Steven Wyatt1, Mohammed A Mohammed2,3, Elizabeth Fisher4, Ruth McConkey5, Peter Spilsbury2. 1. The Strategy Unit, NHS Midlands and Lancashire Commissioning Support Unit, . Kingston House, 438-450 High Street, West Bromwich, West Midlands B70 9LD, UK. 2. The Strategy Unit, NHS Midlands and Lancashire Commissioning Support Unit, West Bromwich, West Midlands UK. 3. Faculty of Health Studies, University of Bradford, Bradford, UK. 4. The Nuffield Trust, London, UK. 5. The Health Foundation, London, UK.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The SARS-CoV-2 outbreak and associated lockdown measures have challenged healthcare. We examine how attendances to ED in England were impacted. METHODS: Interrupted time series regression (January 2019 to June 2020) of data from EDs in 41 English NHS Trusts was used to estimate the initial decrease in attendances and the rate of increase following an interruption from 11 March - 7 April 2020, which included the 23 March lockdown in England. FINDINGS: The SARS-CoV-2 interruption led to an initial 51.1% reduction (95% CI 46.3-55.9%) in ED attendances followed by a linear increase in attendances of 3.0% per week (95% CI 2.5-3.5%). Significantly larger initial reductions were seen in those aged 0-19 years (69.1%), Indian (64.9%), Pakistani (71.8%), Bangladeshi (75.3%), African (63.5%) and Chinese people (74.5%), self-conveying attendees (60.3%) and those presenting with contusions or abrasions (66.9%), muscle and tendon injuries (65.6%), and those with a diagnosis that was not classifiable (72.7%). Significantly smaller initial reductions were seen in those aged 65-74 years (42.6%), 75+ years (40.1%), those conveyed by ambulance (31.9%), and those presenting with the following conditions: central nervous system (44.9%), haematological (44.0%), cardiac (43.7%), gastrointestinal (43.4%), gynaecological (43.2%), psychiatric (40.4%), poisoning (39.7%), cerebro-vascular (39.0%), endocrinological (36.1%), other vascular (34.6%), and maxillo-facial (19.7%). No significant differences in the initial reduction of activity were seen in subgroups defined by sex, deprivation, urbanicity or acuity. INTERPRETATION: The SARS-CoV-2 outbreak and lockdown substantially reduced ED activity. The reduction varied by age groups, ethnicity, arrival mode and diagnostic group but not by sex, deprivation, urbanicity or acuity. FUNDING: No funding to declare.
BACKGROUND: The SARS-CoV-2 outbreak and associated lockdown measures have challenged healthcare. We examine how attendances to ED in England were impacted. METHODS: Interrupted time series regression (January 2019 to June 2020) of data from EDs in 41 English NHS Trusts was used to estimate the initial decrease in attendances and the rate of increase following an interruption from 11 March - 7 April 2020, which included the 23 March lockdown in England. FINDINGS: The SARS-CoV-2 interruption led to an initial 51.1% reduction (95% CI 46.3-55.9%) in ED attendances followed by a linear increase in attendances of 3.0% per week (95% CI 2.5-3.5%). Significantly larger initial reductions were seen in those aged 0-19 years (69.1%), Indian (64.9%), Pakistani (71.8%), Bangladeshi (75.3%), African (63.5%) and Chinese people (74.5%), self-conveying attendees (60.3%) and those presenting with contusions or abrasions (66.9%), muscle and tendon injuries (65.6%), and those with a diagnosis that was not classifiable (72.7%). Significantly smaller initial reductions were seen in those aged 65-74 years (42.6%), 75+ years (40.1%), those conveyed by ambulance (31.9%), and those presenting with the following conditions: central nervous system (44.9%), haematological (44.0%), cardiac (43.7%), gastrointestinal (43.4%), gynaecological (43.2%), psychiatric (40.4%), poisoning (39.7%), cerebro-vascular (39.0%), endocrinological (36.1%), other vascular (34.6%), and maxillo-facial (19.7%). No significant differences in the initial reduction of activity were seen in subgroups defined by sex, deprivation, urbanicity or acuity. INTERPRETATION: The SARS-CoV-2 outbreak and lockdown substantially reduced ED activity. The reduction varied by age groups, ethnicity, arrival mode and diagnostic group but not by sex, deprivation, urbanicity or acuity. FUNDING: No funding to declare.
Authors: Helen I McDonald; Elise Tessier; Joanne M White; Matthew Woodruff; Charlotte Knowles; Chris Bates; John Parry; Jemma L Walker; J Anthony Scott; Liam Smeeth; Joanne Yarwood; Mary Ramsay; Michael Edelstein Journal: Euro Surveill Date: 2020-05
Authors: Marion M Mafham; Enti Spata; Raphael Goldacre; Dominic Gair; Paula Curnow; Mark Bray; Sam Hollings; Chris Roebuck; Chris P Gale; Mamas A Mamas; John E Deanfield; Mark A de Belder; Thomas F Luescher; Tom Denwood; Martin J Landray; Jonathan R Emberson; Rory Collins; Eva J A Morris; Barbara Casadei; Colin Baigent Journal: Lancet Date: 2020-07-14 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Patrick J Lillie; Anda Samson; Ang Li; Kate Adams; Richard Capstick; Gavin D Barlow; Nicholas Easom; Eve Hamilton; Peter J Moss; Adam Evans; Monica Ivan; Yusri Taha; Christopher J A Duncan; Matthias L Schmid Journal: J Infect Date: 2020-02-28 Impact factor: 6.072
Authors: Elizabeth J Williamson; Alex J Walker; Krishnan Bhaskaran; Seb Bacon; Chris Bates; Caroline E Morton; Helen J Curtis; Amir Mehrkar; David Evans; Peter Inglesby; Jonathan Cockburn; Helen I McDonald; Brian MacKenna; Laurie Tomlinson; Ian J Douglas; Christopher T Rentsch; Rohini Mathur; Angel Y S Wong; Richard Grieve; David Harrison; Harriet Forbes; Anna Schultze; Richard Croker; John Parry; Frank Hester; Sam Harper; Rafael Perera; Stephen J W Evans; Liam Smeeth; Ben Goldacre Journal: Nature Date: 2020-07-08 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Megan Cox; Georgina Phillips; Rob Mitchell; Lisa-Maree Herron; Sarah Körver; Deepak Sharma; Claire E Brolan; Mangu Kendino; Osea K Masilaca; Gerard O'Reilly; Penisimani Poloniati; Berlin Kafoa Journal: Lancet Reg Health West Pac Date: 2022-07-07
Authors: Anja Wettstein; Mpho Tlali; John A Joska; Morna Cornell; Veronika W Skrivankova; Soraya Seedat; Johannes P Mouton; Leigh L van den Heuvel; Nicola Maxwell; Mary-Ann Davies; Gary Maartens; Matthias Egger; Andreas D Haas Journal: Epidemiol Psychiatr Sci Date: 2022-06-15 Impact factor: 7.818
Authors: Meriel Elizabeth Raymond; Chris Bird; Oliver van Hecke; Margaret Glogowska; Gail Hayward Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2022-06-07 Impact factor: 3.006
Authors: Syed Ahmar Shah; Sinead Brophy; John Kennedy; Louis Fisher; Alex Walker; Brian Mackenna; Helen Curtis; Peter Inglesby; Simon Davy; Seb Bacon; Ben Goldacre; Utkarsh Agrawal; Emily Moore; Colin R Simpson; John Macleod; Roxane Cooksey; Aziz Sheikh; Srinivasa Vittal Katikireddi Journal: EClinicalMedicine Date: 2022-05-20