Peng Wang1, Xiaoxi Yuan2, Zheng Cui1, Chunyan Xu2, Zhaolong Sun1, Jiahan Li1, Junsong Liu1, Yu Tian2, Hongdong Li1. 1. State Key Laboratory of Superhard Materials, College of Physics, Jilin University, Changchun 130012, P. R. China. 2. Institute for Interdisciplinary Quantum Information Technology, Jilin Engineering Normal University, Changchun 130052, P.R. China.
Abstract
A boron-doped diamond (BDD) has been widely used as an outstanding electrode for constructing high-performance electrochemical biosensors. In this paper, we fabricated a novel electrode combined of nanometer-sized graphite-BDD film (NG-BDD) by chemical vapor deposition. The nanometer-sized graphite (NG) is formed on the (111) facet of BDD via converting an sp3 diamond structure to an sp2 graphitic phase at high temperature in boron-rich ambient. The electrode was characterized by means of scanning electron microscopy, Raman spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. This NG-BDD was performed as an electrode of electrochemical biosensor to detect trace acetaminophen (APAP) accurately. Cyclic voltammetry and differential normal pulse voltammetry are used to investigate the overall performance of the electrochemical device. The sensor has a linear electrochemical response to APAP in the concentration range of 0.02-50 μM, and the detection limit is estimated to be as low as 5 nM. The research has resulted in a solution of constructing a reusable NG-BDD sensor to detect APAP with stability and show potential in extensive application.
A boron-doped diamond (BDD) has been widely used as an outstanding electrode for constructing high-performance electrochemical biosensors. In this paper, we fabricated a novel electrode combined of nanometer-sized graphite-BDD film (NG-BDD) by chemical vapor deposition. The nanometer-sized graphite (NG) is formed on the (111) facet of BDD via converting an sp3 diamond structure to an sp2 graphitic phase at high temperature in boron-rich ambient. The electrode was characterized by means of scanning electron microscopy, Raman spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. This NG-BDD was performed as an electrode of electrochemical biosensor to detect trace acetaminophen (APAP) accurately. Cyclic voltammetry and differential normal pulse voltammetry are used to investigate the overall performance of the electrochemical device. The sensor has a linear electrochemical response to APAP in the concentration range of 0.02-50 μM, and the detection limit is estimated to be as low as 5 nM. The research has resulted in a solution of constructing a reusable NG-BDD sensor to detect APAP with stability and show potential in extensive application.
Carbon-based
structures have attracted tremendous attention owing
to the outstanding and unique structural characteristics in recent
decades.[1] Glassy carbon, carbon nanotubes,
graphene, and boron-doped diamond (BDD) are attracting widespread
interest in an electroanalysis for inherent natures such as a large
specific surface, fast electron transfer, and so on.[2,3] Among them, innovative hybrid sp3-C and sp2-C architectures are wonder materials for its high specific surface
area, high conductivity, and biocompatibility currently.[4] Diamond/graphite nanowires were synthesized in
2007 by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) with additonally introducing
nitrogen, which consist of a diamond core of 5–6 nm in diameter
covered by graphite shells.[5] Arenal et
al. reported diamond nanowires surrounded by graphite sheath adding
more than 10% N2 and revealed that the sp2-bonded
carbon sheath provides the excellent electrical conductivity.[6] A low detection limit for Ag+ could
be obtained in the nitrogen-incorporated ultrananocrystaline diamond/multilayer
graphene composite films.[7] Jiang et al.
