| Literature DB >> 33830375 |
Anna Kaß1,2, Annica Franziska Dörsam3,4, Magdalene Weiß5, Stephan Zipfel1,2, Katrin Elisabeth Giel1,2.
Abstract
Breastfeeding is an effective way to protect and promote the health of the infant and mother. Cultural, social, economic, medical, or psychological factors might interfere with successful breastfeeding. Therefore, maternal eating disorders (EDs) may have detrimental effects on the decision of breastfeeding initiation and on its continuation. There is limited knowledge about the breastfeeding practices of mothers with EDs. We performed a systematic review to generate more evidence in this area. A search was conducted in PubMed and PsycINFO, and several journals were hand searched for relevant publications. Of N = 3904 hits, 13 full texts were included in the qualitative analysis. The findings on total duration of BF between mothers with and without EDs were mixed, but women with EDs showed more negative experiences and emotional problems during BF. There was not enough evidence to conclude on breastfeeding initiation, or on the duration of exclusive breastfeeding. Maternal EDs might have a negative impact on BF practices with possible negative effects on the maternal-child feeding environment. Further studies with comparable data and information on the women's partners' attitudes about breastfeeding are needed.Entities:
Keywords: Anorexia nervosa; Breastfeeding; Bulimia nervosa; Eating disorders; Lactation; Pregnancy
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 33830375 PMCID: PMC8492580 DOI: 10.1007/s00737-021-01103-w
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Arch Womens Ment Health ISSN: 1434-1816 Impact factor: 3.633
Fig. 1Systematic review search process displayed in the PRISMA flow diagram
Distribution of ED diagnoses in the overall sample
| ED | Control | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AN | BN | BED | OSFED | Unspecified ED diagnosis | ||
| 436 | 655 | 2502 | 62 | 1012 | 73,592 | |
| 4667 | ||||||
Abbreviations: N total number, ED eating disorder, AN anorexia nervosa, BN bulimia nervosa, BED binge eating disorder, OSFED other specified feeding and eating disorders
Overview of the research strategy and data extraction process
Note: The initials of authors who were integrated in the respective processes are displayed in brackets
Study characteristics
| Author, Year | Sample | Sample size | Prevalence of ED | Study design | Country | Objectives | ED diagnosis | Measurement of BF | Main results | NOS rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agras et al. | Mother-child dyads with or without history of EDs | 21% (partial) ED (AN = 2, BN = 17, BED = 22) | Longitudinal study | USA | Effect of maternal ED on their children regarding BF | Self-report questionnaire after delivery (EDI + TFEQ) + clinical interview | Self-report questionnaire (IFR) on 3 days/month until child was weaned: method of feeding, date of introduction to solid food | Compared to controls • Daughters sucked more rapidly*, more dawdling and vomiting • *Women with ED fed on a less regular schedule • ↑ Difficulties in weaning from bottle in daughters (delay of 9.6 months) • *Concern about weight of daughters ↑ (age 2–5) | 8/9 | |
| Allen et al. | Mothers with or without history of EDs and at least one child | 11% ED | Prospective cohort study | Australia | Early feeding practices, child ED symptoms and child psychological well-being | EDE-I-12 (current symptoms), parent interview (history of ED) | Parent interview: early feeding practices, duration of BF, age of introduction to solids | Compared to controls • *Women with ED introduced child to solids earlier (15.96 weeks ±1.79 vs. 21.86 ± 0.49 weeks) • No difference in age at weaning (age where BF stopped) (36.09 weeks ±6.25 vs. 39.75 weeks ± 1.66) • No difference in BF practices between daughters and sons | 7/9 | |
| Brinch et al. | Former AN patients | 100% AN | Follow-up of the Copenhagen Anorexia Nervosa Follow-Up Study | Denmark | Parental functioning of former AN patients (retrospective) | In the past by the hospital they were treated | Semi-structured interview about history of pregnancies, development of children, BF behavior | Compared to Danish average: • Same mean duration of BF • 84% of mothers breastfed for an average of 15 weeks • Reasons for weaning: too little milk, no milk, mastitis, physical reasons, dislike BF | 4/9 | |
| Evans and Le Grange | Mother-child dyads with or without history of EDs, children > 7 years | 50% AN or BN | Retrospective cohort study | South Africa | Effect of maternal ED on feeding style, BF duration and emotions during feeding | Questionnaires: EAT + Body Shape Questionnaire | Semi-structured interview about development of child, eating and BF behavior | Compared to controls: • Similar durations of BF (7.6 vs. 7 months) • Initial BF: 81.25% (ED) vs. 90% (control) • 55.6% scheduled feeding vs. 10% (control) • Emotional problems during BF: feeling unsuccessful, guilt, “waves of sadness” • Problems with BF: insufficient lactation, baby’s allergy to breast milk | 7/9 | |
| Hoffman et al. | Mother-child dyads with or without history of EDs | 50% AN or BN or OSFED, 50% NED | Non-randomized cohort study | USA | Feeding styles, child diet, restrictive approaches during feeding of mothers with history of EDs | Interview: SCID-I/P Questionnaire: EDE-Q | IFSQ, modified Toddler Diet Questionnaire | Compared to controls • No difference in percentage of mothers who breastfed >1 month • No difference in age of introduction to solid food | 7/9 | |
