| Literature DB >> 34113185 |
Mohammed A Mamun1,2.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Without integration of the available information, appropriate suicide preventive actions can be hindered. Therefore, this study attempts to review the Bangladeshi COVID-19-related suicide studies for the first time.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19 and psychological impact; hanging in Bangladesh; pandemic and suicide; prevalence and risk factors; suicide and self-harm; suicide deaths in Bangladesh; systematic review
Year: 2021 PMID: 34113185 PMCID: PMC8185458 DOI: 10.2147/PRBM.S315760
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Psychol Res Behav Manag ISSN: 1179-1578
Figure 1PRISMA flowchart of the present review.
Description of the Included Survey-Based Cross-Sectional Studies Concerned with Suicidal Behaviors
| Authors and Publication Year | Sampling Procedure | Data Collection Time | Sample Size | Specific Group and Mean Age | Assessment Tool with Cut-Off Score | Assessment Criteria | Prevalence | Risk Factors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mamun et al 2021 | Online survey, Convenience sampling | 1 to 10 April, 2020 | 10,067 | General population; 29.9 ± 9.6 y | Self-developed item: “Do you think about committing suicide, and are these thoughts persistent and related to COVID-19 issues?” | Considered the COVID-19 inception time with a binary response (Yes/No) | SI: 5% | Female, unemployed, district or divisional town residence, being single (compared to married), alcohol use status, presence of comorbidities, being social media users, more exposure to social media, lower knowledge about COVID-19, lower preventive behaviors of COVID-19, fear of COVID-19 infection, and insomnia. |
| Mamun et al 2020 | Online survey, Sampling not reported | 8 to 25 April, 2020 | 3388 | General population (29.6 ± 6.7 y) and HCPs (30.7 ± 5.6 y) | Self-developed item: “Do you think about committing suicide, and whether these thoughts were persistent due to the COVID-19 related issues and move forward to plan and attempt?” | Considered the COVID-19 inception time with a binary response (Yes/No) | SB: 6.1% (6.0% GP & 6.1% HCPs) | Female, being divorced or married (compared to unmarried), and having no children. |
| Tasnim et al 2020 | Online survey, Nonprobability sampling | April to May, 2020 | 3331 | University students; 21.4 ± 1.9 y | Self-developed item: “During the COVID-19 outbreak, have you ever seriously thought about killing yourself?” | Considered the COVID-19 inception time with a binary response (Yes/No) | SI: 12.8% | Female, higher socio-economic status, urban residence, not performing physical exercise, abnormal sleep status (more or less sleep), not satisfied with studies, cigarette smoking status, suicidal thought history, suicide attempt history, family history of suicide, depression, anxiety, and stress. |
| Rahman et al 2021 | Online survey, Convenience sampling | 10 to 20 July, 2020 | 1415 | General population; 25.42 ± 8.78 y | 4-item Suicide Behaviors Questionnaire-Revised | Considered 4 months for the assessment with standard cutoff points (eg, SR ≥7/18). | SI: 19.0% | Female, marital status of divorced, widows, or widowers (compared to unmarried), lower education levels, living in highly COVID-19 exposure area, economic loss due to the COVID-19 pandemic, relatives or acquaintances who died from COVID-19, fear of COVID-19 infection, depression, and anxiety |
Abbreviations: SB, suicidal behavior; SI, suicidal ideation; SP, suicide plane; SR, suicide risk; GP, general population; HCPs, healthcare professionals.
Description of the Included Case or Case-Series Studies Concerned with Actual Suicide Cases
| Author(s) and Publication Year | Sampling Procedure | Suicide Onset Date | Case (s) | Age (Years) | Gender | Suicide Stressors or Reasons | Suicide Method | Comment(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mamun & Griffiths 2020 | Not applicable | 25 March, 2020 | 1 | 36 y | Male | While the man returned to his village, the villagers thought him infected with COVID-19 based on his fever and flu symptoms and weight loss. The man feared the virus. As of social avoidance and attitudes (ie, xenophobia) by others, he died by suicide. | Hanging | The first case of Bangladeshi suicide related to the COVID-19 pandemic issues, emphasis the public fear |
| Mamun et al 2020 | Not applicable | 20 May, 2020 | 1 | 40 y | Female | At a hospital, a woman was not treated as being infected with COVID-19 by doctors and nurses and did not want to get infected themselves. They also forbidden others not to help the women or go near her. | Hanging | This case reflects fear in the healthcare sittings, where treatment negligence was alleged. |
| Mamun et al 2020 | Not applicable | 11 June, 2020 | 2 | 22 y (son) and 47 y (mother) | Male & Female | The son was not interested in taking the online exam although his father arranged a broadband connection. This leads to argument within the father and son, leading the son oppressed. Further, the son’s parents had arguments at night. The next day, the mother and son killed themselves. | Poisoning | Unusual suicide-pact, considering the relationship of the victims (mother-son). |
| Bhuiyan et al 2020 | Not reported | 6 April, 2020 | 1 | 30 y | Male | Died by suicide due to pressure of unpaid debts, and his family being half-fed and starved for a week after losing work. | Hanging | The first case-series suicide study, that considered the suicide cases occurred in the first 3-week of April. |
| 10 April, 2020 | 1 | 10 y | Female | She was rebuked by her father for asking for food, who had to close his small factory, and therefore, the family had starved for a couple of days. | Hanging | |||
| 12 April, 2020 | 1 | 35 y | Female | After losing her husband’s job, the mother thought that her decreasing could provide more food for the starved children, and attempted suicide. | Hanging | |||
| 13 April, 2020 | 1 | 27 y | Male | Day laborer, who lost job, and was reported struggling with starvation and to compound the situation, his wife left him (prior to the pandemic) and the loneliness made the situation worse. | Hanging | |||
| 14 April, 2020 | 1 | Not reported | Female | The family lost jobs and earning from tea shop, which led economic hardship; in addition, the female, who attempted suicide by killing her two children was asked by her father-in-law to leave the house with husband and children. | Fire with kerosene oil | |||
| 16 April, 2020 | 1 | 30 y | Male | An auto-rickshaw driver was unable to earn any for his family, and his help financial relief approach was denied by the local government calming him to be not deserving cases. | Not reported | |||
| 24 April, 2020 | 2 | 30 y (husband) and 24 y (wife) | Male & Female | A poverty-stricken couple, who had a 3-year old child husband and wife died by suicide due to lockdown-related economic distress and due to existing debts. | Hanging | |||
| Boshra et al 2020 | Google & Bing search | 1 March to 30 September, 2020 | 37 | 10 to 58 y (mean age: 35.2) | 65% Male (n=24) | In most of the cases, multiple suicide stressors were retrieved, where the final list included: lockdown related unemployment (n=17), depression (n=13), family arguments (n=8), fear (n=6), debt (n=6), hunger (n=4), poverty (n=3), parental abuse (n=2), and single cases for xenophobia, social stigma, parental dispute, and lack of access to treatment. | Hanging (n=27), Poisoning (n=5), Jumping (n=4), and Setting on fire (n=1) | This study provided largest suicide data, although the categorization of suicide stressors is not consisted with the prior studies. |