Karmel S Gkika1, Sara Noorani2, Naomi Walsh2, Tia E Keyes1. 1. School of Chemical Sciences, National Centre for Sensor Research, Dublin City University, Dublin 9, Ireland. 2. School of Biotechnology, National Institute for Cellular Biotechnology, Dublin City University, Dublin 9, Ireland.
Abstract
The preparation of two polyarginine conjugates of the complex Os(II) [bis-(4'-(4-carboxyphenyl)-2,2':6',2″-terpyridine)] [Os-(Rn)2]x+ (n = 4 and 8; x = 10 and 18) is reported, to explore whether the R8 peptide sequence that promotes cell uptake requires a contiguous amino acid sequence for membrane permeation or if this can be accomplished in a linearly bridged structure with the additive effect of shorter peptide sequences. The conjugates exhibit NIR emission centered at 754 nm and essentially oxygen-insensitive emission with a lifetime of 89 ns in phosphate-buffered saline. The uptake, distribution, and cytotoxicity of the parent complex and peptide derivatives were compared in 2D cell monolayers and a three-dimensional (3D) multicellular tumor spheroid (MCTS) model. Whereas, the bis-octaarginine sequences were impermeable to cells and spheroids, and the bis-tetraarginine conjugate showed excellent cellular uptake and accumulation in two 2D monolayer cell lines and remarkable in-depth penetration of 3D MCTSs of pancreatic cancer cells. Overall, the data indicates that cell permeability can be promoted via non-contiguous sequences of arginine residues bridged across the metal centre.
The preparation of two polyarginine conjugates of the complex Os(II) [bis-(4'-(4-carboxyphenyl)-2,2':6',2″-terpyridine)] [Os-(Rn)2]x+ (n = 4 and 8; x = 10 and 18) is reported, to explore whether the R8 peptide sequence that promotes cell uptake requires a contiguous amino acid sequence for membrane permeation or if this can be accomplished in a linearly bridged structure with the additive effect of shorter peptide sequences. The conjugates exhibit NIR emission centered at 754 nm and essentially oxygen-insensitive emission with a lifetime of 89 ns in phosphate-buffered saline. The uptake, distribution, and cytotoxicity of the parent complex and peptide derivatives were compared in 2D cell monolayers and a three-dimensional (3D) multicellular tumor spheroid (MCTS) model. Whereas, the bis-octaarginine sequences were impermeable to cells and spheroids, and the bis-tetraarginine conjugate showed excellent cellular uptake and accumulation in two 2D monolayer cell lines and remarkable in-depth penetration of 3D MCTSs of pancreatic cancer cells. Overall, the data indicates that cell permeability can be promoted via non-contiguous sequences of arginine residues bridged across the metal centre.
Metal complex luminophores,
most widely classified as phosphors,
have emerged in the past decade as feasible alternatives to organic
fluorophores for intracellular imaging and sensing.[1,2] The
attractive photophysical properties of such complexes have been widely
reported, and for complexes of ruthenium, these include good photostability,
long emission lifetimes, and Stokes-shifted emission in the red spectral
region.[3−6] While the emission maxima of complexes of Ir(III) and Ru(II) can
be tuned toward the NIR, it can be synthetically challenging and such
tuning may compromise photostability, exacerbated in the physiological
conditions of temperature and buffered media, as well as emission
quantum yield.[7−9] Conversely, osmium (II) polypyridyl complexes exhibit
similar advantages to Ru(II) for imaging but with the additional benefits
of outstanding photostability and deep-red to NIR emission in the
700–850 nm spectral region, making them attractive candidates,
in particular for tissue imaging (although still prone to the impact
of the energy gap law). Although Os(II) polypyridyl complexes have
to date, been much less explored for imaging applications than Ir
or Ru, they are gaining increasing focus.[10−15] Another advantage is that such complexes have long lifetimes in
comparison to organic fluorophores. Os(II) complexes usually exhibit
considerably shorter emission lifetimes than Ru(II) analogues and
thus show low oxygen sensitivity. With lower oxidation potentials
than ruthenium analogues, osmium complexes may also show sensitivity
to other redox species without interference from oxygen. Typically
molecular weight, charge, and lipophilicity mitigate against the membrane
permeability of osmium (II) polypyridyl complexes, providing a barrier
to in-cellulo applications but one rational approach to improve the
efficacy of cellular uptake is to conjugate to short cationic peptides
classified as cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs). The ability of cationic
peptide sequences to cross the cell membrane and facilitate the uptake
of small molecules was first demonstrated in 1965 by Ryser and Hancock
with the cationic amino acid-mediated enhanced uptake of albumin,
followed by studies on conjugation of poly-l-lysine to albumin
and horseradish peroxidase.[16,17] The most studied CPP
is likely the arginine-rich HIV-Tat transduction protein (RKKRRQRRR)
from immunodeficiency virus that has been widely shown to efficiently
cross lipid bilayers.[18,19] Indeed, homopolymers of arginine
(polyarginines) have shown superior cellular uptake compared to other
cationic analogues.[20] The details of the
mechanism by which oligoarginines permeate the membrane remain under
investigation. The key pathway in live cells appears to be ATP-activated
endocytosis,[21] but there are also a number
of studies that show that polyarginine can promote permeation through
a passive mechanism,[22] and they have been
shown in artificial membranes to induce leakiness and topological
changes at the membrane.[23] Polyarginine
interactions with cell surface lipids and formation of neutral complexes
that transport across the bilayer have also been reported as well
as surface attachment through interactions with heparan sulfate proteoglycans.[24−28] Cargo transduction seems to occur for 6–11 Arg residues,
with octaarginine (Arg8 or R8) and nona-arginine (Arg9) being most
efficiently transported.[20] We and others
have reported that R5 or sequences of lower Arg residues are not CPPs,[29] whereas R8 is very effective at promoting metal
complex permeation.[30]Barton and
Brunner first reported the cellular uptake of cargo-carrying
peptide rhodium complexes.[31] Our group
reported the efficient octaarginine-driven transport of an otherwise
cell-impermeable Ru(II) polypyridyl compound, [Ru(bpy)2(pic)]2+, and its application in luminescence imaging.[30] Puckett and Barton also reported the uptake
of ruthenium (II)-dppz (dipyrido[3,2-a:2′,3′-c]phenazine)
complexes conjugated to octaargine.[32] Nona-arginine