presented diamond/graphite nanoplatelet films grown in CH4 and H2 source gases without N2 addition for
the sensitive detection of trace heavy metal ions. They explored the
conductive diamond and graphite hybridized configuration as a DNA
sensor in biological applications. The hybrid sp3-C and
sp2-C based electrochemical devices fabricated by CVD could
operate for a long period of time especially in a harsh environment
because of the tight interfacial association between graphite and
the conductive substrate rather than graphite dispersion on the surface
of commercial electrodes. BDD containing almost complete sp3carbons throughout the lattice has unique electrochemical properties
such as a wide potential window, low background current, and electrochemical
stability.[8,9] The strong interfacial force between graphite
and a BDD substrate solved the bottleneck in the manufacturing of
stable graphite-diamond electrodes.In the last several decades,
the increasing use of medicine prevented
diseases and improved the quality of human health. Acetaminophen (APAP)
is widely used as one of most effective painkiller to relieve pain
and fever.[10,11] Due to its increased use, the
disposal of APAP and manufacturing wastewater has been found to be
increasing in the source water system.[12] APAP exists in concentrations ranging from dozens to hundreds of
nanomolar per liter,[13] thus making it a
rapidly emerging worldwide water problem.[14] In addition, increased APAP in drinking water may lead to increased
mortality and heart and gastrointestinal diseases.[15] Also, the excessive and toxic doses of APAP will not only
accumulate toxic metabolites resulting in liver and kidney damage
but also contaminate water resources. Thus, monitoring APAP in water
is imminently important. Several typical methods, such as spectrophotometry,[16] titrimetry,[17] liquid
chromatography,[18] and chemiluminescence,[19] have been used for quantitatively determining
APAP in pharmaceutical tablets or biological fluids. However, the
classical techniques such as liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry
are unsuitable for a routine analysis because of complex pretreatment
program and expensive and time-consuming systems.[20] Because APAP is electroactive, an electrochemical method
is favorable for detecting APAP. Moreover, electroanalytical techniques
are highly sensitive, less time-consuming, and inexpensive, as well
as a wide dynamic range and quick response can be realized.[21,22]In this study, nanometer-sized graphite-BDD (NG-BDD) was synthesized
in CH4/H2 mixture gas with B(OCH3)3 via CVD. The high temperature will accelerate the process
where carbon atoms tend toward the sp2 state on the (111)
facet of BDD, eventually forming nanometer-sized graphite (NG). The
fabricated NG-BDD electrode at a higher temperature exhibits a linear
electrochemical range of 0.02–50 μM and a low limit of
detection of 5 nM for APAP. It reveals that the fabricated sensor
shows high selectivity, reproducibility, and stability for monitoring
APAP.
Results and Discussion
NG-BDD
Characterization
Figure exhibits the morphological
evolution from the BDD to NG-BDD films at different temperatures from
850 to 1050 °C with constant CH4/H2/B(OCH3)3 flow rates (2/150/2 sccm). As can be seen, the
temperature plays a vital role in the growth from NG-BDD films at
950 °C (L-NG-BDD) to NG-BDD films at 1050 °C (H-NG-BDD).
The polycrystalline BDD films consist of dense grains with an average
size of 1–5 μm at the substrate temperature of 850 °C
(Figure a). When the
temperature increases up to 950 °C, the NG uniformly covers a
small part of the (111) facets of the BDD substrate, as shown in Figure b. With a further
increase in temperature to 1050 °C, the area covered by the NG
has enlarged (Figure c). Figure d is the
image obtained at a high magnification of Figure c. The size of the NG on the (111) facets
of BDD is in the region of 70–500 nm, and the thickness of
graphite is irregular. Therefore, the surface characterization of
the films presents an obvious structural transformation from diamond
crystals (sp3-C) to nanometer-sized graphite (sp2-C) with increasing the substrate temperature. However, under the
same conditions without boron doping, no surface graphitization is
found, which shows that the factor of boron doping plays a decisive
role. NG grown on the (111) facet of BDD might be caused by the high
doping concentration of boron on the (111) facet. The surface characterization
of the films presents an obvious structural transformation from diamond
crystals (sp3-C) to nanometer-sized graphite (sp2-C) in Figure . As
reported in a previous work that the graphene reconstruction favorably
occurred on the (111) BDD.[23] In this paper,
no surface graphitization is found under the same conditions for the
undoped diamond films, meaning that the factor of boron doping plays
a crucial role in forming graphite on the BDD surface. At a higher
temperature (1050 °C), the formation barrier of transferring
diamond to graphite could be easily overcome, and carbon atoms are
easier to reconstruct. NG has already grown on the (111) facet of
BDD at the temperature of 950 °C, and the area of NG enlarges
at the temperature of 1150 °C. It is consistent with the previous
work that the graphite-like surface reconstructions on the (111) facet
of a diamond are based on the DFT.[24,25]
Figure 1
SEM images
of (a) polycrystalline BDD films at 850 °C, (b)
L-NG-BDD, (c) H-NG-BDD, and (d) is the image obtained at a high magnification
of (c).
