Reheman Adili1, Madeline Jackson1, Livia Stanger1, Xiangrong Dai2, Mandy Li3, Benjamin Xiaoyi Li3, Michael Holinstat1,4. 1. Department of Pharmacology, 1259University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA. 2. Zhaoke Pharmaceutical (Hefei) Co. Limited, Hefei, Anhui, China. 3. Lee's Pharmaceutical Holdings Limited. Shatin, Hong Kong, China. 4. Department of Internal Medicine, Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, 1259University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Abstract
Uncontrolled bleeding associated with trauma and surgery is the leading cause of preventable death. Batroxobin, a snake venom-derived thrombin-like serine protease, has been shown to clot fibrinogen by cleaving fibrinopeptide A in a manner distinctly different from thrombin, even in the presence of heparin. The biochemical properties of batroxobin and its effect on coagulation have been well characterized in vitro. However, the efficacy of batroxobin on hemostatic clot formation in vivo is not well studied due to the lack of reliable in vivo hemostasis models. Here, we studied the efficacy of batroxobin and slounase, a batroxobin containing activated factor X, on hemostatic clot composition and bleeding using intravital microcopy laser ablation hemostasis models in micro and macro vessels and liver puncture hemostasis models in normal and heparin-induced hypocoagulant mice. We found that prophylactic treatment in wild-type mice with batroxobin, slounase and activated factor X significantly enhanced platelet-rich fibrin clot formation following vascular injury. In heparin-treated mice, batroxobin treatment resulted in detectable fibrin formation and a modest increase in hemostatic clot size, while activated factor X had no effect. In contrast, slounase treatment significantly enhanced both platelet recruitment and fibrin formation, forming a stable clot and shortening bleeding time and blood loss in wild-type and heparin-treated hypocoagulant mice. Our data demonstrate that, while batroxobin enhances fibrin formation, slounase was able to enhance hemostasis in normal mice and restore hemostasis in hypocoagulant conditions via the enhancement of fibrin formation and platelet activation, indicating that slounase is more effective in controlling hemorrhage.
Uncontrolled bleeding associated with trauma and surgery is the leading cause of preventable death. Batroxobin, a snake venom-derived thrombin-like serine protease, has been shown to clot fibrinogen by cleaving fibrinopeptide A in a manner distinctly different from thrombin, even in the presence of heparin. The biochemical properties of batroxobin and its effect on coagulation have been well characterized in vitro. However, the efficacy of batroxobin on hemostatic clot formation in vivo is not well studied due to the lack of reliable in vivo hemostasis models. Here, we studied the efficacy of batroxobin and slounase, a batroxobin containing activated factor X, on hemostatic clot composition and bleeding using intravital microcopy laser ablation hemostasis models in micro and macro vessels and liver puncture hemostasis models in normal and heparin-induced hypocoagulant mice. We found that prophylactic treatment in wild-type mice with batroxobin, slounase and activated factor X significantly enhanced platelet-rich fibrin clot formation following vascular injury. In heparin-treated mice, batroxobin treatment resulted in detectable fibrin formation and a modest increase in hemostatic clot size, while activated factor X had no effect. In contrast, slounase treatment significantly enhanced both platelet recruitment and fibrin formation, forming a stable clot and shortening bleeding time and blood loss in wild-type and heparin-treated hypocoagulant mice. Our data demonstrate that, while batroxobin enhances fibrin formation, slounase was able to enhance hemostasis in normal mice and restore hemostasis in hypocoagulant conditions via the enhancement of fibrin formation and platelet activation, indicating that slounase is more effective in controlling hemorrhage.
Life-threatening bleeding due to traumatic injury or surgical procedures is the
leading cause of preventable death in the world.[1] Excessive blood loss accounts for around 40% of the deaths associated
with trauma.[2] Hemostasis is a complex physiological process, which arrests bleeding
and involves blood cells and plasma as well as extracellular and matrix
proteins. Platelet accumulation and activation of the coagulation system are
two key mechanisms required for hemostatic clot formation to stop bleeding.[3,4] Platelet adhesion and subsequent platelet activation and aggregation
at the site of vascular injury are vital steps in initiating the hemostatic
process to form platelet plugs (primary hemostasis) and prevent blood loss.[3,5] It has been shown that von Willebrand factor (VWF) and fibrinogen
(Fg) are the two molecules required for platelet adhesion and aggregation in
the event of vascular injury.[3,5,6] Interestingly, platelet adhesion and aggregation still persist in
mice lacking both VWF and Fg, even after further depletion of plasma
fibronectin (pFn).[7-9] We have shown that both plasma Fn and vitronectin (Vn) inhibit
platelet aggregation in their soluble forms, however, the insoluble or
cellular forms of pFN and Vn uniquely support platelet aggregation and
promote hemostasis, demonstrating the complexities of the platelet
aggregation process.[9-11] Formation of a stable hemostatic clot also requires the activation of
the coagulation cascade through a series of enzymatic reactions, leading to
the generation of thrombin.[12] Thrombin is the most potent platelet agonist known to amplify
platelet activation. Thrombin generation ultimately leads to the formation
of fibrin, further enhancing the platelet aggregation process and
platelet-fibrin clot formation (secondary hemostasis) to effectively seal
blood leakage.[13-15] It is well documented that thrombin converts soluble fibrinogen to
fibrin I monomers by releasing fibrinopeptide A and B from the NH2-terminal
domains of the alpha- and beta-chains of fibrinogen.[16] Exposed NH2 termini on fibrin monomers will initiate the fibrin
polymerization at the site of vascular injury and further enhance the
formation of a stable hemostatic clot.[17,18] There are many interactions between the primary and secondary
mechanisms of hemostasis. Activated platelets provide procoagulant cell
surface membranes to activate the coagulation cascade and enhance thrombin
generation. Conversely, thrombin generation also leads to further platelet
activation, amplifying platelet recruitment into the growing platelet fibrin
clot under shear conditions. Thus, the procoagulant activities of platelets
and the formation of fibrin are crucial for effective hemostasis in order to
limit bleeding. In pathological conditions, such as when the integrity of
the vessel wall is disrupted by the rupturing of an atherosclerotic plaque,
however, those same processes can also lead to occlusive thrombi and vessel occlusion.[3,19]Impairment of hemostasis and excessive bleeding associated with trauma is
