Yu Liu1, Qingguo Xue1, Haibin Zuo1, Fan Yang1, Xing Peng1, Jingsong Wang1. 1. State Key Laboratory of Advanced Metallurgy, University of Science and Technology Beijing, 30 Xueyuan Road, Haidian District, Beijing 100083 P. R. China.
Abstract
Herein, the influences of CO2 dilution, N2 dilution, and CO2/N2 (in which half of the N2 is replaced by CO2) dilution on the combustion characteristics of a turbulent, partially premixed CO/H2-air flame were experimentally investigated in terms of the flame structure, flame temperature, and CO and CO2 concentrations in flames. TDLAS (tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy) technique and an infrared gas analyzer were used for such purposes. CO2 dilution not only increases more momentum but also reduces the reaction rate. This results in a much longer flame length than that under N2 dilution. Compared with N2 dilution, the L H (axial length of the high-temperature reaction zone) values for the same levels of CO2 dilution and CO2/N2 dilution are much longer. The highest CO concentration in the CO2 diluted flame is higher than that in the CO/H2 flame and that in the CO2/N2 diluted flame is higher than in that the N2 diluted flame. The sizes of the main chemical reaction zone in CO2 and CO2/N2 diluted flames are larger than that in the N2 diluted flame. The inflection points in the rates of variation of the flame temperature and the CO and CO2 concentrations verify that CO2 dilution creates lower intensities and lower rates of chemical reactions, compared with N2 dilution.
Herein, the influences of CO2 dilution, N2 dilution, and CO2/N2 (in which half of the N2 is replaced by CO2) dilution on the combustion characteristics of a turbulent, partially premixed CO/H2-air flame were experimentally investigated in terms of the flame structure, flame temperature, and CO and CO2 concentrations in flames. TDLAS (tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy) technique and an infrared gas analyzer were used for such purposes. CO2 dilution not only increases more momentum but also reduces the reaction rate. This results in a much longer flame length than that under N2 dilution. Compared with N2 dilution, the L H (axial length of the high-temperature reaction zone) values for the same levels of CO2 dilution and CO2/N2 dilution are much longer. The highest CO concentration in the CO2 diluted flame is higher than that in the CO/H2 flame and that in the CO2/N2 diluted flame is higher than in that the N2 diluted flame. The sizes of the main chemical reaction zone in CO2 and CO2/N2 diluted flames are larger than that in the N2 diluted flame. The inflection points in the rates of variation of the flame temperature and the CO and CO2 concentrations verify that CO2 dilution creates lower intensities and lower rates of chemical reactions, compared with N2 dilution.
With the development of
industry, the consumption of fossil fuels
such as coal, petroleum, and natural gas increases while the problem
of the efficient utilization of energy arises.[1−3] Coal is the
most important energy in China. To realize the efficient and clean
utilization of coal resources, it is one of the most effective technological
approaches to apply the coal gasification technology to obtain producer
gas.[4,5] The main combustible components of producer
gas are CO and H2 while the noncombustible components are
CO2 and N2.[6,7] The producer
gas in industries is usually mixed with water gas and mainly used
as the fuel for heating furnaces, heat treatment furnaces, and IGCC
system boilers.[8−10] Due to the sensitivity of producer gas to the variety
of coal or biomass sources and the gasification process, its components
are not constant, which may make great effects on the combustion characteristics
of producer gas.To get the fundamental understanding of the
combustion characteristics
of the H2/CO flame, some investigations are performed to
measure the laminar flame speed with different CO to H2 ratios or under high pressure.[11−17] CO2 and N2 are the main dilutions for the
H2/CO mixture and have great effects on the combustion
characteristics. Furthermore, the addition of CO2 in the
fuel simulates the EGR (exhaust gas recirculation) system which reduces
the cost of CCS (carbon capture and storage) and the pollution of
NO[18,19] Thus, it is
essential and economical to study the effects of CO2 and
N2 dilution on flames. It has been proved that CO2 dilution significantly influences the flame speed, flame stability,