SEM images
of (a) polycrystalline BDD films at 850 °C, (b)
L-NG-BDD, (c) H-NG-BDD, and (d) is the image obtained at a high magnification
of (c).Figure a displays
the characteristics of Raman spectra of the polycrystalline BDD, L-NG-BDD,
and H-NG-BDD films. In the Raman spectra, the peak of 1330 cm–1 and the broad peaks around at 500 and 1200 cm–1 appear on each of the films. The peak around 1330
cm–1 corresponds to an sp3-bonded carbon,
which is the characteristic peak of a diamond. The asymmetry of the
diamond peak at 1330 cm–1 reveals the high concentration
of boron doping. The broad peaks located at 500 and 1200 cm–1 are related to the boron doping-induced Fano effect and density
of states.[26,27] However, the L-NG-BDD and H-NG-BDD
give an extra band centered at 1594 cm–1 (G peak)
originating from the radial breathing mode of an sp2carbon.[28,29] The D peak at around 1350 cm–1 might be submerged
by a diamond peak at 1330 cm–1. Comparing to the
diamond peak, the peak at 1350 cm–1 submerged, and
the weak peak at 1594 cm–1 indicated the fact that
a small amount of graphite on the (111) facets of BDD is nanometer-sized,
while BDD is high-quality microcrystalline, which is consistent with
the SEM images in Figure
Figure 2
(a) Raman and (b) XRD spectra of BDD, L-NG-BDD, and H-NG-BDD films.
(a) Raman and (b) XRD spectra of BDD, L-NG-BDD, and H-NG-BDD films.The X-ray diffraction (XRD) spectra of the BDD,
L-NG-BDD, and H-NG-BDD
films are presented in Figure b. The same characteristic diffraction peaks at 43.9, 75.4,
and 91.5° are assigned to (111), (220), and (311) diamond diffraction
modes, respectively.[30] The sharp peak at
26.0° corresponds to the (002) graphite in the two NG-BDD samples.
As revealed by graphite peak intensity at 1050 °C that is larger
than that at 950 °C, the graphite grows more on BDD at 1050 °C,
consistent with the results of SEM (Figure b,c). The XRD spectra at different temperatures
demonstrate that the increased temperature will facilitate the growth
of NG.Although the evidence of sp2C=C is
not obvious
in the Raman spectra, the X-ray photoelectron spectrum (XPS) is a
more sensitive surface technique. The as-grown films have hydrogen
termination and are stored under a vacuum before the XPS measurements.
As shown in Figure , the strong C 1s spectra peaks located at 284.6 eV in all samples
are assigned to the sp3C–C present in the diamond
bulk.[31] The spectral feature at 285.3 eV
corresponds to the presence of carbon atoms bound to subsurface hydrogen.[32] The peak found at 284.1 eV in Figure a can be attributed to sp2C=C at the polycrystalline grain boundaries of BDD.[33] The presence of sp2C=C (Figure b,c) can be assigned
to the graphite reconstructed on the BDD surface in the environment
with boron.[23,34] The peak at 284.1 eV, associated
with the graphite group, increases significantly after heating. The
decrease in the full width at half maximum is attributable to the
increase in structural order due to the longer π bonds. The
ratio of sp2C=C dramatically increased due to the
graphitization of the L-NG-BDD films (8.07%) compared to BDD (3.06%).
Especially at the elevated temperature of 1050 °C, the ratio
of sp2C=C increased to 10.46%, which indicates
that the graphite component is more than that at the temperature of
950 °C. These results are in good agreement with the SEM measurements
that an sp2-bonded carbon is present within the films,
but its fraction is not very large.
Figure 3
XPS of (a) BDD, (b) L-NG-BDD, and (c)
H-NG-BDD films.
XPS of (a) BDD, (b) L-NG-BDD, and (c)
H-NG-BDD films.