sequences containing phenylalanine residues have shown to enhance
the cellular uptake of metallocene derivatives.[33] Shorter polymers of arginine, below Arg6, are less efficient
in cellular uptake, whereas longer polymers have shown unpredictable
uptake and can even exert toxic effects.[20,30,34] Sadler and co-workers reported improved
uptake of a permeable Os(II)arene complex upon conjugation to R5
and R8 with the latter showing increased accumulation and toxicity.[35] The monoarginine conjugate, however, showed
a similar uptake to the unfunctionalized parent complex. Therefore,
while there is a clear correlation between R-chain lengths and cellular
uptake for metal complexes, the attachment of cationic amino acid
residues below 5 or above 9 does not guarantee uptake in a predictable
manner.Our group exploited the use of non-specific and targeted
CPPs to
efficiently drive metal complexes across the cell membrane and target
specific organelles.[9,36−40] For example, the light-switching RuII complex
with dppz conjugated to a nuclear localization signal sequence was
highly effective in selectively driving the complex to the nucleus
for imaging of chromosomal DNA using stimulated emission depletion
(STED) microscopy,[39] whereas the Ru-dppz
conjugate bearing a mitochondrial targeting peptide localized at the
mitochondria, confirmed by Raman spectroscopy and luminescence lifetime
imaging.[41] We recently demonstrated that
polyarginines are equally effective in promoting the uptake of Os(II)
polypyridyl complexes where R8 conjugated to [Os(bpy)2(pic)]2+ (bpy = 2,2-bipyridyl, pic = 2(4-carboxylphenyl) imidazo[4,5f]-[1,10]phenanthroline)
facilitated the uptake of the highly photostable and NIR emitting
complex in mammalian cell lines.[11]While 2D monolayer studies can provide valuable information at
the single cell level for a given cell line, three-dimensional (3D)
cell models such as cell aggregates and spheroid structures provide
a more physiologically relevant tumor tissue microenvironment.[42−44] The multi-cellular layering of cells within spheroids leads to the
formation of nutrient and oxygen gradients with hypoxic/necrotic regions
toward the spheroid core and can better reflect permeation of a given
species in vivo than in 2D cell culture where low cell density, lack
of diffusion gradients, and cell–substrate interactions impact
behavior.[45−47] 3D cell models are of growing importance in drug
discovery and toxicity testing. Their application requires luminescent
probes that can deeply permeate the tumor spheroid and also probes
capable of sensing within this environment. It has been shown that
for fluorophores used for contrast, permeation of 2D models does not
guarantee permeation of 3D models and that significant differences
in the extent of permeation and destination of fluorescent probes
can occur.[48]Conjugation to polyarginines
has been used to facilitate the uptake
of gadolinium (III)-based contrast agents for magnetic resonance imaging.[49−51] In addition, although polyarginines have been shown to be highly
effective in promoting cellular uptake of transition metal luminophores,
there have been no studies to date on whether this promotion extends
to 3D cell models. The importance of tumor penetration is also crucial
in the context of therapy by metallodrugs and photodynamic therapy
agents as drug response in 3D cell models may differ when compared
to 2D monolayers.[52−55]A number of non-peptidic approaches to promote metal complexes
in spheroid models have been reported recently. In the context of
therapy, a dinuclear photo-oxidizing RuII(TAP)2 (TAP = 1,4,5,8-tetraazaphenanthrene) complex was reported, showing
in-depth photo-induced cell death of melanoma spheroids using two-photon
excitation.[56] Pt(II)–porphyrin probes
have been employed for 2D and cell spheroid imaging particularly in
the context of phosphorescence-based oxygen sensing.[57] Haycock et al. reported the use of a small-molecule platinum
(II) complex for oxygen mapping of melanoma spheroids using one-photon
phosphorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (PLIM).[58] More recently, two Ir(III) complexes were studied for in vivo PLIM O2 mapping.[59] Papkovsky, Dmitriev, and co-workers have reported metalloluminophores
with long emissive states ranging from Pt(II)–porphyrin probes
to click-assembled Pd(II)–porphyrin nanoconjugates for NIR
mapping of oxygen distribution in 3D microenvironments.[60,61] Efficient cellular uptake of rather large porphyrins is often problematic
in 2D monolayers and 3D models. While nanoparticles can provide a
route for spontaneous or targeted cellular uptake, this strategy requires
expertise in synthesis, and often cellular uptake is unpredictable.
For example, despite the targeting capability of transferrin-conjugated
gold nanoparticles, limited penetration was observed in multicellular
spheroids.[62]Herein, we investigate
whether R8 is as effective in driving permeation
of osmiumNIR emitting luminophore in 3D tumor spheroids as it is
in 2D cell monolayers. We recently reported the successful conjugation
of two mitochondrial penetrating peptides (MPPs) to an achiral osmium
(II) terpyridine complex.[40] The conjugate
showed relatively intense emission in the NIR and excellent photostability,
making it suitable for tissue imaging. The advantage of this complex
is that it does not form isomers and crucially it has conjugation
points at the opposing apices of the complex, thus creating essentially
a linear arrangement of the conjugation sites bridged by the metal.
Here, the Os(II) parent complex [Os(tpybenzCOOH)2]2+ was conjugated to two polyarginine chains of varying lengths
(R4 and R8), and we explore whether the optimal R8 requires a contiguous
peptide structure for uptake or whether it can be accomplished in
a bridged structure with a shorter peptide sequence. We report on
the cellular uptake and localization in a cancerous and non-cancerous
cell line using confocal and lifetime imaging. For the first time,
we investigate the ability of the peptide conjugates to penetrate
3D cell models in pancreatic cancer multicellular tumor spheroids
(MCTSs). To our knowledge, this is the first study of a polyarginine-driven
osmium (II) conjugate used for 3D spheroid imaging.
Experimental Section
Materials
All chemicals and reagents,
cell culture
media, and corresponding components were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich
(Ireland) and were used as received without further purification.
Fetal bovine serum (FBS), heat-inactivated, was purchased from Biosciences
Limited. Polyarginine sequences R8 and R4 (>95%) were procured
from
Celtek Peptides, TN, USA. Resazurin reagent was purchased from PromoKine,
and co-localizing dyes were purchased from Thermo Fisher Scientific.
