| Literature DB >> 33746224 |
Fabio Pagella1,2, Alessandro Pusateri1, Eugenia Maiorano1,2, Giuseppe Spinozzi1, Sara Ugolini1,2, Roberta Lizzio1, Rosolino Mirabella1,2, Carmine Tinelli3, Carla Olivieri2,4, Elina Matti1.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Hereditary haemorrhagic telangiectasia (HHT) is a rare autosomal dominant disease characterised by epistaxis. Surgical procedures for epistaxis vary from diathermocoagulation to nasal closure. The aim of this paper is to report our experience in endoscopic surgical management of epistaxis in HHT patients.Entities:
Keywords: Rendu Osler Weber disease; argon plasma coagulation; endoscopy; epistaxis; hereditary haemorrhagic telangiectasia; nosebleeds
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 33746224 PMCID: PMC7982753 DOI: 10.14639/0392-100X-N0915
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital ISSN: 0392-100X Impact factor: 2.124
Number of epistaxis-related surgical procedures performed in HHT patients.
| Number of surgeries | No. of patients | % |
|---|---|---|
| 1 procedure | 175 | 54.18% |
| 2 procedures | 56 | 17.34% |
| 3 procedures | 43 | 13.31% |
| 4 procedures | 19 | 5.88% |
| 5 procedures | 14 | 4.33% |
| 6 procedures | 5 | 1.55% |
| 7 procedures | 7 | 2.16% |
| 8 procedures | 2 | 0.62% |
| 9 procedures | 1 | 0.31% |
| 10 procedures | 1 | 0.31% |
| Total | 323 | 100% |
Time between surgical procedures in patients with more than one surgery. Results are reported in days, with the median of days between surgeries in each subgroup.
| No. of patients | Median | IQR (25th- 75th) | Min | Max | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First – Second | 150 | 612 | 299 | 1225 | 23 | 4979 |
| Second – Third | 92 | 447 | 205 | 769 | 17 | 3810 |
| Third – Fourth | 50 | 540 | 267 | 917 | 14 | 2175 |
| Fourth – Fifth | 30 | 420 | 279 | 762 | 55 | 1820 |
| Fifth – Sixth | 16 | 583 | 278 | 848 | 19 | 1211 |
| Sixth – Seventh | 11 | 224 | 42 | 697 | 21 | 1468 |
| Seventh – Eighth | 4 | 322 | 207 | 647 | 133 | 930 |
| Eighth – Ninth | 2 | 345 | 311 | 379 | 311 | 379 |
| Ninth – Tenth | 1 | 261 | 261 | 261 | 261 | 261 |
Figure 1.Plot showing the time between surgical procedures (in days) in HHT patients with more than one surgery. Columns: medians; lines: interquartile ranges. Females represented in white and males in black.
Figure 2.Nasal endoscopies in HHT patients, different patterns are shown. In (A), “large” pattern. In (B), “mixed” pattern. In (C), “punctate” pattern.
Figure 3.Intraoperative endoscopic sequence showing an APC procedure on left-side telangiectasias located on the lateral nasal wall.
Figure 4.Intraoperative endoscopic sequence showing a thulium laser procedure on a right-side telangiectasia located on the nasal septum.
Figure 5.Intraoperative endoscopic sequence showing the quantum molecular resonance technology procedure on a left-side telangiectasia located on the inferior turbinate/nasal valve.
Surgical techniques for epistaxis treatment in HHT patients.
