David Naimark1,2,3,4,5, Sharmistha Mishra1,4,5,6,7, Kali Barrett1,2,8, Yasin A Khan1,2,8, Stephen Mac1,2, Raphael Ximenes2,6,9, Beate Sander1,2,5,8,10,11. 1. Institute of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada. 2. Toronto Health Economics and Technology Assessment Collaborative, University Health Network, Toronto, Canada. 3. Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, Canada. 4. Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada. 5. Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada. 6. Institute of Medical Sciences, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada. 7. MAP Centre for Urban Health Solutions, Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute, St Michael's Hospital, Toronto, Canada. 8. University Health Network, Toronto, Canada. 9. Escola de Matemática Aplicada, Fundação Getúlio Vargas, Rio de Janeiro, Brasil. 10. ICES, Toronto, Canada. 11. Public Health Ontario, Toronto, Canada.
Abstract
Importance: Resurgent COVID-19 cases have resulted in the reinstitution of nonpharmaceutical interventions, including school closures, which can have adverse effects on families. Understanding the associations of school closures with the number of incident and cumulative COVID-19 cases is critical for decision-making. Objective: To estimate the association of schools being open or closed with the number of COVID-19 cases compared with community-based nonpharmaceutical interventions. Design, Setting, and Participants: This decision analytical modelling study developed an agent-based transmission model using a synthetic population of 1 000 000 individuals based on the characteristics of the population of Ontario, Canada. Members of the synthetic population were clustered into households, neighborhoods, or rural districts, cities or rural regions, day care facilities, classrooms (ie, primary, elementary, or high school), colleges or universities, and workplaces. Data were analyzed between May 5, 2020, and October 20, 2020. Exposures: School reopening on September 15, 2020, vs schools remaining closed under different scenarios for nonpharmaceutical interventions. Main Outcomes and Measures: Incident and cumulative COVID-19 cases between September 1, 2020, and October 31, 2020. Results: Among 1 000 000 simulated individuals, the percentage of infections among students and teachers acquired within schools was less than 5% across modeled scenarios. Incident COVID-19 case numbers on October 31, 2020, were 4414 (95% credible interval [CrI], 3491-5382) cases in the scenario with schools remaining closed and 4740 (95% CrI, 3863-5691) cases in the scenario for schools reopening, with no other community-based nonpharmaceutical intervention. In scenarios with community-based nonpharmaceutical interventions implemented, the incident case numbers on October 31 were 714 (95% CrI, 568-908) cases for schools remaining closed and 780 (95% CrI, 580-993) cases for schools reopening. When scenarios applied the case numbers observed in early October in Ontario, the cumulative case numbers were 777 (95% CrI, 621-993) cases for schools remaining closed and 803 (95% CrI, 617-990) cases for schools reopening. In scenarios with implementation of community-based interventions vs no community-based interventions, there was a mean difference of 39 355 cumulative COVID-19 cases by October 31, 2020, while keeping schools closed vs reopening them yielded a mean difference of 2040 cases. Conclusions and Relevance: This decision analytical modeling study of a synthetic population of individuals in Ontario, Canada, found that most COVID-19 cases in schools were due to acquisition in the community rather than transmission within schools and that the changes in COVID-19 case numbers associated with school reopenings were relatively small compared with the changes associated with community-based nonpharmaceutical interventions.