primarily due to blood loss from injury in addition to subsequent activation
of coagulation, hyperfibrinolysis, consumption of platelets, coagulation
factors, and hemodilution from aggressive resuscitation.[20,21] The existence of underlying medical conditions, such as congenital or
acquired bleeding disorders, can also increase the risk of excessive
bleeding in the event of vascular injury.[22,23] While current anti-thrombotic therapies, including both anti-platelet
and anti-coagulation therapies, may reduce or prevent the thrombotic
complication of cardiovascular disease and possible mortality, it’s
associated with the increased risk of bleeding due to the inhibition of key
elements required for normal hemostasis.[24] Despite the existence of a variety of antithrombotic agents that are
clinically available, cessation of uncontrolled bleeding is mostly achieved
by surgical interventions and systematic pharmacological reagents targeted
at restoring hemostasis, especially in hypocoagulant conditions, are very limited.[25] Furthermore, the effects of available hemostatic reagents on
hemostatic clot composition in vivo are not well
characterized due to the lack of reliable in vivo
hemostasis models.Snake venom serine proteinases have long been known to affect various
physiological functions including blood coagulation and fibrinolysis.[26-28] Snake venom toxins have been extensively studied as potential drug
targets, and several toxin-based antithrombotic drugs are currently in use
or under development for trials, including our previous work in the
development of Anfibatide, the first-in-class anti-GPbα antagonist.[29-31] Batroxobin is a thrombin-like serine protease from the venom of
Bothrops atrox and is the most intensively studied active pharmaceutical
ingredient from snake venom. In contrast to the cleavage of Fg by thrombin,
batroxobin releases only FpA resulting in the polymerization of fibrin
monomers or acting as a defibrase.[32,33] This process is not inhibited by antithrombin or heparin cofactor II.[34] Therefore, batroxobin can induce clot formation in platelet-rich
plasma without affecting platelet function in vitro in the
presence of heparin, making it a viable heparin-insensitive diagnostic test
in parallel with thrombin time.[35] Most recently, batroxobin has been shown to bind fibrin(ogen) with
higher affinity than thrombin and promotes greater clot expansion in
vitro.
[36] Notably, the ability of batroxobin to polymerize fibrin makes it a
potential hemostatic agent and it has been successfully isolated for
development as a medical adhesive hemostatic drug.[34,35,37] Snake venoms that contain both batroxobin and factor X activator have
been reported to have a higher efficacy in promoting intravascular coagulation.[38] This indicates that the cleavage of fibrinogen by batroxobin coupled
with the promotion of pro-coagulant activity by factor X, the first enzyme
in the common pathway of the coagulation cascade, might have a better
hemostatic efficacy than either alone. While the findings from in
vitro studies are promising, they may not fully reflect
hemostatic clot formation in vivo, especially the dynamics
of hemostatic clot composition, stability of the clot and the associated
risk of bleeding. Therefore, further in vivo studies on the
efficacy of snake venom-derived drugs on hemostatic clot formation and
bleeding are warranted.Slounase is a batroxobin extracted from the venom of viperidae containing
activated factor X and formulated for small volume intravenous injections.[39] In this study, we determine the effect of slounase on hemostatic clot
composition and bleeding in vivo using intravital microcopy
laser ablation hemostasis models in micro and macro vessels and liver
puncture hemostasis models in normal and heparin-induced hypocoagulant mice.
Furthermore, we assess the hemostatic potential of slounase in platelet
recruitment and fibrin formation in growing thrombi in vivo
in response to vascular injury in parallel with batroxobin and activated
factor X and provide the mechanistic insights of these hemostatic reagents
in the hemostatic process.
Materials and Methods
Reagents
Slounase, batroxobin and activated factor X were obtained from Lee’s
Pharmaceutical Holdings Limited (Hong Kong China). Unfractionated
Heparin was acquired from SAGENT Pharmaceuticals (IL, USA). DyLight
488 anti-GPIbβ was obtained from Emfret Analytics (Eibelstadt,
Germany). Anti-mouse fibrin antibody was a kind gift from Dr. R.
Camire (Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia) and was fluorescently
labeled using an Alexa Flour 647 antibody labeling kit (Thermo
Fisher).
Experimental Animals
All experimental procedures in this study were approved by the
Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at the University of
Michigan. C57BL/6 wild-type (WT) mice were purchased from Jackson
Laboratories (Bar Harbor, ME, USA) and housed in the research facility
at the University of Michigan.
Laser-Ablation Cremaster Arteriole Rupture Hemostasis Model
Adult male mice (10-12 weeks old) were anesthetized by an intraperitoneal
injection of ketamine/xylazine (100 and 10 mg/kg, respectively) and
the cremaster arteriole was surgically prepared and superfused with
preheated bicarbonate saline buffer throughout the experiment as described.[11,40] The mice were intravenously administered with DyLight
488-conjugated rat anti-mouse platelet GP1bβ antibody (0.1 μg/g;
EMFRET Analytics) and Alexa Fluor 647-conjugated anti-fibrin (0.3
μg/g) via a jugular vein cannula prior to vascular injury, and
cremaster microcirculation was monitored and recorded under
multichannel intravital microscopy. Mice were intravenously injected
in bolus with control buffer (normal coagulant control mice) or 1000
U/kg of unfractionated heparin to inhibit coagulation (hypocoagulant
mice). Hemostatic reagents of batroxobin, activated factor X, or
slounase (0.1 and 1U/kg) were administered intravenously by a jugular
vein catheter prior to vascular injury. The cremaster muscle arteriole
(30-50 µm in diameter) was exposed to a high intensity 532-nm laser
pulse (70 lJ; 100 Hz; for about 7 ns) in order to puncture a hole
through the vessel wall, which resulted in red blood cell (RBC)
extravasation as visualized by RBC leakage (bleeding) from the
vessel.The entire process of RBC extravasation and formation of the
platelet-fibrin hemostatic plug at the site of injury, which resulted
in the cessation of RBC extravasation, was recorded in real-time using
a Zeiss Axio Examiner Z1 intravital fluorescent microscope equipped
with a solid laser launch system under a 63X water-immersion
objective. The dynamics of platelet accumulation and fibrin formation
within the hemostatic clot were analyzed by the changes in the mean
fluorescent intensity over time using the Slidebook 6.0 program. The
time required for the cessation of RBC extravasation following the
rupture of the vessel wall was determined by reviewing single-frame
still images under a bright field. Arterial bleeding time was defined
as the time from laser pulse injury until cessation of RBC leakage
from the vessel.
