| Literature DB >> 33815799 |
Laura K Elmer1, Christine L Madliger1, Daniel T Blumstein2, Chris K Elvidge1, Esteban Fernández-Juricic3, Andrij Z Horodysky4, Nicholas S Johnson5, Liam P McGuire6, Ronald R Swaisgood7, Steven J Cooke1.
Abstract
Multidisciplinary approaches to conservation and wildlife management are often effective in addressing complex, multi-factor problems. Emerging fields such as conservation physiology and conservation behaviour can provide innovative solutions and management strategies for target species and systems. Sensory ecology combines the study of 'how animals acquire' and process sensory stimuli from their environments, and the ecological and evolutionary significance of 'how animals respond' to this information. We review the benefits that sensory ecology can bring to wildlife conservation and management by discussing case studies across major taxa and sensory modalities. Conservation practices informed by a sensory ecology approach include the amelioration of sensory traps, control of invasive species, reduction of human-wildlife conflicts and relocation and establishment of new populations of endangered species. We illustrate that sensory ecology can facilitate the understanding of mechanistic ecological and physiological explanations underlying particular conservation issues and also can help develop innovative solutions to ameliorate conservation problems.Entities:
Keywords: Conservation; multidisciplinary; sensory ecology; sensory modality
Year: 2021 PMID: 33815799 PMCID: PMC8009554 DOI: 10.1093/conphys/coab002
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Conserv Physiol ISSN: 2051-1434 Impact factor: 3.079
Summary of successful applications of sensory ecology in conservation and wildlife management
| Sensory modality | Taxa | Species | Conservation issue solved | Overview | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vision | Bird | Canada geese ( | Reduce airstrikes | Development of artificial lights to minimize collisions with aircraft |
|
| Fairy terns ( | Relocation | Visual decoys attracted endangered fairy terns to safe breeding areas |
| ||
| Griffon vultures ( | Relocation | Cliff paintings that mimicked droppings attracted vultures to nest on suitable cliffs |
| ||
| Fish | White sturgeon ( | Reduce entrapment and entrainment | Behavioural guidance of age-0 white sturgeon using coloured and strobing lights |
| |
| Invertebrate | Mayflies (Ephemeroptera), stoneflies (Trichoptera), dolichopodid dipterans, and tabanid flies (Tabanidae) | Ameliorate sensory trap | Fragmenting the solar-active area of solar panels reduced attractiveness of these panels to aquatic insects |
| |
| Reptile | Green sea turtle ( | Ameliorate sensory trap | New dimmer, amber lights on Florida beaches reduced misguidance of sea turtle hatchlings away from the ocean |
| |
| Green sea turtle ( | Reduce bycatch | Bycatch of turtles in commercial bottom gillnet fisheries reduced through use of LED and chemical light stick deterrents. |
| ||
| Audition | Bird | Black-capped vireo ( | Relocation | Playing recordings of conspecific song attracted birds to more suitable habitats safe from brood parasitic species. |
|
| European starling ( | Reduce airstrikes | Use of sound frequencies to create a ‘sonic net’ to deter birds from airfields |
| ||
| Mammal | Harbour porpoise ( | Reduce bycatch | Acoustic alarms successfully reduced bycatch of porpoises in gillnet fisheries, without reduced catch of target species |
| |
| Fish | Asian carps ( | Invasive species control | Sound barriers effective at controlling spread of invasive Asian carps in the Great Lakes |
| |
| Multiple | Relocation | Playback of healthy reef sounds increased fish abundance and species richness in degraded coral reef habitat |
| ||
| Chemoreception | Bird | Hooded plover ( | Reduce predation on threatened species | Conditioned taste aversion successful at reducing predation on threatened hooded plover eggs |
|
| Mammal | Common goat ( | Invasive species control | Female goats captured, sterilized and put in a chemically induced estrus to release pheromones to attract males for ineffective mating. Eradicated invasive goats from certain Galapagos Islands |
| |
| Fish | Sea lamprey ( | Invasive species control | Pheromone-based trapping highly effective, species-specific, method of capturing invasive sea lamprey in the Great Lakes |
| |
| Invertebrate | Gypsy moth ( | Invasive species control | Invasive gypsy moths in the USA have devasting effects of forests that can be effectively controlled with pheromone traps |
| |
| Electroception | Fish | Hammerhead sharks ( | Reduce bycatch | Commercial trawl fishing hooks made from electrorepulsive metals successful at reducing bycatch of sharks |
|
This table summarizes case studies where sensory ecology has been demonstrated to benefit conservation or wildlife management. We summarize relevant literature from all sensory modalities (vision, olfaction, chemoreception, electroreception and magnetoreception), across six major taxa (birds, mammals, fish, invertebrates, reptiles and amphibians) where valid case studies exist. We note that no relevant literature was found for amphibian species.
