Marcela Gonçalves1,2, Karen da Silva Santos1,2, Simone Santana da Silva3, Thalita Caroline Cardoso Marcussi1,2, Kisa Valladão Carvalho1,4, Cinira Magali Fortuna1,2. 1. Universidade de São Paulo, Escola de Enfermagem de Ribeirão Preto, PAHO/WHO Collaborating Centre for Nursing Research Development, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brazil. 2. Scholarship holder at the Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq), Brazil. 3. Universidade do Estado da Bahia, Campus VII, Senhor do Bonfim, Bahia, Brazil. 4. Scholarship holder at the Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP), Brazil.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: to know the interferences of leprosy in women's lives and how they reinvent themselves in coping with the disease. METHOD: a descriptive study with a qualitative approach. The theoretical-methodological framework adopts an approximation to the cartographic method and some concepts of schizoanalysis, which were used to analyze the data. The tools used to produce the data were the interview and the logbook. The interviews were conducted from July to November 2019, at the participants' homes. RESULTS: the group consisted of nine women. To display the data, we were inspired by Deleuze's ideas about difference and repetition. The results were organized in three thematic axes that address the lives of these women affected by leprosy, which accompany concerns, anxieties and worries about the effects of the disease. The transformations in the female body, the financial maintenance itself due to the comorbidities caused by leprosy and its difficulties in guaranteeing rights are elements strongly pointed out by women. CONCLUSION: there is overlap and interference of the female condition in a patriarchal society that still accompanies it. We bet on the strength of becoming-a-woman and the need to consider them in their singularities and in their context for producing care permeated by meetings of the affirmation of the power of life.
OBJECTIVE: to know the interferences of leprosy in women's lives and how they reinvent themselves in coping with the disease. METHOD: a descriptive study with a qualitative approach. The theoretical-methodological framework adopts an approximation to the cartographic method and some concepts of schizoanalysis, which were used to analyze the data. The tools used to produce the data were the interview and the logbook. The interviews were conducted from July to November 2019, at the participants' homes. RESULTS: the group consisted of nine women. To display the data, we were inspired by Deleuze's ideas about difference and repetition. The results were organized in three thematic axes that address the lives of these women affected by leprosy, which accompany concerns, anxieties and worries about the effects of the disease. The transformations in the female body, the financial maintenance itself due to the comorbidities caused by leprosy and its difficulties in guaranteeing rights are elements strongly pointed out by women. CONCLUSION: there is overlap and interference of the female condition in a patriarchal society that still accompanies it. We bet on the strength of becoming-a-woman and the need to consider them in their singularities and in their context for producing care permeated by meetings of the affirmation of the power of life.
Leprosy is an infectious disease caused by Mycobacterium leprae, which, if left
untreated, can lead to disabilities1. It is an
ancient disease, still very stigmatized in society2. It is on the list of neglected diseases, which affects the population
of the most disadvantaged regions, and is included in the international agenda of
the global commitments made by the United Nations (UN)3. We know that the neglected diseases, in addition to being a public
health problem, have low investments in the discovery of new treatments, in research
and in the necessary measures for its control.Brazil is a country with a high burden for the disease and ranks second in the list
of countries with the highest number of cases in the world4. Brazil presented a 30% reduction in the number of case
detections, from 40,100 in 2007 to 25,200 in 20165. Despite the numbers, the fight is still arduous, since its challenges
are not only restricted to the biological sphere, as the cure has been achieved with
multidrug therapy. It is also important to consider comprehensive care for people
affected by leprosy, involving social and cultural aspects in the quest to overcome
the present stigma6.Individuals are subjective beings, built in the political, economic, historical and
cultural circumstances. In this sense, the subjectivity of women with leprosy is
marked by a history of inequality and violence. In the context of Brazilian women,
leprosy causes physical transformations due to the clinical manifestations of the
disease, transforms the color of the skin through polychemotherapy, brings
psychological impacts by the diagnosis, given that, for being a woman and having the