| Study | Study design | No. of patients | Treatment | Outcome of interest | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boyer H. et al., 2011 [ | Retrospective | 7 | Sclerotherapy | Epistaxis frequency and severity | 100% improved |
| Morais D. et al., 2012 [ | Retrospective | 45 | Sclerotherapy | Epistaxis frequency and severity | 95% Improved |
| Boyer H. et al., 2015 [ | Randomised controlled trial | 17 | Sclerotherapy | ESS | Improved |
| Esteban-Casado S. et al., 2019 [ | Cross-sectional | 38 | Sclerotherapy and topical nasal propranolol | ESS, VAS, EQ-5D | Improved |
| Ghaheri B. et al., 2006 [ | Retrospective | 18 | Bipolar cautery | Need for recurrent intervention | Recurrent intervention in 50% at a mean follow-up of 2.3 years |
| Bergler W. et al., 1999 [ | Prospective | 12 | APC | Epistaxis frequency and intensity | Improved |
| Pagella F. et al., 2006 [ | Prospective | 36 | APC | Reported bleeding | 100% reduction at 6 months |
| Pagella F. et al., 2013 [ | Retrospective | 26 | APC | Epistaxis score | Improved at 12 months |
| Jørgensen G. et al., 2011 [ | Prospective | 30 | Laser | Epistaxis duration | Reduced at 1.5 and 6 months |
| Kuan E.C. et al., 2017 [ | Retrospective | 20 | Laser | SNOT-22 | Improved at 1.5 months |
| Fiorella M.L. et al., 2012 [ | Retrospective | 24 | Diode laser | Epistaxis frequency and severity | Improved |
| Poje G. et al., 2017 [ | Retrospective | 17 | Diode laser | Epistaxis frequency and severity | Improved |
| Papaspyrou G. et al., 2016 [ | Retrospective | 38 | Nd:YAG laser | Need for recurrent intervention | 18% recurrent intervention at a mean follow-up of 3 years |
| Papaspyrou G. et al., 2017 [ | Prospective | 45 | Nd:YAG laser +/- APC | Need for recurrent intervention | 20-33% recurrent intervention at 3-10 years |
| Joshi H. et al., 2011 [ | Case series | 5 | Coblation | Epistaxis control | 80% of patients |
| Mortuaire G. et al., 2013 [ | Prospective | 16 | Coblation | Epistaxis frequency and duration | Reduced frequency at 6 months |
| Rotenberg B. et al., 2015 [ | Retrospective | 37 | Coblation | ESS | Improved at 6 months |
| Luk L. et al., 2014 [ | Prospective | 11 | Coblation vs KTP laser | ESS | No difference in mean ESS |
| Ishibashi T. et al., 2003 [ | Case report | 2 | Harmonic | Frequency of epistaxis | Improved |
| Ichimura K. et al., 2006 [ | Retrospective | 15 | Septodermoplasty | Patient satisfaction | 100% satisfied |
| Lesnik G.T. et al., 2007 [ | Retrospective | 9 | Septodermoplasty with septectomy | Epistaxis frequency, QoL, blood transfusions | 100% improved QoL, blood transfusion reduced |
| Levine C.G. et al., 2008 [ | Retrospective | 106 | Septodermoplasty | QoL | 62% responded and 86% improved |
| Harvey R. et al., 2008 [ | Retrospective | 33 | Septodermoplasty | Frequency of KTP laser | Frequency of KTP laser treatment decreased (p = 0.012) |
| Rimmer J. et al., 2014 [ | Prospective | 7 | Septodermoplasty | Epistaxis frequency and severity | 100% improvement |
| Lee J.M. et al., 2019 [ | Prospective | 7 | Temporary nasal occlusion with Floseal® | ESS and clinical assessment of nasal cavity | No significant ESS improvement(p = 0.179); clinical assessment of nasal cavity improved (p = 0.0088) at 1 month |
| Hosni A.A. et al., 1994 [ | Case series | 2 | Nasal closure | Epistaxis frequency | Improved |
| Ichimura K. et al., 2012 [ | Prospective | 7 | Nasal closure | Epistaxis cessation | 57% success |
| Richer S. et al., 2012 [ | Retrospective | 43 | Nasal closure | Epistaxis cessation | 84% responded and 83% success |
| Lund V. et al., 2017 [ | Retrospective | 100 | Nasal closure | Epistaxis cessation | 50% responded and 94% success |
| Andersen J.H. et al., 2020 [ | Retrospective | 10 | Nasal closure | GBI | Overall GBI score of 38.05 with an average follow-up 66 months |
ESS: Epistaxis Severiry Score; VAS: visual analoge scale; EQ-5D: EuroQol-5D scale; APC: Argon plasma coagulation; SNOT-22: Sinonasal outcome test-22; QoL: Quality of life; KTP: Potassium-titanyl-phosphate; GBI: Glasgow benefit inventory.