Noam B Teyssier1, Anna Chen1, Elias M Duarte1, Rene Sit2, Bryan Greenhouse3,4, Sofonias K Tessema3. 1. Department of Medicine, EPPIcenter, University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA. 2. Chan Zuckerberg Biohub, San Francisco, CA, USA. 3. Department of Medicine, EPPIcenter, University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA. sofoniask.tessema@ucsf.edu. 4. Chan Zuckerberg Biohub, San Francisco, CA, USA. sofoniask.tessema@ucsf.edu.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Whole-genome sequencing (WGS) is becoming increasingly useful to study the biology, epidemiology, and ecology of malaria parasites. Despite ease of sampling, DNA extracted from dried blood spots (DBS) has a high ratio of human DNA compared to parasite DNA, which poses a challenge for downstream genetic analyses. The effects of multiple methods for DNA extraction, digestion of methylated DNA, and amplification were evaluated on the quality and fidelity of WGS data recovered from DBS. METHODS: Low parasite density mock DBS samples were created, extracted either with Tween-Chelex or QIAamp, treated with or without McrBC, and amplified with one of three different amplification techniques (two sWGA primer sets and one rWGA). Extraction conditions were evaluated on performance of sequencing depth, percentiles of coverage, and expected SNP concordance. RESULTS: At 100 parasites/μL, Chelex-Tween-McrBC samples had higher coverage (5 × depth = 93% genome) than QIAamp extracted samples (5 × depth = 76% genome). The two evaluated sWGA primer sets showed minor differences in overall genome coverage and SNP concordance, with a newly proposed combination of 20 primers showing a modest improvement in coverage over those previously published. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, Tween-Chelex extracted samples that were treated with McrBC digestion and are amplified using 6A10AD sWGA conditions had minimal dropout rate, higher percentages of coverage at higher depth, and more accurate SNP concordance than QiaAMP extracted samples. These findings extend the results of previously reported methods, making whole genome sequencing accessible to a larger number of low density samples that are commonly encountered in cross-sectional surveys.
BACKGROUND: Whole-genome sequencing (WGS) is becoming increasingly useful to study the biology, epidemiology, and ecology of malaria parasites. Despite ease of sampling, DNA extracted from dried blood spots (DBS) has a high ratio of human DNA compared to parasite DNA, which poses a challenge for downstream genetic analyses. The effects of multiple methods for DNA extraction, digestion of methylated DNA, and amplification were evaluated on the quality and fidelity of WGS data recovered from DBS. METHODS: Low parasite density mock DBS samples were created, extracted either with Tween-Chelex or QIAamp, treated with or without McrBC, and amplified with one of three different amplification techniques (two sWGA primer sets and one rWGA). Extraction conditions were evaluated on performance of sequencing depth, percentiles of coverage, and expected SNP concordance. RESULTS: At 100 parasites/μL, Chelex-Tween-McrBC samples had higher coverage (5 × depth = 93% genome) than QIAamp extracted samples (5 × depth = 76% genome). The two evaluated sWGA primer sets showed minor differences in overall genome coverage and SNP concordance, with a newly proposed combination of 20 primers showing a modest improvement in coverage over those previously published. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, Tween-Chelex extracted samples that were treated with McrBC digestion and are amplified using 6A10AD sWGA conditions had minimal dropout rate, higher percentages of coverage at higher depth, and more accurate SNP concordance than QiaAMP extracted samples. These findings extend the results of previously reported methods, making whole genome sequencing accessible to a larger number of low density samples that are commonly encountered in cross-sectional surveys.
Authors: Stephanie Marciniak; Tracy L Prowse; D Ann Herring; Jennifer Klunk; Melanie Kuch; Ana T Duggan; Luca Bondioli; Edward C Holmes; Hendrik N Poinar Journal: Curr Biol Date: 2016-12-05 Impact factor: 10.834
Authors: Geraldine A Van der Auwera; Mauricio O Carneiro; Christopher Hartl; Ryan Poplin; Guillermo Del Angel; Ami Levy-Moonshine; Tadeusz Jordan; Khalid Shakir; David Roazen; Joel Thibault; Eric Banks; Kiran V Garimella; David Altshuler; Stacey Gabriel; Mark A DePristo Journal: Curr Protoc Bioinformatics Date: 2013
Authors: Sarah Auburn; Susana Campino; Taane G Clark; Abdoulaye A Djimde; Issaka Zongo; Robert Pinches; Magnus Manske; Valentina Mangano; Daniel Alcock; Elisa Anastasi; Gareth Maslen; Bronwyn Macinnis; Kirk Rockett; David Modiano; Christopher I Newbold; Ogobara K Doumbo; Jean Bosco Ouédraogo; Dominic P Kwiatkowski Journal: PLoS One Date: 2011-07-18 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Samuel O Oyola; Cristina V Ariani; William L Hamilton; Mihir Kekre; Lucas N Amenga-Etego; Anita Ghansah; Gavin G Rutledge; Seth Redmond; Magnus Manske; Dushyanth Jyothi; Chris G Jacob; Thomas D Otto; Kirk Rockett; Chris I Newbold; Matthew Berriman; Dominic P Kwiatkowski Journal: Malar J Date: 2016-12-20 Impact factor: 2.979
Authors: Annie N Cowell; Dorothy E Loy; Sesh A Sundararaman; Hugo Valdivia; Kathleen Fisch; Andres G Lescano; G Christian Baldeviano; Salomon Durand; Vince Gerbasi; Colin J Sutherland; Debbie Nolder; Joseph M Vinetz; Beatrice H Hahn; Elizabeth A Winzeler Journal: mBio Date: 2017-02-07 Impact factor: 7.867
Authors: Ernest Diez Benavente; Ana Rita Gomes; Jeremy Ryan De Silva; Matthew Grigg; Harriet Walker; Bridget E Barber; Timothy William; Tsin Wen Yeo; Paola Florez de Sessions; Abhinay Ramaprasad; Amy Ibrahim; James Charleston; Martin L Hibberd; Arnab Pain; Robert W Moon; Sarah Auburn; Lau Yee Ling; Nicholas M Anstey; Taane G Clark; Susana Campino Journal: Sci Rep Date: 2019-07-08 Impact factor: 4.379
Authors: Samuel O Oyola; Yong Gu; Magnus Manske; Thomas D Otto; John O'Brien; Daniel Alcock; Bronwyn Macinnis; Matthew Berriman; Chris I Newbold; Dominic P Kwiatkowski; Harold P Swerdlow; Michael A Quail Journal: J Clin Microbiol Date: 2012-12-05 Impact factor: 5.948
Authors: Zalak Shah; Matthew Adams; Kara A Moser; Biraj Shrestha; Emily M Stucke; Miriam K Laufer; David Serre; Joana C Silva; Shannon Takala-Harrison Journal: Malar J Date: 2020-03-30 Impact factor: 2.979
Authors: Sofonias K Tessema; Nicholas J Hathaway; Noam B Teyssier; Maxwell Murphy; Anna Chen; Ozkan Aydemir; Elias M Duarte; Wilson Simone; James Colborn; Francisco Saute; Emily Crawford; Pedro Aide; Jeffrey A Bailey; Bryan Greenhouse Journal: J Infect Dis Date: 2022-04-01 Impact factor: 5.226