flame structure, and heat release characteristics of laminar H2/CO, H2/N2, CH4/O2, and MTHF flames.[20−28] The effects of CO2 dilution on the flame characteristics,
flame structure, emissions, temperature, and flame dynamics in turbulent
CH4/air, CO/H2/CO2, H2/O2, and CH4/H2 flames were also
discussed.[29−35] On the other hand, the impacts of N2 dilution on the
flame characteristics have been analyzed in some investigations and
their results were mainly related to the burning velocity, flame stability,
flame structure, and flame chemiluminescence in laminar CH4/air and H2/CO flames.[36−43] The addition of CO2 has effects on the flame structure
in H2/CO2/N2 and H2/O2 counterflow diffusion flames.[44,45] Furthermore,
the effects of the stagnation plate, flame temperature, and fuel properties
on the combustion characteristics and emissions of diffusion flames
were experimentally studied.[46−48] In most of the aforementioned
studies, the flame structure, flame stability, and flame speed are
the most important parameters for the combustion characteristics of
CO2 diluted laminar or turbulent premixed flames and N2 diluted laminar premixed flames. In a variety of industrial
heating applications, the flame temperature, species concentration,
and flame length of nonpremixed or partly premixed flames in a turbulent
industrial burner are mainly of concern.The flame temperature
and species concentration in flames are important
for combustion since they characterize the combustion process. The
measurements of flame temperature and species concentration in the
turbulent burner of industrial furnaces are significant for monitoring
the high-temperature zone and verify some reaction mechanisms under
a complex combustion environment. Tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy
(TDLAS) is a novel developed real-time online detection technique
providing high sensitivity, fast response, and high precision, which
has been utilized for temperature and species concentration measurement
in flames.[49−52] In the previous study of the present authors, a combustion diagnostic
system based on TDLAS was developed and used to measure the flame
temperature in turbulent partly premixed CO/CO2 and CO/CO2/H2 flames, which simulates the combustion of converter
gas in an industrial burner.[53]In
the current work, rather than premixing fuel gas and air, the
fuel was partially premixed with air in a turbulent industrial burner.
Three dilutions including N2, CO2, and CO2/N2 (in which half of the N2 was replaced
by CO2) were added to the fuel gas (CO/H2 mixture)
to simulate the combustion of producer gas and water gas and investigate
their impacts on the flame characteristics. To identify the effects
of different dilutions, the flame structure, flame temperature, CO,
and CO2 concentrations in flames were studied experimentally.
To analyze the effects caused by the different dilutions, the differences
in the corresponding flame length, the abrupt change in the high-temperature
zone, and the inflection points in the derivatives of temperature
and concentrations were discussed.
Experimental
Section
Combustion Diagnostic System Based on TDLAS
In this study, the combustion diagnostic system, which is shown
in Figure , is utilized
to investigate the flame structure, flame temperature, and CO2 concentration in flames.
Figure 1
Schematic diagram of the combustion diagnostic
system.[54] Reprinted with permission from
[Liu et al.]:[Springer
Nature].
Schematic diagram of the combustion diagnostic
system.[54] Reprinted with permission from
[Liu et al.]:[Springer
Nature].The CO, H2, CO2, and N2 gases
are supplied by gas cylinders from Praxair with purity of 99.9, 99.999,
99.999, and 99.999%, respectively. The oxidant gas is offered by an
air compressor (Soret Gas Equipment KS-75A), while a refrigeration
dryer (FLD-1D) is used as the supporting equipment to eliminate the
effects of water vapor in the compressed air. The flow rates of air
and fuel are controlled by mass flow controllers (MFCs) with an accuracy
of ±1% S.P. and displayed on the operating screen together with
the pressure.A turbulent partly premixed industrial burner
is shown in Figure . The gas and air
are partly premixed in a cup and then ignited by an electric ignition
device. The further mixing of gas and air and the beginning of combustion
reactions occurs in the zone between the spark and nozzle.