Electrochemical
Characterization for Detecting
APAP
The BDD, L-NG-BDD, and H-NG-BDD electrodes are proposed
to detect 6.5 μM APAP solutions by DNPV (Figure a). As can be seen, the BDD shows the broad
and weak oxidation waves centered at 556 mV. Compared with BDD, it
is observed that the oxidation peak potential of APAP shifts negatively
by using L-NG-BDD and H-NG-BDD at 476 and 383 mV, respectively. Furthermore,
the oxidation peak currents of APAP at L-NG-BDD and H-NG-BDD improved
significantly. The peak current at H-NG-BDD is almost sixfold that
of BDD, indicating that the NG might enlarge the surface area and
reaction sites to obtain a high sensitivity.
Figure 4
(a) DNPV curves for 6.5
μM APAP obtained on BDD (black short
dash dot), L-NG-BDD (red dash), and H-NG-BDD electrodes (blue solid)
in 0.1 M PBS with a scan rate of 50 mV s–1. The
inset graph is the DNPV curve at a high magnification on BDD. (b)
Impedance spectra of BDD, L-NG-BDD, and H-NG-BDD electrodes tested
in a 5 mM Fe(CN)63–/4– solution
containing 0.1 M KCl.
(a) DNPV curves for 6.5
μM APAP obtained on BDD (black short
dash dot), L-NG-BDD (red dash), and H-NG-BDD electrodes (blue solid)
in 0.1 M PBS with a scan rate of 50 mV s–1. The
inset graph is the DNPV curve at a high magnification on BDD. (b)
Impedance spectra of BDD, L-NG-BDD, and H-NG-BDD electrodes tested
in a 5 mM Fe(CN)63–/4– solution
containing 0.1 M KCl.Electrochemical impedance
spectroscopy (EIS) is an effective way
used widely to study the interface characteristics of electrodes.
It usually includes a semicircular part and line part at a higher
frequency and lower frequency respectively, corresponding to the electron
transfer limiting process and the diffusion process.[35] The electron transfer kinetics of BDD, L-NG-BDD, and H-NG-BDD
are further explored. Thus, the impedance spectra of BDD, L-NG-BDD,
and H-NG-BDD in 5 mM Fe(CN)63–/4– solution are shown in Figure b. All the impedance spectra are fitted with a detailed fitting
data (Table ). The
charge transfer resistances taking place at the solution interface
(Rct) of BDD, L-NG-BDD, and H-NG-BDD are
86.9, 68.7, and 57.7 Ω, respectively. The Rct of L-NG-BDD is smaller than BDD, which means that the
graphite promotes electron transfer. It is confirmed that H-NG-BDD
has the better electron transfer ability for the lowest Rct.
Table 1
R(Q(RW)) Circuit Modeling Results
of BDD, L-NG-BDD, and H-NG-BDD Electrodes Tested in a 5 mM Fe(CN)63–/4– Solution Containing 0.1 M KCla
sample
Rs (Ω)
CPE (mF)
Rct (Ω)
Zw (Ω/cm2 S–1)
BDD
11.4
3.48
86.9
243.3 ×
10–6
L-NG-BDD
12.7
4.05
68.7
314.3 × 10–6
H-NG-BDD
11.6
4.20
57.7
220.6 ×
10–6
Rs is
the solution resistance of the electrolyte, CPE is a constant phase
element that takes into account the interfacial irregularities, Rct is the charge transfer resistance taking
place at the solution interface, and Zw is the Warburg diffusion impedance element.