Laser Ablation Saphenous Vein Hemostasis Model
The laser ablation saphenous vein hemostasis model was performed as
described in detail.[41,42] Briefly, adult mice (10-12 weeks old) were anesthetized as
described above and intravenously administered fluorescently labeled
antibodies against platelets and fibrin as described above. The
saphenous vein was surgically exposed under an intravital microscope
and superfused throughout the experiment with preheated
bicarbonate-buffered saline. Mice were intravenously injected in bolus
with 1000U/Kg of unfractionated heparin alone or followed by 1 U/kg of
batroxobin, activated factor X, or slounase, separately 10 minutes
prior to vascular injury. Saphenous vein blood flow was visualized
under a 20X water immersion objective using a Zeiss Axio Examiner Z1
fluorescent microscope. The saphenous vascular wall was exposed to two
maximum-strength 532-nm laser pulses (70 lJ; 100 Hz; for about 7 ns,
10 ms intervals) to puncture a hole (48 to 65 µm in diameter) through
the vessel wall, which resulted in bleeding visualized by the escape
of fluorescent platelets to the extravascular space. The laser injury
was performed at 30 seconds and repeated at 5- and 10-minute intervals
at the same site of injury to assess the platelet-fibrin hemostat clot
formation. The dynamics of platelet accumulation and fibrin deposition
within the clot were recorded in real-time and analyzed as described
above using the Slidebook 6.0 program.
Hepatic-Pricking Injury Bleeding Model
Adult mice (8-10 weeks old) were anesthetized as described above and were
intravenously bolus injected with 1000 U/kg of heparin alone, followed
by intravenous treatment of 1 U/kg of batroxobin, activated factor X,
slounase or control buffer via the tail vein. The amount of blood loss
following the injury was assessed using a modified hepatic-prick
injury-bleeding model as described.[37] Briefly, the anesthetized mice were placed in a supine position
on a heating pad and the left lobe of the liver was exteriorized on
parafilm via a midline incision through the abdominal wall in order to
prevent the absorption of body fluids. Then, a penetrative pricking
injury was made in the thickest area in the middle of the left liver
lobe using a 16G needle. Immediately after making the injury, the
pre-weighed filter paper and parafilm were placed under the lobe,
allowing the filter paper to absorb blood for 10 minutes as the
heating board was tilted at 45 degrees. The parafilm was used to
prevent the absorption of body fluids other than blood exiting the
wound. The filter paper with blood was measured by a microscale to
evaluate the total amount of blood loss by injury in each mouse.
Statistical Analysis
Experimental results were analyzed by unpaired and paired two-tailed
student t-tests as well as a two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA)
between experimental groups with the Prism 7.0 software (GraphPad).
Differences with a P-value less than 0.05 were
considered statistically significant. Data is expressed as mean ±
standard error of the mean (SEM).
Results
Slounase Treatment does Not Induce Platelet Adhesion or Aggregation
in the Absence of Vascular Injury In Vivo
In order to determine if intravenous (IV) administration of slounase,
batroxobin, or activated factor X results in spontaneous platelet
adhesion, aggregation, or thrombus formation, blood flow in the
cremaster microvessels was continuously monitored under brightfield
and fluorescent channels with a real-time intravital microscope during
the intravenous injection of slounase, batroxobin and activated factor
X as well as 90 minutes post-treatment. No platelet interaction,
adhesion, aggregate formation or fibrin formation was detected in
respective channels in cremaster arterioles, venules and capillaries
in the absence of vascular injury. Intravenous injection of 1 U/kg of
slounase, batroxobin or activated factor X did not cause fluorescently
labeled platelets to adhere to or form any visible platelet aggregates
on the vessel wall, similar to mice treated with control buffer (5
mice per group). Intravenous treatment of these agents did not alter
blood flow or spontaneously cause any detectable platelet-fibrin
thrombosis in cremaster microcirculation in the extended 90 min
recording period, indicating that slounase does not cause
intravascular thrombosis in the absence of vascular injury (Figure
1).
Figure 1.
Intravenous administration of slounase, batroxobin or
activated factor X did not cause detectable platelet
adhesion or platelet aggregate formation in the absence of
vascular injury in vivo. Blood flow in
cremaster microcirculation of WT mice was monitored in
real-time and recorded under the intravital microscope.
Circulating platelets were fluorescently labeled as green
and detection of fibrin was achieved by injecting
fluorescently conjugated anti-fibrin antibody as red
in vivo. 1 U/kg of activated factor
X, batroxobin, slounase, or control buffer were
intravenously injected while real-time recording and
continuously monitored for an extended period of time up
to 90 minutes without inducing vascular injury. No
platelet adhesion, aggregation or fibrin formation was
detected in cremaster microcirculation prior to, during,
or up to 90 minutes post injection. Representative
pictures of overlaid bright field with fluorescent
channels after subtracting fluorescent backgrounds (10 min
post injection) show no fluorescent platelet adherence,
aggregation, or fibrin formation on the cremaster
arterioles vessel wall in the absence of injury in
vivo following the injection of slounase
(bottom right), batroxobin (bottom left), or activated
factor X (top right) respectively.
Intravenous administration of slounase, batroxobin or
activated factor X did not cause detectable platelet
adhesion or platelet aggregate formation in the absence of
vascular injury in vivo. Blood flow in
cremaster microcirculation of WT mice was monitored in
real-time and recorded under the intravital microscope.
Circulating platelets were fluorescently labeled as green
and detection of fibrin was achieved by injecting
fluorescently conjugated anti-fibrin antibody as red
in vivo. 1 U/kg of activated factor
X, batroxobin, slounase, or control buffer were
intravenously injected while real-time recording and
continuously monitored for an extended period of time up
to 90 minutes without inducing vascular injury. No
platelet adhesion, aggregation or fibrin formation was
detected in cremaster microcirculation prior to, during,
or up to 90 minutes post injection. Representative
pictures of overlaid bright field with fluorescent
channels after subtracting fluorescent backgrounds (10 min
post injection) show no fluorescent platelet adherence,
aggregation, or fibrin formation on the cremaster
arterioles vessel wall in the absence of injury in
vivo following the injection of slounase
(bottom right), batroxobin (bottom left), or activated
factor X (top right) respectively.