Instrumentation
1H and COSY NMR spectra
were recorded at 600 MHz using a Bruker spectrometer, and a deuterated
solvent was used for homonuclear lock. The spectra were processed
and calibrated against solvent peaks using Bruker Topspin software
(v3.6.2). High-resolution mass spectrometry (HR-MS) was performed
at the Mass Spectrometry Facility, NUI Maynooth. Analytical HPLC was
performed on a Varian 940-LC with a photometric diode array (PDA)
detector with peak monitoring at 280 and 490 nm channels. Gradient
elution was applied using a 0.1% v/v TFA in the MeCN/water mixture.
The mobile phase was of HPLC-grade quality and was filtered and purged
with nitrogen prior to use. Prior to sample injection, the samples
were filtered (0.8 μm pore size). The typical chromatographic
run time was 20 min at a flow rate of 1 mL min–1.
Synthesis
The [Os(tpybenzCOOH)2]2+ parent complex was prepared according to the synthetic procedure
reported in the literature.[40,63] The general procedure
for the preparation of Os(II) bioconjugates is described below. The
purity and characterization data are included in the Supporting Information.
Preparation of Os(II) Bioconjugates, [Os-(R)2] (n = 4 and 8; x = 10 and 18)
[Os(tpybenzCOOH)2]2+ (1 equiv), 20 mg of
peptide (4 equiv), DIPEA
(20 equiv), and PyBOP (8 equiv) were dissolved in 700 μL of
DMF. The reaction mixture was stirred for 24 h at room temperature.
The mixture was added dropwise to saturated NH4PF6 (aq) to obtain dark brown solids which were collected via vacuum filtration and washed with water and diethyl ether. The solids
were dissolved in acetone and added dropwise to a TBAC/acetone solution
to obtain the chloride salt of the peptide conjugate. The solids were
washed with copious amounts of acetone and diethyl ether yielding
[Os-(R)2] (n = 4 and 8; x = 10 and
18).
All absorbance measurements
were performed on a Jasco V670 Spectrophotometer (Jasco Spectra Manager
v2 software). Emission spectra were obtained using a Varian Cary Eclipse
Fluorescence Spectrophotometer (Varian Cary Eclipse Software v1.1).
The excitation and emission slit widths were set to 10 nm unless stated
otherwise. Lifetime measurements were performed on a PicoQuant FluoTime
100 FLS TCSPC system using a 450 nm pulsed laser (PicoQuant PDL800-B)
and an external Thurlby Thandar Instruments TGP110 10 MHz pulse generator.
Luminescence lifetime data were acquired up to 10,000 counts, and
decay curves were analyzed using PicoQuant Fluofit software and tail-fit
statistical modeling (tail-fit criteria; 0.9 < χ2 < 1.1). The samples were de-aerated by solution-purging with
nitrogen for 20 min. All lifetime measurements were performed in triplicate
at room temperature (293 K) and are reported as mean ± SD.
Monolayer Cell and 3D Spheroid Cell Cultures
Two cell
lines were studied: an adherent mammalian cell line, Chinese hamsterovarian (CHO–K1), and a lung carcinoma cancer cell line (A549).
Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium (DMEM)/Hams F-12
was used for CHO cells and DMEM for A549 cells. Both media were supplemented
with 10% FBS and 1% penicillin–streptomycin. The cells were
grown at 37 °C with 5% CO2 and sub-cultured at 90%
confluency.The humanpancreatic cancer cell line (HPAC) was
cultured in Gibco Roswell Park Memorial Institute medium supplemented
with 5% FBS at 37 °C with 5% CO2. HPAC cells were
seeded at 2.5 × 103 cells/well of 96-well round-bottom
plates pre-coated with poly-Hema (poly-2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate,
Sigma). Cells were allowed to be compact and form 3D spheroid structures
after 72 h.
Cytotoxicity Studies
The Alamar
blue assay (Promocell
GmbH) was used to assess the cell viability of A549 and CHO cells
treated with the [Os-(R4)2]10+ probe.
The cells were seeded in 96-well plates (flat-bottomed culture treated)
at 104 cells per well for 24 h at 37 °C with 5% CO2. The probe was added at concentrations 150, 100, 75, 50,
35, 25, 15, 10, 5, and 1 μM and incubated for 24 h prior to
the addition of the Resazurin reagent (10% v/v) for 7 h at 37 °C
in the absence of light. Absorbance readings were carried out at 570
and 600 nm (corrected for background subtraction) using a CLARIOstar
(plus) (v 5.70) plate reader. The viability assay was performed in
triplicate for each cell line.
Confocal Laser Scanning
Microscopy
Uptake studies were
carried out for A549 and CHO cell lines. Cells were seeded at 1.5
× 105 cells in 35 mm glass-bottom culture dishes (Ibidi,
Germany). Cells were allowed to grow for 24 h at 37 °C with 5%
CO2. The growth medium was removed, and a specific concentration
of [Os-(R)2] (n = 4 and 8; x = 10+ and 18+) was added and allowed to incubate for
24 and 48 h at 37 °C with 5% CO2 in the dark. The
dye/media solution was removed, and cells were washed twice with supplemented
phosphate-buffered saline (PBS, 1.1 mM MgCl2 and 0.9 mM
CaCl2). Cells were directly imaged using a Leica TSP DMi8
confocal microscope (63× oil immersion objective lens unless
stated otherwise) with a heated stage at 37 °C.[Os-(R)2] (n = 4 and 8; x = 10+ and 18+) was excited using a 490 nm white light laser,
and the emission range was set to be between 650 and 800 nm. DRAQ7,
a nuclear staining dye, was added (3 μM) to distinguish intact
live cells from permeabilized/dead cells. The 633 nm laser was used
to excite DRAQ7, and emission was collected between 635 and 750 nm.
For co-localization studies, MitoTracker Deep Red (100 nM) and LysoTracker
Green (50 nM) were used to selectively stain mitochondria and lysosomes,
respectively. MitoTracker Deep Red was excited at 644 nm and emission
was collected between 655 and 720 nm, and LysoTracker Green was excited
at 504 nm and emission was collected at 511 nm.
Phototoxicity
DRAQ7 was added to live A549 cells treated
with [Os-(R4)2]10+ (30 μM/24
h). A group of cells were selected for continuous irradiation using
490 nm excitation (0.84 μW/cm2). Emission was collected
between 650 and 800 nm for [Os-(R4)2]10+. The 633 nm laser was used to excite DRAQ7, and emission was collected
between 635 and 750 nm. This was repeated for an untreated control
sample exposed to continuous irradiation and stained with DRAQ7.
