Catherine Arsenault1, Bereket Yakob2, Tizta Tilahun2, Tsinuel Girma Nigatu2, Girmaye Dinsa2,3, Mirkuzie Woldie2,4, Munir Kassa4, Peter Berman5,6, Margaret E Kruk5. 1. Department of Global Health and Population, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, 665 Huntington Avenue, Boston, MA, 02115, USA. carsenault@hsph.harvard.edu. 2. Fenot Project, Harvard T.H. Chan school of Public Health and School of Population and Public Health, University of British Columbia, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. 3. Department of Public Health and Health Policy, College of Health Sciences, Haramaya University, Harar, Ethiopia. 4. Ministry of Health, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. 5. Department of Global Health and Population, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, 665 Huntington Avenue, Boston, MA, 02115, USA. 6. School of Population and Public Health, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Several studies have reported inadequate levels of quality of care in the Ethiopian health system. Facility characteristics associated with better quality remain unclear. Understanding associations between patient volumes and quality of care could help organize service delivery and potentially improve patient outcomes. METHODS: Using data from the routine health management information system (HMIS) and the 2014 Ethiopian Service Provision Assessment survey + we assessed associations between daily total outpatient volumes and quality of services. Quality of care at the facility level was estimated as the average of five measures of provider knowledge (clinical vignettes on malaria and tuberculosis) and competence (observations of family planning, antenatal care and sick child care consultations). We used linear regression models adjusted for several facility-level confounders and region fixed effects with log-transformed patient volume fitted as a linear spline. We repeated analyses for the association between volume of antenatal care visits and quality. RESULTS: Our analysis included 424 facilities including 270 health centers, 45 primary hospitals and 109 general hospitals in Ethiopia. Quality was low across all facilities ranging from only 18 to 56% with a mean score of 38%. Outpatient volume varied from less than one patient per day to 581. We found a small but statistically significant association between volume and quality which appeared non-linear, with an inverted U-shape. Among facilities seeing less than 90.6 outpatients per day, quality increased with greater patient volumes. Among facilities seeing 90.6 or more outpatients per day, quality decreased with greater patient volumes. We found a similar association between volume and quality of antenatal care visits. CONCLUSIONS: Health care utilization and quality must be improved throughout the health system in Ethiopia. Our results are suggestive of a potential U-shape association between volume and quality of primary care services. Understanding the links between volume of patients and quality of care may provide insights for organizing service delivery in Ethiopia and similar contexts.
BACKGROUND: Several studies have reported inadequate levels of quality of care in the Ethiopian health system. Facility characteristics associated with better quality remain unclear. Understanding associations between patient volumes and quality of care could help organize service delivery and potentially improve patient outcomes. METHODS: Using data from the routine health management information system (HMIS) and the 2014 Ethiopian Service Provision Assessment survey + we assessed associations between daily total outpatient volumes and quality of services. Quality of care at the facility level was estimated as the average of five measures of provider knowledge (clinical vignettes on malaria and tuberculosis) and competence (observations of family planning, antenatal care and sick child care consultations). We used linear regression models adjusted for several facility-level confounders and region fixed effects with log-transformed patient volume fitted as a linear spline. We repeated analyses for the association between volume of antenatal care visits and quality. RESULTS: Our analysis included 424 facilities including 270 health centers, 45 primary hospitals and 109 general hospitals in Ethiopia. Quality was low across all facilities ranging from only 18 to 56% with a mean score of 38%. Outpatient volume varied from less than one patient per day to 581. We found a small but statistically significant association between volume and quality which appeared non-linear, with an inverted U-shape. Among facilities seeing less than 90.6 outpatients per day, quality increased with greater patient volumes. Among facilities seeing 90.6 or more outpatients per day, quality decreased with greater patient volumes. We found a similar association between volume and quality of antenatal care visits. CONCLUSIONS: Health care utilization and quality must be improved throughout the health system in Ethiopia. Our results are suggestive of a potential U-shape association between volume and quality of primary care services. Understanding the links between volume of patients and quality of care may provide insights for organizing service delivery in Ethiopia and similar contexts.
Authors: John D Birkmeyer; Andrea E Siewers; Emily V A Finlayson; Therese A Stukel; F Lee Lucas; Ida Batista; H Gilbert Welch; David E Wennberg Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2002-04-11 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Mengiste M Mesfin; James N Newell; John D Walley; Amanuel Gessessew; Tassew Tesfaye; Frew Lemma; Richard J Madeley Journal: Health Policy Plan Date: 2009-08-03 Impact factor: 3.344
Authors: Nathan P Miller; Agbessi Amouzou; Mengistu Tafesse; Elizabeth Hazel; Hailemariam Legesse; Tedbabe Degefie; Cesar G Victora; Robert E Black; Jennifer Bryce Journal: Am J Trop Med Hyg Date: 2014-05-05 Impact factor: 2.345
Authors: Andrew Cheung; Thérèse A Stukel; David A Alter; Richard H Glazier; Vicki Ling; Xuesong Wang; Baiju R Shah Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 2016-12-13 Impact factor: 25.391