Rs is
the solution resistance of the electrolyte, CPE is a constant phase
element that takes into account the interfacial irregularities, Rct is the charge transfer resistance taking
place at the solution interface, and Zw is the Warburg diffusion impedance element.In order to explore the kinetic reaction of the H-NG-BDD
electrode,
the various cyclic voltammetry (CV) of 10 μM APAP in 0.1 M NaH2PO4-Na2HPO4 buffer solution
(PBS) (pH 7.4) with different scan rates is presented in Figure a. The scan rates
are 10, 20, 30, 40, and 50 mV s–1. The redox peak
current linearly increases against the increasing of scan rate with
correlation coefficients (R2) of 0.99
(Figure S1), suggesting an adsorption-controlled
process at a low scan rate.[36] The redox
peak current linearly increases against the increasing square root
of scan rates (50, 100, 150, 200, 250, 300, 350, 400, 450, and 500
mV s–1), suggesting a typical diffusion-controlled
process at a high scan rate. It can be seen in Figure S2 that the anode peak potential (Ep) is proportional to the natural logarithm of the scan
rate with the relationship expressed as: Ep = 0.015 ln υ + 0.358. Based on Laviron equation,[37,38] the value of the transfer coefficient (α) and the number of
transferred electrons (n) are calculated to be 0.63
and 2.2, in agreement with the previous results.[39] The electrochemical redox behavior of APAP is investigated
in 10 nM APAP with different pH values ranging from 6.0 to 8.0, and
the maximum peak current is obtained at pH 7.4 (Figure b). Thus, the 0.1 M PBS buffer solution with
pH 7.4 is selected for subsequent experiments. In Figure S3, the peak potential negatively shifting with the
increase of pH value indicates that the redox behavior is a process
involving protons.[40] The equation of peak
potential depending on the pH is Ep =
0.055pH + 0.800. Based on the slope of 0.055, the proton number (m) is estimated to be about 2. Therefore, the oxidation
of APAP involves a two-electron and two-proton process, which is consistent
with the previous works.[41−43] The mechanisms of APAP electrochemical
reactions that the molecule loses two electrons and two protons to
become N-acetyl-p-benzoquinone imine
are shown in Scheme .
Figure 5
(a) Five CV curves of 10 μM APAP on the H-NG-BDD electrode
at different scan rates in 0.1 M PBS (pH = 7.4). The scan rates are
10, 20, 30, 40 and 50 mV s–1. (b) DNPV diagrams
of 10 μM APAP on the H-NG-BDD electrode with different pH values.
The pH values of 0.1 M PBS are 8.0, 7.4, 7.0, 6.6, and 6.0.
Scheme 1
Mechanisms of APAP Electrochemical Reactions
(a) Five CV curves of 10 μM APAP on the H-NG-BDD electrode
at different scan rates in 0.1 M PBS (pH = 7.4). The scan rates are
10, 20, 30, 40 and 50 mV s–1. (b) DNPV diagrams
of 10 μM APAP on the H-NG-BDD electrode with different pH values.
The pH values of 0.1 M PBS are 8.0, 7.4, 7.0, 6.6, and 6.0.
Optimization of Accumulation
Process
Differential normal pulse voltammetry (DNPV) is a
technique that
involves applying amplitude potential pulses on a linear ramp potential.
In DNPV, a base potential value is chosen at which there is no faradaic
reaction and is applied to the electrode. The base potential is increased
between pulses with equal increments. The current is immediately measured
before the pulse application and at the end of the pulse, and the
difference between them is recorded. The parameters that determine
the peak current of DNPV include pulse amplitude, first pulse width,
and second pulse width on the signal response. The optimization of
the parameters of DNPV is an important step to realize the excellent
peak current and sensitivity of this pulse technique, including the
study of the dependence of the parameters above. The first pulse width
varies from 100 to 300 ms, the second pulse width varies from 20 to
60 ms, and pulse amplitude varies from 30 to 60 mV. Experimental details
are presented in Figure , which gives the experimental data of how the accessible parameters
affect the peak current and resolution. From the data in Figure and similar data,
optimized parameters for the subsequent analytical work are chosen:
first pulse width of 200 ms; second pulse width of 50 ms; and pulse
amplitude of 50 mV.
Figure 6
DNPV diagrams on the H-NG-BDD electrode of APAP in phosphate
buffer
pH 7.4 at different (a) first pulse widths from 100 to 400 ms; (b)
second pulse widths from 30 to 60 ms; and (c) pulse amplitudes from
30 to 60 mV. Concentration of APAP for panels (a–c): 2 μM.
DNPV diagrams on the H-NG-BDD electrode of APAP in phosphate
buffer
pH 7.4 at different (a) first pulse widths from 100 to 400 ms; (b)
second pulse widths from 30 to 60 ms; and (c) pulse amplitudes from
30 to 60 mV. Concentration of APAP for panels (a–c): 2 μM.