Slounase Treatment Enhances Platelet-Fibrin Hemostatic Clot Formation
in Laser-Ablation Cremaster Arteriole Puncture Hemostasis Model in
Wild-Type Mice
In order to confirm the effects of batroxobin, activated factor X, and
slounase on hemostatic clot formation and bleeding in response to
penetrative vascular injury in vivo, WT mice were intravenously
administered 1 U/kg of batroxobin, activated factor X, or slounase 10
minutes prior to initiating a laser-induced puncture to the wall of
the cremaster arteriole in the intravital microscopy laser-ablation
cremaster arteriole hemostasis model, as we characterized in our
previous study.[40,42] In control mice, immediately upon cremaster arteriole vessel
wall rupture induced by laser, red blood cells (RBCs) and blood
components extravasated from the ruptured section of the cremaster
arteriole, and the bleeding was monitored under a bright field (Figure 2A).
The process of hemostatic clot formation at the site of arterial wall
rupture was recorded under fluorescent channels as platelets
accumulated at the point of vessel injury along with fibrin formation,
leading to the formation of a hemostatic clot, but did not result in
vessel occlusion. Formation of the platelet-rich fibrin clot at the
site of arteriole rupture resulted in diminished RBC extravasation
from the arteriole and led to the complete cessation of RBC leakage
into the extravascular space. The hemostatic response to vascular
injury was significantly enhanced in mice pre-treated with batroxobin,
activated factor X, or slounase when compared to buffer controls
(Figure
2A). As expected, the hemostatic response was robustly
increased in mice treated with activated factor X as both platelet and
fibrin clot formation were significantly enhanced at the site of
vascular injury, resulting in vessel occlusion and interruption of
blood flow. Enhancement of the platelet-fibrin clot by slounase was
modest and limited to the site of vascular injury when compared to
treatment with activated factor X, but seemed stronger than batroxobin
treatment. Overall, all three reagents strongly enhanced hemostatic
clot formation in vivo compared to WT controls
(supplemental movies 1A-D). Analysis of the single frames of images
over time in the bright field indicated a trend toward a reduction in
RBC extravasation time in both the activated factor X and slounase
conditions when compared to the batroxobin and control treatments, but
was not statistically significant in WT mice in normal coagulant
stasis (Figure
2B, Mean RBC extravasation time: control = 105.5 ± 6
seconds; batroxobin= 108.8 ± 15 seconds, activated factor X=99 ± 12
seconds and slounase= 83.4 ± 13 seconds, n = 8 per group
P > 0.05). Quantitative analysis of the
dynamics of platelet accumulation and fibrin formation by florescent
intensity shows a notable increase in platelet recruitment and fibrin
formation by slounase and activated factor X (platelet:
P < 0.0001; fibrin: P <
0.001), while the effect of batroxobin on platelet fibrin within the
clot was modest (Figure 2C).
Figure 2.
Hemostatic clot formation was enhanced in WT normal coagulant
mice pretreated with activated factor X, batroxobin or
slounase. WT mice were pretreated with 1 U/kg of slounase,
batroxobin, activated factor X or control buffer
respectively and hemostatic response and bleeding were
assessed by a laser-ablation puncture to the cremaster
arterioles as described. (A) Representative images of
hemostatic clot formation in response to laser-induced
cremaster arteriole wall rupture. Platelet accumulation is
shown in green, fibrin formation is shown in red and
composite images of hemostatic clot formation are shown in
yellow. (B) The time required for the cessation of RBC
extravasation from arterioles in WT control mice and WT
mice treated with 1U/kg of slounase, batroxobin, or
activated factor X (Data from 2-3 independent injuries per
mouse, 3 mice in each group. P <
0.001). (C) Dynamics of mean fluorescent intensity of
platelets (left) and fibrin (right) in a hemostatic clot
plotted as a function of time. WT mice were pretreated
with slounase, batroxobin, activated factor X or control
buffer and fluorescent intensity was recorded over 5
minutes. The shaded regions are representative of the
standard error (SEM).
Hemostatic clot formation was enhanced in WT normal coagulant
mice pretreated with activated factor X, batroxobin or
slounase. WT mice were pretreated with 1 U/kg of slounase,
batroxobin, activated factor X or control buffer
respectively and hemostatic response and bleeding were
assessed by a laser-ablation puncture to the cremaster
arterioles as described. (A) Representative images of
hemostatic clot formation in response to laser-induced
cremaster arteriole wall rupture. Platelet accumulation is
shown in green, fibrin formation is shown in red and
composite images of hemostatic clot formation are shown in
yellow. (B) The time required for the cessation of RBC
extravasation from arterioles in WT control mice and WT
mice treated with 1U/kg of slounase, batroxobin, or
activated factor X (Data from 2-3 independent injuries per
mouse, 3 mice in each group. P <
0.001). (C) Dynamics of mean fluorescent intensity of
platelets (left) and fibrin (right) in a hemostatic clot
plotted as a function of time. WT mice were pretreated
with slounase, batroxobin, activated factor X or control
buffer and fluorescent intensity was recorded over 5
minutes. The shaded regions are representative of the
standard error (SEM).
Hypocoagulant Activity Induced by Prophylactic Heparin Pretreatment
Resulted in Impaired Clot Formation and Extended Bleeding in Arteriole
Rupture Model
As the conversion of Fg to fibrin in blood by batroxobin occurs in the
presence of heparin, hypocoagulant activity in mice was induced by
heparin treatment and impairment of hemostasis was characterized using
the intravital microscopy laser-ablation cremaster arteriole puncture
hemostasis model in vivo. WT mice were injected with
a high dose of heparin (1000 U/kg) to inhibit thrombin generation and
to create a hypocoagulant condition in the mice. The impairment of
hemostatic clot formation and bleeding associated with the
hypocoagulant condition was characterized in vivo
using a laser-ablation cremaster arteriole puncture model of
hemostasis under intravital microscopy. As expected, heparin-treatment
in mice resulted in a strong inhibition of platelet-fibrin clot
formation and the inability to form a hemostatic clot in response to
vascular injury, which resulted in extended bleeding. Analysis of the
dynamics of mean fluorescent intensity for platelets and fibrin within
the clot showed a complete inhibition of both platelet recruitment and
fibrin formation and prevented the formation of a hemostatic clot at
the site of vascular injury following the arteriole wall rupture when
compared to controls (Figure 3A and C, platelet:
P < 0.001, fibrin: P <
0.001). Although some transient platelet clot formation was observed
immediately following the vessel rupture, the thrombi were unstable
and unable to seal the site of injury during the recorded period of
time (5 min). Due to the strong inhibition of clot formation by
heparin, RBCs and other blood components continuously extravasated
from the injury site during the recording period. Arterial bleeding
time was significantly prolonged and failed to cease for the 5 minutes
recorded (P < 0.0001, n = 8 per group; Figure
3B).
