Madelyn R Frumkin1, Thomas L Rodebaugh2. 1. Department of Psychological & Brain Sciences, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, MO, United States. Electronic address: mfrumkin@wustl.edu. 2. Department of Psychological & Brain Sciences, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, MO, United States.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Chronic pain is conceptualized as a biopsychosocial phenomenon that involves both physical and emotional processes. The vast majority of research regarding these facets of chronic pain characterizes differences between individuals. In this review, we describe problems with assuming that differences between persons accurately characterize within-person processes. We also provide a systematic review of studies that have examined within-person relationships between pain and affect among individuals with chronic pain. METHOD: Articles published by December 2020 that pertained to within-person assessment of pain and emotion, affect, or mood were identified. Data regarding study design, adherence, and concurrent and prospective relationships among pain and affect variables were extracted and summarized. RESULTS: Of 611 abstracts, 55 studies met inclusion criteria. Results suggest that individuals with chronic pain tend to experience increased negative affect and decreased positive affect when experiencing more severe pain (rpooled = .18 and - .19, respectively). However, the size of these effects appeared smaller than between-person associations, and there was evidence of significant variability between individuals. Examination of predictive relationships between pain and affect largely suggested the tendency of symptoms to predict themselves, rather than pain predicting affect or vice versa. CONCLUSIONS: Consistent with group-level relationships, experiencing more severe pain relative to an individual's average seems to be associated with more negative affect and less positive affect. However, individuals vary in the size and even direction of these effects. More research is necessary to understand the implications of such variability for the assessment and treatment of chronic pain.
OBJECTIVE: Chronic pain is conceptualized as a biopsychosocial phenomenon that involves both physical and emotional processes. The vast majority of research regarding these facets of chronic pain characterizes differences between individuals. In this review, we describe problems with assuming that differences between persons accurately characterize within-person processes. We also provide a systematic review of studies that have examined within-person relationships between pain and affect among individuals with chronic pain. METHOD: Articles published by December 2020 that pertained to within-person assessment of pain and emotion, affect, or mood were identified. Data regarding study design, adherence, and concurrent and prospective relationships among pain and affect variables were extracted and summarized. RESULTS: Of 611 abstracts, 55 studies met inclusion criteria. Results suggest that individuals with chronic pain tend to experience increased negative affect and decreased positive affect when experiencing more severe pain (rpooled = .18 and - .19, respectively). However, the size of these effects appeared smaller than between-person associations, and there was evidence of significant variability between individuals. Examination of predictive relationships between pain and affect largely suggested the tendency of symptoms to predict themselves, rather than pain predicting affect or vice versa. CONCLUSIONS: Consistent with group-level relationships, experiencing more severe pain relative to an individual's average seems to be associated with more negative affect and less positive affect. However, individuals vary in the size and even direction of these effects. More research is necessary to understand the implications of such variability for the assessment and treatment of chronic pain.
Authors: Alicia Grattan; Mark D Sullivan; Kathleen W Saunders; Cynthia I Campbell; Michael R Von Korff Journal: Ann Fam Med Date: 2012 Jul-Aug Impact factor: 5.166
Authors: Eric L Garland; Craig J Bryan; Patrick H Finan; Elizabeth A Thomas; Sarah E Priddy; Michael R Riquino; Matthew O Howard Journal: Drug Alcohol Depend Date: 2017-04-01 Impact factor: 4.492
Authors: John W Burns; James I Gerhart; Kristina M Post; David A Smith; Laura S Porter; Erik Schuster; Asokumar Buvanendran; Anne Marie Fras; Francis J Keefe Journal: J Pain Date: 2015-08-28 Impact factor: 5.820