Spheroid Treatment with Os-Compounds
Spheroids were
treated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ at 30
μM for 24 h and 100 μM for 24 and 48 h. Control spheroids
were treated with the parent complex [Os(tpybenzCOOH)2]2+ and [Os-(R8)2]18+ at 100
μM for 48 h. Non-treated spheroids were also prepared as a negative
control. Spheroids were co-stained with DAPI at 10 μM for 90
min. Each spheroid was collected individually and embedded in collagen
in eight-well chamber slides, incubated for 90 min, and observed under
confocal microscopy.
Preparation of Fixed Spheroid Sections
HPAC spheroids
were treated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ at
100 μM for 48 h. The spheroids were collected, washed with PBS,
and fixed in 4% NBF (neutral buffered formalin) for 30 min. The spheroids
were then washed with PBS again and transferred into 10, 20, and 30%
sucrose in PBS at 4 °C overnight until spheroids sank to the
bottom. Spheroids were placed in an optimal cutting temperature (OCT)
embedding matrix gel in a histology mold and placed at −80
°C overnight. Spheroids were cut into 5 μm sections using
a cryostat. Sections were co-stained with DAPI. The slides were observed
under confocal microscopy.
Confocal Microscopy of HPAC Spheroids
For imaging,
HPAC spheroids were plated in collagen-treated eight-well chamber
slides. HPAC spheroids were directly imaged from the eight-well chamber
using a Leica TSP DMi8 confocal microscope (10× dry and 40×
oil immersion objective). Z-scanning was used to
acquire images across the z-axis of the spheroid
sample. On average, 45–50 images were acquired at approximately
5 μm apart. 3D Z-stack images were used for spheroid reconstructions
and 2D projection images are also reported. The Os(II) parent complex
and bioconjugates were excited using a 490 nm white light laser, and
the emission range was set to be between 650 and 800 nm (a false red
color was used for the Os(II) channel). DAPI was excited at 405 nm,
and emission was collected between 423 and 580 nm.
Evaluation
of Spheroid Viability
The 3D spheroid viability
was evaluated using Alamar Blue. Briefly, 2.5 × 103 cells were seeded in each well of a 96-well round-bottom plate pre-coated
with poly-Hema. The cells were allowed to grow and form spheroids
for 72 h. The spheroids were then treated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ at 100 μM for 24 and 48 h. The Alamar
Blue reagent at a concentration of 10% was added to each well and
incubated for 5 h at 37 °C. Fluorescence was measured at 535/590
excitation/emission wavelengths on a plate reader (Biotek) using Gen4
software. Background fluorescence was measured by using a blank consisting
of medium only. Percentage viability was calculated relative to untreated
controls.
Phosphorescence Lifetime Imaging Microscopy
Live A549
cells or HPAC spheroids were prepared and treated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ as described previously. Luminescence
lifetime imaging was carried out using a PicoQuant 100 system attached
to a Leica TSP inverted (DMi8) confocal microscope using a 63×
or 40× oil immersion objective. Each sample was acquired for
120 s with a 512 × 512 resolution using the 405 nm. Data was
analyzed using PicoQuant SymphoTime software.
Results and Discussion
Preparation
and Characterization of the Bis-tetra and Bis-octa
Arginine Os(II) Conjugates
We reported recently on the preparation
and photophysical characteristics of the achiral Os(II) parent complex,
[Os(tpybenzCOOH)2]2+, used in this study.[40,64] For an osmium polypyridyl complex, it exhibits a comparatively high
emission quantum yield and in particular, as described, has the advantage
from the perspective of the current application of a linear structure
with bilateral conjugation sites, offering the possibility to extend
a linear peptide sequence bridged by the metal center. The tridentate
ligand structure also avoids the complexity of the possibility of
preparation of isomers. Here, we explore the impact of polyarginine
chains of different lengths to each carboxyl termini of the Os(II)
complex, to understand in such an arrangement, if the octaarginine
sequence we have observed to be so efficient in driving related metal
complexes across the cell membrane and into the cytoplasm require
that the arginine residues are contiguous and if longer arginine chains
further improve the uptake. A comparative study on multivalent antimicrobial
peptides reported enhanced antimicrobial activity for divalentmetallocene
conjugates.[65] The general chemical structure
of the conjugates, [Os-(R)2] (n = 4 and 8; x = 10+ and 18+), is shown in Figure A. Each polyarginine
chain was composed of four or eight d-Arg residues. Studies
have shown that internalization is not stereospecific as both d- and l-Arg enter cells efficiently.[20]
Figure 1
(A) General chemical structure of Os(II)-terpyridine-based polyarginine
conjugates following amide coupling of R (n = 4 and 8) to [Os(tpybenzCOOH)2]2+ parent complex. (B) Absorbance and normalised emission spectra
of [Os-(R4)2]10+ (30 μM/PBS
buffer pH 7.4) under aerated and de-aerated conditions with λexc 490 nm and excitation and emission slit widths of 10 nm.
(A) General chemical structure of Os(II)-terpyridine-basedpolyarginine
conjugates following amide coupling of R (n = 4 and 8) to [Os(tpybenzCOOH)2]2+ parent complex. (B) Absorbance and normalised emission spectra
of [Os-(R4)2]10+ (30 μM/PBS
buffer pH 7.4) under aerated and de-aerated conditions with λexc 490 nm and excitation and emission slit widths of 10 nm.Bis-octaarginine and bis-tetraarginine conjugation
to the carboxyl
termini of [Os(tpybenzCOOH)2]2+ was achieved
via amide coupling using PyBOP/DIPEA following the procedures reported
previously.[40,41] The structure and purity of the
conjugates were confirmed by 1H and COSY NMR, reverse-phase
HPLC (PDA 490 nm), and high-resolution LC mass spectrometry. Both
polyarginine conjugates showed very similar photophysical properties
in PBS (pH 7.4) to the parent complex and OsII MPP previously
reported.[40] The absorbance and emission
spectra of [Os-(R4)2]10+ (30 μM)
are shown in Figure B. The emission maximum centered at 754 nm coincides well with the
biological window and is usefully situated outside of the range of
cellular autofluorescence. [Os-(R4)2]10+ and [Os-(R8)2]18+ in aerated PBS
(pH 7.4) exhibited luminescence lifetimes of 89.6 ± 5.3 ns and
89.2 ± 6.1, respectively, which, as for their related MPP conjugates,
were only modestly affected by de-aeration (τOs–R4 103 ± 6.9 ns and τOs–R8 108.6 ±
11.1 ns).