Figure 2
Structure of
the turbulent partly premixed industrial burner.[54] Reprinted with permission from [Liu et al.]:[Springer
Nature]. The burner sleeve inside the combustion chamber has a length
of 250 mm. The ignition place is 150 mm apart from the nozzle.
Structure of
the turbulent partly premixed industrial burner.[54] Reprinted with permission from [Liu et al.]:[Springer
Nature]. The burner sleeve inside the combustion chamber has a length
of 250 mm. The ignition place is 150 mm apart from the nozzle.The laser diode controller, DFB laser, combiner,
and splitter are
used to generate two beams of lights of specific wavelengths. The
detector and the BNC adapter convert the received optical signal into
an electrical signal and transmit it to the data processing center
on the computer, while the other BNC adapter linked to the laser diode
controller synchronizes the output signal with the input signal. The
integrating sphere (THORLABS IS200-4) between the laser probe and
the detector is used to reduce the error caused by the nonuniform
distribution of the incident light source or the beam deviation, resulting
in more reliable measurement results. The internal structure of the
integrating sphere is shown in Figure . In the current work, the measurement error of the
flame temperature and CO2 concentration is within ±2%
F.S.
Figure 3
Internal structure of the integrating sphere.[54] Reprinted with permission from [Liu et al.]:[Springer Nature].
The integrating sphere has an inner wall coated with the material
with the diffuse reflection coefficient close to 1.0. Several apertures
are opened as the input port of light and the reception port of the
detector. The light inside the sphere is reflected many times through
the inner wall, forming a light with uniform distribution.
Internal structure of the integrating sphere.[54] Reprinted with permission from [Liu et al.]:[Springer Nature].
The integrating sphere has an inner wall coated with the material
with the diffuse reflection coefficient close to 1.0. Several apertures
are opened as the input port of light and the reception port of the
detector. The light inside the sphere is reflected many times through
the inner wall, forming a light with uniform distribution.
TDLAS Theory: Two-Line Direct Absorption Spectroscopy
TDLAS is governed by the law of Beer–Lambert.[55] The fractional transmission can be expressed
as eq ,where I0 and I are the incident and
transmitted laser
intensity, P is the static pressure, L is the gas medium length, S(T)
is the line strength of the transition, which is only a function of
temperature, Φ(υ) is the line shape function, and X is the concentration of the absorbing gas. The line shape
function Φ(υ) represents the relative light intensity
of the unit frequency interval. The area underneath the line shape
function is normalized so that ∫–∞+∞Φ(υ)dυ = 1.
The integrated absorbance across the absorption feature can be obtained
by eq ,Species concentration X can
be obtained using eq ,For the temperature
measurement in two-line direct absorption spectroscopy,
the flame temperature can be achieved by comparing the line strength
of two different transitions with different temperature dependences.[56] The line strength S(T) can be expressed according to the known line strength
at a reference temperature T0, which is
defined by eq ,[50]where Q(T) is the molecular partition
function, E″ is the lower-state
energy, c is the speed of light, h is Planck’s constant,
and k is Boltzmann’s constant.The temperature
can be deduced from the measurement of the integrated
absorbance ratio for two different temperature-dependent transitions,
and the ratio of these two integrals is given by eq ,where Pabs is the partial pressure of
the absorbing species, S(T0, v) is the line strength of the transition
centered at v for the reference temperature T0, and T is the temperature
of the gas
which can be obtained using eq ,The quantity hc/k has a numerical value of 1.438 cm·K. A1 and A2 are the
integrated areas of the absorption lines.In this work, the
two absorption lines are determined based on
the following rules:[57]Both lines
need sufficient absorption over the selected temperature
range.The absorption ratio should be single-valued with temperature,
and the line strengths of the two lines should be similar.The
two lines should have sufficiently different lower state energies E″ to yield an absorption ratio that is sensitive
to the probed temperature.The two lines should be free of significant
interference from nearby
transitions.The two lines are desired to have the same line
shape function.The two lines are close enough to be scanned
by a single laser.To select two suitable absorption lines,
the plotted spectral simulation
of the chosen absorption lines (P = 1 atm, X = 10%, and L = 45 mm) is shown in Figure using the HITRAN
database. As H2O is one product of the CO/H2–air flame, the absorption lines of H2O are also
illustrated in Figure to choose the absorption lines with the strong absorbance of CO2 and weak absorbance of H2O. To guarantee the high
signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and minimal interference from ambient
water vapor, the strong absorbance of CO2 and high-temperature
sensitivity are required. Considering the rules and requirements above,
the spectral lines of 1996.89 and 2004.02 nm (marked in Figure ) are chosen as light beams
to probe the absorption of CO2. The lower state energy
(E″) for 1996.89 nm is 994.19 cm-1 and the E″ for 2004.02 nm is 106.13 cm–1.
