| Literature DB >> 34092136 |
Mandeep Ubhi1, Shirish Dubey2,3, Caroline Gordon4,5, Tochukwu Adizie6, Tom Sheeran6, Kerry Allen7, Rachel Jordan8, Steven Sadhra9, Jo Adams10, Rashmika Daji11, John A Reynolds4,5, Kanta Kumar1.
Abstract
SLE has a range of fluctuating symptoms affecting individuals and their ability to work. Although South Asian (SA) patients are at increased risk of developing SLE there is limited knowledge of the impact on employment for these patients in the UK. Understanding ethnicity and disease-specific issues are important to ensure patients are adequately supported at work. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with patients of SA origin to explore how SLE impacted on their employment. Thematic analysis was used to analyse the data which are reported following COREQ guidelines. Ten patients (8 female; 2 male) were recruited from three rheumatology centres in the UK and interviewed between November 2019 and March 2020. Patients were from Indian (n = 8) or Pakistani (n = 2) origin and worked in a range of employment sectors. Four themes emerged from the data: (1) Disease related factors; (2) Employment related factors; (3) Cultural and interpersonal factors impacting on work ability; (4) Recommendations for improvement. Patients' ability to work was affected by variable work-related support from their hospital clinicians, low awareness of SLE and variable support from their employers, and cultural barriers in their communities that could affect levels of family support received. These findings highlight the need for additional support for SA patients with SLE in the workplace.Entities:
Keywords: South Asian; Systemic lupus erythematosus; employment; ethnicity; lupus
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34092136 PMCID: PMC8283190 DOI: 10.1177/09612033211022816
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Lupus ISSN: 0961-2033 Impact factor: 2.911
Demographic information of patients interviewed.
| Patient ID | Gender | Level of education | Age (years) | Country of birth | Ethnicity | SLE duration (years) | Employment sector | Years in employment | Working pattern |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 | F | GCSE | 55–59 | Kenya | Indian | 33 | Retail | 15+ | Part time |
| P2 | M | Other – Class 10 | 40–44 | Pakistan | Pakistani | 13 | Catering | 6–10 | Part time |
| P3 | F | Degree | 45–49 | UK | Indian | 12 | Local Government | 3–5 | Full time |
| P4 | F | Degree | 30–34 | UK | Indian | 17 | Administrative | 6–10 | Full time |
| P5 | M | A Level | 50–54 | UK | Indian | 12 | Manufacturing | 3–5 | Full time |
| P6 | F | A Level | 50–54 | UK | Indian | 26 | Catering | 6–10 | Full time |
| P7 | F | Degree | 40–44 | UK | Indian | 13 | Customer service | 15+ | Full time |
| P8 | F | A Level | 20–24 | UK | Indian | 0.25 | Customer service | 1–2 | Part time |
| P9 | F | Degree | 30–34 | UK | Indian | 10 | Skilled | 6–10 | Full time |
| P10 | F | Degree | 44–49 | UK | Pakistani | 5 | Medical | <1 | Full time |
LupusQoL scores.
| Domains | Median (range) |
|---|---|
| Physical health | 54.69 (25, 90.63) |
| Pain | 70.83 (16.67, 100) |
| Planning | 50 (0, 100) |
| Intimate relationship | 43.75 (0, 100) |
| Burden to others | 50 (0, 91.67) |
| Emotional health | 56.25 (4.17, 87.5) |
| Body image | 45.83 (5, 100) |
| Fatigue | 37.5 (12.5, 93.75) |
Higher scores indicate better HRQoL with a range of 0 (worst) to 100 (best).
Themes and subthemes that emerged from the data.
| Themes | Subthemes |
|---|---|
| Theme 1: Disease related factors affecting work ability | 1.1 Fluctuating symptomology1.2 Clinician support1.3 Lack of disease specific work information at diagnosis |
| Theme 2: Employment related factors affecting work ability | 2.1 Employer support2.2 Workplace adjustments2.3 Occupational health2.4 Future career plans |
| Theme 3: Cultural and interpersonal related factors affecting work ability | 3.1 Lack of awareness3.2 Fear of stigma in the wider community3.3 Family support |
| Theme 4: Recommendations for improvement | 4.1 Clinician discussion4.2 Employer campaign4.3 Video resource |
Patient quotes throughout the text.