Areas of sensory ecology research that have furthered our understanding of sensory issues, with potential to help solve conservation issues
| Sensory modality | Taxa | Species | Overview | Reference | Conservation potential |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vision | Bird | Brown-headed cowbird ( | Certain wavelengths are more likely to enhance detection and avoidance by individuals |
| Using these lights on aircraft to reduce collisions. |
| Various | Birds have more laterally projected vision, and this may contribute to increased collisions with human infrastructure |
| Warning signs placed on the ground before human infrastructure may be more beneficial to helping birds avoid collisions | ||
| Mammal | Laboratory Wistar rats | Artificial light at night negatively affects sleep in rats |
| Increase our understanding of the negative impacts artificial light at night can have on various animals | |
| Tammar wallabies ( | Artificial light at night can affect reproductive timing of tammar wallabies |
| Increase our understanding of the effects of artificial light at night. Reduce artificial light at night during reproductive seasons of tammar wallabies | ||
| Invertebrate | Various | Artificial light at night causes temporal disorientation, phototaxis and visual desensitisation |
| Increase our understanding on this sensory trap. Possible solutions such as reducing the intensity or duration of artificial light at night, or using frequencies less attractive to insects | |
| Reptile | Green sea turtle ( | Sea turtles are more likely to consume plastic waste that resembles their common prey |
| Increase our understanding of this sensory trap. Reduce plastic waste in ocean | |
| Audition | Bird | Western bluebird ( | Noisy gas compressor stations increase physiological stress and reduce hatching success compared with quieter sites |
| Use of newer or quieter compressor stations or using improved sound insulation at compressor sites |
| Ovenbird ( | Noisy compressor sites reduce mating success by dampening conspecific calls |
| Use of newer or quieter compressor stations or using improved sound insulation at compressor sites | ||
| Various | Roadway traffic noise alone compromises avian density and overall body condition of birds in the area |
| Increase our understanding of the impacts of noise pollution | ||
| Mammal | Pinnipeds | Acoustic deterrents effective at deterring pinnipeds from fish farms and fisheries |
| This knowledge could be used in a conservation context to prevent bycatch, or vessel collisions, of pinnipeds | |
| Brazilian free-tailed bat ( | Activity of bats was lower at noisy compressor sites compared with quieter stations |
| Use of newer or quieter compressor stations or using improved sound insulation at compressor sites | ||
| Greater mouse-eared bats ( | Smooth vertical building surfaces can act as acoustic mirrors to echolocating bats, resulting in collisions |
| Redesign of certain buildings making them more ‘visible’ to echolocating bats | ||
| Killer whales ( | Noise from shipping traffic is a chronic stressor for killer whales and can disrupt foraging behaviour, pod communication, and echolocating clicks to detect prey |
| Re-routing ships to avoid major whale habitat, use of quieter ships, reducing speed at which ships travel near important whale habitat | ||
| Fish | Ambon damselfish ( | Ambon damselfish physiologically stressed by motorboat noise and show reduced ability to evade predators |
| Banning motorboats from certain areas of important damselfish habitat | |
| Invertebrate | Zooplankton | Seismic studies used to detect petroleum in the ocean can cause significant mortality of zooplankton |
| Further our understanding. Reduce the number of seismic studies conducted in the ocean | |
| Field crickets ( | Traffic noise distracted female field crickets meaning they did not orient to male auditory calls |
| Further our understanding | ||
| Hermit crab ( | Sound of motorboat noise distracts crabs and modifies their risk assessment allowing humans to get closer before retracting in their shells |
| Banning motorboats from certain areas of important crab habitat | ||
| Squid ( | Pile driving sounds elicited body pattern changes, inking, jetting and startle responses |
| Further our understanding. Future consideration in placement of wind farms to avoid important squid habitat | ||