functions that are assigned to her socially, everything gets exacerbated.The person affected by leprosy experiences a so-called psychological vulnerability,
not only due to the stigma associated with the disease, but also due to the
consequences of the disease and the treatment itself. A research study7 states that, with the use of drugs and with
leprosy reactions, people affected by the disease can develop transformations in the
perception of their body image. They also point out these people's difficulties in
continuing daily life and work activities, which can lead them to isolate themselves
socially. In the same direction, another survey8 refers to women with leprosy and the impacts produced by
transformations in their physical body, affecting self-esteem and affective
relationships.Thus, the diagnosis of leprosy brings specificities for women, after all, in addition
to being accompanied by the stigma inherent in the disease, it is added to the
gender standards socially imposed on this social group.According to another study9, the situation of
social vulnerability occurs through the alteration of the potential for reaction to
difficult situations. By accepting that people are vulnerable, the possibility of
placing them under guardianship emerges, thinking that they do not know how to take
care of themselves. Therefore, it is essential that the health team that provides
care to women with leprosy is prepared to identify and understand the specificities
that involve this condition. It is necessary to know the way in which this
assistance is being provided, to listen to the person who receives the assistance
and to know their strengths and potential.The present production contributes towards knowing the ways of life of women who live
with leprosy, in valuing the gender issues that permeate their routine and with
adversities arising from financial and labor problems (how they deal, how they
managed to reinvent themselves on their journey and continue life).With this, it is expected to encourage reflections to professionals and future health
professionals for such complexities, which need attention, to provide comprehensive
care to women affected by leprosy, who suffer from society's demand of being a
woman, added to the weight of the diagnosis2
,
10
-
11. Thus, this study aims to understand the
interferences of leprosy in the lives of women and how they reinvent themselves in
coping with the disease.
Method
This is a descriptive study with a qualitative approach. The theoretical
methodological framework adopted was an approximation to the cartographic method and
some concepts of schizoanalysis by Deleuze and Guattari, such as, for example,
affection and power. The tools used to produce the data were the interview and the
logbook.The cartography was presented by Deleuze as a method and way for producing knowledge.
Here, we will bring social cartography, which involves movements, relationships,
power games, confrontation between forces, struggles, statements, practices of
resistance and freedom12. Cartography is a
means of creating research and the researcher's encounter with his field. In this
case, the researcher will be producing knowledge considering their perceptions,
paying attention to the affections and sensations produced when they live the
research. These encounters produce and undo meanings13.In cartographic research, annotations are used, which are prepared after the
activities involving data production14. We
will call these notes a logbook. The registration of the construction of the
research must be done not to know what is researched but, above all, to witness the
research process15. From the first contact
with the Health Unit, the diary began with the record of the researcher's
impressions, feelings and perceptions. Particular attention was paid to the ways in
which the service works, to the relationships that professionals established with
women and to the affections triggered in the meetings with the participants and with
the field. In addition to writing, audio was used, which allowed recording at
different times, that is, before starting data production, during and after it.
These records were considered in the analysis, bringing the possibility to
contextualize and reflect on the research process. In this way, it was possible to
exercise the cartography of affections and encounters that lead women undergoing
leprosy treatment to create coping strategies for adversity. Also in relation to the
approach to the cartographic method, it was possible to find and experience this
power in the dialog between the participant and the researcher.Data production took place from July to November 2019, in a municipality in the
inland of the state of São Paulo, in a referral center for specialties that offers
leprosy treatment. It is important to note that, in the municipality involved, there
is also another specialized outpatient clinic linked to a quaternary level hospital.