Uptake Studies of [Os-(R)2] Conjugates
As reported previously,
the parent complex without peptide is cell membrane impermeable. Uptake
of the Os(II)bis-octaarginine conjugate was studied in live A549lung carcinoma and a non-cancerous CHO cell line. Surprisingly, confocal
laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) revealed that bis-conjugation to
octaarginine did not facilitate transport of the complex.[66] The conjugate remained as impermeable to the
cell membrane as the parent Os(II) complex at 30 μM/24 h and
100 μM/24 h (Figure S12). As expected,
in the absence of any permeation, A549 and CHO cells remained healthy
as confirmed by co-staining with DRAQ7, a dye which stains the nucleus
of damaged/dead cells.As previously mentioned, evidence suggests
that cargo cellular uptake is enhanced with an increase in arginine
chain length for polyarginine CPPs. However, whereas it has been widely
observed that R8 or R9 provides optimal uptake, the inhibition of
uptake with longer polyarginine chains has also been noted. For example,
Sugiura et al. noted, consistent with our data, that fluorescently
labeled R8 was efficiently drawn across live cell membranes, whereas
R16 was not.[67] Studies have also shown
that the cellular uptake ability of oligoarginine conjugates depends
on the total number of Arg residues and not necessarily on the exact
arginine sequence.[68,69] As the chain length increases,
the uptake behavior becomes less predictable. For example, studies
found that R15 conjugation showed superior uptake to R20–R30
and R75 proved to be toxic toward cells.[20] Long peptides of lysine have also shown cellular toxic effects.[70] The reason for reduced uptake by longer arginine
chains is not entirely clear as the mechanism of arginine-mediated
uptake is still debated. If translocation is the key mechanism, it
may be that the longer chain lengths associate too strongly with the
membrane or do not cause the appropriate degree of curvature at the
cell membrane or are an inappropriate length to span the membrane
in endocytosis. It is notable that long-term incubation with the complex
did not cause cytotoxicity, confirmed by the absence of DRAQ7 from
the nucleus, indicating that membrane destabilization by these long
R chains can be excluded.As reported previously, R8 promotes
the uptake of Ru and Os(II)
polypyridyl complexes across live cell membranes, so we then conjugated
two R4 chains to each terminus of the complex.In contrast to
[Os-(R8)2]18+,
[Os-(R4)2]10+ was rapidly and efficiently
internalized into live A549 and CHO cells at 30 μM following
24 h incubation in the dark. As shown in Figure , emission from the cytoplasm was evident
at 24 h and by 48 h as punctuate staining. Previously reported rutheniumoctaarginine conjugates have generally been found to be nuclear excluding
with non-specific distribution throughout the cytoplasm.[38,39] Uptake of an osmium polypyridyl phenanthroline imidazole complex
conjugated to R8, [Os(bpy)2(pic-arg8)]10+ showed comparable uptake to its ruthenium analogue,
although unlike the Ru analogue, nuclear penetration of the osmium
complex was observed in CHO cells particularly under photoirradiation.[11] The increased lipophilic character of the osmium
complex compared to its ruthenium analogue was suggested as a reason
for its nuclear permeation.[11] Given the
punctate distribution of the complex at later time points, to establish
distribution of [Os-(R4)2]10+, co-localization
studies were carried out using Lysotracker Green for the lysosomes
and MitoTracker Deep Red for the mitochondria. Staining with DRAQ7
was used to identify damaged cells. A Pearson’s coefficient
value of 0.56 revealed only moderate co-localization with MitoTracker
Deep Red at 30 μM/24 h, suggesting that at these conditions,
the conjugate enters but is not exclusively localized at the mitochondria
(Figure S13).
Figure 2
Uptake and co-localization
studies of [Os-(R4)2]10+ in live
A549 cells where the osmium channel is shown
in green. Cells were incubated in the absence of light with 30 μM
[Os-(R4)2]10+ for (A) 24 h and for
(B,C) 48 h. Co-localization studies at 48 h with Lysotracker Green
(50 nM) confirmed lysosomal confinement evident by the overlap of
the (D) osmium channel with (E) Lysotracker Green (orange) in the
(F) overlay image (Pearson’s coefficient = 0.69). A 490 nm
white light laser was used to excite the conjugate, and emission was
collected between 650 and 800 nm. The LysoTracker Green dye was excited
at 504 nm and emission was collected at 511 nm.
Uptake and co-localization
studies of [Os-(R4)2]10+ in live
A549 cells where the osmium channel is shown
in green. Cells were incubated in the absence of light with 30 μM
[Os-(R4)2]10+ for (A) 24 h and for
(B,C) 48 h. Co-localization studies at 48 h with Lysotracker Green
(50 nM) confirmed lysosomal confinement evident by the overlap of
the (D) osmium channel with (E) Lysotracker Green (orange) in the
(F) overlay image (Pearson’s coefficient = 0.69). A 490 nm
white light laser was used to excite the conjugate, and emission was
collected between 650 and 800 nm. The LysoTracker Green dye was excited
at 504 nm and emission was collected at 511 nm.As shown in Figure D–F, the punctuate staining of [Os-(R4)2]10+ (green) at 30 μM/48 h co-localized well with
Lysotracker Green (orange) confirming localization of the conjugate
in lysosomal structures. Trafficking to the lysosomes of HIV-TAT and
octaarginine following uptake has been reported previously and has
been linked to an endocytic uptake mechanism.[71] A similar uptake and distribution in A549 cells were observed when
incubated for 24 h at higher complex concentrations of 100 μM
[Os-(R4)2]10+ (Figure S14). Uptake of [Os-(R4)2]10+ was also studied in a non-cancerous CHO cell line. As shown
in Figure A,B, CHO
cells treated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ at
30 μM and incubated for 24 h showed extensive cytoplasmic and
nucleoli staining. In this case, nuclear penetration did not concern
a photo- or thermally activated process as penetration was observed
following incubation of [Os-(R4)2]10+ in the dark.