Figure 3.
Heparin treatment in mice potently inhibited platelet
accumulation and fibrin formation at the site of vascular
injury in vivo and impaired hemostasis, resulting in
prolonged bleeding in the laser-ablation cremaster
arteriole puncture hemostasis model. WT mice were
intravenously injected with saline (control) or 1000 U/kg
heparin to inhibit coagulation in vivo
then the hemostatic response and bleeding were assessed by
laser-ablation puncture to the cremaster arterioles as
described. The cremaster muscle arteriole wall was exposed
to a high-intensity laser pulse to puncture a hole, and
bleeding was monitored by RBC extravasation from the
cremaster arterioles wall. The subsequent formation of a
platelet-fibrin hemostatic clot was recorded in real-time
under intravital microscopy. (A) Representative images of
hemostatic clot formation in WT control mice (upper panel)
and WT mice pretreated with heparin in response to
laser-induced cremaster arteriole wall rupture. Platelet
accumulation is shown in green, fibrin formation is shown
in red and composite images are shown in yellow. (B) The
time required for the cessation of RBC extravasation from
arterioles in WT control mice (black) and WT mice treated
with heparin (green) was analyzed by reviewing sequential
images offline. (Data from 2 independent injuries per
mouse, 4 mice in each group. P <
0.0001). (C) Dynamics of platelet accumulation and fibrin
formation in response to injury were assesses by the
changes in the fluorescent intensity of platelets (left)
and fibrin (right) in a hemostatic clot in WT control mice
(black) and WT mice treated with heparin (green). The
shaded regions are representative of the standard error
(SEM).
Heparin treatment in mice potently inhibited platelet
accumulation and fibrin formation at the site of vascular
injury in vivo and impaired hemostasis, resulting in
prolonged bleeding in the laser-ablation cremaster
arteriole puncture hemostasis model. WT mice were
intravenously injected with saline (control) or 1000 U/kg
heparin to inhibit coagulation in vivo
then the hemostatic response and bleeding were assessed by
laser-ablation puncture to the cremaster arterioles as
described. The cremaster muscle arteriole wall was exposed
to a high-intensity laser pulse to puncture a hole, and
bleeding was monitored by RBC extravasation from the
cremaster arterioles wall. The subsequent formation of a
platelet-fibrin hemostatic clot was recorded in real-time
under intravital microscopy. (A) Representative images of
hemostatic clot formation in WT control mice (upper panel)
and WT mice pretreated with heparin in response to
laser-induced cremaster arteriole wall rupture. Platelet
accumulation is shown in green, fibrin formation is shown
in red and composite images are shown in yellow. (B) The
time required for the cessation of RBC extravasation from
arterioles in WT control mice (black) and WT mice treated
with heparin (green) was analyzed by reviewing sequential
images offline. (Data from 2 independent injuries per
mouse, 4 mice in each group. P <
0.0001). (C) Dynamics of platelet accumulation and fibrin
formation in response to injury were assesses by the
changes in the fluorescent intensity of platelets (left)
and fibrin (right) in a hemostatic clot in WT control mice
(black) and WT mice treated with heparin (green). The
shaded regions are representative of the standard error
(SEM).
Slounase Restores Platelet Fibrin Clot Formation and Limits Bleeding
in Heparin-Treated Mice
The effects of slounase, batroxobin, and activated factor X on platelet
recruitment and fibrin formation, the two primary components of the
hemostatic clot, were studied in heparin-induced hypocoagulant mouse
as characterized above. The restoration of blood clotting in
hypocoagulant conditions and reversal of bleeding was assessed in
intravital microscopy laser-ablation cremaster arteriole puncture
hemostasis model in vivo. In heparin-treated control
mice (with buffer treatment), there was a loss of the hemostatic
response as is evidenced by the complete inhibition of fibrin
formation and platelet recruitment into the clot in the laser-ablation
cremaster arteriole puncture model of hemostasis (Figure 4A). Fibrin formation
is detectable at the site of vascular rupture in vivo
in mice that were administered 1 U/kg of batroxobin in the presence of
heparin, confirming that batroxobin indeed converts Fg to fibrin,
independent of thrombin in vivo in the presence of
heparin. Despite the detectable fibrin clot formation in the presence
of batroxobin, there was no notable enhancement of platelet
recruitment into the clot as is shown by the dynamics of florescent
intensity of the platelets (Figure 4A). 1 U/kg of
activated factor X failed to enhance clot formation as the
heparin–anti-thrombin complex strongly inhibits activated factor X.[43] Contrastingly, 1 U/kg of slounase significantly enhanced both
platelet recruitment and fibrin formation and partially restored clot
formation in the presence of heparin, which resulted in a significant
shortening of bleeding time, demonstrating that slounase has much a
much better hemostatic effect than either batroxobin or activated
factor X alone (Figure 4A and B and supplemental movies 2A-D).
Additionally, the effect of slounase was detectable in a 10-fold lower
dose (0.1 U/kg) than batroxobin with no effect on platelet-fibrin clot
formation (Figure
4D). The time required to stop the RBC extravasation was
shorter following the administration of slounase at 1 and 0.1 U/kg
(P < 0.001) compared to batroxobin.
Administration of batroxobin at 0.1 U/kg showed no shortening in
arterial bleeding time (n-6 in each group. P >
0.05) (Figure 4C and
E).
Figure 4.