Calibration Curve and Limit
of Detection
Under the optimal experimental conditions of
DNPV, the electrochemical
oxidation of APAP is carried out at the H-NG-BDD electrode with various
concentrations of APAP and of detection range from 0.02 to 50 μM
(Figure a). We received
two linear regression equations: Q = 0.306C + 0.334 (R2 = 0.99, 0.02–0.1
μM) and Q = 1.908C + 0.174
(R2 = 0.99, 0.1–50 μM), a
detection limit (DL) of (5 nM) is calculated using the equation DL
= 3 × SD (standard deviation)/slope (Figure b). At low APAP levels, the local concentration
at the electrode surface is rapidly depleted by the catalysis of NG,
resulting in the high sensitivity of the electrode response. At higher
APAP concentrations, the surface of the electrode might be fouled
by the reaction products resulting in a lower slope.[44] Also, it attains to the saturation level at a higher concentration.
Thus, the sensor showed different linear correlations at different
concentration ranges. The performance of the H-NG-BDD electrode exhibits
a lower detection limit and wide detection range comparing to the
most previous reports in the literature for the detection of APAP[11,36,45−48] (Table ).
Figure 7
(a) DNPV diagrams of APAP with the concentrations
of (a) 0.02,
(b) 0.04, (c) 0.06, (d) 0.08, (e) 0.10, (f) 1, (g) 2, (h) 3, (i) 4,
(j) 5, (k) 10, (l) 15, (m) 20, (n) 25, (o) 30, (p) 35, (q) 40, (r)
45, and (s) 50 μM on the H-NG-BDD electrode. Inset graph is
the DNPV curves at the high magnification of APAP with the concentrations
of 0.02–0.1 μM (b) Calibration curve of detecting APAP.
Inset graph is calibration curve with an APAP concentration of 0.02–0.1
μM. The buffer is 0.1 M PBS (pH = 7.4).
Table 2
Relevant Published Redox Electrochemical
Biosensors for APAP Detectiona
(a) DNPV diagrams of APAP with the concentrations
of (a) 0.02,
(b) 0.04, (c) 0.06, (d) 0.08, (e) 0.10, (f) 1, (g) 2, (h) 3, (i) 4,
(j) 5, (k) 10, (l) 15, (m) 20, (n) 25, (o) 30, (p) 35, (q) 40, (r)
45, and (s) 50 μM on the H-NG-BDD electrode. Inset graph is
the DNPV curves at the high magnification of APAP with the concentrations
of 0.02–0.1 μM (b) Calibration curve of detecting APAP.
Inset graph is calibration curve with an APAP concentration of 0.02–0.1
μM. The buffer is 0.1 M PBS (pH = 7.4).GCE: glassy carbon; SPE: screen-printed
electrode; and MWCNT: multiwalled carbon nanotube.
Theoretical Study of APAP
Adsorbed on H-NG-BDD
and BDD
In order to understand the adsorption of APAP molecules
on H-NG-BDD and BDD in detail, the theoretical analysis is carried
out by density functional theory (DFT). Because the difference between
H-NG-BDD and BDD is the NG grown on the (111) facets of BDD, the theoretical
model is simplified to calculate the adsorption energy of APAP and
NG (or BDD) to explore the sensitive role of each electrode. The crystal
structure of APAP with NG and APAP with BDD are shown in Figure . We have considered
the hydrogen termination of the BDD when considering the DFT calculation.
The result of H-BDD is presented. However, for the case of H-NG, the
H-terminated NG is structurally unstable and turns into sp3-C. Thus, the NG is calculated without any termination. The adsorption
energy (Ead) is calculated by the equation
of Ead = EAPAP + electrode – Eelectrode – EAPAP, where EAPAP + electrode is the total energy of the
combined APAP and electrodes of H-NG-BDD (or BDD), and Eelectrode and EAPAP are the
energy of the electrode and a single APAP molecule, respectively.
