions regarding the skilled nursing visit frequency and episode duration. This important clinical decision can impact patient outcomes including hospitalization. Episode duration has recently gained greater importance due to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) decrease in reimbursable episode length from 60 to 30 days. We examined admissions nurses' visit pattern decision-making and whether it is influenced by documentation available before and during the first home visit, agency standards, other disciplines being scheduled, and electronic health record (EHR) use. This observational mixed-methods study included admission document analysis, structured interviews, and a think-aloud protocol with 18 nurses from 3 diverse HHC agencies (6 at each) admitting 2 patients each (36 patients). Findings show that prior to entering the home, nurses had an information deficit; they either did not predict the patient's visit frequency and episode duration or stated them based on experience with similar patients. Following patient interaction in the home, nurses were able to make this decision. Completion of documentation using the EHR did not appear to influence visit pattern decisions. Patient condition and insurance restrictions were influential on both frequency and duration. Given the information deficit at admission, and the delay in visit pattern decision making, we offer health information technology recommendations on electronic communication of structured information, and EHR documentation and decision support.Entities:
Keywords: decision making; documentation; electronic health record; home health care; nursing informatics; visit pattern
Year: 2021 PMID: 34267494 PMCID: PMC8239998 DOI: 10.1177/1084822321990775
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Home Health Care Manag Pract ISSN: 1084-8223
Characteristics of the 3 Participating Agencies.
| Characteristic | Agency | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Geographic area | Rural | Suburban | Urban |
| Size | Small | Medium | Medium |
| Part of a hospital system | No | Yes | Yes |
| Electronic health record system | Commercial, laptop-based EHR from regional vendor | Commercial, laptop-based EHR from a leading national HHC vendor | Commercial, laptop-based EHR from a leading national hospital vendor |
| Patient population demographics | Majority white, older, lower socio-economic population | Majority white, older, middle and lower socio-economic population | Majority African-American, middle-aged and older, lower socio-economic population |
Group Codes and Component Themes.
| Group code | Themes |
|---|---|
| Information deficits | Based on incomplete information in referral documentation |
| Nurse experience | Nurse Experience with previous, similar patients |
| Policy driven | Compliance with agency procedures |
| Episode of 9 weeks | |
| Estimate high on visit frequency (higher number of visits per week) | |
| Estimate high on duration so follow-up nurse has orders until the end of the cert period | |
| Estimate high on number, frequency of visits in case patient declines and needs more visits to avert need to request physician to write a new order | |
| Physician specified VTF on order | |
| Weekend scheduling criteria: Patient is new to home care and needs a second visit which falls on the weekend | |
| Other clinicians are involved | Physician appointment or other external clinical appts (outside the home) |
| Therapy visits/Other services | |
| Patient is stable/stabilizing | Monitoring (eg, 1 visit per week) as reason to justify episode longer length for stable/stabilizing patient: No specification that frequency be reduced |
| Reduced visit frequency so as to monitor patient (eg, 1 visit per week) | |
| Reduced visit frequency as patient condition stabilizes | |
| Clinical condition: stable, more “under control” | |
| Conditions such as chronic conditions or behavioral issues (excludes wounds) take time to address | |
| Acute needs | Availability of medical equipment that reduces need for more frequent visits |
| Follow-up needed due to medical condition or missing meds: schedule visit on the next day | |
| Provide required in-home nurse service (eg, lab draw) | |
| View/assess wound and/or dressing | |
| Wound appearance indicates need for more frequent nursing care | |
| Wound type (eg, pressure) and pressure ulcer stage (as per NPUAP classification) | |
| Clinical condition: skin risk and breakdown score (eg, Braden Scale score) | |
| Clinical condition: fragile, not stable: patient condition is at risk for deterioration | |
| Resolve medication questions before medical visit (eg, self-administration of medications in blister packages in advance of physician visit when patient will receive a script for medications packaged in pill bottles) | |
| Patient/Caregiver education | Caregiver education |
| Patient’s need for education | |
| Resolve medication questions before next medical visit (eg, administration of medications in blister packages in advance of physician visit when patient will receive a script for medications packaged in pill bottles) | |
| Insurance restrictions | Insurance restrictions |
| Quality of the caregiver | Quality of the caregiver: Caregiver availability, willingness and/or /capability |
| Patient caregiver preference | Patient/caregiver preference for scheduling |
| Depends on the day | Avoid scheduling on weekends/holidays |
| Avoid scheduling on Mondays which are busy days for agency | |
| Wednesday placement: Nurse’s preference to schedule visit in the middle of the week so as to spread visits among the weekdays | |
| Staffing | Nurse work schedule |
| Patient burden consideration | Patient burden consideration for example avoid scheduling a visit 2 days after discharge because patient is usually exhausted |
| Frontloading | Front-load |
Figure 1.Visit pattern decision response by phase by agency*.