Figure 4
Simulation of the CO2 and H2O absorption
lines at different temperatures.[54] Reprinted
with permission from [Liu et al.]:[Springer Nature].
Simulation of the CO2 and H2O absorption
lines at different temperatures.[54] Reprinted
with permission from [Liu et al.]:[Springer Nature].
Operating Conditions and Data Analysis
In this study, experiments were carried out under several different
conditions, as shown in Table . High purity CO2, N2, and CO2/N2 (in which half of the N2 was replaced by
CO2) were used as different diluents in CO/H2 gas. In Table , Q is the flow rate of different gases, V% represents the volume fractions of CO, H2, CO2, and N2 in their mixtures, Φ is
the equivalence ratio, and D is the dilution.
Table 1
Combustion Conditions Used in This
Study (Cases 1 to 13)
case
Qfuel
QCO
VCO%
QH2
VH2%
QDCO2
VCO2%
QDN2
VCO2%
Qair
Φ
L/min
L/min
%
L/min
%
L/min
%
L/min
%
L/min
1
37.0
28
76
9
24
0
0
0
0
300
0.29
2
40.2
28
70
9
22
3.2
8
0
0
300
0.29
3
44.0
28
64
9
20
7.0
16
0
0
300
0.29
4
48.6
28
58
9
19
11.6
24
0
0
300
0.29
5
54.4
28
51
9
17
17.4
32
0
0
300
0.29
6
40.2
28
70
9
22
0
0
3.2
8
300
0.29
7
44.0
28
64
9
20
0
0
7.0
16
300
0.29
8
48.6
28
58
9
19
0
0
11.6
24
300
0.29
9
54.4
28
51
9
17
0
0
17.4
32
300
0.29
10
40.2
28
70
9
22
1.6
4
1.6
4
300
0.29
11
44.0
28
64
9
20
3.5
8
3.5
8
300
0.29
12
48.6
28
58
9
19
5.8
12
5.8
12
300
0.29
13
54.4
28
51
9
17
8.7
16
8.7
16
300
0.29
The CO
concentration in the flame was sampled and measured using
an infrared gas analyzer with the linearity error of ±2% F.S.
(IGS-09S, Beijing Stead Automation Equipment., Ltd). The flame temperature
and CO2 concentration in the flame were measured using
two-line scanned-wavelength direct absorption spectroscopy. The scanning
rate of the laser is 2 × 106 Hz, and the signal frequency
was 100 Hz. To obtain sufficiently accurate results, 2 × 106 signal-shots were averaged for each position. Thirty positions
along the axial direction at the burner centerline were selected for
the temperature measurements, while 15 positions were used for CO2 concentration measurements.Figures and 6 show the representative
measurements (Plot 0) of
the absorption spectra of CO2 along with the corresponding
Voigt-fitting profiles (Plot 1). The CO2 absorption in
this section was calculated from the difference between the CO2 absorption of the environment and the flame to reduce the
influence of the surroundings. The instability of the turbulent flame
led to the deviations between the measurements and the Voigt-fitting.
Plot 2 shows the residuals of the two plots, which represent the normalized
difference between the measured data and the Voigt-fitting profile.