The calculated Ead values of APAP molecules
on H-NG-BDD and BDD in Table are −0.220 and −0.115 eV, respectively. It
means that the surface of the H-NG-BDD electrode has a stronger adsorption
capacity for APAP because of the lower Ead. NG is grown on BDD directly, thus the binding force between NG
and BDD is firm. NG has a stronger adsorption to APAP, and the background
current of BDD is low. The better performance of the H-NG-BDD electrode
could be attributed to the synergistic effect of BDD and NG as follows:
the BDD substrate exhibits low background signals; the strong interfacial
force between NG and BDD substrate offers a stable electrode; NG has
stronger adsorption to APAP; and the defective sheets of NG provides
active sites for electrocatalytic APAP.
Figure 8
Crystal structure of
APAP with NG and APAP with BDD. Brown, pink,
red, gray, and green balls represent C, H, O, N, and B, respectively.
Table 3
Calculated Ead of APAP Molecules on NG and BDD
samples
EAPAP + electrode (eV)
Eelectrode (eV)
EAPAP (eV)
Ead (eV)
NG
–1609.97
–1482.27
–127.47
–0.22
BDD
–1712.49
–1584.91
–127.47
–0.12
Crystal structure of
APAP with NG and APAP with BDD. Brown, pink,
red, gray, and green balls represent C, H, O, N, and B, respectively.
Interference Analysis
Dopamine, uric
acid, ascorbic acid, and tryptophan could exist with APAP in biological
samples, and thus interferes with the analysis of detecting APAP important
in practical electrochemical APAP sensors. A total of 10-fold concentration
(85 μM) of dopamine, uric acid, and tryptophan is added in 0.1
M of PBS (pH = 7.4) mixed to APAP with a concentration of 8.5 μM.
It is clear that the H-NG-BDD electrode could distinguish the oxidation
peaks of each interference well (black line in Figure ). The uric acid peak is submerged and cannot
be identified when the concentration of APAP reaches 50 μM (red
line in Figure ).
The results prove that the detection of APAP is evidently distinguished
from the mixtures and without sensitivity to ascorbic acid. From the
DNPV curves, the oxidation peaks of interference with great separation
imply the excellent selectivity of H-NG-BDD and possibility of developing
a sensor with various sensing platforms.
Figure 9
DNPV diagrams of 8.5
μM APAP (black line) and 50 μM
APAP (red line) with the 85 μM concentration of dopamine, uric
acid, ascorbic acid, and tryptophan on the H-NG-BDD electrode.
DNPV diagrams of 8.5
μM APAP (black line) and 50 μM
APAP (red line) with the 85 μM concentration of dopamine, uric
acid, ascorbic acid, and tryptophan on the H-NG-BDD electrode.
Reproducibility and Stability
of the Sensor
The reproducibility of H-NG-BDD is investigated
by CV for 10 repetitive
measurements of 5 μM of APAP. The relative standard deviation
less than 2.3% reveals the excellent reproducibility at the H-NG-BDD
electrode. Furthermore, five H-NG-BDD electrodes prepared under the
same condition were applied for detecting 5 μM of APAP, and
the low relative standard deviation of 3.6% for the current response
suggests a good electrode-to-electrode reproducibility. The stability
of the H-NG-BDD electrode for testing the APAP solution remained for
10 days. After one experiment, the electrode is cleaned by the repeated
cycling of CV and washed by deionized water and then stored in a refrigerator
at 4 °C. For 5 μM APAP, the peak current responses fluctuate
in the region of −2.7 to 3.8% compared to the initial peak
current (Figure S4), revealing the stability
and accuracy of the H-NG-BDD electrode.
Analysis
of Real Samples
The H-NG-BDD
electrode was used to evaluate the performance of commercial drug
samples containing APAP. Two drug tablets were analyzed to determine
the concentration of APAP by DNPV. Tylenol (Johnson Inc., Canada)
and Baifuning (Shanghai Squibb Ltd., China) tablets containing 500
mg of APAP were dissolved in PBS (pH 7.4) first, then filtered through
a cellulose acetate membrane (pore size 0.45 mm; US), and finally
diluted to an appropriate concentration range for an electrochemical
analysis. The measurement results of APAP concentration are shown
in Table . The results
show that the electrode is a promising electrochemical sensor for
the accurate detection of APAP.