| Chemoreception | Bird | Seabirds (order: Procellariiformes) | Marine plastics release DMS, which is also a common odorant released by the prey of many seabirds. Resulting plastic ingestion can lead to mortality |
| Potential to synthesize plastics without chemical compounds attractive to seabirds or other marine life |
| Mammal | Harvest mice ( | Captive breeding improved in mice by familiarizing females with male scents |
| Proof of concept. This technique could be used to improve breeding success of endangered species, or species in captivity | |
| Pygmy loris ( | Urine scent has been shown to influence mate choice in threatened female pygmy loris |
| This knowledge can be used to promote more beneficial mate pairing in this threatened species. Proof of concept—this technique could be used to promote more beneficial mate parings in other endangered species | ||
| Fish | Sheephead swordtail fish ( | Water polluted by sewage effluent chemicals has been shown to reduce female preference for male olfactory cues |
| Further our understanding of the negative impacts of water pollution on fish species, which could aid in stressing the need to reduce sewage effluent in natural aquatic habitats | |
| Invertebrate | Spanish moon moth ( | Pheromone trapping effective at attracting endangered species |
| Potential to use pheromone trapping as an effective way at monitoring populations of endangered invertebrates | |
| Magnetoreception | Bird | European robin ( | Electromagnetic noise from human activity disrupts magnetic compass orientation |
| Investigate use of potential electromagnetic frequencies that do not disrupt magnetic compass orientation |
| Invertebrate | Edible crab ( | Electromagnetic field emissions attracted crabs to underwater cable sites and reduced foraging behaviour |
| Consideration of the location of underwater cable routes in areas of important crab habitat | |
| Multisensory | Fish | Sea lamprey ( | ‘Pull’ of attractive light frequencies and ‘push’ of odor repellents effective at controlling juvenile sea lamprey movement |
| Potential for more effectively controlling movement of sea lamprey to either (a) protect individuals from entrapment/entrainment, or (b) control spread of invasive lamprey in certain areas |
This table summarizes sensory ecology research that has furthered our understanding of certain conservation issues, with potential to help develop innovative solutions to these problems. Although the case studies summarized here have not been demonstrated to benefit conservation practices, we do discuss potential ways in which the knowledge could be applied for the benefit of conservation and wildlife management. We summarize relevant literature from all sensory modalities (vision, olfaction, chemoreception, electroreception and magnetoreception), across six major taxa (birds, mammals, fish, invertebrates, reptiles and amphibians) where appropriate research exists. We note that no relevant literature was found for amphibian species.
Figure 1This figure provides a visual representation of taxa with known case studies demonstrating the application of sensory ecology to benefit wildlife conservation and management. Animals are categorized into six taxa: birds, mammals, invertebrates, fish, reptiles or amphibians. Each of these taxa is visually represented in the figure by a species from that taxon for which there has been a notable research demonstrating strong benefits of the integration of sensory ecology with conservation. Part (A) represents the three common senses, vision, audition and chemoreception, for which there is a larger amount of literature linking sensory ecology and conservation. Each of the six taxa specified by this paper are here categorized as either ‘well studied’ or ‘less studied’ depending on the presence or absence, respectively, of known literature linking sensory ecology to the conservation of species (or multiple species) of that taxon. Part (B) represents two sensory modalities, electroreception and magnetoreception, which have considerably smaller literature bases linking sensory ecology to conservation. However, we do note a single case study for each of these sensory modalities for which sensory ecology has benefited conservation of a species. Select Images by S. Bell, J. Hawkey, L. Fishman, K. Kraeer, and T. Saxby, courtesy of the Integration and Application Network, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science (ian.umces.edu/symbols/).