| Literature DB >> 33917688 |
Andrés M Murillo-Pedrozo1, Eliana Martínez-Herrera2,3, Elena Ronda-Pérez4,5, Andrés A Agudelo-Suárez1,4.
Abstract
This study explored the general and oral health perceptions in the Venezuelan immigrant population in Medellín (Colombia) and its conditioning factors. A qualitative study involving Venezuelan immigrants ≥18 years with a minimum stay of six months in Colombia was conducted. Dentists, dental students, and other health professionals also participated. Semi-structured interviews (n = 17), focus groups (n = 2), and key informants' interviews (n = 4) were utilized. The interviews and focus groups were recorded and transcribed for later narrative content analysis. A high degree of vulnerability of participants was found due to the precarious living conditions from the premigratory moment and the lack of job placement possibilities at the time of settling in Colombia, where the migratory status played a fundamental role. Among the perceived needs, the mitigation of noncommunicable diseases stood out. Poor mental health symptoms (depression and anxiety) were perceived, and oral health was not a priority. Barriers to accessing health and dental care were found. The migrant condition was found to be a determinant that affected physical, mental, and oral health and the provision of health care. This situation is of interest to the construction of public health policies that guarantee access to fundamental rights.Entities:
Keywords: emigration and immigration; health services accessibility; mental health; oral health; qualitative research
Year: 2021 PMID: 33917688 PMCID: PMC8068052 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph18083897
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Sociodemographic characteristics of the Venezuelan participants in Medellín, Colombia (n = 17).
| Characteristics | |
|---|---|
| Sex | |
| Male | 8 (47) |
| Female | 9 (53) |
| Zone | |
| Urban (cities and municipalities) | 14 (82) |
| Rural (sidewalks, villages, little towns) | 3 (18) |
| Age (years), mean (range) | 37 (19–56) |
| Time of residence in Colombia (months), mean (range) | 24 (9–60) |
| Medical antecedents in Venezuela | |
| Yes | 3 (18) |
| No | 14 (82) |
| Employment situation | |
| Yes | 7 (41) |
| No | 10 (59) |
| Presence of work contract | |
| Yes | 3 (18) |
| No | 14 (82) |
| Health insurance | |
| Yes | 6 (35) |
| No | 11 (65) |
| Marital status | |
| Single | 6 (35) |
| Married/cohabitated | 10 (59) |
| Widow | 2 (12) |
| Education | |
| Primary | 1 (6) |
| Incomplete secondary | 1 (6) |
| Complete secondary | 5 (29.4) |
| Technical studies | 5 (29.4) |
| University | 5 (29.4) |
Figure 1List of topics used for the fieldwork in the study.
Figure 2Final design for the categories based on the qualitative findings. NGOs: nongovernmental organizations.
Verbatim interview extracts from participants’ discourses. Medellín, Colombia (2020) *.
| Categories | Keywords | Verbatim Extracts form Participants’ Discourses |
|---|---|---|
| (1) Migratory process | Motivations | (a) “[I am] seeking a better future for my family and my babies.” (I-12, female, 23 years old) |
| (b) “Because in Venezuela there was no food, there was no medicine, there was nothing, looking for a better one here.” (I-6, female, 46 years old) | ||
| (c) “Because of the situation in the country, because of the circumstances that all Venezuelans are going through, because of this government, a dictatorship.” (I-3, male, 29 years old) | ||
| The trip | (d) “In a chirrinchera [typical Venezuelan word] … a chirrinchera is a truck that has rails on the sides, and there, one comes standing. For all that is La Guajira [Colombian region], grabbing the trails of Maicao [Colombian municipality].” (I-9, female, 56 years old) | |
| (e) “Along the trails and that day, a family member drowned because it was in the rain, and a family member drowned when crossing the river. We passed … Well, that was horrible.” (I-6, female, 46 years old) | ||
| Destination choice | (f) “It is the closest place we have. Even though Brazil is also close to Venezuela, the closest is Colombia.” (I-8, female, 37 years old) | |
| (g) “Here in Medellín [Colombia], we had an acquaintance. He was a comadre [relative] of my wife, who was here in Medellín. She received us for three days.” (I-7, male, 33 years old) | ||
| (2) Health | Health concept | (a) “For me, health is the physical and mental state that people have and that must be guaranteed and supported by a system.” (I-4, male, 35 years old) |
| (b) “To have a better quality of life, being in health, because if one does not have good health, how can one have a better quality of life to work, to do other things, to take care of even the family.” (I-14, female, 44 years old) | ||
| Perception of current health status | (c) “Well, thank God. Since I got here, I have never had a difficulty such as telling you that I have been in bed. Thank God, no.” (I-16, male, 34 years old) | |
| (d) “Today, I feel a little bad, from the colon, and I don’t sleep. Sometimes I don’t sleep because sometimes it won’t let me sleep [due to] a lot of pain.” (I-2, male, 45 years old) | ||
| (e) “Right now, it has improved because here, at least you can get the right medicine for hypertension both for me and my dad.” (I-13, male, 45 years old) | ||
| Oral health status | (f) “I came from Venezuela. I had work done on my tooth [molar], but only halfway—that is, I could not finish it.” (I-11, male, 40 years old) | |
| (g) “I consider that much of this burden of diseases came from Venezuela, which obviously worsened. Yes, [due to] cavities not attended here, that come from there and are not treated here [and] the difficult access here, they became worse. That’s the reason for the emergency care for them.” (KI, dentist, female, public health professional, public sector) | ||
