Thomas F Döring1, Daniel Neuhoff2. 1. Agroecology and Organic Farming Group, University of Bonn, Auf dem Hügel 6, 53121, Bonn, Germany. tdoering@uni-bonn.de. 2. Agroecology and Organic Farming Group, University of Bonn, Auf dem Hügel 6, 53121, Bonn, Germany.
Abstract
Current use of mineral nitrogen (N) fertilizers is unsustainable because of its high fossil energy requirements and a considerable enrichment of the biosphere with reactive N. Biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) from leguminous crops is the most important renewable primary N source, especially in organic farming. However, it remains unclear to which degree BNF can sustainably replace mineral N, overcome the organic to conventional (O:C) yield gap and contribute to food security. Using an agronomic modelling approach, we show that in high-yielding areas farming systems exclusively based on BNF are unlikely to sustainably reach yield levels of mineral-N based systems. For a high reference wheat yield (7.5 t ha-1) and a realistic proportion of fodder legumes in the rotation (33%) even optimistic levels of BNF (282 kg N ha-1), resulted in an O:C ratio far below parity (0.62). Various constraints limit the agricultural use of BNF, such as arable land available for legumes and highly variable performance under on-farm conditions. Reducing the O:C yield gap through legumes will require BNF performance to be increased and N losses to be minimised, yet our results show that limits to the productivity of legume-based farming systems will still remain inevitable.
Current use of mineral n class="Chemical">nitrogen (N) fertilizers is unsustainable because of its high fossil energy requirements and a considerable enrichment of the biosphere with reactive N. Biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) from leguminous crops is the most important renewable primary N source, especially in organic farming. However, it remains unclear to which degree BNF can sustainably replace mineral N, overcome the organic to conventional (O:C) yield gap and contribute to food security. Using an agronomic modelling approach, we show that in high-yielding areas farming systems exclusively based on BNF are unlikely to sustainably reach yield levels of mineral-N based systems. For a high reference wheat yield (7.5 t ha-1) and a realistic proportion of fodder legumes in the rotation (33%) even optimistic levels of BNF (282 kg N ha-1), resulted in an O:C ratio far below parity (0.62). Various constraints limit the agricultural use of BNF, such as arable land available for legumes and highly variable performance under on-farm conditions. Reducing the O:C yield gap through legumes will require BNF performance to be increased and N losses to be minimised, yet our results show that limits to the productivity of legume-based farming systems will still remain inevitable.
Authors: J K Ladha; A Tirol-Padre; C K Reddy; K G Cassman; Sudhir Verma; D S Powlson; C van Kessel; Daniel de B Richter; Debashis Chakraborty; Himanshu Pathak Journal: Sci Rep Date: 2016-01-18 Impact factor: 4.379
Authors: Samiran Banerjee; Florian Walder; Lucie Büchi; Marcel Meyer; Alain Y Held; Andreas Gattinger; Thomas Keller; Raphael Charles; Marcel G A van der Heijden Journal: ISME J Date: 2019-03-08 Impact factor: 10.302