Comparative Study of Lamina Cribrosa Thickness Between Primary Angle-Closure and Primary Open-Angle Glaucoma.

PURPOSE: To compare lamina cribrosa thickness (LCT) of primary angle-closure glaucoma (PACG) and primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) using the enhanced depth-imaging mode of the Heidelberg Spectralis spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (EDI-OCT). PATIENTS AND METHODS: A comparative cross-sectional study was conducted. We enrolled 34 patients with PACG, 38 with POAG, and 62 controls, testing only one eye of each participant. Lamina cribrosa thickness was determined at the center of the optic nerve head using EDI-OCT. Nine points of LCT were measured, and LCT averages were analyzed.
RESULTS: Mean age, number of glaucoma medications, current intraocular pressure (IOP), cup to disc ratio, and visual field indices, were not significantly different between PACG and POAG eyes. The maximum IOP (SD) was higher in PACG than in POAG, at 32.5 (10.46) vs 25.05 (6.42) mmHg (p = 0.001), and LCTs were significantly different among the PACG, POAG and control groups. Mean (SD) LCTs were 226.99 (31.08), 257.17 (19.46), and 290.75 (28.02) μm, respectively (p < 0.001). Lamina cribrosa thickness was correlated with mean deviation of the visual field (p = 0.001; correlation coefficient, rs = 0.347), while it was inversely correlated with maximum IOP (p < 0.001; correlation coefficient, rs = -0.592). Linear regression analysis revealed that LCT was inversely related to age (p = 0.008), female (p = 0.018), and maximum IOP (p = 0.002). LCT was marginally related to visual field MD (p = 0.053).
CONCLUSION: Glaucomatous eyes had thinner LCT than controls, and maximum IOP was inversely correlated to the LCT. PACG eyes had higher maximum IOP and thinner LCT than POAG ones. In living eye, EDI-OCT emphasizes the pressure-dependent mechanism of glaucoma on lamina cribrosa deformation and the higher IOP-loaded stress which leads to a greater lamina cribrosa strain.

Introduction

Lamina cribrosa assessment has recently become a field of interest, as it can be visualized in vivo with spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT).1,2 Spaide et al3 developed an Enhanced Depth Imaging (EDI) technique using SD-OCT (EDI-OCT) to visualize deeper retinal structures, such as the choroid and the lamina cribrosa. An EDI-OCT increases the visibility of the anterior and posterior lamina cribrosa surface in non-human primates compared to the conventional SD-OCT technique,4 and can therefore be used to measure lamina cribrosa thickness (LCT).

Primary angle-closure glaucoma (PACG) is one of the leading causes of blindness worldwide,5 and its prevalence is highest in Asia.6 A relatively small eye with a crowded anterior chamber leads to irido-trabecular apposition and IOP elevation. Optic nerve head and retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) changes in PACG have been studied using imaging technologies such as the Heidelberg retina tomograph (HRT),7,8 scanning laser polarimetry9 and OCT.10

Studies of lamina cribrosa in PACG are sparse. We conducted a comparative study of LCT in primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) and primary PACG. This research explored thickness differences in lamina cribrosa and factors related to LCT in these two types of glaucoma.

Methods

A comparative cross-sectional study design was employed to investigate LCT in PACG and POAG patients and in healthy controls. The study was performed with the informed consent of the participants and followed all of the guidelines for experimental investigation using human subjects required by the Ethics Committee (EC) of Rajavithi Hospital. All investigations were carried out in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki. The study protocol was approved by EC in December 2012. All participants were recruited from the Department of Ophthalmology, Rajavithi Hospital, between January and October 2013.

Participants were ≥50 years of age with a best-corrected visual acuity of ≥20/63. POAG was defined as the presence of glaucomatous optic disc (diffuse or focal thinning of the neuro-retinal rim) and an abnormal visual field consistent with glaucoma. IOP was >21 mmHg and showed an open angle when applying gonioscopy. PACG was defined as an eye that had at least 180 degrees of iridotrabecular contact or peripheral anterior synechiae (PAS) with elevated IOP, with glaucomatous optic disc and/or visual field defect. Acute PACG (APACG) was defined as PACG eye that had eye pain, halo, nausea/vomiting, corneal edema, and IOP > 21 mmHg. Patients who had the previous history of APACG were also eligible only when the optical media was clear for OCT scanning. Maximum IOP was defined as the highest IOP-recorded from our hospital database or from referral document. The control group consisted of those having an IOP of between 10 and 21 mmHg with no history of increased IOP, normal anterior chamber angle, an absence of glaucomatous disc appearance, and no visible retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) defect. Eyes after cataract surgery or peripheral iridotomy were eligible.