Slounase treatment restored hemostatic clot formation and
shortened arterial bleeding time in heparin-induced
hypocoagulant mice. WT mice were intravenously injected
with 1000U/kg of heparin to induce a hypocoagulant
condition. After confirming the absence of hemostatic
response to injury using a laser-ablation puncture to the
cremaster arteriole, mice were given intravenous treatment
with 0.1 or 1 U/kg of activated factor X, batroxobin or
slounase. Then, the hemostatic response to injury was
continuously evaluated through RBC extravasation and
hemostatic clot formation in real time under a microscope
in response to the laser-ablation cremaster arteriole
puncture as described. (A) Representative images of
hemostatic clot formation in heparinized WT mice treated
with control buffer or 1U/kg of activated factor X,
batroxobin, or slounase, respectively. (B) Dynamics of
fluorescent intensity of platelets (top) and fibrin
(bottom) in a hemostatic clot in heparinized WT mice
treated with saline or 1U/kg of activated factor X,
batroxobin or slounase (P < 0.001).
The shaded regions are representative of the standard
error (SEM). (C) The time required for the cessation of
RBC extravasation from arterioles in heparinized WT mice
treated with saline or 1 U/kg (left) of activated factor
X, batroxobin or slounase. (Data from 2 independent
injuries per mouse, 3 mice in each group.
P<0.0001). (D) Dynamics of
fluorescent intensity of platelets (left) and fibrin
(right) in a hemostatic clot in heparinized WT mice
treated with saline or 0.1 U/kg of activated factor X,
batroxobin or slounase. The shaded regions are
representative of the standard error (SEM). (E) The time
required for the cessation of RBC extravasation from
arterioles in heparinized WT mice treated with saline or
0.1 U/kg of activated factor X, batroxobin or slounase.
(Data from 2 independent injuries per mouse, 3 mice in
each group. P < 0.0001).
Slounase treatment restored hemostatic clot formation and
shortened arterial bleeding time in heparin-induced
hypocoagulant mice. WT mice were intravenously injected
with 1000U/kg of heparin to induce a hypocoagulant
condition. After confirming the absence of hemostatic
response to injury using a laser-ablation puncture to the
cremaster arteriole, mice were given intravenous treatment
with 0.1 or 1 U/kg of activated factor X, batroxobin or
slounase. Then, the hemostatic response to injury was
continuously evaluated through RBC extravasation and
hemostatic clot formation in real time under a microscope
in response to the laser-ablation cremaster arteriole
puncture as described. (A) Representative images of
hemostatic clot formation in heparinized WT mice treated
with control buffer or 1U/kg of activated factor X,
batroxobin, or slounase, respectively. (B) Dynamics of
fluorescent intensity of platelets (top) and fibrin
(bottom) in a hemostatic clot in heparinized WT mice
treated with saline or 1U/kg of activated factor X,
batroxobin or slounase (P < 0.001).
The shaded regions are representative of the standard
error (SEM). (C) The time required for the cessation of
RBC extravasation from arterioles in heparinized WT mice
treated with saline or 1 U/kg (left) of activated factor
X, batroxobin or slounase. (Data from 2 independent
injuries per mouse, 3 mice in each group.
P<0.0001). (D) Dynamics of
fluorescent intensity of platelets (left) and fibrin
(right) in a hemostatic clot in heparinized WT mice
treated with saline or 0.1 U/kg of activated factor X,
batroxobin or slounase. The shaded regions are
representative of the standard error (SEM). (E) The time
required for the cessation of RBC extravasation from
arterioles in heparinized WT mice treated with saline or
0.1 U/kg of activated factor X, batroxobin or slounase.
(Data from 2 independent injuries per mouse, 3 mice in
each group. P < 0.0001).
Slounase Enhances Hemostatic Clot Formation in Large Vessels in
Heparin-Treated Mice
The effect of slounase on hemostatic clot formation in large vessel
injury was assessed in heparin-treated, hypocoagulant mice using the
intravital microscopy saphenous vein hemostasis model with repeated
penetrative vascular injury at 0, 5, and 10 minutes as described.[41] Induction of a penetrative injury on the saphenous vein vessel
wall by a high intensity laser resulted in the immediate accumulation
of platelets at the site of injury along with the formation of a
fibrin ring that surrounded the edges of the vascular injury to
stabilize the clot. Applying the repeated laser injury on the
saphenous vein vessel wall resulted in the formation of a serially
larger and more robust, stable platelet-fibrin hemostatic clot (Figure 5A and
B). Fibrin formation was strongly inhibited in response
to injury in heparin-treated mice. However, unlike the cremaster
arteriole puncture hemostasis model, platelet accumulation was
diminished, but not abolished despite the high dose of heparin
treatment. Platelet accumulation was observed shortly after vein
injury, but was transient, unstable, and easily embolized, as is
evidenced by the sharp drop in platelet intensity (Figure 5B).
Consistent with the cremaster hemostatic model, activated factor X
administration did not significantly enhanced platelet-fibrin clot
formation at the site of injury. Batroxobin treatment restored some
fibrin formation at the site of vascular injury, but did not enhance
platelet recruitment. Slounase treatment significantly enhanced
platelet recruitment and fibrin formation, leading to a more stable
hemostatic clot in response to repeated vascular injury (N = 6, n = 8
per group, P < 0.01. Figure 5B).
Figure 5.
Slounase treatment enhances hemostatic plug formation in the
saphenous vein of hypocoagulant mice. WT mice were
intravenously injected with control buffer or 1000 U/kg of
heparin to induce a hypocoagulant condition. Subgroups of
heparin-treated mice were also were given intravenous
treatment with 1 U/kg of activated factor X, batroxobin
and slounase. Hemostatic plug formation in the saphenous
vein wall was assessed using laser-ablation cremaster
arteriole hemostasis model under intravital microscopy as
described. (A) Representative images of the saphenous vein
in multi-channel prior to vascular injury (with a
fluorescent background) are shown in the top panel.
Representative images of hemostatic clot formation after
vascular injury (2nd laser injury after the subtraction of
the fluorescent background) in control WT mice, WT mice
treated with heparin alone, or further treated with 1 U/kg
of activated factor X, batroxobin or slounase, are shown
below as indicated. Within the hemostatic plug that formed
at the site of injury on the saphenous vessel wall,
platelet accumulation is shown in green, fibrin formation
is shown in red and composite images are shown in yellow.
