Jessica G Fried1, Jina Pakpoor2, Charles E Kahn3, Hanna M Zafar4. 1. Department of Radiology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan. Electronic address: jefried@med.umich.edu. 2. Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. 3. Vice Chair, Department of Radiology and Vice Chair of Informatics, Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. 4. Co-director, Automated Radiology Recommendation Tracking Engine; Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The Protecting Access to Medicare Act of 2014 requires clinicians to consult Appropriate Use Criteria (AUC) when ordering advanced imaging procedures. Free-text order indications are available when there is no applicable structured indication but are unscored by the AUC. We determined the proportion of free-text indications among all advanced imaging orders and the proportion of free-text indications that could be mapped to a single structured indication. METHODS: All outpatient advanced diagnostic imaging orders placed in a large multisite health system were recorded after initial AUC deployment (November 20, 2017, to December 19, 2017). Clinicians were prompted upon order entry to select a structured indication or enter a free-text indication. We manually reviewed the two imaging examinations with the highest rate of free-text indications: enhanced CT abdomen/pelvis and unenhanced CT head. Regression analysis examined differences in patient-, imaging-, context-, and provider-level characteristics between scored and unscored examinations. RESULTS: Among all 39,533 orders for advanced imaging procedures, 59% (23,267 of 39,533) were unscored by the system. The regression model c-statistic (0.50-0.55) demonstrated poor model fit to evaluate for differences between scored and unscored examinations. Free-text indications were found in 71% (16,440 of 23,267) of unscored examinations and 42% (16,440 of 39,533) of all examinations. Manual review of all 1,693 CT abdomen/pelvis and 1,527 CT head examinations with free-text indications revealed that 3,132 free-text indications (97%) could be mapped to a single existing structured indication. DISCUSSION: Of all initially placed outpatient advanced imaging procedure orders, 42% included free-text indications and 97% of manually reviewed free-text indications could be mapped to a single structured indication.
OBJECTIVE: The Protecting Access to Medicare Act of 2014 requires clinicians to consult Appropriate Use Criteria (AUC) when ordering advanced imaging procedures. Free-text order indications are available when there is no applicable structured indication but are unscored by the AUC. We determined the proportion of free-text indications among all advanced imaging orders and the proportion of free-text indications that could be mapped to a single structured indication. METHODS: All outpatient advanced diagnostic imaging orders placed in a large multisite health system were recorded after initial AUC deployment (November 20, 2017, to December 19, 2017). Clinicians were prompted upon order entry to select a structured indication or enter a free-text indication. We manually reviewed the two imaging examinations with the highest rate of free-text indications: enhanced CT abdomen/pelvis and unenhanced CT head. Regression analysis examined differences in patient-, imaging-, context-, and provider-level characteristics between scored and unscored examinations. RESULTS: Among all 39,533 orders for advanced imaging procedures, 59% (23,267 of 39,533) were unscored by the system. The regression model c-statistic (0.50-0.55) demonstrated poor model fit to evaluate for differences between scored and unscored examinations. Free-text indications were found in 71% (16,440 of 23,267) of unscored examinations and 42% (16,440 of 39,533) of all examinations. Manual review of all 1,693 CT abdomen/pelvis and 1,527 CT head examinations with free-text indications revealed that 3,132 free-text indications (97%) could be mapped to a single existing structured indication. DISCUSSION: Of all initially placed outpatient advanced imaging procedure orders, 42% included free-text indications and 97% of manually reviewed free-text indications could be mapped to a single structured indication.
Authors: Vartan M Vartanians; Christopher L Sistrom; Jeffrey B Weilburg; Daniel I Rosenthal; James H Thrall Journal: Radiology Date: 2010-06 Impact factor: 11.105
Authors: Ali S Raja; Sarvenaz Pourjabbar; Ivan K Ip; Christopher W Baugh; Aaron D Sodickson; Michael O'Leary; Ramin Khorasani Journal: AJR Am J Roentgenol Date: 2018-11-07 Impact factor: 3.959
Authors: Justin W Timbie; Peter S Hussey; Lane F Burgette; Neil S Wenger; Afshin Rastegar; Ian Brantley; Dmitry Khodyakov; Kristin J Leuschner; Beverly A Weidmer; Katherine L Kahn Journal: Rand Health Q Date: 2015-07-15