Exclusion criteria were intraocular or neurologic diseases that cause visual field loss. Cases of unreliable visual field (false negative ≥25%; false positive ≥25%; fixation losses ≥20%) and poor quality of EDI-OCT scanning (<20) were excluded. Glaucoma patients that had undergone glaucoma surgery (eg, filtering surgery, goniosynechialysis, trabeculotomy, goniotomy) were also excluded.

Ophthalmologic assessment included best-corrected visual acuity, slit-lamp biomicroscopy, Goldmann applanation tonometry, gonioscopy, axial length (IOL Master, Carl Zeiss-Meditec, Dublin, CA), central corneal thickness (CCT, Corneo-Gage Plus, Sonogage Inc., Cleveland, OH), dilated stereoscopic examination of the ONH and fundus, color disc photography, and standard automated perimetry using the 24–2 Swedish Interactive Threshold Algorithm standard program (Humphrey Visual Field Analyzer, Carl Zeiss-Meditec, Dublin, CA). An EDI-OCT using Heidelberg Spectralis OCT (Heidelberg Engineering, Heidelberg, Germany) was performed, and only one eye of each participant was analyzed.

Enhanced Depth-Imaging Spectral-Domain Optical Coherence Tomography of the Optic Nerve Head and Lamina Cribrosa Thickness Measurement

OCT B-scans of the ONH were obtained using an EDI-OCT of Heidelberg Spectralis OCT, with a 20-degree retinal window. The center of ONH was identified using a horizontal cross-sectional B-scan. The EDI mode enhanced the visualization of lamina cribrosa beneath the optic disc cup. We defined LCT as the distance between the anterior and posterior borders of the high reflective region. The image was enlarged to 1:1 pixels with the Spectralis OCT program to line up the lamina cribrosa borders. Each anterior and posterior border, which was not in a straight line, was marked with 9 points. LCT was measured by one of us (A.K.), using horizontal cross-sectional B-scan for 9 points (equally distanced) at the central plane of ONH (Figure 1). Intra-observer and inter-observer reproducibility of LCT measurements were tested in 20 cases, revealing kappa of 0.77 and 0.74, respectively. An analysis of the average LCT was performed, and Bruch’s membrane openings (BMO) were marked and measured at the horizontal scan of the lamina cribosa.

Figure 1

Lamina cribrosa thicknesses of different groups imaged by EDI mode of Heidelberg Spectralis SD-OCT using the horizontal cross-sectional B-scan, which ran through the center of the ONH.

Statistical Analysis

Statistical analysis was performed with SPSS software (version 16.0.0; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). Normal distribution was detected using Shapiro–Wilk test. A test of variance for normal distributed data was achieved with Levene’s test, and independent Student t-tests and one-way ANOVA with Bonferonni correction were used to compare the data between and among the groups for normally distributed data. Kruskal–Wallis and Mann–Whitney-U test were applied to compare the data between and among the groups for abnormally distributed data, and the level of statistical significance was set at p < 0.05. The relationships between LCT and the characteristic factors including IOP and visual field indices were applied using Spearman correlations and linear regression analysis.

