Amanda Rodrigues1, Claudio J Struchiner2, Lara E Coelho3, Valdilea G Veloso3, Beatriz Grinsztejn3, Paula M Luz4. 1. Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. 2. Escola de Matemática Aplicada, Fundação Getúlio Vargas, Praia de Botafogo, 190, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. 3. Instituto Nacional de Infectologia Evandro Chagas, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Av. Brasil 4365, Manguinhos, Rio de Janeiro, 21040-900, Brazil. 4. Instituto Nacional de Infectologia Evandro Chagas, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Av. Brasil 4365, Manguinhos, Rio de Janeiro, 21040-900, Brazil. luzpaulamendes@gmail.com.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Late antiretroviral treatment initiation for HIV disease worsens health outcomes and contributes to ongoing transmission. We investigated whether socioeconomic inequalities exist in access to treatment in a setting with universal access to care and treatment. METHODS: This study investigated the association of educational level, used as a proxy for socioeconomic status, with late treatment initiation and treatment initiation with advanced disease. Study participants included adults (≥25 years) who started treatment from 2005 to 2018 at Instituto Nacional de Infectologia Evandro Chagas of Fundação Oswaldo Cruz (INI/FIOCRUZ), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Educational level was categorized following UNESCO's International Standard Classification of Education: incomplete basic education, basic education, secondary level, and tertiary level. We defined late treatment initiation as those initiating treatment with a CD4 < 350 cells/mL or an AIDS-defining event, and treatment initiation with advanced disease as those initiating treatment with a CD4 < 200 cells/mL or an AIDS-defining event. A directed acyclic graph (DAG) was constructed to represent the theoretical-operational model and to understand the involvement of covariates. Logistic regression models were used to estimate the adjusted odds ratios (aOR) and 95% confidence intervals (95%CI). Multiple imputation using a chained equations approach was used to treat missing values and non-linear terms for continuous variables were tested. RESULTS: In total, 3226 individuals composed the study population: 876 (27.4%) had incomplete basic education, 540 (16.9%) basic, 1251 (39.2%) secondary level, and 525 (16.4%) tertiary level. Late treatment initiation was observed for 2076 (64.4%) while treatment initiation with advanced disease was observed for 1423 (44.1%). Compared to tertiary level of education, incomplete basic, basic and secondary level increased the odds of late treatment initiation by 89% (aOR:1.89 95%CI:1.47-2.43), 61% (aOR:1.61 95%CI:1.23-2.10), and 35% (aOR:1.35 95%CI:1.09-1.67). Likewise, the odds of treatment initiation with advanced disease was 2.5-fold (aOR:2.53 95%CI:1.97-3.26), 2-fold (aOR:2.07 95%CI:1.59-2.71), 1.5-fold (aOR:1.51 95%CI:1.21-1.88) higher for those with incomplete basic, basic and secondary level education compared to tertiary level. CONCLUSION: Despite universal access to HIV care and antiretroviral treatment, late treatment initiation and social inequalities persist. Lower educational level significantly increased the odds of both outcomes, reinforcing the existence of barriers to "universal" antiretroviral treatment.
BACKGROUND: Late antiretroviral treatment initiation for HIV disease worsens health outcomes and contributes to ongoing transmission. We investigated whether socioeconomic inequalities exist in access to treatment in a setting with universal access to care and treatment. METHODS: This study investigated the association of educational level, used as a proxy for socioeconomic status, with late treatment initiation and treatment initiation with advanced disease. Study participants included adults (≥25 years) who started treatment from 2005 to 2018 at Instituto Nacional de Infectologia Evandro Chagas of Fundação Oswaldo Cruz (INI/FIOCRUZ), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Educational level was categorized following UNESCO's International Standard Classification of Education: incomplete basic education, basic education, secondary level, and tertiary level. We defined late treatment initiation as those initiating treatment with a CD4 < 350 cells/mL or an AIDS-defining event, and treatment initiation with advanced disease as those initiating treatment with a CD4 < 200 cells/mL or an AIDS-defining event. A directed acyclic graph (DAG) was constructed to represent the theoretical-operational model and to understand the involvement of covariates. Logistic regression models were used to estimate the adjusted odds ratios (aOR) and 95% confidence intervals (95%CI). Multiple imputation using a chained equations approach was used to treat missing values and non-linear terms for continuous variables were tested. RESULTS: In total, 3226 individuals composed the study population: 876 (27.4%) had incomplete basic education, 540 (16.9%) basic, 1251 (39.2%) secondary level, and 525 (16.4%) tertiary level. Late treatment initiation was observed for 2076 (64.4%) while treatment initiation with advanced disease was observed for 1423 (44.1%). Compared to tertiary level of education, incomplete basic, basic and secondary level increased the odds of late treatment initiation by 89% (aOR:1.89 95%CI:1.47-2.43), 61% (aOR:1.61 95%CI:1.23-2.10), and 35% (aOR:1.35 95%CI:1.09-1.67). Likewise, the odds of treatment initiation with advanced disease was 2.5-fold (aOR:2.53 95%CI:1.97-3.26), 2-fold (aOR:2.07 95%CI:1.59-2.71), 1.5-fold (aOR:1.51 95%CI:1.21-1.88) higher for those with incomplete basic, basic and secondary level education compared to tertiary level. CONCLUSION: Despite universal access to HIV care and antiretroviral treatment, late treatment initiation and social inequalities persist. Lower educational level significantly increased the odds of both outcomes, reinforcing the existence of barriers to "universal" antiretroviral treatment.