This outpatient clinic was not a field of investigation because it also serves the
region, with several municipalities making up the majority of its target population
and, thus, the research was restricted to the chosen municipality that is considered
endemic in leprosy.At first, the project was presented to the manager of the health unit and she talked
to the nursing team, explaining the presence of the researcher in the service and
asking them to guide her as to the dates and times of the women's service. With the
collaboration of the team, the researcher developed a strategy to approach possible
participants at the end of the consultation or care in the service. At that moment,
the objective of the research, the risks, benefits, and the interview were jointly
presented to the women undergoing treatment.Data production took place through interviews with approaches to cartographic
management, with questions in accordance with the research objective. They were
carried out with women under leprosy treatment who agreed to participate, being able
to choose the date, place and time. All of them chose their homes as the location of
the interview because there were already other tasks scheduled after care in the
health unit.The mean duration of the interviews was 1 hour and 20 minutes, they were
audio-recorded and later on transcribed for analysis. The person who conducted the
interviews was one of the authors, a nurse who, at the time of data production, was
pursuing graduate studies at the master's level and had already carried out
qualitative research studies with interviews.Nineteen women were invited to participate in the research, with acceptance and
participation of nine; two accepted but were not found at their homes, another four
women gave up, and four refused. They justified their non-participation due to lack
of time and for not feeling comfortable talking to the researcher. As for the
inclusion and exclusion criteria, the method used does not provide for this way of
dealing with the participants, but we emphasize that we interviewed only women over
18 years old. Likewise, for surveys in cartographic mode, it is the meetings and
their intensity that determine the number of participants, having as a reference the
possibility of having answered the research objectives. No new interviews were
conducted because they were considered sufficient in the analytical process.After the transcription of the interviews, a careful reading was carried out with the
modulation and intonations of the participant's voice (such as pauses, moments of
transformation in the pitch of the voice and the perceived affections). On top of
these markings, a second reading was made with emphasis on the parts of the
interview that affected the researchers and that indicated thematic convergences in
line with the objectives and, thus, analytical axes were constructed. The records of
the interviews, as they were reread and analyzed, were enriched with the notes from
the researcher's logbook. Qualitative research studies have reflexivity as
reliability of data, producing changes in the researchers and in their initial
perspectives. In this investigation, this process was conducted by the production of
the logbook, by discussions of the findings with the research group, in the
qualification and defense exam of the master's degree.In order to keep confidentiality in relation to the names of the participants, these
were replaced by the names of famous women in history, namely: Enedina Alves
Marques, Raimunda Putani, Bertha Lutz, Maria da Penha, Chiquinha Gonzaga, Cora
Coralina, Maria Quitéria, Anna Neri, Dandara Palmares. Affections perceived in the
interview and which were described in the logbook were also added to some speech
fragments.The research was submitted to the Research Ethics Committee and approved through the
CAAE 07625519.4.0000.5393 protocol. The Free and Informed Consent Form was signed
after being read and appreciated by the participants, prior to the interviews.
Results
The group was composed by nine women, aged between 30 and 62 years old. Four women
identified themselves as married, one separated, one divorced, two in a stable
relationship and one single. Regarding the profession, three were away from work,
one retired, one was a housewife, one a cleaning lady, one an epilator, one a
seamstress and one a day care worker. Two women had completed elementary school, two
had incomplete elementary school, four had completed high school and only one had
completed higher education.To present the data, we were inspired by Deleuze's ideas about difference and
repetition. This philosophy shows us that, what is known is repetition, and what is
contradicted is the difference16. We seek a
non-Manichean reading, with a view to monitoring the processes experienced by women
with leprosy and herein retold. These are situations related to the female
condition, at the same time that new forms of reinvention and resistance are
triggered every day.The results were therefore organized into three axes: Women with leprosy: Crossroads
between the Skin, the Shape and the Feminine; Earning a living: (Un)achievable work;
State Violence in the Professional Practices.
1. Women with leprosy: Crossroad between the Skin, the Shape and the
Feminine
With leprosy and its treatment, skin transformations are predicted. Such
transformations are strongly cited by the interviewees and understood in
different ways. Furthermore, it is important to pay attention to the fact that
such transformations do not only touch the body, but concern the feminine way of
presenting themselves and the relationships with the body. They also give
visibility to the operation of discriminatory systems, including in relation to
skin color, in their production of significant differences in cultural and
material status.(...) there, [name of the professional] told me, she
played - lowered the voice - she's dark, right?, -
speaking normally - she said: You'll become almost as dark as I am,
laughs, then I said - lowered the voice - there's no
problem (...) (Dandara, shy); Then, there's a serious
problem too, I got black, I'm not that color - pause - the
drugs left me black (...) (Maria Quitéria, incisive).However, what is seen as something negative for some, differently, for others is
seen as something good.(...) and I was pretty much clear and the leprosy treatment also makes
you darker, with a more beautiful color I think laughs gave
a - raises the voice - tanned laughs (Chiquinha);
(...) there is a drug, which still dyes the skin (...) and everyone
thinks I'm tanned from the beach, understood? laughs
(...) (Raimunda).Another aspect mentioned by the interviewees ratifies questions about the
influence of the consumer society, which values a body that resembles those
exposed and evaluated as "desirable". This, in our society, it leads its owner
to have greater satisfaction and high self-esteem. The vain woman is repeated in
the speeches.(...) I liked the short very much (...) And, then, till then I stopped
using... - pause - visits came home, then I'd put on a pair
of pants (...) - lowers the voice - and I was a little bit
dull (...) (Bertha); (...) I stopped taking care of myself,
(...) I didn't do any eyebrows anymore, hair I don't have the courage to
paint, the nails I don't feel like caring anymore, then - raises
the voice - I stopped caring about my looks (...) (Anna,
resigned); (...) all my hair fell out, I had to put on a hair extension.