Higher residuals indicate that the turbulent flame fluctuated violently.
Figure 5
Measured
absorption spectra of CO2 at 1996.89 nm near
1100 K. The Voigt fit to the experimental data is plotted for comparison,
along with the residuals.
Figure 6
Measured
absorption spectra of CO2 at 2004.02 nm near
1100 K. The Voigt fit to the experimental data is plotted for comparison,
along with the residuals.
Measured
absorption spectra of CO2 at 1996.89 nm near
1100 K. The Voigt fit to the experimental data is plotted for comparison,
along with the residuals.Measured
absorption spectra of CO2 at 2004.02 nm near
1100 K. The Voigt fit to the experimental data is plotted for comparison,
along with the residuals.
Results and Discussions
Flame
Structure
The lean fuel combustion
was studied by maintaining an equivalence ratio of 0.29. Then, a turbulent
partially premixed burner was utilized to simulate the combustion
in industrial furnaces. Finally, three diluents, CO2, N2, and CO2/N2 (in which half of the N2 was replaced by CO2) were added to the fuel gas
(CO/H2 mixture) to simulate the combustion of producer
gas and water gas. The flow rates of air, CO, and H2 were
kept constant and the volume fractions of the diluents were raised
from 8 to 32%. Images of the flames were captured using a camera.
The camera was set at the side of the flame with an exposure of 1/10
s. As can be seen in Figure , overall the flames comprised a bright blue zone followed
by a purple-orange zone. The bright blue zone resulted from the entrainment
of the fuel gas mixed with air while the purple-orange zone indicated
the existence of soot particles. As the flame diameters derived by
image processing software ranged 38–40 mm, the flame diameters
changed little following the addition of the diluents. Comparing the
images of the CO/H2 flame and the flame with 32% dilution,
this change is very obvious.
Figure 7
Variations in the lean fuel flame structure
with different diluents
((a) CO2 dilution, (b) N2 dilution, and (c)
CO2/N2 dilution).
Variations in the lean fuel flame structure
with different diluents
((a) CO2 dilution, (b) N2 dilution, and (c)
CO2/N2 dilution).Figure shows that
the flame length increased with the increasing dilution. Compared
with N2 dilution, the flame length under CO2 dilution was longer. The flame length under CO/N2 dilution
was between the two diluents above. In this study, the flame length
was defined as the distance between the nozzle and the highest point
along the axial flame; this was obtained by measuring the visible
length of the flame. Figure shows flame lengths derived by image processing software
which are calculated by averaging the flame lengths of 20 images,
and the mathematical relationship between the flame length and dilution
ratio obtained by Origin software. The increasing rate of the flame
length, , was denoted as , where the amount of increase in the flame
length, ΔLf, was calculated as ΔLf = LD – L0. Here, LD is the
flame length for each variation of the diluent, L0 is the length of the CO/H2 flame (98 mm),
and VD% is the volume fraction of each
variation of the diluent. ΔLf and are presented
in Table . Figure and Table indicate that, compared with
the dilution of N2, both of ΔLf and for the CO2 and CO2/N2 diluted flames were larger. As it was difficult to
predict the mixing degree of CO/H2 and the diluent in the
turbulent partially premixed burner, investigations into the flame
speed in the turbulent premixed flame, (),[58] and the
flame height in the turbulent jet diffusion flame, (),[59] were not
sufficient to determine how the diluent affected the flame length.
In this study, the flow rates of CO, H2, and air were kept
constant and the amount of each diluent was equivalent; the only variable
was the momentum. According to the momentum formula , the total flow rate, v, and area, S, were kept constant, whereas the density
of the mixed gas varied with each different diluent. As the density
of CO2 (1.98 g/L) at normal atmospheric temperature is
greater than that of N2 (1.25 g/L), the increase in momentum
following CO2 dilution was higher than that for dilution
with an equivalent amount of N2, thus resulting in a longer
flame length.