Entities:
Keywords:
ART or antiretroviral therapy; Brazil; HIV; Late treatment initiation; Universal care
Authors: José A Pérez-Molina; Marta Díaz-Menéndez; María N Plana; Javier Zamora; Rogelio López-Vélez; Santiago Moreno Journal: J Antimicrob Chemother Date: 2011-11-29 Impact factor: 5.790
Authors: Carina Cesar; Cathy A Jenkins; Bryan E Shepherd; Denis Padgett; Fernando Mejía; Sayonara Rocha Ribeiro; Claudia P Cortes; Jean W Pape; Juan Sierra Madero; Valeria Fink; Omar Sued; Catherine McGowan; Pedro Cahn Journal: Lancet HIV Date: 2015-10-22 Impact factor: 12.767
Authors: Mari M Kitahata; Stephen J Gange; Alison G Abraham; Barry Merriman; Michael S Saag; Amy C Justice; Robert S Hogg; Steven G Deeks; Joseph J Eron; John T Brooks; Sean B Rourke; M John Gill; Ronald J Bosch; Jeffrey N Martin; Marina B Klein; Lisa P Jacobson; Benigno Rodriguez; Timothy R Sterling; Gregory D Kirk; Sonia Napravnik; Anita R Rachlis; Liviana M Calzavara; Michael A Horberg; Michael J Silverberg; Kelly A Gebo; James J Goedert; Constance A Benson; Ann C Collier; Stephen E Van Rompaey; Heidi M Crane; Rosemary G McKaig; Bryan Lau; Aimee M Freeman; Richard D Moore Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2009-04-01 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Priscila Ribeiro Guimarães Pacheco; Ana Laura Sene Amâncio Zara; Luiz Carlos Silva E Souza; Marília Dalva Turchi Journal: J Trop Med Date: 2019-04-07
Authors: Angela Cescon; Sophie Patterson; Colin Davey; Erin Ding; Janet M Raboud; Keith Chan; Mona R Loutfy; Curtis Cooper; Ann N Burchell; Alexis K Palmer; Christos Tsoukas; Nima Machouf; Marina B Klein; Sean B Rourke; Anita Rachlis; Robert S Hogg; Julio S G Montaner Journal: J Int AIDS Soc Date: 2015-10-05 Impact factor: 5.396
Authors: Amanda Rodrigues; Claudio J Struchiner; Lara E Coelho; Valdilea G Veloso; Beatriz Grinsztejn; Paula M Luz Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2021-04-01 Impact factor: 3.295
Authors: Yanink Caro-Vega; Peter F Rebeiro; Bryan E Shepherd; Pablo F Belaunzarán-Zamudio; Brenda Crabtree-Ramirez; Carina Cesar; Paula Mendes Luz; Claudia P Cortes; Denis Padget; Eduardo Gotuzzo; Catherine C McGowan; Juan G Sierra-Madero Journal: Lancet Reg Health Am Date: 2022-01-13
Authors: Emilia M Jalil; Thiago S Torres; Paula M Luz; Laylla Monteiro; Ronaldo I Moreira; Cristiane R V de Castro; Iuri da C Leite; Marcello Cunha; Rita de Cássia Elias Estrela; Michelle Ramos; Brenda Hoagland; Sandra Wagner Cardoso; Peter Anderson; Valdilea G Veloso; Erin Wilson; Beatriz Grinsztejn Journal: J Int AIDS Soc Date: 2022-03 Impact factor: 5.396
Authors: Kelika A Konda; Thiago S Torres; Gabriela Mariño; Alessandra Ramos; Ronaldo I Moreira; Iuri C Leite; Marcelo Cunha; Emilia M Jalil; Brenda Hoagland; Juan V Guanira; Marcos Benedetti; Cristina Pimenta; Heleen Vermandere; Sergio Bautista-Arredondo; Hamid Vega-Ramirez; Valdilea G Veloso; Carlos F Caceres; Beatriz Grinsztejn Journal: J Int AIDS Soc Date: 2022-10 Impact factor: 6.707