| Larsson and Andersson-Ellström | Mother-child dyads with or without history of EDs | 11% ED | Cross-sectional study | Sweden | Progress and experiences of BF and length of BF periods | Self-report questionnaire | Self-report questionnaire of 40 items: BF activity, experiences of BF and of changes of the breasts | Compared to controls: • *Fewer women exclusively breastfed at 3 months (73% (ED) vs. 84% (control)) • No BF at 3 months: ↑ in ED mothers (19%) vs. controls (7%) • Weak tendency: more negative experiences with breast changes and less positive feelings in connection with BF | 6/9 | |
| Martini et al. | Pregnant women with or without history of EDs | 53% ED | Longitudinal study (NEST-p) | UK | Comparison of women with C-ED or P-ED to healthy controls in relation to BF and maternal feeding attitudes at 8 weeks and 6 months postnatally | Interview: SCID-IV-TR Axis 1 Disorder at baseline Questionnaire: EDE-Q (36 items) at every measurement point | IFQ (28 items), primary feeding method at 8 weeks/6 months | C-ED and P-ED compared to controls: • No difference: percentage of mothers exclusively BF at 8 weeks (64.4% HC/66.7% P-ED/52% C-ED) • No difference: percentage of mothers exclusively or partially BF at 6 months (66.7% HC/73.9% P-ED/57.1% C-ED) • P-ED less awareness about infant hunger and satiety; high concern about infant becoming overweight at 8 w/6 m • C-ED high concern about infant becoming overweight at 6 m • Scheduled feeding slightly higher for C-ED at 6 m | 7/9 | |
| Micali et al. | Mother-child dyads with or without history of EDs and with or without other psychiatric problems | 2.7% AN, 1.6% BN | Longitudinal analysis of the ALSPAC study | UK | Feeding difficulties at age 1 and 6 months and BF during first year of life in mothers with history of ED compared to women with or without other psychiatric disorders | Self-report questionnaire about recent or past psychiatric problems | Questionnaire about BF at 1, 6, 15 months postnatally: feeding behaviors and difficulties | AN and BN compared to controls: • More likely to start BF (83% vs. 76%) • *Less likely to stop BF in the first year • AN more early onset feeding difficulties • Infants of women with ED: similar rate of fast drinking | 7/9 | |
| Nguyen et al. | Mother-child dyads with or without history of EDs | 9.5% AN or BN | Longitudinal analysis of the Generation R study | The Netherlands | Association of maternal history of ED with diet quality and BF practices | Self-report questionnaire for AN and BN | Postnatal questionnaire about BF behavior at 2, 6, 12 months | Compared to controls • No difference in duration of BF (among mothers who breastfed) | 6/9 | |
| Popovic et al. | Women with a history of AN or BN or no ED, at least one child | 1.9% AN and/or BN ( | Analysis of the NINFEA birth cohort study | Italy | Association of maternal history of ED with infant wheezing | Self-report questionnaire about lifetime ED diagnosis | Online questionnaires during pregnancy, at 6 + 18 months postpartum: BF more or less than 6 months? | Compared to controls • More likely to BF less than 6 months | 6/9 | |
| Torgersen et al. | Mother-child dyads with or without history of EDs | 0.1% AN ( | Longitudinal analysis of the MoBa study | Norway | Prevalence of BF between women with any ED subtype and mothers without ED in the first 6 months after birth | Self-report questionnaire after DSM-IV criteria | Questionnaire 6 months after birth: BF practices, bottle feeding, introduction of other drinks and solid food | Compared to controls • 98% initially BF, no difference between groups • No difference in risk of early cessation of exclusive BF • Risk of early cessation before 6 months * increased for AN and EDNOS-P) | 6/9 | |
| Torgersen et al. | Mother-child dyads with or without history of EDs | 0.1% AN ( | Longitudinal analysis of the MoBa study | Norway | Dietary feeding patterns of women with ED compared to the diet of children of mothers without ED | Self-report questionnaire after DSM-IV criteria | Questionnaire 6 months after birth: BF practices (stopped BF = 0, still BF = 1) | • BF rates 6 months postpartum: AN 58%, BN 79%, BED 76%, EDNOS-P 59%, no-ED 82% | 6/9 | |
| Waugh and Bulik | Women with or without history of EDs, children between 12 and 48 months, each group 5 boys and 5 girls | n = 10 ED (6 AN, 7 BN) (active ED = 6) | 30% AN ( | Longitudinal study | New Zealand | Health and development, temperament, body satisfaction, nutritional status of children, mealtime interaction patterns in offspring 1–4 years | Either Diagnostic Interview for Genetic Studies or Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R | Interview: initial feeding method, reason for bottle feeding (+ Child’s Plunket Book) | Compared to controls • Initial BF: 8 ED mothers vs. 10 control • ED mothers more difficulties maintaining BF * BF until weaning: 6 ED mothers vs. 10 control • 2 ED mothers ceased BF within 6 weeks because of BF problems: embarrassment, insufficient milk amounts • 2 ED mothers no BF at all: embarrassment, depression | 8/9 |
Abbreviations: NOS Newcastle Ottawa Scale, ED eating disorder, NED non-eating disorder, C-ED current eating disorder, AN anorexia nervosa, BN bulimia nervosa, BED binge eating disorder, OSFED other specified feeding and eating disorders, HC healthy controls, ALSPAC Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children, MoBa Norwegian Mother and Child Cohort Study, NINFEA Nascita ed INFanzia: gli Effetti dell’Ambiente, BF breastfeeding, EDE-I/Q Eating Disorder Examination-Interview/Questionnaire, EAT Eating Attitudes Test, DSM Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, SCID Structured Clinical Interview for DSM Axis I Disorders; *significant finding (p < 0.05); TFEQ Three-Factor Eating Questionnaire, IFR Infant Feeding Report, IFSQ Infant Feeding Styles Questionnaire, IFQ Infant Feeding Questionnaire