Note. *Responses not present for all observations.
Figure 2.Visit pattern frequency cross-phase changes by agency.*
Note. *Responses not present for all observations.
Figure 3.Visit pattern duration cross-phase changes by agency.*
Note. *Responses not present for all observations.
Study Themes Organized by Phase of Occurrence and Group Code, with Illustrative Quotes (with U for Urban Agency, S for Suburban, and R for Rural).
| Phase(s) | Group code | Quote |
|---|---|---|
| All | Acute needs | “If he has a lot of edema, if I hear a lot of rales, if I don’t think he has his meds, and I need that follow up, then I put him in for the next day.” (S04) |
| “Most patients require twice a week, if they’re of medical concern.” (S03) | ||
| “I knew with the wound care we might be [out there often] but he looks like he’s pretty fragile so we’ll come out more to see him. . .just to make sure the wound care is getting done and that he’s not declining because he looks like he had a pretty big decline.” (R06) | ||
| “I think we are 2 to 3 visits because of her recent 3 hospitalizations in the last 4 months” (U01) | ||
| “I think I’m going to put her on for a weekend visit so Saturday. It all depends when her wound vac machine comes, gets delivered to her house. Because we would have to apply that, so if she gets it today, we’ll have the nurse come out tomorrow to apply it.” (U08) | ||
| Pre-visit | Information Deficit | “I don’t see anything as far as the [wound care] orders. I guess I’ll be deciding.” (R07) |
| “That would depend too on my assessment once we got there to see what kind of shape he’s in.” (R10) | ||
| “I’m not really sure what we’re doing to the wounds” (U08) | ||
| Nurse experience | “She sounds fairly routine post-op. She had her knee revised, she had a total knee revision. We’ve had her as a patient before so my guess is that it would be 1 or 2 nursing visit follow ups for pain.” (R11) | |
| Pre-visit and visit | Policy driven | “9 weeks, just the way how it falls, 9 weeks falls on a Sunday, but we have to bulk it out to the end of the certification period.” (U13) |
| Other clinicians are involved | “Physical therapy is coming out to see her, occupational therapy is coming out to see her. We’re almost seeing her every day, but different disciplines. . .Therapy goes out 3 times a week or so. We’ll say Monday Wednesday Friday, so we go Tuesday Thursday, so we keep our eyes on you, evaluating how well you’re progressing.” (R05) | |
| “We can’t go and see a patient on the same day they see their doctor. It’s double dipping.” (R04) | ||
| Pre-visit and Post-visit | Patient is stable | “Her blood sugars were a little bit high but she did say that they were pretty well controlled. She is only on pills, she’s not on insulin at this point.” (R05) |
| “I mean after assessing his wound, it is fairly healed at this point so I won’t have anybody coming out tomorrow to teach or reevaluate or anything like that.” (R07) | ||
| “I want to give him enough time to get the depression and eating disorder addressed, that’s still our primary goal—CHF. . .Keep him out of the hospital for 30 days and give him as much education as we possibly can. . .make sure his vital signs aren’t changing and his lungs aren’t changing.” (S04) | ||
| Infrequently mentioned with no discernable pattern | Patient/Caregiver education | “There’s still questions that need clarification. And particularly with those few medication questions. I want to make sure that’s all right. I want it right before she goes to the doctor.” (S03) |
| Insurance restrictions | “Part of it is going to be he has Keystone 65 and they gave us 12 visits. . .for the first month.”(S04) | |
| “So starting tomorrow we’re going to start teaching the caregiver to do the wound care because Medicare won’t pay for us to come out every day.” (R06) | ||
| Quality of the caregiver | “After seeing him and seeing all the care that he gets it doesn’t seem like he’s going to need as intensive nursing care because he does have around the clock, good, knowledgeable caregivers.” (S12) | |
| “Wife unable to pack [wound] due to recent illness. . .we’ll have to get wound care orders changed at that point in time to see if. . .[we could] go maybe to a daily dressing.” (R04) | ||
| Patient/Caregiver preference | “I would have preferred to have him on Sunday but I can’t, I got to go by what he wants so at least he’ll let us in Monday.”(S05) | |
| Depends on the day | “we can avoid Mondays by adding patients because they’re [nurses] always already very busy, then I go to Tuesday or Wednesday”(R10) | |
| Staffing | “I don’t always work on Wednesday so sometimes I have to move that [visit].”(S08) | |
| Patient burden consideration | “tomorrow he’s going to be completely exhausted, usually the second day you come home you’re tired” (S04) | |
| Frontloading | “Normally when I admit a patient I usually like to have them seen quite often in the beginning just to make sure they’re doing okay so it will probably 2-3 visits initially, then that can be based off of when I go in here, things may change.” (U01) |