Results

Subject Baseline Characteristics

Spectralis OCT with EDI techniques were obtained for 64 controls and 77 patients with glaucoma. We excluded seven patients from this study because of poor EDI-OCT scanning quality, which the lamina borders could not be visualized clearly. A total of 62 controls and 72 glaucoma (38 POAG, and 34 PACG) were analyzed. Baseline characteristics are summarized in Table 1. Mean age was not different among the three groups (p = 0.859), nor between the POAG and PACG groups (p = 0.755). The percentages of females in the control, POAG, and PACG groups were 72.58%, 50% and 67.65%, respectively. The current IOP, maximum IOP, vertical cup-to-disc ratio (C/D), BMO, axial length, CCT, mean deviation (MD), and pattern standard deviation (PSD) of the visual field were significantly different between glaucoma and controls (p ≤ 0.016) while the number of medications, current IOP, C/D, MD, and PSD were not different between POAG and PACG groups (p = 0.525, p = 0.141, p = 0.510, p = 0.854, p = 0.378, respectively, Mann–Whitney-U test). The maximum IOP differed significantly between POAG and PACG eyes, at 25.05 ± 6.42 mmHg vs 32.50 ± 10.46 mmHg (p = 0.001). POAG had significantly longer axial length than PACG (23.73 ± 1.02 vs 22.89 ± 0.81 mm, p < 0.001), and also a thinner CCT (524.32 ± 35.31 vs 540.33 ± 28.72 μm, p = 0.015). Bruch’s membrane opening in controls was smaller than in glaucoma but was not different between the glaucoma groups.

Table 1

Patient Characteristics of Each Group

	Control (n=62)	POAG (n=38)	PACG (n=34)	P	P
Age (yrs)	64.74±9.48	65.34±9.88	65.88±10.46	0.859* ANOVA	1.000† ANOVA
Sex: N (%)					–
- Male	17 (27.42%)	19 (50%)	11 (32.35%)
- Female	45 (72.58%)	19 (50%)	23 (67.65%)	–
Current IOP (mmHg)	13.82±2.95	16.34±5.53	17.18±4.45	0.000* Kruskal-Wallis	0.141† Mann–Whitney-U-Test
Max IOP (mmHg)	14.76±3.17	25.05±6.42	32.50±10.46	0.000* Kruskal-Wallis	0.001† Mann–Whitney-U-Test
No. of Medication	0.00±0.00	1.55±0.98	1.79±1.23	0.000* Kruskal-Wallis	0.525† Mann–Whitney-U-Test
C/D ratio	0.41±0.13	0.79±0.11	0.76±0.17	0.000* Kruskal-Wallis	0.510† Mann–Whitney-U-Test
MD (dB)	−1.32±1.49	−13.39±9.24	−13.49±8.54	0.000* Kruskal-Wallis	0.854† Mann–Whitney-U-Test
PSD	2.23±0.84	6.99±3.77	7.69±3.75	0.000* Kruskal-Wallis	0.378† Mann–Whitney-U-Test
AXL (mm)	23.22±0.77	23.73±1.02	22.89±0.81	0.000* ANOVA	0.000† ANOVA
CCT (μm)	540.13±34.41	524.32±35.32	540.33±28.72	0.016* Kruskal-Wallis	0.015† Mann–Whitney-U-Test

Notes: Values are presented as mean ± standard deviation; *Comparison between POAG and controls; †Comparison between PACG and controls.

Abbreviations: POAG, primary open-angle glaucoma; PACG, primary angle-closure glaucoma; IOP, intraocular pressure; C/D, cup to disc ratio; MD, mean deviation of perimetry; PSD, pattern standard deviation; AXL, axial length; CCT, central corneal thickness.

Comparison of Lamina Cribrosa Thickness Among Groups

Mean LCT in controls, POAG, and PACG was 290 ± 28.02 μm, 257.17 ± 19.46 μm and 226.99 ± 31.08 μm, respectively. There was a significant difference among the three groups (p < 0.001) as shown in Table 2. Mean LCT of POAG was significantly thicker than that of PACG (p < 0.001).

Table 2

Lamina Cribrosa Thickness and Bruch’s Membrane Opening Measurement, Obtained with EDI-OCT

	Control (n=62)	POAG (n=38)	PACG (n=34)	P	P
Lamina cribrosa thickness Mean±SD (μm)	290.75±28.02	257.17±19.46	226.99±31.08	0.000*	0.000†
Min-Max	233.89–376.78	219.33–301.33	165.33–302.56
Bruch’s membrane opening Mean±SD (μm)	1550.47±151.41	1680.91±195.46	1599.00±183.59	0.004* ANOVA	0.189† ANOVA

Notes: *Comparison among 3 groups. †Comparison between POAG and PACG.

Abbreviations: POAG, primary open-angle glaucoma; PACG, primary angle-closure glaucoma; SD, standard deviation.