(B) Quantitative analysis of platelet accumulation and
fibrin formation in the hemostatic clot with repetitive
vascular injury to the saphenous vein. Times of vascular
injury are indicated at 30 seconds and repeated at 5 and
10 minutes. The kinetic curves represent the relative
platelet (top) and fibrin (bottom) fluorescent intensity
(n = 6; 2 independent injuries in each mouse, 3 mice in
each group). Slounase treatment in heparinized WT mice
partially restored clot formation by enhancing platelet
adhesion and accumulation as well as fibrin formation
(P < 0.05) in the saphenous vein
when compared with batroxobin and activated factor X
treatment in heparin-treated hypocoagulant mice.
Slounase treatment enhances hemostatic plug formation in the
saphenous vein of hypocoagulant mice. WT mice were
intravenously injected with control buffer or 1000 U/kg of
heparin to induce a hypocoagulant condition. Subgroups of
heparin-treated mice were also were given intravenous
treatment with 1 U/kg of activated factor X, batroxobin
and slounase. Hemostatic plug formation in the saphenous
vein wall was assessed using laser-ablation cremaster
arteriole hemostasis model under intravital microscopy as
described. (A) Representative images of the saphenous vein
in multi-channel prior to vascular injury (with a
fluorescent background) are shown in the top panel.
Representative images of hemostatic clot formation after
vascular injury (2nd laser injury after the subtraction of
the fluorescent background) in control WT mice, WT mice
treated with heparin alone, or further treated with 1 U/kg
of activated factor X, batroxobin or slounase, are shown
below as indicated. Within the hemostatic plug that formed
at the site of injury on the saphenous vessel wall,
platelet accumulation is shown in green, fibrin formation
is shown in red and composite images are shown in yellow.
(B) Quantitative analysis of platelet accumulation and
fibrin formation in the hemostatic clot with repetitive
vascular injury to the saphenous vein. Times of vascular
injury are indicated at 30 seconds and repeated at 5 and
10 minutes. The kinetic curves represent the relative
platelet (top) and fibrin (bottom) fluorescent intensity
(n = 6; 2 independent injuries in each mouse, 3 mice in
each group). Slounase treatment in heparinized WT mice
partially restored clot formation by enhancing platelet
adhesion and accumulation as well as fibrin formation
(P < 0.05) in the saphenous vein
when compared with batroxobin and activated factor X
treatment in heparin-treated hypocoagulant mice.
Slounase Treatment Reduces Blood Loss in Liver Injury in
Heparin-Treated Hypocoagulant Mice
Intravital microscopic in vivo hemostasis models are
advantageous in their ability to image and compare clot formation and
bleeding time. However, it is difficult to evaluate the amount of
blood loss following a severe vascular injury in these models.
Therefore, the hemostatic effect of slounase on blood loss was
assessed in a liver injury model in heparin-treated, hypocoagulant
mice. Total blood loss from a severe liver injury was significantly
reduced in slounase-treated mice, which is consistent with the results
from the other hemostasis models tested (Figure 6A and B;
P < 0.05). No significant change in blood
loss was observed in the activated factor X treatment group under the
same experimental conditions (5 mice/group, P >
0.05). While a trend toward decreased blood loss was observed in the
presence of batroxobin, this was not observed to be statistically
significant (P > 0.05).
Figure 6.
Slounase treatment reduces total blood loss in the liver
wound model. (A) Mice were treated with 1000U/kg of
heparin followed by an intravenous injection with 1U/kg of
slounase, batroxobin, or activated factor X respectively.
Blood loss in mice was assessed using a pre-weighed filter
paper following a needle injury to the left lobe of the
mouse liver as described (top). Bleeding in hypocoagulant
mice induced by heparin following the injury is shown
(bottom). (B) Total amount of blood lost in mice treated
with heparin alone or further treated with activated
factor X, batroxobin or slounase. Slounase treatment
effectively reduced the blood loss when compared to
control buffer treatment in the hypocoagulant condition
induced by heparin treatment (n = 5 mice /group,
P < 0.05).
Slounase treatment reduces total blood loss in the liver
wound model. (A) Mice were treated with 1000U/kg of
heparin followed by an intravenous injection with 1U/kg of
slounase, batroxobin, or activated factor X respectively.
Blood loss in mice was assessed using a pre-weighed filter
paper following a needle injury to the left lobe of the
mouse liver as described (top). Bleeding in hypocoagulant
mice induced by heparin following the injury is shown
(bottom). (B) Total amount of blood lost in mice treated
with heparin alone or further treated with activated
factor X, batroxobin or slounase. Slounase treatment
effectively reduced the blood loss when compared to
control buffer treatment in the hypocoagulant condition
induced by heparin treatment (n = 5 mice /group,
P < 0.05).
Discussion
Rapid response to vascular injury resulting in stable hemostasis is a key
element in minimizing morbidity and mortality due to excessive blood loss
following traumatic injury or surgery. Uncontrolled bleeding is associated
with serious adverse outcomes including shock, blood transfusions, extended
surgery time, impaired wound healing, longer hospital stays, and death.[1,25] The prevalence and clinical burden of hemorrhage remains considerably
high, as bleeding is associated with more than one third of deaths as a
result of trauma in the hospital setting.[44] Achieving the prompt cessation of bleeding is critical in maintaining
hemodynamic stability, ensuring oxygen delivery to vital tissues, and
preventing organ failure. Despite advances in the understanding of the roles
of the platelet and coagulation pathways in thrombosis and hemostasis, the
availability of effective, reliable, and safe hemostatic agents is still
limited. There is an urgent, unmet need for effective systemic
pharmacological hemostatic agents, especially for patients in hypocoagulant
conditions at risk of bleeding. Snake venom serum proteinases are known to
alter the hemostatic balance of the various key factors in platelets and the
coagulation/fibrinolysis cascade.[26] The biochemical properties and effects of batroxobin coagulation have
been well characterized. The hemostatic benefits of batroxobin contribute to
its ability to form fibrin in a thrombin independent manner.[36] However, its effect on hemostatic clot composition and platelet
procoagulant activity in vivo is not yet studied due to the
lack of reliable in vivo hemostasis models. In this study,
we used intravital microscopy-based micro- and macro-vascular in
vivo hemostasis models to quantitatively assess the
hemostatic effect of slounase compared to batroxobin and activated factor X.