Figure 8
Flame lengths and the mathematical relationship between
the flame
length and dilution ratio for different diluents.
Table 2
ΔLf and for Different
Diluents and Levels of Dilution
dilution
CO2
N2
CO2/N2
volume fraction
(%)
8
16
24
32
8
16
24
32
8
16
24
32
ΔLf (mm)
9
22
38
57
4
12
23
36
6
16
29
45
1.12
1.37
1.58
1.78
0.50
0.75
0.96
1.12
0.75
1.00
1.21
1.41
Flame lengths and the mathematical relationship between
the flame
length and dilution ratio for different diluents.Unlike flame propagation
kinetics, chemical reactions are related
to the equilibria in the thermodynamic reactions. First, N2 does not participate in the reactions in flames in the range of
1200 K, meaning that it only diluted the reactants and affected the
chemical reaction kinetics in flames. CO2 is an important
product of CO/H2 flames. The effects of CO2 dilution
were compared to those of N2 dilution to estimate the influences
of kinetic factors and then the effects of the variation of thermodynamic
reactions caused by CO2 dilution on the chemical reaction
rate and flame length. Considering 32% N2 (17.4 L/min)
dilution as an example, according to the momentum formula , as the momentum increases caused by the
two diluents were equal, the calculated CO2 addition amount
was 13.8 L/min and the dilution ratio was 27%. Assuming that CO2 dilution only affected the momentum change, the flame length
obtained under 27% CO2 dilution should have been the same
as that under 32% N2 dilution. However, the flame length
obtained under a CO2 dilution ratio of 24% had exceeded
the flame length of that under 32% N2 dilution. The main
chemical reactions in the CO/H2 flame that could be affected
by CO2 dilution are CO + OH = CO2 + H (1) and
CO +O2 = CO2 (2).[60] Under the condition of lean fuel combustion, there was sufficient
O2. The flow rates of air, CO, and H2 were kept
constant in this study. This implies that CO, O2, H, and
OH were not the factors affecting the progress of chemical reactions.
This indicates that CO2 dilution inhibited the chemical
reactions in the flame, which reduced the reaction rate and increased
the flame length.
Flame Temperature
The flame temperature
and its change in the high-temperature zone have a great influence
on the performance of industrial furnaces. In this work, the temperature
distributions along the flame axial centerline were measured under
several different conditions (Case 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11,
and 13).Figure shows the flame temperature distribution along the centerline of
the flame axis as the amount of each diluent was increased. As the
amount of each diluent increased, the flame temperature decreased.
This occurred due to the dilution effect of the diluent on the reactants,
which reduced the intensity of the reaction and the heat release.
The highest flame temperatures for each diluent are listed in Table . TH is the highest temperature recorded in each flame. Under
CO2 dilution, the flame temperature was much lower than
that with the same amount of N2, whereas the flame temperature
under CO2/N2 dilution was between the two. Since
the specific heat of CO2 at normal atmospheric temperature
is higher than that of N2, the mixed gas under 16 and 32%
CO2 dilution will absorb more heat, resulting in the flame
temperature 2 and 5 K higher than that under N2 dilution
theoretically, respectively. In addition, CO2 dilution
is not conducive to the exothermic reaction of CO oxidation, which
will also reduce the intensity of the reaction, resulting in a lower
flame temperature.
Figure 9
Centerline flame temperature distributions under different
diluents
and different levels of dilution.
Table 3
TH under Different Dilutions
of CO2, N2, and CO2/N2
flame
CO/H2
CO/H2/CO2
CO/H2/N2
CO/H2/CO2/N2
dilution
none
CO2
N2
CO2/N2
VD (%)
none
8
16
24
32
8
16
24
32
16
32
TH (K)
1228
1202
1167
1123
1064
1218
1195
1168
1135
1181
1092
Centerline flame temperature distributions under different
diluents
and different levels of dilution.Taking the derivative of the flame temperature
by Origin software, the rate of variation of the temperature at different
positions in the axial direction was obtained, as shown in Figure . It is interesting
to note that as the axial distance increased, two inflection points
appeared in the derivative of the flame temperature. In this work,
the inflection point was defined as the point where there was a significant
difference in the temperature variation rate. At the first point,
the flame temperature reached the peak value, and the intensity and
rate of the chemical reaction in the flame both reached their maximums.