Table 4
Measurements of APAP
in Paracetamol
Samples
samples
added (μM)
detected
(μM)
recovery
(%)
RSD (%)
tablet1
10
9.8
98%
1.2
tablet1
20
19.8
99%
3.1
tablet2
30
30.6
102%
2.2
tablet2
40
41.2
103%
2.4
Conclusions
In the present study, we have developed a highly electroactive
H-NG-BDD film by a one-step growing process. The NG grown on the (111)
facets of BDD comes from the reconstruction after boron doping at
a high temperature. The sensor based on H-NG-BDD exhibits a good linear
range from 0.02 to 50 μM for detecting APAP and realizes a low
detection limit of 5 nM. The redox mechanism of APAP on the H-NG-BDD
belongs to a two-electron and two-proton process. Furthermore, the
adsorption between APAP and the H-NG-BDD electrode indicates that
the APAP is easier to be detected according to the theoretical calculation.
The H-NG-BDD sensor shows high selectivity, reproducibility, and stability
for monitoring APAP. The H-NG-BDD electrode would have a very broad
application prospect in the electrochemical analysis of other drugs
and not only limited to APAP.
Methods
Materials
APAP (guaranteed reagent)
was obtained from Sigma-Aldrich. Dopamine, uric acid, and tryptophan
were used of analytical grade from Sigma-Aldrich. NaH2PO4 and Na2HPO4 (analytical grade) were
purchased from Sigma-Aldrich and prepared with water purified by a
Barnstead Ultrapure filtration system. PBS was used as a solvent to
dilute various detected compounds throughout the experiment.
Preparation of the NG-BDD Electrode
First, the mirror-polished
Si substrate was scratched with nanodiamond
powders (10 nm) for 30 min. Second, the substrate was ultrasonicated
with nanodiamond powders in an acetone solution for 90 min to increase
the nucleation points. At last, the Si substrate was cleaned by ultrasonic
treatment with acetone, ethanol, and purified water for 10 min and
dried with nitrogen. The NG-BDD films were produced on the treated
Si wafers by microwave plasma CVD at 2.45 GHz. CH4/H2 flow rates were 2/150 sccm, and the liquid B(OCH3)3 (incorporated boron source) at room temperature was
carried by bubbling H2 gas of which flow rates were 2 sccm.
The NG-BDD films were deposited for 6 h with a thickness of 5 μm
at a pressure of 8.8 kPa at the temperature between 950 and 1050 °C.
Characteristic Apparatus
A scanning
electron microscope (SEM, JSM-6480LV) was used to characterize the
surface morphologies of the NG-BDD films. The analysis of the XPS
was performed using a VG ESCALAB MK II with a monochromated Al Kα
source. The crystal structure of the products was characterized by
XRD (Rigaku D/Max-Ra) using Cu Kα radiation at a wavelength
of 1.5418 Å. The structure of the NG-BDD electrodes was obtained
by Raman spectroscopy (Renishaw in Via Raman microscope equipped with
514 nm laser excitation).
Electrochemical Measurements
In a
three-electrode system, platinum wire, saturated calomel electrode,
and NG-BDD electrodes were served as the counter, reference, and working
electrodes, respectively. The area of the NG-BDD electrode was 0.10
cm2. The EIS texts were measured in a solution containing
5 mM Fe(CN)63–/4– and 0.1 M KCl.
The electrochemical measurements carried out in a PBS of NG-BDD electrodes
were investigated by using CV and DNPV using an electrochemical workstation
(CHI 760E) at room temperature.
Calculation
Methods
DFT-based Vienna
Ab initio Simulation Package code[49] was
used for investigating the interaction between an APAP molecule and
BDD (or NG). The Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof of generalized
gradient approximation[50] was chosen for
the exchange-correlation functional. A kinetic cut-off energy of 400
eV and Monkhorst-Pack k-meshes with a grid spacing of 2π ×
0.2 Å–1 were adopted to ensure the energy convergence.
The 4 × 4 supercells were used.
Authors: Michael Doherty; Chris Hawkey; Michael Goulder; Iain Gibb; Nicola Hill; Sue Aspley; Sandie Reader Journal: Ann Rheum Dis Date: 2011-09 Impact factor: 19.103