| Literature DB >> 34069738 |
Attà Negri1, Claudia Zamin2, Giulia Parisi3, Anna Paladino1, Giovanbattista Andreoli1.
Abstract
The biopsychosocial paradigm is a model of care that has been proposed in order to improve the effectiveness of health care by promoting collaboration between different professions and disciplines. However, its application still faces several issues. A quantitative-qualitative survey was conducted on a sample of general practitioners (GPs) from Milan, Italy, to investigate their attitudes and beliefs regarding the role of the psychologist, the approach adopted to manage psychological diseases, and their experiences of collaboration with psychologists. The results show a partial view of the psychologist's profession that limits the potential of integration between medicine and psychology in primary care. GPs recognized that many patients (66%) would often benefit from psychological intervention, but only in a few cases (9%) were these patients regularly referred to a psychologist. Furthermore, the referral represents an almost exclusive form of collaboration present in the opinions of GPs. Only 8% of GPs would consider the joint and integrated work of the psychologist and doctor useful within the primary health care setting. This vision of the role of psychologists among GPs represents a constraint in implementing a comprehensive primary health care approach, as advocated by the World Health Organization.Entities:
Keywords: biopsychosocial model; comprehensive primary health care; general practitioner; multi-professional health team; primary health care psychologist
Year: 2021 PMID: 34069738 PMCID: PMC8161354 DOI: 10.3390/healthcare9050613
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Healthcare (Basel) ISSN: 2227-9032
Overview of the areas and questions of the survey.
| Thematic Areas | Examples of Questions | Answer Options |
|---|---|---|
| Degree | Year | |
| Education and career information | First specialization | |
| Other specialization | ||
| Previous medical activity in other services | ||
| Patients’ medical conditions and need for psychological interventions | How often do you meet patients who could benefit from psychological intervention? | Never, sometimes, often, always |
| Beliefs and attitudes towards mental health professionals | In your opinion, what are the goals of the intervention of these different professionals: psychologist, psychotherapist, counselor and psychiatrist? | Open-ended |
| Attitudes towards the psychologist | If you had the opportunity, would you offer your patients a psychological intervention in your clinic? | No, yes |
| In case you answered “yes” to the previous question, which psychological intervention would you offer? | Visit jointly conducted by doctor and psychologist, individual psychological/psychotherapy sessions, group posttherapy, other | |
| How much could the psychologist/psychotherapist’s work overlap and hinder the doctor’s work? | Not at all, a little, moderately, a lot | |
| Features of collaborations with psychologists | How often did you refer patients to a psychologist/psychotherapist with symptoms concerning the following medical areas? (urology, cardiology, dermatology, etc.) | Never, sometimes, often, always |
| As for patients you referred to a psychologist/psychotherapist, did you have feedback by the psychologist/psychotherapist? How? | No, yes; by phone, in person, other |
The prevalent GPs’ beliefs about mental health professionals.
| Professionals | Intervention Targets | Intervention Goals | Reasons for Referral |
|---|---|---|---|
| Psychiatrist | Severe psychic symptoms (major depression, psychosis) | Diagnosis and psychopharmacological treatment | To heal and manage severe psychological symptoms |
| Psychologist | Psychic and functional symptoms | Diagnosis, treatment, and psychological support | To heal and manage mild psychological symptoms |
| Psychotherapist | Psychic and functional symptoms | Diagnosis, treatment, and psychological support | To heal and manage mild psychological symptoms |
| Counselor | Existential and relational difficulties | Personal skills empowerment, promotion of an active role toward their own problems | To help in managing specific life issues |
Figure 1Areas of patients’ symptoms and referral frequency (%) to a psychologist.