The temperature variation rate dropped sharply at the other point,
indicating rapid decreases in the chemical reaction intensity and
reaction rate. The variation rate from the second point to the flame
front tended to stabilize, indicating that the temperature variation
was mainly affected by air dilution. Although other inflection points
were observed for Case 1, 2, and 6, these were caused by the rapid
temperature decrease from the flame to the exhaust zone. According
to the flame temperature and its variation rate, the flame could be
divided into two parts in this study. The area before the second inflection
point was defined as the high-temperature reaction zone, meaning that
nearly all fuel was consumed and almost all chemical reactions were
completed. The subsequent area was defined as the postcombustion zone
as no major reaction occurred. The high-temperature reaction zone
increased following the addition of diluents. The axial length of
the high-temperature reaction zone (LH) and variations in LH are presented
in Table . Compared
with under N2 dilution, the LH was longer under identical levels of CO2 and CO2/N2. This indicates that the intensities and rates of
the chemical reactions in flames under CO2 dilution were
lower than those under N2 dilution. To verify the effects
of CO2 on the chemical reactions and understand the reaction
process, the species concentrations in these flames are discussed
in the next section.
Figure 10
Derivative to the flame temperature under different diluents
and
levels of dilution.
Table 4
LH for
Each Dilution and Levels of Dilution
flame
CO/H2
CO/H2/CO2
CO/H2/N2
CO/H2/CO2/N2
dilution
none
CO2
N2
CO2/N2
VD (%)
none
8
16
24
32
8
16
24
32
16
32
LH (mm)
98
112
126
140
161
98
105
119
133
119
147
Derivative to the flame temperature under different diluents
and
levels of dilution.
CO and CO2 Concentration in Flames
Species
concentrations in flames are important parameters for characterizing
the combustion process. In this work, the CO and CO2 concentrations
along the axial direction at the flame centerline under several different
conditions (Case 1, 3, 7, and 11) were measured. The effects of the
three diluents on CO and CO2 concentrations and their variations
were investigated.Figure shows the comparison of CO and CO2 concentration
distributions along the flame axial centerline. The CO concentration
reached its peak at the outlet of the burner, while the profile of
the CO2 concentration distribution was similar to a Gaussian
curve. The highest CO concentration (CH) values in the undiluted and diluted flames are presented in Table . Theoretically, the
CO concentration should have decreased under the three different diluents.
However, the CH measured in the CO2 diluted flame was higher than in the CO/H2 flame,
and the CH measured in the CO2/N2 diluted flame was higher than that in the N2 diluted flame. The addition of CO2 inhibited the oxidation
of CO to CO2, increasing the CO concentration.
Figure 11
CO and CO2 concentration distributions along the flame
axial centerline for different diluents and different levels of dilution.
