K N Subramanyam1, P Khanchandani2, A V Mundargi2, M Suneelkumar2, R Reddy2. 1. Department of Orthopaedics, Sri Sathya Sai Institute of Higher Medical Sciences, Prashanthigram, Puttaparthi, Andhra Pradesh, 515134, India. drkoushik@hotmail.com. 2. Department of Orthopaedics, Sri Sathya Sai Institute of Higher Medical Sciences, Prashanthigram, Puttaparthi, Andhra Pradesh, 515134, India.
Abstract
PURPOSE: The aims of this study were to compare radiological and functional outcomes of Ilizarov ligamentotaxis and locked volar plating in comminuted intra-articular distal radius fractures (AO type C2/C3) using a non-randomised superiority trial. METHODS: A total of 72 patients with AO C2/C3 distal radius fractures were allotted into Ilizarov ligamentotaxis (n = 30) and locked volar plating (n = 42) groups based on patient preference. Primary outcome was the ability to achieve and stably maintain acceptable radiological parameters (post-operative, 6 weeks, 3 months, 12 months), and secondary outcome was functional scoring (at 12 months). RESULTS: All patients completed the study. All fractures united uneventfully. Plating was superior to Ilizarov in restoring ulnar variance (100% versus 80%, p value 0.004), but Ilizarov was superior to plating in restoring volar tilt (as opposed to neutral tilt, 83.3% versus 47.8%, p value 0.002). Both groups were comparable in restoring radial height, radial inclination and intra-articular reduction and stably maintaining all five parameters over long term. There was a statistically significant difference between the two groups with regard to mean ulnar variance (plating superior) and volar tilt (Ilizarov superior) at all stages of follow-up, whereas radial height and radial inclination were comparable at all points. There was no significant change of all radiological parameters over a follow-up period. At the end of one year, DASH score was slightly better (not clinically appreciable) in the Ilizarov group (8.47 versus 13.61, p value 0.03), but Gartland and Werley scores were comparable between both groups. Mean duration of external fixation in the Ilizarov group was 43.07 ± 8.94 days. Apart from five cases of pin site infections, there were no complications. CONCLUSION: Ilizarov ligamentotaxis is a comparable option to locked volar plating in achieving radiological restoration and clinical function in comminuted intra-articular distal radius fractures, AO types C2 and C3. Restoration of ulnar variance needs utmost care while performing Ilizarov ligamentotaxis. Ilizarov comes with the disadvantages of reduced patient preference, pin site infections, need for removal of external fixator and slightly slower return to activity. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: CTRI/2018/08/015549 LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, Non-randomised prospective trial.
PURPOSE: The aims of this study were to compare radiological and functional outcomes of Ilizarov ligamentotaxis and locked volar plating in comminuted intra-articular distal radius fractures (AO type C2/C3) using a non-randomised superiority trial. METHODS: A total of 72 patients with AO C2/C3 distal radius fractures were allotted into Ilizarov ligamentotaxis (n = 30) and locked volar plating (n = 42) groups based on patient preference. Primary outcome was the ability to achieve and stably maintain acceptable radiological parameters (post-operative, 6 weeks, 3 months, 12 months), and secondary outcome was functional scoring (at 12 months). RESULTS: All patients completed the study. All fractures united uneventfully. Plating was superior to Ilizarov in restoring ulnar variance (100% versus 80%, p value 0.004), but Ilizarov was superior to plating in restoring volar tilt (as opposed to neutral tilt, 83.3% versus 47.8%, p value 0.002). Both groups were comparable in restoring radial height, radial inclination and intra-articular reduction and stably maintaining all five parameters over long term. There was a statistically significant difference between the two groups with regard to mean ulnar variance (plating superior) and volar tilt (Ilizarov superior) at all stages of follow-up, whereas radial height and radial inclination were comparable at all points. There was no significant change of all radiological parameters over a follow-up period. At the end of one year, DASH score was slightly better (not clinically appreciable) in the Ilizarov group (8.47 versus 13.61, p value 0.03), but Gartland and Werley scores were comparable between both groups. Mean duration of external fixation in the Ilizarov group was 43.07 ± 8.94 days. Apart from five cases of pin site infections, there were no complications. CONCLUSION: Ilizarov ligamentotaxis is a comparable option to locked volar plating in achieving radiological restoration and clinical function in comminuted intra-articular distal radius fractures, AO types C2 and C3. Restoration of ulnar variance needs utmost care while performing Ilizarov ligamentotaxis. Ilizarov comes with the disadvantages of reduced patient preference, pin site infections, need for removal of external fixator and slightly slower return to activity. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: CTRI/2018/08/015549 LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, Non-randomised prospective trial.
Authors: R A Rogachefsky; S R Lipson; B Applegate; E A Ouellette; A M Savenor; J A McAuliffe Journal: J Bone Joint Surg Am Date: 2001-04 Impact factor: 5.284
Authors: S Pechlaner; A Kathrein; M Gabl; M Lutz; P Angermann; R Zimmermann; R Peer; S Peer; M Rieger; M Freund; A Rudisch Journal: Handchir Mikrochir Plast Chir Date: 2002-05 Impact factor: 1.018