Figure 3
Confocal luminescence images of [Os-(R4)2]10+ in CHO cells. Live cells were incubated with
30 μM
[Os-(R4)2]10+ for 24 h in the absence
of light and co-stained with DRAQ7. (A,C) The distribution of the
conjugate (in green) is shown in a group of cells co-stained with
DRAQ7 (in blue). (B,D) Closed-up image of a single A549 cell shows
nucleoli staining. The 633 nm laser was used to excite DRAQ 7 and
emission was collected between 635 and 750 nm.
Confocal luminescence images of [Os-(R4)2]10+ in CHO cells. Live cells were incubated with
30 μM
[Os-(R4)2]10+ for 24 h in the absence
of light and co-stained with DRAQ7. (A,C) The distribution of the
conjugate (in green) is shown in a group of cells co-stained with
DRAQ7 (in blue). (B,D) Closed-up image of a single A549 cell shows
nucleoli staining. The 633 nm laser was used to excite DRAQ 7 and
emission was collected between 635 and 750 nm.The [Os-(R4)2]10+ conjugate exhibited
temperature-dependent uptake as cell permeation of A549 and CHO cells
was inhibited at 4 °C, suggesting that an activated process,
such as endocytosis, is involved for cellular entry (Figure S15). Previously reported octaarginine conjugates of
metal complex cargo have been shown to be internalized via an activated membrane transport process.[11,72,73]Co-staining studies using DRAQ7 confirmed
that the A549 cells remained
viable after both 24 h and 48 h treatment with the conjugate at 30
μM (Figure S16). The absence of DRAQ7
from the cell nuclei of A549 cells treated with the conjugate at a
higher concentration of 100 μM/24 h confirmed that no cell death
was induced at this higher concentration (Figure S14A,B). After extending the incubation time for 100 μM
[Os-(R4)2]10+ to 48 h, some DRAQ7
staining was evident, indicating modest cytotoxic effects at extended
incubations and higher probe concentration (Figure S14C–E). In order to assess potential photo-induced
toxic effects, a group of A549 cells, pretreated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ (30 μM/24 h) and stained with
DRAQ7, was continuously irradiated using 490 nm excitation (at 0.84
μW/cm2, approximately 3 times higher than the imaging
intensity). Under these conditions, no DRAQ7 was found to enter cell
nuclei following 3 h of irradiation, confirming that the osmium conjugate
is non-photocytotoxic under these conditions (Figure S17). We attribute this to the insensitivity of the
excited state of this species to molecular oxygen. It is not quenched
by O2 and thus does not generate cytotoxic singlet oxygen
under irradiation, and the low excited-state oxidation potential of
the complex limits photoredox reactions with DNA or protein constituents.
The extent of nucleoli staining of [Os-(R4)2]10+ and cellular damage in CHO cells, following 24 h
of incubation at 30 μM, was evident by the entry of DRAQ7 (blue)
in several cell nuclei (Figure C,D).The viability of A549 and CHO cells treated with
[Os-(R4)2]10+ was assessed by incubating
the conjugate
overnight at concentrations up to 150 μM at 37 °C with
5% v/v CO2 using the Alamar Blue assay (Figure S18). The reduction of the resazurin reagent to resorufin
was used to directly measure cell viability. The conjugate was found
to be remarkably non-toxic toward A549 cells with an IC50 exceeding 150 μM and cell viability was above 71% up to 100
μM. [Os-(R4)2]10+ was found
to be somewhat more toxic to CHO cells where viability decreased to
<70% above 35 μm with an IC50 ≈ 75.1 ±
1.1 μM. It is likely that the cytotoxicity in CHO cells is the
result of wider distribution of the conjugate in this cell line, which
is evident by confocal imaging where cytoplasmic staining and nucleoli
staining were observed. The previously reported [Os(tpybenzCOOH)2]2+ complex conjugated to two MPPs exhibited a
concentration-dependent localization and cytotoxicity toward HeLa
and MCF 7 cells with an IC50 ≈ 30 μM.[40] However, here conjugation of the Os(II) complex
to two tetraarginine chains leads to significantly decreased toxicity
likely owing to the preferential cytoplasmic staining of the conjugate.
Overall, [Os-(R4)2]10+ is not photocytotoxic,
and the dark toxicity of the bis-tetraarginineOs(II) conjugate toward
A549 and CHO cell lines is low and comparable to the reported ruthenium
and osmium octaarginine compounds.[11,37] In addition,
[Os-(R4)2]10+ was less toxic than
the octaarginine conjugate [Ir(dfpp)2(picCHONH) (Arg8]9+ with IC50 values of 54.1 and 35
μM against CHO and SP2 cells, respectively.[73]
PLIM and Cell Mapping
The relatively
long emission
lifetimes of the metal complexes render them potentially useful as
probes for mapping of the environment of live cells using luminescence
lifetime imaging. For example, Ir(III) and Ru(II) polypyridyl complexes
have been employed as O2 sensors using PLIM studies.[29,52,53] PLIM was carried out here to
investigate the emission lifetime of the conjugate in the environment
of live cells.Figure shows the false-color images of the lifetime distributions
of the Os(II) probe in A549 cells at 30 μM following uptake
at 24 and 48 h incubation. The emission lifetime of the conjugate
was found to vary with localization, attributed to environmental effects.
When taken up in the cytoplasm and partially confined in mitochondria
at 24 h, the lifetimes fit to a tri-exponential decay with a very
short component (τ3) that was present under all circumstances
of 2 ns and attributed to background scatter/reflectance. The dominant
amplitude component (67%) of the decay, τ1, was measured
as 92.2 ns ± 2.9 ns with a second component of lifetime, τ2, recorded as 15.8 ± 1.5 ns (25%). Notably, when confined
to the lysosomes and the surrounding cytoplasm at 30 μM/48 h,
the [Os-(R4)2]10+ conjugate exhibited
significantly reduced lifetimes of 37 ± 1.8 ns (54%) and 9.3
± 0.6 ns (32%). Although O2-insensitive, the conjugate
is expected to respond to redox-active species in the sub-cellular
environment, but response on the basis of the pH of the lysosome can
be excluded as the emission lifetime of the parent complex in aqueous
solution (pH 4.1) showed no response to acidic pH (Figure S10). The oxidation potential of osmium is typically
300 mV lower than comparable Ru analogues, and for the parent complex
here, the oxidation potential is 656 mV versus Ag/AgCl.[40] The lysosome is an acidic organelle with a rich
cocktail of redox-active species including metalloenzymes and thiols
likely to quench and thus modulate the excited-state lifetime of this
complex. The absence of O2 sensitivity but potential redox
sensitivity to other species offers an advantage of Os polypyridyl
complexes over ruthenium and iridium complexes in imaging, offering
opportunities to monitor localization and metabolic changes in cells
or tissues without interference from oxygen.