Relationship Between Lamina Cribrosa Thickness and Intraocular Pressure

The relationship between the LCT and the maximum IOP was evaluated using Spearman correlation analysis. The LCT and the maximum IOP were significantly different between the POAG and PACG eyes (Tables 1 and 2), and mean LCT revealed a negative correlation with the maximum IOP (p < 0.001; correlation coefficient, r = −0.592; Figure 2).

Figure 2

Relationship of lamina cribrosa thickness and maximum IOP using Spearman correlation analysis.

Relationship Between Lamina Cribrosa Thickness and Visual Field Mean Deviation

POAG and PACG eyes had a similar visual field MD (−13.39 ± 9.24 vs −13.49 ± 8.54 dB) while Spearman analysis revealed a positive correlation between LCT and MD (p = 0.001; correlation coefficient, r = 0.347; Figure 3).

Figure 3

Relationship of lamina cribrosa thickness and mean deviation of the visual field using Spearman correlation analysis.

Relationship Between Lamina Cribrosa Thickness, Bruch Membrane Opening, and Axial Length

Spearman analysis showed no correlation between LCT and BMO, (p = 0.803, r = −0.023), LCT and AL (p = 0.713, r = 0.32).

Linear regression analysis revealed that LCT was inversely related to age (p = 0.008), female (p = 0.018), and maximum IOP (p = 0.002). LCT was marginal related to visual field MD (p = 0.053).

Discussion

In the present study, EDI-OCT showed that lamina cribrosa in glaucomatous eyes was thinner than in controls. This is a posterior portion of the sclera at the optic nerve head (ONH), composed of connective tissues and elastic fibers,11 which provides the main support for the optic nerve axons when exiting the eye. The lamina cribrosa helps to maintain the pressure gradient among IOP, cerebrospinal pressure, and the surrounding tissue.12 Structural changes in the lamina cribrosa have been thought to cause early damage when glaucomatous optic neuropathy is diagnosed.11,13 Increased IOP can cause posterior displacement of the lamina,14 leading to optic nerve axon damage. Clinically, an enlarged ONH cup is a typical sign of lamina change. In addition, axoplasmic blockage by lamina distortion can cause retinal ganglion cell damage and ONH changes.

Lamina cribrosa structures have been studied in animal15 or enucleated eyes.12,14,16 Histomorphometric investigations reveal that the lamina thickness is significantly lower in eyes with advanced glaucomatous optic nerve damage than in non-glaucomatous eyes. EDI-OCT can be applied for evaluation of the LCT in living eyes and for monitoring LCT in follow-up periods.

In the present study, both groups had advanced-stage glaucoma, with an MD of −13 dB. LCT had an inverse correlation with maximum IOP, which was higher in PACG than in POAG (32 mmHg vs 25 mmHg). PACG eyes had higher IOP stress on lamina cribrosa than POAG, leading to a more severe strain of lamina deformation and thinner LCT.17

Intraocular pressure is an important risk factor for glaucoma damage and progression.18–21 In an experiment with ex vivo porcine eyes using SD-OCT, Fatehee et al22 reported that LCT decreased after acute IOP elevation, and the higher the IOP, the thinner was the lamina thickness. In our study, some cases of PACG had a history of a previous acute attack. The peak IOP destroyed the connective tissue around the ONH, and the lamina cribrosa subsequently thinned. The dose-response of IOP and glaucomatous damage is commonly presented in clinical studies. Gazzard et al23 reported a relationship between IOP and visual field loss in PACG and POAG. They found that pre-treated IOP was higher in PACG patients than in POAG patients, and that visual field defect was also worse in PACG. De Moraes et al24 found that the peak IOP, rather than the fluctuation of IOP and mean IOP, was the strongest risk factor for visual field damage progression in treated glaucoma patients. A specific threshold for IOP elevation may have to be reached to lead to lamina cribrosa deformation and/or lamina backward movement.

In addition, linear regression analysis showed that LCT was inversely related to female and age. In histologic study, female appears to have thinner LC than male.25 In glaucoma situation, IOP can possibly further damage LC and make it even thinner. Xiao et al reported that lamina thickness in healthy Chinese subjects, aged >60 years old, are thicker than in younger age groups.26 However, in our study, older age had thinner lamina cribosa. The reason for this result remained unclear. We speculated that the thickness of lamina cribosa might not indicate its rigidity. When the IOP is elevated, a thicker lamina beam might be more susceptible to be compressed, leading to thinner lamina cribosa. Future research on the relationship between lamina thickness and rigidity is required to elucidate this issue.