Notably, we investigated the mechanistic insights of their effect on
platelet recruitment and fibrin formation, the two key components of clots,
in an in vivo setting in both normal and hypocoagulant mice
to explore an effective strategy to enhance hemostasis.Snake venoms toxins contain a variety of components that exert procoagulant,
anticoagulant, pro-platelet and anti-platelet functions, as well as
fibrinolytic activators and hemorrhaging.[45,46] The efficacy and safety of hemostatic agents purified from snake
venom for the treatment of hemostatic disorders largely depend on the
biochemical properties and purity of derivates of snake venom during the
manufacturing process. Targeting the key steps to enhance hemostasis may be
associated with a higher risk of thrombosis or bleeding. Our results from
real-time monitoring of microcirculation under intravital microcopy confirm
that an intravenous injection of slounase, batroxobin or activated factor X
into mice did not cause any detectable adhesion or aggregation of
fluorescently labeled platelets or spontaneously induce fibrin formation in
the absence of vascular injury, demonstrating the safety profile of all
three treatments in vivo. Modification of the existing
cremaster arteriole thrombotic hemostasis model with a penetrative vascular
injury by laser under intravital microscopic imaging allowed us to real-time
monitor and quantitatively assess both hemostatic clot composition and
bleeding in vivo without causing vessel occlusion.
Consistent with the reports from published studies, our results show that
batroxobin treatment indeed promotes platelet-fibrin clot formation by
enhancing fibrin formation at the site of vascular rupture in normal WT mice.[36,47] As expected, the hemostatic response at the site of injury to
vascular rupture was robustly enhanced and caused massive intravascular
clotting, resulting in vessel occlusion in WT mice pretreated with a high
dose of activated factor X.Our results indicate that a high dose of activated factor X could increase the
risk of vessel occlusion and may not be a safe approach for maintaining
hemostasis. Nevertheless, inhibiting the activation of factor X remains an
attractive anti-thrombotic approach. In contrast, slounase treatment in WT
mice in vivo resulted in a modest enhancement in both
platelet and fibrin clot formation in a cremaster arteriole rupture model,
supporting slounase as exhibiting a better safety profile for hemostasis
compared to activated factor X. Remarkably, the limited amount of activated
factor X contained in slounase seems to lead to the enhancement of platelet
recruitment into the fibrin clot but does not result in vessel occlusion as
activated factor X is known to enhance thrombin generation.[38,48] This result indicates that the modest promotion of platelet
recruitment along with enhanced fibrin formation might be a viable
hemostatic approach.In order to imitate hypocoagulant conditions and increased bleeding risk in
bleeding disorders in vivo, mice were treated with heparin
to inhibit thrombin generation and activation of coagulation. As we
expected, heparin treatment resulted in the inhibition of fibrin formation
and platelet accumulation, ultimately extending bleeding time in response to
vascular injury in the cremaster arterioles and saphenous vein models.
Batroxobin treatment in mice under these hypocoagulant conditions was shown
to promote the formation of a fibrin clot at the site of injury, shortening
the arterial bleeding time despite the presence of heparin. This result
confirms that batroxobin induces fibrin clot formation and promotes
hemostasis in vivo independent of thrombin. However,
platelet accumulation associated with enhanced fibrin formation in
batroxobin treated mice was not significant, indicating batroxobin alone may
not sufficiently promote platelet procoagulant activity. Activated factor X
failed to enhance clot formation when administered alone in the presence of
heparin. This was expected as it has been previously shown that the
heparin–anti-thrombin complex strongly inhibits activated factor X.[43] In contrast with results from activated factor X treatment in
heparin-treated mice, we observed that slounase was able to enhance clot
formation by promoting both fibrin formation and platelet recruitment in the
presence of heparin. The ability of the activated factor X contained in
slounase to promote platelet procoagulant activity could be a result of a
modification leading to the stabilization of activated factor X through its
interaction with batroxobin, or possibly due to the local availability and
concentration of heparin present at the site of vascular injury. The effects
and implications of this interaction could be a topic of future study.
Nevertheless, our data strongly indicate that slounase exhibited a more
desirable hemostatic profile by enhancing both platelet accumulation and
fibrin formation, the two primary components required for clot formation in
micro and macro vascular injury models, even under hypocoagulant conditions.
Our results are further supported by the decreased blood loss in
slounase-treated mice in the liver injury model.Interestingly, the observation that slounase effectively enhanced
platelet-fibrin clot formation in the presence of heparin demonstrates its
ability to bypass coagulation. The use of bypassing agents in a clinical
setting has provided a useful method of circumventing defects in the
clotting cascade.[49,50] By inhibiting thrombin using heparin, we are able to show that
slounase has the ability to bypass coagulation, leading to the formation of
a platelet-fibrin clot in a thrombin-independent manner.[51] However, future investigations into the effect of slounase on other
hypocoagulent conditions, such as hemophilia and the loss of platelet
coagulation factor due to trauma, as well as in the presence of other
anti-platelet and anti-coagulant therapies could reveal more potential
clinical applications. Our study results suggest that slounase may represent
an effective bypassing hemostatic agent and could be beneficial in treating
defects in the coagulation pathway.In summary, our study results strongly indicate that slounase enhances
hemostasis in normocoagulable conditions and restores hemostasis by
shortening bleeding time and blood loss in the event of vascular injury in
hypocoagulant stasis. Notably, our study results show that slounase improves
hemostasis by both enhancing fibrin formation and platelet procoagulant
activity, while batroxobin mainly enhances fibrin formation in
vivo. Findings from this study provide important mechanistic
insight into hemostatic clot formation in vivo and
demonstrate the potential benefit of developing therapeutic approaches to
achieve better hemostasis for the treatment of bleeding disorders.Click here for additional data file.Supplemental Material, sj-docx-1-cat-10.1177_10760296211018510 for
Slounase, a Batroxobin Containing Activated Factor X Effectively
Enhances Hemostatic Clot Formation and Reducing Bleeding in
Hypocoagulant Conditions in Mice by Reheman Adili, Madeline Jackson,
Livia Stanger, Xiangrong Dai, Mandy Li, Benjamin Xiaoyi Li and Michael
Holinstat in Clinical and Applied Thrombosis/Hemostasis
Authors: Yiming Wang; Adili Reheman; Christopher M Spring; Jalil Kalantari; Alexandra H Marshall; Alisa S Wolberg; Peter L Gross; Jeffrey I Weitz; Margaret L Rand; Deane F Mosher; John Freedman; Heyu Ni Journal: J Clin Invest Date: 2014-09-02 Impact factor: 14.808