| Quote reference in text | Patient quote |
|---|---|
| Quote 1 | I can’t just keep bringing just lupus into to it, they think that’s an excuse. If I need some time off work because I’m aching, they consider it as fake. (Patient 1, female, 55–59 years) |
| Quote 2 | I am very wary about the hospital appointments. Now, I just take that as annual leave because I am scared what employers will do. (Patient 10, female, 44–49 years) |
| Quote 3 | My joints were all swelling up and I can’t stand for long. I can’t sit for long time. Then the doctor told me that you have to quit that job. So I did that at the time. Two years I didn’t work at all. (Patient 2, male, 40–44 years) |
| Quote 4 | When I was first diagnosed…there was very little information on how this affects your body and work. (Patient 9, female, 30–34 years) |
| Quote 5 | I didn’t know it would mean I’d need to take time off work. I didn’t know what the symptoms were or how the medication would affect me. (Patient 8, female, 20–24 years) |
| Quote 6 | It was just one page with very little information– you can’t really take that to an employer. They would still ask me what I needed, and I didn’t have a clue. (Patient 8, female, 20–24 years) |
| Quote 7 | I did take information in, to ask them to read it, but they haven’t got time, they just put them in the folder, I don’t know. I do keep mentioning to them about lupus, but either they aren’t interested or what, they just say “yes we do know”. (Patient 1, female, 55–59 years) |
| Quote 8 | I have got really good managers. Say if I came into work not feeling well, I tend to go back home and work from home rest of the day. (Patient 4, female, 30–34 years) |
| Quote 9 | I mean obviously you struggle financially (to go part-time). But it’s either that, or struggling with lupus and full-time work, and being ill all the time. (Patient 6, female, 50–54 years) |
| Quote 10 | I even suggested at one point “can I juggle my hours so that I’m not that stressed in the morning to get to work”, and that was denied … I found them to be so unsupportive. So I just had to hand in my notice because I couldn’t put up with it any more. (Patient 10, female, 44–49 years) |
| Quote 11 | Yes, a phased return. I had to increase by an hour a day, that was excellent. There was no way I was going to start on an eight hour per day. (Patient 5, male, 50–54 years) |
| Quote 12 | I think “what will happen if I am not able to work?” I have very young kids you know … I don’t have experience to do anything else, plus with my problems, I can’t go to another trade now … if they sack me from here it will be very difficult. (Patient 2, male, 40–44 years) |
| Quote 13 | It gives you that confidence and you look forward to getting out rather being stuck in the house. It gives a purpose doing something that you enjoy, and it takes your mind off your own health. (Patient 6, female, 50–54 years) |
| Quote 14 | I think the Asian British can understand more, they can be more open minded and have computers to look things up. My parents or in-laws didn’t look things up on the computer. It’s like telling my parents about diabetes, I think it’s difficult for them to understand, than the English speaking patients. (Patient 6, female, 50–54 years) |
| Quote 15 | But this is something I have to live with … I can’t not tell anybody anything, and I wouldn’t want to hide this from my in-laws. (Patient 8, female, 20–24 years) |
| Quote 16 | I was born and bred this this country. I don’t see that “oh I have to keep things in”, like we have in our culture, where you can’t tell anybody anything, I don’t have that stigma. (Patient 10, female, 44–49 years) |
| Quote 17 | I did have a very difficult time at the start of my marriage because I was living with my in-laws … that generation will never understand … they thought “oh you go to the doctors to have medication and then it’s okay”. It is a bit frustrating because they still want to you to go to places, and visit, and behave in a certain way. (Patient 6, female, 50–54 years) |
| Quote 18 | So more guidance on what to tell the work people would be useful. It just said that I can carry on working with lupus, but I didn’t know what I needed to change. If it did, I could have given that to my manager and said, “this is what I need.” (Patient 8, female, 20–24 years) |
| Quote 19 | I think most of the people in companies should understand what certain people suffer with, and what the symptoms are, and how it affects them at work. (Patient 1, female, 55–59 years) |
| Quote 20 | I can read English, and even for me it was overwhelming. But it can also help our family members, like in my family, my mum can’t write or read English. She can’t speak in English. I can’t speak Punjabi very well, so I can’t relay that message of the condition to her. (Patient 8, female, 20–24 years) |