(...) - lowers the voice - this here is almost all hair
extension (...) - returns to the tone of voice - there is a
colleague of mine (...) she fixed the hair extension and put it on me
(...) (Cora).
2. Earning a Living: (Un)achievable work
Women with leprosy seek financial assistance from beneficiary bodies to continue
their lives. In their speeches, women repeatedly show their concern with
retirement in old age or with the maintenance of some financial gain, given the
limitations presented by the disease.(...) I filed for INSS (...) the lawyer filed an appeal and to conduct
an expert examination through the forum (...) when I did, the expert denied
my case. (...) Then, my lawyer appealed (...) I was paid for7 years, my
benefit was cut now in 2017 (...) - lowers the voice - I
appealed several times, - returns to the tone of voice -
and as I'm not working, how will I pay the INSS (...)
(Dandara); (...) I think I'll get this new law (retirement)
(...) because I'm going to be 57. So, I think I'll get it.
(...) - lowers the voice - But it's good... -
returns to the tone of voice - May the Lord give me strength,
working. (Maria da Penha).Informal domestic work is also a concern.(...) I get cleaning works - lowers the voice - to do.
(...) - returns to the tone of voice - my service here at
home, - lowers the voice - I do it myself. Not even if it
hurts, you must keep on going. (...) - returns to the tone of voice
- the orthopedic doctor said that I couldn't work (...) I was reading,
leprosy gives the right - pause - to sickness or retirement
aid (...) I've contributed many years to the INPS, but at the moment I don't
have a registered labor booklet - lowers the voice.
(...) (Anna).Women report loss of labor, moral and human rights.(...) the day I was going to take the dose sometimes I wasn't going to
work (...) I was a little unwell (...) it happened that one day they fired
me - raises the voice. - returns to the tone of voice -
they never claimed that it was due to some certificate (...) I was
amazed, - raises the voice - I cried (nervous
laughs) (...) Did I do anything wrong? But... no. (...) -
lowers the voice - so, I just think it was because of the disease
(...) (Bertha, sad); (...) when they found out, that
there's no way of not finding out (...) I go to the doctor about three times
a week (...) there was a lesion on my skin (...) I was away for 15 days.
When I came back, they demanded another exam, as if it was an admission
testing (...) the occupational physician refused to return. (...) I'm away
without getting anything. I'm waiting for the government, - raises
the voice - I'm registered, I'm still there (...) - returns to
the tone of voice - without getting a penny. (...) I don't
know...- pause - lowers the voice - what I'm going to do
with my life (...) (Cora).Women also received other means to assist in maintaining the home.Sometimes - pause - I have help from the social worker
(...) - lowers the voice - it's also some help
there. (Enedina); (...) I receive the basket (the
baskets intended for the tuberculosis program of the municipality that are left
are for people who are being treated for leprosy) from there, right? And
my kids get the pension, and my mom and dad help me, and I do a little
something or other, you know? - lowers the voice - it's not
easy (Cora).One of the women reports necessary adaptations to the domestic service, due to
leprosy.(...) - lowers the voice - Polishing a pot, no
more. - returns to the tone of the voice - Today, just
passing a kitchen loofah (...) I stopped doing this, you know, like... with
a lot of - raises the voice - force - returns to
the tone of voice - the service. So, I do lighter. But I can still
do (Anna).
