Benjamin F Bigelow1, Nicholas Siegel1, Gregory R Toci1, Jeffrey A Elsner1, Caitlin W Hicks2, Christopher J Abularrage3. 1. Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland. 2. Division of Vascular Surgery & Endovascular Therapy, Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, Baltimore, Maryland. 3. Division of Vascular Surgery & Endovascular Therapy, Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, Baltimore, Maryland. Electronic address: cabular1@jhmi.edu.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Research output is one element of a multifactorial process that residency programs consider when evaluating applicants. However, there are minimal data assessing research productivity on admittance into research-oriented integrated vascular surgery residency (RO-IVSR) programs. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the association of peer-reviewed research and the RO-IVSR match process. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Vascular surgery residents who matched into an RO-IVSR in 2015-2017 were divided into those matching an RO-IVSR top 10 program versus other. Total publications, first authorships, and type of research were compared between groups. Mann-Whitney U-tests were then performed between discrete levels of research productivity (0-1 versus ≥2 publications) to detect differences in ability to match a top 10 program. RESULTS: One hundred and fifty-eight residents published a total of 214 original research articles (83%), 26 case reports (10%), and 19 systematic reviews (7%). There were 66 first authorships (25%). Median total publications at RO-IVSR top 10 versus other programs were 2 versus 1 (P < 0.01). Top 10 IVSR had a significant difference in median publications for all other research categories. The ability to match into a top 10 program by discrete levels of research productivity at 0-1 versus 2+ showed significance (P < 0.05) in all research categories, including total publications, first authorships, and H-index. CONCLUSIONS: There was significantly higher research productivity among medical students who matriculate to top 10 IVSR programs. Furthermore, having 2 or more publications significantly increased the likelihood of attending a top 10 program. Thus, top programs likely use an applicants' research productivity as a distinct qualification category and a marker of future success.
BACKGROUND: Research output is one element of a multifactorial process that residency programs consider when evaluating applicants. However, there are minimal data assessing research productivity on admittance into research-oriented integrated vascular surgery residency (RO-IVSR) programs. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the association of peer-reviewed research and the RO-IVSR match process. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Vascular surgery residents who matched into an RO-IVSR in 2015-2017 were divided into those matching an RO-IVSR top 10 program versus other. Total publications, first authorships, and type of research were compared between groups. Mann-Whitney U-tests were then performed between discrete levels of research productivity (0-1 versus ≥2 publications) to detect differences in ability to match a top 10 program. RESULTS: One hundred and fifty-eight residents published a total of 214 original research articles (83%), 26 case reports (10%), and 19 systematic reviews (7%). There were 66 first authorships (25%). Median total publications at RO-IVSR top 10 versus other programs were 2 versus 1 (P < 0.01). Top 10 IVSR had a significant difference in median publications for all other research categories. The ability to match into a top 10 program by discrete levels of research productivity at 0-1 versus 2+ showed significance (P < 0.05) in all research categories, including total publications, first authorships, and H-index. CONCLUSIONS: There was significantly higher research productivity among medical students who matriculate to top 10 IVSR programs. Furthermore, having 2 or more publications significantly increased the likelihood of attending a top 10 program. Thus, top programs likely use an applicants' research productivity as a distinct qualification category and a marker of future success.
Authors: Ivan David Lozada-Martinez; Jeremías Carvajal-Bautista; Yelson Alejandro Picón-Jaimes; Gonzalo Dominguez-Alvarado; Luis Felipe Cabrera-Vargas; Lilian Torregrosa-Almonacid; Oscar Guevara-Cruz; Alexis Rafael Narvaez-Rojas Journal: Ann Med Surg (Lond) Date: 2022-04-28