| (h) “Main reasons for [dental] consultation (...) they [Venezuelans] always come for many root tips of teeth, many dental caries, many pulpitis …” (FG-1, dentist, public and private sectors) | ||
| Mental health | (i) “I am currently consulting with a psychologist because I manage a very high level of anxiety and stress.” (I-4, male, 35 years old) | |
| (j) “The most frequent, precisely that one, [is] that of problems in cultural adaptation, and that is one of those that prevail within these reasons for consultation and that there is a pattern that is repetitive and that one would not only believe that occurs in adults. No, it really occurs in all types of populations.” (KI, psychologist, female, NGO) | ||
| (k) “My house [Venezuela], of course. I was also in my comfort zone, my house, my job, where I lived, what was normal, my routine, my family, my dad [referring to the family in Venezuela]” (I-15, female, 42 years old) | ||
| (3) Barriers and facilitators of access to health services | Special Permission for Residence (PEP) | (a) “As we do not have passports, right now, they [the government] are taking out the PEP, unlike those people who have stamped their passports. Since we do not have passports because we cannot get it, we would have to wait for Colombian migration to take a day to get PEP.” (I-8, female, 37 years old) |
| (b) “The first barrier is the link. If Venezuelans do not have the temporary or special permit, they cannot link as they want. For me, that is the first barrier. Once they have permission, they can be linked.” (FG-1, dentist, public and private sectors) | ||
| Cost | (c) “No, but here, I have not even been able to go to a dentist due to the same situation that, here, everything is very expensive.” (I-1, female, 45 years old) | |
| Employment/working conditions | (d) “I was working in Parque Berrío [a main square in the city], in a sewing workshop. They make sheets, cut sheets, make quilts, and all that.” (I-17, male, 31 years old) | |
| (e) “I work daily selling manillas [a kind of souvenir] on buses. I live with my wife [and] my two daughters. My wife works the same way, selling manillas.” (I-7, male, 33 years old) | ||
| (f) “They [Venezuelans] are afraid of losing their jobs … In order not to miss their job, they don’t want an appointment on a Saturday because they don’t work on Sunday. So, they don’t want to use the sick leave because they don’t want to miss their job because if they miss job, they get fired.” (FG-1, dentist, public and private sector) | ||
| Housing | (g) “Here, to rent a house they don’t allow you with a PEP; you have to have real property, you have to have a guarantor. You have to have all those kinds of documents, and if you don’t have a document to support you, they don’t give you anything. So, it is very difficult to be from one place to another.” (I-17, male, 31 years old) | |
| (h) “We are in a very little room—how to say, three by three practically … we are eight: she [sister] with her three daughters and I with my family. (I-13, male, 45 years old) | ||
| Affiliation to the General Social Security System (health insurance) | (i) “My mother and grandmother did enter with border permits. They do not have PEP—that is, since they have not taken a census again, I have not been able to get them out. If my mother had the permit, I would already have it affiliated with the EPS [Acronym in Spanish for Empresas Promotoras de Salud, in English means: health maintenance organization]. That is the limitation that I have.” (I-11, male, 40 years old) | |
| (j) “I am very calm in the aspect of health because I already have my wife and my daughter linked to the EPS—that is, that tranquility that if I need a consultation, I [can] easily ask for it.” (I-11, male, 40 years old) | ||
| (4) Support networks | Family | (a) “Well, since he [a friend] has his family here, here, where we have rented, is family. The man above is his cousin.” (EI-1, female, 45 years old) |
| Nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) | (b) “The UNHCR [NGO with an office in Medellín] gave me the appointment by phone and told me that I had an appointment here [Famicove, an NGO located in Medellín]. I didn’t even know where it was, even the lady who is seeing herself right now came and was the one who accompanied me to look for the address of Famicove.” (I-E09, female, 56 years old) | |
| Church | (c) “Those from the church also arrived, how do I say, well, those who work in the rectory also arrived, saw me, [health staff] took my blood pressure. Almost every day, they went to the house, they took my blood pressure, they [health staff] gave me the pill.” (I-6, female, 45 years old) | |
| (5) Expectations | Short term | (a) “Our plans right now … [are] to get something more comfortable for ourselves because since … we are five people who live here and, well, we are very, very small, but we have … plans to go to something bigger.” (I-1, female, 45 years old) |
| (b) “Stay as we are right now, look for a good job, why do we do, without a job we can’t do anything else...” (I-17, male, 31 years old) | ||
| Medium term | (c) “My plans for the future [are to] validate my career [and] practice my profession here. I want to do another specialization, but I want to do it here and nothing else. [I want to] get a job in my area.” (I-4, male, 35 years old) | |
| Long term | (d) “Right now, in the situation we are in [all migrants], we wanted to return, but right now in Venezuela, things are much worse than when we came.” (I-7, male, 33 years old) | |
| (e) “The truth is, yes, I would like…, but right now, the only way for me to return is not to stay but to go visit, let the government fall, visit the family again, which is what one misses the most.” (I-16, male, 34 years old) |
* The alphanumeric code used to identify the source of the verbatim quote is as follows: I—interview, sex, number; KI—key informant, sex, type; FG—focus group, type.