Figure 4
Luminescence lifetime
imaging [Os-(R4)2]10+ at 30 μM
in live A549 cells. (A) Confocal image of
a single cell following conjugate uptake at 24 h and (B) lifetime
distribution in the expanded cytoplasmic region of the cell. (C) PLIM
acquired following uptake at 48 h. The PLIM images were acquired using
the 405 nm excitation laser line. The PLIM images of the entire cell
of (B) and (C) and corresponding emission decays are shown in the Supporting Information (Figures S19–S20).
Luminescence lifetime
imaging [Os-(R4)2]10+ at 30 μM
in live A549 cells. (A) Confocal image of
a single cell following conjugate uptake at 24 h and (B) lifetime
distribution in the expanded cytoplasmic region of the cell. (C) PLIM
acquired following uptake at 48 h. The PLIM images were acquired using
the 405 nm excitation laser line. The PLIM images of the entire cell
of (B) and (C) and corresponding emission decays are shown in the Supporting Information (Figures S19–S20).
Confocal Imaging of HPAC Spheroids
The excellent membrane
permeability of the bis-tetraarginineOs(II) conjugate, its low photocytotoxicity,
and NIR emission suggest its suitability as a probe for tissue imaging,
and to date, there have been no applications of Os luminophores applied
as 3D multicellular spheroids imaging probes. However, as noted, multicellular
spheroids present a very different microenvironment. Thus, we investigated
their penetration into 3D MCTSs. 3D cell spheroids are prepared by
culturing cancer cells in a non-adherent environment, which promotes
the formation of aggregates of cell layers.[42−45]We performed studies on
MCTSs composed of HPACs grown in ultra-low attachment well plates
for 3 days. The spheroids were incubated with the [Os-(R4)]10+conjugate at 30 and 100 μM for 24 and 48 h
each. For comparison, the ability of the Os(II) parent complex and
the bis-octaarginine conjugate, [Os-(R8)2]18+, to penetrate 3D spheroids was also assessed by incubating
with the compounds at 100 μM for 48 h. In the latter cases,
no spheroid penetration or accumulation was observed for either parent
or bis-octaarginine compound, consistent with studies on 2D cell monolayers
(Figure S21).Conversely, confocal
luminescence microscopy studies revealed that
the bis-tetraarginine conjugate readily permeates the HPAC spheroids.
It is important to note that the probes are incubated with the live
spheroid in aqueous buffer/media without application of a permeant
such as detergent or solvent. As shown in the 3D reconstruction depth
coding images, spheroid penetration was evident following incubation
with [Os-(R4)]10+ at 30 μM/24 h, although
staining at the center of the spheroid, at 72 ± 5 μm, was
not observed at this concentration (Figure A). However, by increasing the complex concentration
to 100 μM/24 h, extensive probe penetration and distribution
to the core of the spheroid were achieved (Figure B). Hambley et al. reported on the depth
of penetration of a series of platinum complexes in cancer cell spheroids,
observing that it was inversely proportional to the rate of cellular
uptake.[54] It is likely that rapid accumulation
of the probe at 30 μM results in penetration and accumulation
of complex at the first few cell layers, leaving insufficient concentration
of probe to measurably diffuse to the center of the MCTS at lower
concentrations. Full Z-stack images are shown in the Supporting Information (Figures S22–S23).
Figure 5
3D reconstruction
depth coding images of whole live HPAC spheroids
treated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ at (A)
30 μM/24 h and (B) 100 μM/24 h. Confocal images were acquired
at different planes in the z direction throughout
the spheroids (from the bottom to above each spheroid). A 490 nm white
light laser was used to excite the conjugate, and emission was collected
between 650 and 800 nm. Scale bar reads 100 μm.
3D reconstruction
depth coding images of whole live HPAC spheroids
treated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ at (A)
30 μM/24 h and (B) 100 μM/24 h. Confocal images were acquired
at different planes in the z direction throughout
the spheroids (from the bottom to above each spheroid). A 490 nm white
light laser was used to excite the conjugate, and emission was collected
between 650 and 800 nm. Scale bar reads 100 μm.Figure shows
representative
z-stack images of a single live HPAC spheroid treated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ at 100 μM for 48 h. Emission
from the conjugate (in red) is observed throughout cell layers and
deep into the spheroid core. A nuclear localizing dye, DAPI (in blue),
was used as a co-staining contrast dye. Figure shows the extent of probe distribution in
spheroid regions following incubation with [Os-(R4)2]10+, where uniform cytoplasmic staining, that
is mainly nuclear excluding, is observed at 100 μM/24 h and
48 h.
Figure 6
Z-stack images of a single live HPAC spheroid pre-treated with
[Os-(R4)2]10+ (100 μM/48 h)
and co-stained with DAPI (10 μM). Each image corresponds to
the cross section from the bottom to the upper part along the z-axis. Representative cross sections are shown using bright-field
contrast as the background. Scale bar reads 100 μm. A 490 nm
white light laser was used to excite the conjugate, and emission was
collected between 650 and 800 nm. The 405 nm excitation laser was
used to excite DAPI, and emission was collected between 423 and 580
nm.
Figure 7
Confocal images (2D projection) of HPAC spheroid
regions treated
with Os-(R4)2 at (A) 30 μM/24 h, (B) 100
μM/24 h, and (C) 100 μM/48 h at 37 °C. The spheroids
were co-stained with DAPI (10 μM) and (D–F) overlay images
with DAPI channel. A 490 nm white light laser was used to excite the
conjugate, and emission was collected between 650 and 800 nm. The
405 nm excitation laser was used to excite DAPI, and emission was
collected between 423 and 580 nm (40× obj.).