3. State Violence in the Professional Practices
When rights are violated, the search for help is also unattainable. The existence
of nuances of power articulated to the State cuts across the entire social
structure and is present in society, including the interviewed social group. For
example, such nuances are observed in the first moment that follows.(...) talking to the doctor (...) she said - lowers the voice -
wow, but it's going to give you such a headache (...) -
returns to the tone of voice - I will tell you, but you own your life
(...) if I were you - lowers the voice - I wouldn't move
it, it's not worth it, you know? (...) - returns to the tone of
voice - why don't you get sick aid? (...) - raises the voice -
And so I did, you know? And it worked, thanks God. Thanks God, it
worked... there, I didn't even open a process, nor did I, you
know... (Bertha, satisfied).One of the interviewees reports that she suffered domestic violence for a long
time, being physical and psychological aggressions from her then husband,
seeking support for her decision to report him.(...) there is a sister (from the church) who is a
military police officer (...) I said (...) I think I will make a Police
Report. against him (husband). - lowers the voice - Then
she said, I'll give you some advice, don't do it! - returns to the
tone of the voice - Don't do it, because - raises the voice -
I'm in the middle... - returns to the tone of the voice -
they'll treat you badly and something else [name of
ex-husband] will be angry with you and then he will kill you. We will be
paying, and - raises the voice - The Lord -
returns to the tone of voice - is going to solve that situation. Then, I
said okay. - lowers the voice - I don't want his evil.
(...) (Maria da Penha, indifferent, shakes her shoulders).
Discussion
The first axis was entitled "Women with Leprosy: Crossroads between the Skin, the
Shape and the Feminine" and, in it, we approach the concerns of women in relation to
the female body and appearance when affected by leprosy.A territory of concerns opens up for them; and everyday issues, such as how to dress,
the possibility that the others will see the spots and leprosy, gradually shape the
meetings. This same territory, from the experience with leprosy, could open itself
to questioning social impositions as to how to follow a certain female model.The society where we live encourages a close eye on body aesthetics, in most women.
Such evidence is in magazines, television, encouraging and showing that there is a
beauty standard2. Power relations are marked
by discipline. In this sense, the bodies shown here are disciplined by a "normative
imposition" in a manufacturing process of individuals17. Society establishes the doctrines to be followed, and the designed
body is affected by that society in which it is inserted2.An international research study18 refers to
body image as being linked to a mental concept but, above all, it is related to a
social phenomenon. It points out that factors such as Body Mass Index (BMI), social
media, self-esteem, and family relationships, exert pressure on the individuals and
especially on women.One of the interviewees said, "I stopped caring about my looks these days,"
considering that I wasn't cutting my nails or dyeing my hair. We can think of beauty
as an institution, as well as health and language, among many others. Others had
transformations in their appearance, such as hair loss and changes in the way of
dressing, but they reinvented themselves in the face of difficulties, as can be seen
in the "put on some hair extension" statement.With the autonomy of women taking force and being present in several spheres, the
historical system of domination over the woman's body had rearrangements, creating
new ways of maintaining domination over the subjectivity of bodies, one of them
through the fixation of beauty for a certain aesthetic standardization19. For researchers, violence and domination of
the female body are present and intensified today and reinforce the hierarchy
between genders20
-
21.Other authors have also noticed shame and suffering in the report of women affected
by leprosy due to transformations in their bodies, such as spots and functional
transformations2. Leprosy and its
treatment will override the established way of being a woman, with a given
appearance, a given weight, a given skin color. Another overlap is made between the
prejudices triggered by the black skin color (transformation caused by the
treatment) and the disease, as in "the drug made me black".The Brazilian history is composed of centuries of black slavery and the imposition of
white domination22. This subordination left
marks in the social imagination and is expressed in the rejection of the possibility
of having a blackened skin and in the negation of the black in us. Thus, women with
leprosy being treated and with darkened skin gradually overlaps conditions of social
non-acceptance23.The authors24 bring us the idea of serialized
subjectivity, a certain way of being and being in life that befits integrated world
capitalism. In this sense, women in the instituted way must be vain, take care of
their appearance, have no spots, be thin, adding up to a series of impositions that
are sometimes incompatible with being affected by leprosy or even with the condition
of life, including genetics. In this way, health professionals could adopt active
listening to these aspects that generate suffering and isolation. The encounter
between the health professional and the woman with leprosy could constitute a field
for the movement of life power.Every individual is on a plane of consistency, in which they become variable at all
times, affecting each other, according to the relationship that is built, in order
to develop a degree of power, a power to be affected25. We can say that the meetings between professionals and users are not
