Jackie Robinson1, Caitlin Pilbeam2, Hetty Goodwin3, Deborah Raphael3, Susan Waterworth3, Merryn Gott3. 1. Faculty of Medical Health Sciences, School of Nursing, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand. j.robinson@auckland.ac.nz. 2. Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. 3. Faculty of Medical Health Sciences, School of Nursing, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Inequities in the provision of palliative care for people with cardiac disease have been well documented in the literature. Despite experiencing significant palliative care needs, those with cardiac disease are less likely to be referred to specialist palliative care services and more likely to die in a hospital when compared to those with cancer. The unpredictable trajectory of heart failure has been identified as a key barrier to providing palliative care with many people experiencing a long period of stability with appropriate medical treatment. However, as the disease progresses and cardiac function deteriorates, exacerbations of acute decompensation can lead to what is often perceived to be 'sudden' death. The aim of this study is to explore the impact of uncertainty on how death is remembered by bereaved family members of people with heart disease. METHODS: Thematic analysis of free text collected during a postal survey of bereaved family's experiences of healthcare services in the last 3 months of life using the New Zealand version of the VOICES questionnaire was undertaken. Data was analysed using a three-dimensional conceptual framework of "scientific uncertainty". RESULTS: Eight hundred and twenty-seven completed questionnaires were received of which 12.6% (n = 105) indicated that they had cared for someone at the end of life with cardiac disease. Experiences of uncertainty were found to have a significant impact upon bereaved family. Four key themes were identified; distrust in healthcare professionals, stories left incomplete, loss, regret and missed opportunity and disempowerment. CONCLUSIONS: This study highlights the ongoing impact on bereaved family when uncertainty is not made explicit in conversations regarding end of life for people with heart disease. Timely and sensitive conversations regarding the uncertainty of when death may occur is an important factor in ensuring that bereaved family are not left with unresolved narratives. Reframing how we think and talk about uncertainty in end of life care is important, as clinicians' uncertainties may not always reflect or match up with families' uncertainties. Being explicit about our inability to be certain about the timing of death may thus lead to a more positive and complete experience for bereaved family.
BACKGROUND: Inequities in the provision of palliative care for people with cardiac disease have been well documented in the literature. Despite experiencing significant palliative care needs, those with cardiac disease are less likely to be referred to specialist palliative care services and more likely to die in a hospital when compared to those with cancer. The unpredictable trajectory of heart failure has been identified as a key barrier to providing palliative care with many people experiencing a long period of stability with appropriate medical treatment. However, as the disease progresses and cardiac function deteriorates, exacerbations of acute decompensation can lead to what is often perceived to be 'sudden' death. The aim of this study is to explore the impact of uncertainty on how death is remembered by bereaved family members of people with heart disease. METHODS: Thematic analysis of free text collected during a postal survey of bereaved family's experiences of healthcare services in the last 3 months of life using the New Zealand version of the VOICES questionnaire was undertaken. Data was analysed using a three-dimensional conceptual framework of "scientific uncertainty". RESULTS: Eight hundred and twenty-seven completed questionnaires were received of which 12.6% (n = 105) indicated that they had cared for someone at the end of life with cardiac disease. Experiences of uncertainty were found to have a significant impact upon bereaved family. Four key themes were identified; distrust in healthcare professionals, stories left incomplete, loss, regret and missed opportunity and disempowerment. CONCLUSIONS: This study highlights the ongoing impact on bereaved family when uncertainty is not made explicit in conversations regarding end of life for people with heart disease. Timely and sensitive conversations regarding the uncertainty of when death may occur is an important factor in ensuring that bereaved family are not left with unresolved narratives. Reframing how we think and talk about uncertainty in end of life care is important, as clinicians' uncertainties may not always reflect or match up with families' uncertainties. Being explicit about our inability to be certain about the timing of death may thus lead to a more positive and complete experience for bereaved family.
Entities:
Keywords:
Cardiac disease; End of life care; Palliative care; Uncertainty
Authors: Katherine J Hunt; Alison Richardson; Anne-Sophie E Darlington; Julia M Addington-Hall Journal: BMJ Support Palliat Care Date: 2017-11-03 Impact factor: 3.568
Authors: Kieran L Quinn; Amy T Hsu; Glenys Smith; Nathan Stall; Allan S Detsky; Dio Kavalieratos; Douglas S Lee; Chaim M Bell; Peter Tanuseputro Journal: J Am Heart Assoc Date: 2020-02-19 Impact factor: 5.501
Authors: Jeanette Ziehm; Erik Farin; Jonas Schäfer; Kathrin Woitha; Gerhild Becker; Stefan Köberich Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2016-08-08 Impact factor: 2.655