Hao et al reported different outcomes of LCT from those of our study. Chronic PACG (CPACG) patients had thicker LCT than those with POAG.27 These patients with CPACG had no history of acute attack previously. Both glaucoma groups had the same IOP level, at about 19 mmHg, and their visual field mean deviations were not significantly different (−10.5 vs 13 dB). The discrepancy in the results of these two studies may relate to IOP levels; we included patients with a history of acute attack, and their maximum IOP was higher than in the research by Hao et al Their study debated whether optic disc size in CPACG might be smaller than in POAG, but they did not measure the BMO. Our study showed no difference in BMO between PACG and POAG eyes.

Korean POAG patients were found to have thinner lamina than Thai POAG counterparts, while the mean severity of visual field damage in Thai patients was more advanced (−13.39 dB in Thai vs −6.58 dB in Korean).28 These differences might relate to differences in ethnicity, but different techniques were used to measure the LCT. The Korean study measured 3 points of the laminae,16 while we examined 9. They reported that LCT in normal-tension glaucoma (NTG) was thinner than in POAG.28 Their findings conflict with our observation that LCT was inversely correlated with IOP; however, NTG may have another pathophysiology, rather than IOP.29 We speculated that pre-existing thin lamina cribrosa might be susceptible to such low IOP in NTG, and a prospective study of LCT and glaucoma incidence should be conducted to elucidate this issue.

Among Asian controls, LCTs were different. The LCTs of Koreans, Thais, and Chinese were 348, 290, and 202 μm, respectively. These differences could be related to the measurement techniques; as yet, there is no standard protocol for LCT measurement. We found that the LCT, determined by EDI-OCT, was not a uniform structure; in particular, the posterior border had an irregular pattern (Figure 1). We measured the lamina at 9 points at equal distances from border to border at the central plane of the ONH, but we could not measure the entire lamina cribrosa due partly to the shadows of blood vessels. However, enhancing the contrast of SD-OCT images improved the visibility of the posterior lamina boundary. This method is similar to that used in the study by Jonas et al,30 which measured the thickness in the center of the optic disc, at the optic disc borders, and in the intermediary positions between the center and borders of the ONH. These different techniques demonstrate that LCT measurement is still inconsistent; therefore, automated software as used in choroidal thickness measurement31 to identify the anterior and posterior border of lamina cribrosa and for the lamina thickness measurement would be useful in decreasing intra- and inter-observer errors when using different techniques.

Bruch’s membrane opening, indicating the optic disc margin of the ONH, was larger in the glaucoma groups than in controls. This finding might be the cause and/or effect of IOP-related stress and strain on the lamina cribrosa and the scleral canal wall. Pre-existing large ONH, eg, in African-descent optic disc, is predisposed to glaucomatous damage.32 Large ONH, for instance in myopia, may be associated with low scleral rigidity and might be susceptible to IOP.33 On the other hand, IOP-related stress could distend lamina cribrosa and peripapillary sclera, having an effect on scleral canal wall expansion.17 The BMO would be displaced laterally. In this study, however, the BMO in POAG was not significantly different from that of PACG, and there was no correlation between IOP, LCT and BMO.

Limitations of the present study included the recruitment of patients from a referral tertiary eye care in a cross-sectional manner, so that most of the glaucomatous eyes were at an advanced stage, and we could not speculate about the trend of pre-glaucomatous thickness of lamina cribrosa in POAG and PACG eyes. The maximum IOP data of the individuals were collected from hospital records or referral letters and may not have been correct. Our small sample size might be a source of bias, and we were unable to enroll matched IOP of POAG and PACG patients.

In conclusion, this study supports the use of SD-OCT with EDI mode for detecting lamina cribrosa change. The LCT was significantly thinner in the glaucoma (POAG and PACG) group compared to control eyes, and we found that maximum IOP was inversely correlated to LCT, and PACG had a higher maximum IOP and thinner LCT than POAG. The pressure-dependent mechanism deformed the lamina cribrosa in which the higher IOP-loaded stress led to a greater lamina cribrosa strain.