always powerful. Very often, the clinical reasoning centered on the biological body
does not consider these aspects and naturalizes the transformations of the body,
sometimes for women, a new body. A study26
points out that, even with the determination of the cure, leprosy can still be
present in the body marks, which can lead women to change the way they see their
bodies and change the treatment given to it, in a negative way, relating the new
body with the disease and remembering the past body with a healthy life. This shows
us that, even with the cure, the lives of these women can remain marked, requiring a
reformulation in the way of life.In this way, apathy and rejection find their way into the lives of these women,
although other ways of living are possible, other transformations. The
transformations are made up of escape lines, among which there is the
becoming-a-woman and so many others. Of these, the essences and meanings unfold
according to a more intensive element, in which affections are modulated27. The becoming-a-woman has no need to enter
into the policies of multiculturalism or gender policies; after all, this
transformation can generate new subjectivities that have not yet been taken by
consumerist capitalism, nor by Christian morality27.In the second axis, the participants brought anguish and concerns about remuneration
for maintaining life. The work situations of these women were also observed. There
is a new overlap between social status and leprosy, between jobs performed and
wages, between low schooling and the profession, between disrespected labor rights
and the obligation of domestic work.Corroborating other studies6
,
28, we can also observe that the schooling of
the majority did not exceed high school and, also, the work activities did not
require specific training. As a consequence, we find informal work contracts,
generating absence of benefits, such as sickness benefit and paid leave28. Concomitant to this, it is reasserted that
low schooling can favor losses related to precarious living and health conditions,
aggravating vulnerability to diseases and poverty29
-
30.Considered a neglected disease, leprosy invites us to reflect on elements intrinsic
to this, such as, for example, the relationship between the involvement of
low-income people and the low interest of the technology, equipment and
pharmaceutical industries in the development of measures to solve the problem6
,
30. This great relationship between the
disease and low income indicates that there can be an association with the social
determinants, since leprosy is found in areas with greater pockets of poverty30.Some interviewees sought ways to guarantee sustenance and also had social services,
in addition to the unit where they conduct the treatment, to help with provisions
for the home: "I get the (basic) basket" and "I get help from the social worker". A
new overlap occurs: unfavorable economic condition, female condition and leprosy.
Leprosy is classified as a public health problem, due to its ability to bring
physical, social and economic disabilities31.
People affected by leprosy with lower incomes and lower schooling levels are
susceptible to developing physical disabilities, since there are precarious living
conditions and obstacles to accessing the health service30. When the diagnosis is late, the quality of life of the
affected individuals can change, in view of the potential of leprosy to damage to
the nerves32.One of our interviewees appears to have some involvement of the nerves in her arms,
which makes it difficult to do the job, but does not prevent her from doing it: "Not
even if it hurts, you must keep on going". With access to work in not well-paid
professions, the women interviewed reported experiences of dismissal, loss of
rights. From the working conditions, precarious living conditions emerge, since the
sum of time of private and formal domestic service, in addition to the lack of time
to sleep, generates physical and mental illnesses33. The authors34 assert that the
increase in jobs in situations of precariousness is due to the growth of salaried
jobs without a formal contract and of self-employment. This can culminate in the
violation of rights if the person needs some benefit. In addition, women raised
concerns about retirement and the maintenance of life in their old age.Sometimes, health professionals carry out educational actions to tell users about the
disease, its impacts and treatment. With the theoretical framework that supports
this study, we assert that health education carried out in the instituted manner
reproduces logics and does not change what is happening, as it is based on the idea
that people freely choose their ways of living, choosing for example to eat
healthily, practice sports etc., and that, for such, it is enough to be informed by
some specialist to change the behavior. We believe that people from disadvantaged
social classes will eat what they can, work as they can and survive under the
circumstances imposed by their social conditions.Returning to the idea of transformation, we bet on education as a meeting power for
multiple transformations, a triggering of powers, giving possibility for the
creation of other lines, with the opening of other paths, managing the small
openings in the active organizations35. The
experience of the disease could produce new transformations and reflections on, for
example, the domestic work as women's attribution. Some reported adaptations, for
example, "pots, I don't polish anymore", although they didn't stop washing them. A
study36 states that the more a culture
aims at women within the domestic sphere, the less that group will have
opportunities to achieve equality in any sphere, with respect to men. In the form of
