Literature DB >> 33715618

Response to 'Systematic reviews do not always capture context of real-world intervention programmes for childhood obesity' by Wild et al., 2021 in BMC Public Health.

Robyn Littlewood1,2, Oliver J Canfell3,4,5, Jacqueline L Walker6.   

Abstract

In a correspondence to BMC Public Health, Wild et al. respond to our systematic review that synthesised results of interventions to prevent or treat childhood obesity in Māori and Pacific Islanders. Our review included the Whānau Pakari study as one of six included studies - a multidisciplinary intervention for Māori children and adolescents living with obesity led by their research team. Our review suggested that future research can incorporate stronger co-design principles when designing culturally-tailored interventions to maximise cultural specificity, enhance engagement, facilitate program ownership and contribute to improved health and weight-related outcomes. We commend Whānau Pakari and the team of Wild et al. on their sustained commitment to addressing obesity in priority populations and agree that systematic reviews struggle to capture real-world context of interventions for complex diseases such as obesity. In this article, we respond sequentially to the comments made by Wild et al. and (1) clarify the scope of our review article (2) reiterate our commendation of mixed-methods approaches that capture real-world context (3) explain a referencing error that caused a misinterpretation of our results (4) clarify our interpretation of some Whānau Pakari characteristics (5) welcome partnership to facilitate shared learning with Wild et al.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Adolescent; Child; Intervention; Obesity; Oceanic ancestry group; Systematic review

Year:  2021        PMID: 33715618      PMCID: PMC7958423          DOI: 10.1186/s12889-021-10487-4

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  BMC Public Health        ISSN: 1471-2458            Impact factor:   3.295


  9 in total

1.  Feasibility of an after-school group-based exercise and lifestyle programme to improve cardiorespiratory fitness and health in less-active Pacific and Maori adolescents.

Authors:  Yongchie Chansavang; C Raina Elley; Brighid McCaffrey; Chloe Davidson; Ofa Dewes; Lance Dalleck
Journal:  J Prim Health Care       Date:  2015-03-01

2.  A Novel Home-Based Intervention for Child and Adolescent Obesity: The Results of the Whānau Pakari Randomized Controlled Trial.

Authors:  Yvonne C Anderson; Lisa E Wynter; Cameron C Grant; Tami L Cave; José G B Derraik; Wayne S Cutfield; Paul L Hofman
Journal:  Obesity (Silver Spring)       Date:  2017-10-19       Impact factor: 5.002

3.  Getting the balance right: qualitative evaluation of a holistic weight management intervention to address childhood obesity.

Authors:  S Visram; T D Hall; L Geddes
Journal:  J Public Health (Oxf)       Date:  2012-09-11       Impact factor: 2.341

4.  Healthier Together: Co-design of a culturally tailored childhood obesity community prevention program for Māori & Pacific Islander children and families.

Authors:  Jessica Hardt; Oliver J Canfell; Jacqueline L Walker; Kerri-Lyn Webb; Sebastien Brignano; Tevita Peu; Daphne Santos; Kirstine Kira; Robyn Littlewood
Journal:  Health Promot J Austr       Date:  2020-12-14

5.  Interventions to increase physical activity in children 0-5 years old: a systematic review, meta-analysis and realist synthesis.

Authors:  J A Hnatiuk; H E Brown; K L Downing; T Hinkley; J Salmon; K D Hesketh
Journal:  Obes Rev       Date:  2018-09-26       Impact factor: 9.213

6.  The effect of a multi-disciplinary obesity intervention compared to usual practice in those ready to make lifestyle changes: design and rationale of Whanau Pakari.

Authors:  Yvonne C Anderson; Lisa E Wynter; Kris R Moller; Tami L Cave; Gerard M S Dolan; Cameron C Grant; Joanna M Stewart; Wayne S Cutfield; Paul L Hofman
Journal:  BMC Obes       Date:  2015-10-08

Review 7.  Effectiveness of Family-Based Behavior Change Interventions on Obesity-Related Behavior Change in Children: A Realist Synthesis.

Authors:  Gemma Enright; Margaret Allman-Farinelli; Julie Redfern
Journal:  Int J Environ Res Public Health       Date:  2020-06-08       Impact factor: 3.390

8.  Interventions to prevent or treat childhood obesity in Māori & Pacific Islanders: a systematic review.

Authors:  Robyn Littlewood; Oliver J Canfell; Jacqueline L Walker
Journal:  BMC Public Health       Date:  2020-05-19       Impact factor: 3.295

Review 9.  Research co-design in health: a rapid overview of reviews.

Authors:  Peter Slattery; Alexander K Saeri; Peter Bragge
Journal:  Health Res Policy Syst       Date:  2020-02-11
  9 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.