| Literature DB >> 33893811 |
M D Slooter1, M S E Mansvelders1, P R Bloemen2, S S Gisbertz1, W A Bemelman1, P J Tanis1, R Hompes1, M I van Berge Henegouwen1, D M de Bruin1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The aim of this systematic review was to identify all methods to quantify intraoperative fluorescence angiography (FA) of the gastrointestinal anastomosis, and to find potential thresholds to predict patient outcomes, including anastomotic leakage and necrosis.Entities:
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2021 PMID: 33893811 PMCID: PMC8271268 DOI: 10.1093/bjsopen/zraa074
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BJS Open ISSN: 2474-9842
Fig. 1PRISMA diagram for the review
Clinical outcomes in human studies
| Reference | Basis of change in management | Change in management | Anastomotic leakage | Necrosis |
|
| ||||
| Huh | Conventional assessment | 0 of 30 (0) | 1 of 30 (3) | n.a. |
| Ishige | FA | 6 of 20 (30) | 0 of 20 (0) | n.a. |
| Kamiya | Doppler ultrasonography and FA | 5 of 26 (19) | n.a. | 2 of 26 (8) |
| Koyanagi | FA | 0 of 40 (0) | 7 of 40 (18) | n.a. |
| Kumagai | Time from first fluorescence root RGEA to anastomotic site > 60 s | 18 of 70 (26) | 1 of 70 (1) | n.a. |
| Yukaya | n.r. | n.a. | 9 of 27 (33) | n.a. |
|
| ||||
| Foppa | FA | 4 of 160 (2·5) | n.a. | 1 of 4 (25) |
| Kim | FA | 30 of 310 (9·7) | 2 of 310 (0·6) | n.a. |
| Kudszus | FA | 28 of 201 (13·9) | 7 of 201 (3·5) | n.a. |
| Protyniak | Conventional assessment | 4 of 77 (5) | 2 of 77 (3) | n.a. |
| Sherwinter | Conventional assessment | 2 of 20 (10) | 2 of 20 (10) | n.a. |
| Son | n.r. | n.a. | 5 of 86 (6) | 1 of 86 (1) |
| Wada | FA | 18 of 112 (16·1) | 5 of 112 (4·5) | n.a. |
Values in parentheses are percentages. GI, gastrointestinal; n.a., not applicable; FA, fluorescence angiography; RGEA, right gastroepiploic artery; n.r., not reported.
Quantitative fluorescence parameters
| Reference | Parameters | Units | Overall mean(s.d.) value of parameters | Cut‐off value* |
|
| ||||
| Manually assessed time | ||||
| Huh | Time to first visible fluorescence signal | min | 4·1(3·2) | n.a. |
| Kim | Time to first visible fluorescence signal | s | 37(16) | n.a. |
| Koyanagi | Flow speed of ICG fluorescence | cm/s | 2·8(1·3) | 1·76 cm/s (OR 36·5) |
| Kumagai | Time from first fluorescence root from RGEA to anastomotic site | s | 35·3 (total range 13·0–204·0) | Anastomotic site in area perfused < 90 s (preferably < 60 s) |
| Quan | Time to first visible fluorescence signal | s | 138·0(82·1) | n.a. |
| Sherwinter | Time to maximum fluorescent excitation | s | 33·0(1·82) | n.a. |
| Wada | Time to first visible fluorescence signal | s | 39 (total range 20–120) | n.a. |
| Software‐derived fluorescence–time curves† | ||||
| Bornstein | Rate of change of maximum (timing map), maximum pixel intensity (perfusion map) | n.r. | n.r. | n.a. |
| Diana | Fmax, Tmax, slope (perfusion cartogram) | AU, s, AU/s | Tmax 5·69(3·68) | n.a. |
| Ishige | Fmax, Tmax | AU, s | 84·9(28·2), 18·9(6·5) | n.a. |
| Kamiya | Fmax, T1/2 | AU, s | n.r. | T1/2 9·2 s (0·82; 80; 92) |
| Kudszus | Curve | AU, s | n.r. | n.a. |
| Nerup | Fbg, Fmax, Tmax, slope, Fnorm | AU, s, AU/s | n.r. | n.a. |
| Nerup | Fnorm | AU, s | n.r. | n.a. |
| Son | Fbg, Fmax, Fnorm, T1/2, Tmax, TR, slope | AU, s, AU/s | 10·6(1·0), 58·0(3·4), n.r., 11·7(0·8), 30·3(2·3), 0·4(0·0), 2·5(0·2)‡ | T1/2 18 s (0·963; 100; 83·7) |
| TR 0·6 (0·929; 83·3; 96·3) | ||||
| Slope 0·7 AU/s (0·123; 66·7; 92·5) | ||||
| Wada | Fmax, T1/2, Tmax, slope | AU, s, AU/s | 91·4(31·9), 12·5(7·6), 32·8(15·9), 3·6(2·2)‡ | Fmax 52·0 AU (n.r.; 100; 92·5) Slope 2·1 AU/s (n.r.; 100; 75·7) |
| Yukaya | Fbg, Fmax, Fnorm, Tbg, Tmax, Tout 80% | AU, s | Tbg 41·7(2·4) | n.a. |
|
| ||||
| Ashitate | CBR over time (Fnorm/Fbg) | n.a. | n.r. | n.a. |
| Matsui | CBR over time (Fnorm/Fbg) | n.a. | n.r. | n.a. |
| Quan | Ratio of gastric conduit CBR/oesophageal CBR | n.a. | 0·97(0·024) | n.a. |
|
| ||||
| Foppa | Maximum pixel intensity | SPY units | n.r. | n.a. |
| Protyniak | Lowest pixel intensity | 0–256 greyscale | 66§ | n.a. |
|
| ||||
| Huh | Fluorescence and clinical scoring system | 1–5 points | FS 3·5 (range 3–5) | n.a. |
| Sherwinter | Fluorescence and clinical scoring system | 1–5 points | n.r. | n.a. |
Values in parentheses are area under the curve, sensitivity (%) and specificity (%).
For an explanation of derivatives, see
For patients without anastomotic leakage.
Average mean according to volume of procedures. n.a., Not applicable; ICG, indocyanine green; OR, odds ratio; RGEA, right gastroepiploic artery; n.r., not reported; Fmax, maximum intensity; Tmax, time from ICG inflow to Fmax; AU, arbitrary units; T1/2, time from ICG inflow to half of Fmax; Fbg, baseline or background intensity; Fnorm, Fmax corrected for background (Fmax subtracted by Fbg); TR, time ratio (T1/2 divided by Tmax); Tout, time of ICG outflow; Tbg, time from ICG injection to ICG inflow in tissue of interest;; CBR, contrast‐to‐background ratio; FS, fluorescence score.
Fig. 2Fluorescence–time curve and its derivatives