Z-stack images of a single live HPAC spheroid pre-treated with
[Os-(R4)2]10+ (100 μM/48 h)
and co-stained with DAPI (10 μM). Each image corresponds to
the cross section from the bottom to the upper part along the z-axis. Representative cross sections are shown using bright-field
contrast as the background. Scale bar reads 100 μm. A 490 nm
white light laser was used to excite the conjugate, and emission was
collected between 650 and 800 nm. The 405 nm excitation laser was
used to excite DAPI, and emission was collected between 423 and 580
nm.Confocal images (2D projection) of HPAC spheroid
regions treated
with Os-(R4)2 at (A) 30 μM/24 h, (B) 100
μM/24 h, and (C) 100 μM/48 h at 37 °C. The spheroids
were co-stained with DAPI (10 μM) and (D–F) overlay images
with DAPI channel. A 490 nm white light laser was used to excite the
conjugate, and emission was collected between 650 and 800 nm. The
405 nm excitation laser was used to excite DAPI, and emission was
collected between 423 and 580 nm (40× obj.).Furthermore, following treatment with the tetraarginine conjugate,
the live spheroids were examined for morphological changes by comparing
with non-treated (control) spheroids, and the viability assay showed
no evidence of toxicity (Figure S24).A key advantage of Os(II) polypyridyl complexes is that they exhibit
NIR emission well resolved from the autofluorescence window. Emission
from cellular fluorophores, such as nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide
(NAD+/NADH) and flavins, occurs mainly at shorter light
wavelengths (350–550 nm); thus; in detecting fluorophores emitting
below 700 nm, autofluorescence can be readily filtered out.[4,74,75] [Os-(R4)2]10+ exhibits an emission maximum centered at 754 nm,
and the emission collected here between 650 and 800 nm corresponding
to the Os(II) channel (Figure A) avoids any background signal from biological autofluorescence
(Figure B). Furthermore,
as shown in the above PLIM images, the relatively long lifetimes of
these probes also enable facile discrimination of contributions from
autofluorescence in lifetime data.
Figure 8
Confocal images of a single live HPAC
spheroid treated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ (100 μM/48 h). A 490 nm
white light laser was used for excitation, and emission was collected
between (A) 650 and 800 nm; Os(II) channel and (B) 500–570
nm; autofluorescence window. (C) Os(II)/autofluorescence channel overlay.
Confocal images of a single live HPAC
spheroid treated with [Os-(R4)2]10+ (100 μM/48 h). A 490 nm
white light laser was used for excitation, and emission was collected
between (A) 650 and 800 nm; Os(II) channel and (B) 500–570
nm; autofluorescence window. (C) Os(II)/autofluorescence channel overlay.To further evaluate the distribution of the conjugate
inside the
spheroids, fixed cryosections of HPAC spheroids that were pre-treated
with [Os-(R4)2]10+ (100 μM)
when live were prepared and imaged. The confocal fluorescence images
confirm the wide distribution of the conjugate throughout the spheroid
(Figures S25–S26). Punctuate staining
and overlap with DAPI dye in the fixed samples suggest preferential
accumulation of the conjugate at certain regions and some nuclear
penetration and localization. The latter was not noted in the live
pancreatic spheroid samples. However, it is important to note that
the process of fixation has a profound impact on the cellular structures
and can alter the distribution of probes within cells. Indeed, redistribution
of nona-arginine-modified fluorescent dyes was noted after fixation
where nucleolus migration was observed.[76] Furthermore, as shown in the PLIM image of punctuate staining of
[Os-(R4)2]10+ in fixed HPAC spheroids
(Figure S27), the lifetime distribution
is very uniform. Here, the decay conforms to a bi-exponential fit
where the osmium conjugate shows only a single-component decay with
a lifetime of 16.4 ns, which is short-lived than in solution (τ
≈ 89.6 ± 5.3 ns) but comparable to the lifetimes recorded
in the 2D monolayer cell studies. However the lifetime of [Os-(R4)2]10+ and its uniformity are likely
to reflect the sample fixation, which causes extensive cross-linking
of protein structures into a gel state within the cell.[77,78]
Conclusions
Using an achiral Os(II) bisterpyridinyl-coordinated
complex with
linear bilateral conjugation sites, we demonstrate that assembly of
polyarginine at opposing ends of the structure exhibits an additive
effect in terms of cargo cellular permeation. Whereas the parent complex
is completely impermeable to live 2D and 3D cells, the octaarginine
conjugate prepared as two tetraarginine moieties conjugated to the
termini of the Os center shows excellent permeability and behaves
in an analogous way to previously reported octaarginine derivatives
of related complexes. In contrast, when two octaarginine peptides
are appended to the termini, the conjugate is rendered completely
impermeable to the 2D and 3D cell cultures.The [Os-(R4)2]10+ conjugate exhibited
exceptionally low cytotoxicity and photocytotoxicity and an emission
maximum at 754 nm coinciding with the biological window. The [Os-(R4)2]10+ emission is essentially oxygen-insensitive
but exhibits a relatively long-lived emission lifetime of approximately
89 ns in PBS that facilitates its use in phosphorescence lifetime
imaging. Uptake was found to be efficient in all cell lines explored,
but the distribution varied with cell type and where [Os-(R4)2]10+ accessed the lysosome its emission lifetime
was significantly reduced likely attributed to emission quenching
redox-active species in that organelle. We examined the application
of conjugates in imaging a multilayer pancreatic cancer cell model;
to our knowledge, this is the first example of an Os luminophore applied
to imaging of 3D multicellular spheroids. While the parent complex
and [Os-(R8)2]18+ conjugate were
found to be impermeable, widespread and in-depth staining into the
3D MCTS was achieved with [Os-(R4)2]10+ without any impact on cellular function. The emission collected
was well outside the autofluorescence window toward the NIR region
of the spectrum suitable for tissue imaging. Our data demonstrate
that the efficiency of octaarginine as a permeant does not require
contiguous arrangement of the amino acids but shows that the sequence
can be bridged at the luminophore termini. This approach may be more
broadly applicable and could pave the way to novel compounds that
combine shorter peptide sequences such as signal and CPP sequences
and could also address issues in peptide synthesis concerning cumulative
lower yields with longer peptides. This work also illustrates the
value of non-cytotoxic osmium derivatives as probes for studying the
MCTS environment.
Authors: Mark Stitch; Rayhaan Z Boota; Alannah S Chalkley; Tony D Keene; Jeremy C Simpson; Paul A Scattergood; Paul I P Elliott; Susan J Quinn Journal: Inorg Chem Date: 2022-09-12 Impact factor: 5.436