Importance: Resurgent COVID-19 cases have resulted in the reinstitution of nonpharmaceutical interventions, including school closures, which can have adverse effects on families. Understanding the associations of school closures with the number of incident and cumulative COVID-19 cases is critical for decision-making. Objective: To estimate the association of schools being open or closed with the number of COVID-19 cases compared with community-based nonpharmaceutical interventions. Design, Setting, and Participants: This decision analytical modelling study developed an agent-based transmission model using a synthetic population of 1 000 000 individuals based on the characteristics of the population of Ontario, Canada. Members of the synthetic population were clustered into households, neighborhoods, or rural districts, cities or rural regions, day care facilities, classrooms (ie, primary, elementary, or high school), colleges or universities, and workplaces. Data were analyzed between May 5, 2020, and October 20, 2020. Exposures: School reopening on September 15, 2020, vs schools remaining closed under different scenarios for nonpharmaceutical interventions. Main Outcomes and Measures: Incident and cumulative COVID-19 cases between September 1, 2020, and October 31, 2020. Results: Among 1 000 000 simulated individuals, the percentage of infections among students and teachers acquired within schools was less than 5% across modeled scenarios. Incident COVID-19 case numbers on October 31, 2020, were 4414 (95% credible interval [CrI], 3491-5382) cases in the scenario with schools remaining closed and 4740 (95% CrI, 3863-5691) cases in the scenario for schools reopening, with no other community-based nonpharmaceutical intervention. In scenarios with community-based nonpharmaceutical interventions implemented, the incident case numbers on October 31 were 714 (95% CrI, 568-908) cases for schools remaining closed and 780 (95% CrI, 580-993) cases for schools reopening. When scenarios applied the case numbers observed in early October in Ontario, the cumulative case numbers were 777 (95% CrI, 621-993) cases for schools remaining closed and 803 (95% CrI, 617-990) cases for schools reopening. In scenarios with implementation of community-based interventions vs no community-based interventions, there was a mean difference of 39 355 cumulative COVID-19 cases by October 31, 2020, while keeping schools closed vs reopening them yielded a mean difference of 2040 cases. Conclusions and Relevance: This decision analytical modeling study of a synthetic population of individuals in Ontario, Canada, found that most COVID-19 cases in schools were due to acquisition in the community rather than transmission within schools and that the changes in COVID-19 case numbers associated with school reopenings were relatively small compared with the changes associated with community-based nonpharmaceutical interventions.
Authors: Shari Krishnaratne; Hannah Littlecott; Kerstin Sell; Jacob Burns; Julia E Rabe; Jan M Stratil; Tim Litwin; Clemens Kreutz; Michaela Coenen; Karin Geffert; Anna Helen Boger; Ani Movsisyan; Suzie Kratzer; Carmen Klinger; Katharina Wabnitz; Brigitte Strahwald; Ben Verboom; Eva Rehfuess; Renke L Biallas; Caroline Jung-Sievers; Stephan Voss; Lisa M Pfadenhauer Journal: Cochrane Database Syst Rev Date: 2022-01-17
Authors: Tina Felfeli; Raphael Ximenes; David M J Naimark; Philip L Hooper; Robert J Campbell; Sherif R El-Defrawy; Beate Sander Journal: CMAJ Open Date: 2021-11-23
Authors: Alexander Preiss; Emily Hadley; Kasey Jones; Marie C D Stoner; Caroline Kery; Peter Baumgartner; Georgiy Bobashev; Jessica Tenenbaum; Charles Carter; Kimberly Clement; Sarah Rhea Journal: Infect Dis Model Date: 2022-02-04
Authors: David M Goldfarb; Louise C Mâsse; Allison W Watts; Sarah M Hutchison; Lauren Muttucomaroe; Else S Bosman; Vilte E Barakauskas; Alexandra Choi; Nalin Dhillon; Michael A Irvine; Frederic Reicherz; Collette O'Reilly; Sadaf Sediqi; Rui Yang Xu; Hamid R Razzaghian; Manish Sadarangani; Daniel Coombs; Sheila F O'Brien; Pascal M Lavoie Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2022-04-05 Impact factor: 2.692
Authors: Zeynep Ertem; Elissa Schechter-Perkins; Emily Oster; Polly van den Berg; Isabella Epshtein; Nathorn Chaiyakunapruk; Fernando Wilson; Elli Perenchevich; Warren Pettey; Westyn Branch-Elliman; Richard Nelson Journal: Res Sq Date: 2021-07-15