Table 5
CH Values
in Flames for Different Diluents and Different Levels of Dilution
flame
CO/H2
CO/H2/CO2
CO/H2/N2
CO/H2/CO2/N2
dilution
none
CO2
N2
CO2/N2
VD (%)
none
16
16
16
CH (%)
38.24
41.78
28.62
31.93
CO and CO2 concentration distributions along the flame
axial centerline for different diluents and different levels of dilution.There
were two inflection points in the distributions of CO and
CO2 concentrations in flames with different diluents. By
evaluating the derivatives of the CO and CO2 concentrations,
the variation rates of the CO and CO2 concentrations at
different positions along the flame axial direction were obtained,
as shown in Figure . The variation rate of CO concentration
decreased first in the N2 (16%) and CO2/N2 (8%/8%) diluted flames, while that of the CO2 concentration
increased first. Both variation rates then flattened. The inflection
points were in the mutation region of the variation rate. Following
dilution with CO2 (16%), the profile of CO2 concentration
variation rate was identical to those of the other two diluted flames,
while the variation rate of the CO concentration decreased at the
burner outlet. This was due to the inhibition of high CO2 concentration on CO oxidation, which reduced the chemical reaction
intensity. In the zone before the two inflection points, the CO and
CO2 concentrations varied drastically, indicating that
strong CO oxidation reactions were occurring in the flame. As the
intensity of the chemical reaction then became very low, variations
in CO and CO2 concentrations in this zone were mainly affected
by air dilution, which stabilized their variation rates. Since the
interval distance between the concentration measurement positions
was 14 mm, the inflection point was located in the area 14 mm before
the mutation point, as marked in Figure and presented in Table . PIP is the distance between
the inflection point and nozzle, which can be defined as the size
of the main reaction zone. The PIP under
pure CO2 dilution was larger than that under N2 dilution. When 50% of the N2 was replaced with CO2, the PIP was also larger than
that under pure N2 dilution. The sizes of the main chemical
reaction zone in the CO2 and CO2/N2 diluted flames were larger than that of N2 dilution.
This indicates that CO2 dilution had a lower intensity
and rate of the chemical reactions in flames, compared with that under
N2 dilution. In addition, the inflection points for flame
temperature were also in the mutation areas for the CO and CO2 concentrations, which verified the effect of CO2 on the chemical reactions.
Figure 12
Derivatives of CO and CO2 concentrations for different
diluents and different levels of dilution.
Table 6
PIP Values
for Different Diluents and Different Levels of Dilution
flame
CO/H2
CO/H2/CO2
CO/H2/N2
CO/H2/CO2/N2
dilution
none
CO2
N2
CO2/N2
VD (%)
none
16
16
16
PIP (mm)
84–98
112–126
98–112
112–126
Derivatives of CO and CO2 concentrations for different
diluents and different levels of dilution.
Conclusions
Inert gases can significantly influence the combustion characteristics
of industrial gases. In this study, the effects of using different
diluents in a turbulent partially premixed CO/H2–air
flame were experimentally investigated. The effects of CO2, N2, and CO2/N2 dilution were determined
in terms of the flame structure, flame temperature, and CO and CO2 concentrations in the flames. The flame temperature and CO2 concentration were measured along the axial direction at
the flames’ centerline using the TDLAS technique, by employing
the spectral lines of 1996.89 and 2004.02 nm, respectively. The CO
concentration was measured using an infrared gas analyzer. The major
results of this investigation are as follows:The flame length increased with increasing
levels of dilution for each diluent, owing to the increasing momentum.
The flame length was longer under CO2 dilution than that
under the same level of N2 dilution. As CO2 has
a higher density than N2 at normal atmospheric temperature
and inhibits chemical reactions in the flame, CO2 dilution
not only increases more momentum but also reduces the reaction rate,
thus resulting in a much longer flame length than that for N2 dilution.The flame
temperature decreased with
increasing levels of dilution. The highest flame temperature under
CO2 dilution was much lower than that under the same level
of N2 dilution. Compared with N2 dilution, the LH values under the same levels of CO2 and CO2/N2 dilution were much longer. These
results indicate that the intensities and rates of the chemical reactions
in the flames under CO2 dilution were lower than those
under N2 dilution.The highest CO concentration in the
CO2 diluted flame was higher than that in the CO/H2 flame and that in the CO2/N2 diluted
flame was higher than that in the N2 diluted flame. The
sizes of the main chemical reaction zone in the CO2 and
CO2/N2 diluted flames were larger than that
under N2 dilution. The addition of CO2 inhibited
the oxidation of CO to CO2, increasing CO concentration.There were inflection points
in the rates of variation of the flame
temperature, CO concentration, and CO2 concentration in
flames; these points were nearly in the same position. This is the
validation of the effects of CO2 dilution on the flame
temperature and species concentration in flames.