a manifesto, there is the struggle of women for a more just and egalitarian society,
whose representative is the feminist movement37.In the "State Violence in the Professional Practices" axis, we saw situations in
which the State, which manifests itself in the professional practices, in this case
professional medical and police practices, discourages the struggle for access to
women's rights. We consider that the professional practices are not just a set of
techniques and knowledge, they are not neutral practices, but political actions that
carry ideological positions, not assumed as such. Thus, it is through the
professional practices that there is materialization of state violence, which we
consider to be unacceptable and a cause of exclusion and repeated violence against
women.These practices are linked to historical aspects and, in this sense, it is worth
remembering that the history of leprosy is strongly marked by the presence of the
State, determining who should be isolated. Such forms of treatment were established
according to the power lines of the respective historical-cultural moment38. These attitudes culminated in violent
practices to those involved until today, inviting us to reflect on the policies
already established and those to come39
-
40. This context shows the way in which
social constructions, such as those focused on body and gender standards, mark the
lives of people with leprosy. Therefore, the production of their care requires the
consideration of factors such as socioeconomic, cultural, body changes, sexuality
and gender. The participants reported losing their jobs due to the disease. One of
them reports that she talked to the physician, seeking some support regarding the
loss of her job; however, the professional convinced her otherwise. This indicates
that the actions of the State regulate the lives and rights of people affected by
leprosy. Another participant brought an emotional account of a life of violence
caused by her ex-husband. Domestic violence against women contains many factors, but
it is a problem rooted in power relations, as a consequence of gender
inequalities41.State violence is demonstrated by making it difficult to guarantee access to rights
and preventing access to the justice system42. As we have seen, the police contradict the desire of Maria da Penha who
wants to report her husband, at the time, for assault. People affected by leprosy
generally have low incomes, experiencing daily violations of their rights. Against
this background, it is observed that there is little knowledge about their social
security and assistance rights, and there is not always guidance from the health
professionals43
-
44. Sickness benefit and retirement are
social rights conquered and should be accessible to everyone; however,
impossibilities are faced daily by the administrative power, even when there are
records on the precision of law43. The
guarantee and the use of the benefits offered by the State can improve the living
conditions of the person affected by leprosy44. However, we consider that tackling social inequality cannot be
restricted to simple aids with a basic food basket.The history of leprosy has progressed in many ways, but there is a need for
legislative progress as well. It is necessary to guarantee the rights of the current
victims, so that history does not reproduce, in order to maintain inadequate
conditions. We could not fail to report concerns about the current policies in the
country on easing labor rights, recrudescence of retirement rules (with a social
security reform that penalizes women in particular) and unfinancing of public
policies such as the SUS, not only thinking about Brazilian women with leprosy, but
in all the people exposed to diseases and bacteria, as well as many neglects,
machismo and inequalities.The main contribution of the study is to offer reflections on the female condition
and leprosy. Another contribution, no less important, is the approach of the theme
based on the theoretical and methodological framework, which can generate
contributions for the care of women with leprosy.As for the limitations, we point out that, during data production, the care provided
by the nursing team was considered, especially the pre- and post-nursing
consultations, but the care provided by the medical team was not considered. We
consider that these aspects have not been deepened and that they could bring
analytical elements to understand the situation of women with leprosy and their
follow-up. For this reason, we recommend future studies on the theme of women and
leprosy that focus on the relationships between professionals and women, deepening
the reflections produced in this research.
Conclusion
Leprosy interferences in women's lives are shown in the relationship with their
bodies that are already socially modeled, in the relationship with domestic work and
with the means for support. There is an overlap and interference of the female
condition in a patriarchal society with aspects of the history of leprosy and the
prejudice that still accompanies it.The findings show the violations of rights and the ways in which these women have
dealt with them, undergoing reformulations and reinventions. Those are resistance
gestures translated into continuity of actions that ensure daily life and, thus, new
ways of living are being produced, in transformations and facing leprosy. The
reinvention processes permeate the creation of their reception networks, the
maintenance of their own life projects, not giving up facing limiting contexts, the
persistence in the continuity of the treatment of the disease, and the effort in the
search to overcome life's traumas. We bet on the strength of the becoming-a-woman,
inviting health professionals to consider singularities and the context, in order to
produce services that are meetings to assert the power of life.