Gerardo Tricarico1, Valter Travagli2. 1. COVID1 Unit, Presidio Ospedaliero Sant'Andrea, Vercelli, Italy; UCM United Campus of Malta, UCM Higher Education Institution Foundation, Msida, Malta. 2. Dipartimento di Biotecnologie, Chimica e Farmacia-Dipartimento di Eccellenza Nazionale, Università degli Studi di Siena, Siena, Italy. Electronic address: valter.travagli@unisi.it.
To the Editor:We read with care and interest the original article from Ballow and Haga about the possible explanation for why some individuals have life-threatening COVID-19 disease whereas others have no or mild symptoms.Because this is not the conclusive report and we appreciate the attempt to explain the peculiar reactions of some patients with COVID-19, we would like to suggest some specific ideas with a view to more targeted therapeutic interventions.First, it is not easy to determine the relation between risk factors predisposing people to a more severe reaction to COVID-19 infection with regard to vitamin D deficiency and genetic risk factors. On the other hand, genetic alterations suggest interesting ideas with regard to multigene expression, especially on large specific chromosomes for epithelial membrane proteins in the lungs, according to recent papers on this topic.Second, apparent contradictions in COVID-19 mortality and morbidity in patients with common variable immune deficiency allow the authors to produce a scholarly examination of the immune imbalance and dysregulation of innate and adaptive immune responses in patients with severe COVID-19. The factors analyzed, sometimes in a correlated manner, are (1) the importance of the type I interferon pathway; (2) immune-senescence; (3) age-independent comorbidities such as hypertension, diabetes, and obesity; (4) the uncontrollable proinflammatory response in the lungs driven by macrophage-activation syndrome; (5) the T cell and subtype response; and (6) the antibody response against the viral envelope S (spike) and N (nucleocapsid) proteins.However, before concluding that “a combination of multiple genetic and non-genetic factors contribute to an individual's unique immune response and susceptibility to SARS-CoV-2 infection,” in our opinion, it is of paramount importance to introduce the vascular endothelium into the discussion. Endothelial damage to various organs was also highlighted by autopsy outcomes.With regard to the subject of the vascular endothelium, information reported on the AB0 blood group loci that were associated with severe SARS-CoV-2 infection may find a more complete and significant interpretation in this direction, as also may be the case regarding the integrity of endothelial glycoproteins.
,Thus, we encourage an examination of these points, not to negate any of the points made but to augment and improve this thought-provoking original article, which sheds further light on why some people develop serious COVID-19 disease after infection whereas others exhibit only mild symptoms.
Authors: John P Reilly; Nuala J Meyer; Michael Gs Shashaty; Brian J Anderson; Caroline Ittner; Thomas G Dunn; Brian Lim; Caitlin Forker; Michael P Bonk; Ethan Kotloff; Rui Feng; Edward Cantu; Nilam S Mangalmurti; Carolyn S Calfee; Michael A Matthay; Carmen Mikacenic; Keith R Walley; James Russell; David C Christiani; Mark M Wurfel; Paul N Lanken; Muredach P Reilly; Jason D Christie Journal: J Clin Invest Date: 2021-01-04 Impact factor: 14.808
Authors: Erola Pairo-Castineira; Sara Clohisey; Lucija Klaric; Andrew D Bretherick; Konrad Rawlik; Dorota Pasko; Susan Walker; Nick Parkinson; Max Head Fourman; Clark D Russell; James Furniss; Anne Richmond; Elvina Gountouna; Nicola Wrobel; David Harrison; Bo Wang; Yang Wu; Alison Meynert; Fiona Griffiths; Wilna Oosthuyzen; Athanasios Kousathanas; Loukas Moutsianas; Zhijian Yang; Ranran Zhai; Chenqing Zheng; Graeme Grimes; Rupert Beale; Jonathan Millar; Barbara Shih; Sean Keating; Marie Zechner; Chris Haley; David J Porteous; Caroline Hayward; Jian Yang; Julian Knight; Charlotte Summers; Manu Shankar-Hari; Paul Klenerman; Lance Turtle; Antonia Ho; Shona C Moore; Charles Hinds; Peter Horby; Alistair Nichol; David Maslove; Lowell Ling; Danny McAuley; Hugh Montgomery; Timothy Walsh; Alexandre C Pereira; Alessandra Renieri; Xia Shen; Chris P Ponting; Angie Fawkes; Albert Tenesa; Mark Caulfield; Richard Scott; Kathy Rowan; Lee Murphy; Peter J M Openshaw; Malcolm G Semple; Andrew Law; Veronique Vitart; James F Wilson; J Kenneth Baillie Journal: Nature Date: 2020-12-11 Impact factor: 69.504