| Literature DB >> 33604269 |
Morten B Haulrig1, Claus Zachariae1,2, Lone Skov1,2.
Abstract
Psoriasis is a chronic inflammatory skin disease that affects up to 1.2% of children and adolescents. The treatment options for childhood psoriasis are often based on the same principles as in adults. However, most data on safety and efficacy derive from adult studies, and only a few of the frequently used treatments have achieved approval for use in children. The aim of this study was to review the current literature on off-label treatments for psoriasis in children and adolescents. We searched PubMed and identified 50 studies on off-label treatments. Of these, 23 studies were clinical trials (four randomized). There are only a small number of available studies on off-label treatments for children and adolescents with psoriasis, and many of these are retrospective reviews with few participants. Despite the current lack of studies, we still recommend the use of unapproved treatments since we have clinical experience with treatments such as topical corticosteroids, vitamin D analogs, and methotrexate that have shown promising effects. Regular clinical trials are needed to investigate the safety and efficacy of unapproved treatments. Due to The Pediatric Investigation Plans issued by The European Union, new drugs developed by pharmaceutical companies are required to undergo clinical trials in a pediatric population to get their application for marketing authorization processed. This will hopefully lead to much more data on the efficacy and safety of the new treatments, including treatments for children and adolescents with psoriasis.Entities:
Keywords: adolescents; childhood; psoriasis; unapproved treatment
Year: 2021 PMID: 33604269 PMCID: PMC7886293 DOI: 10.2147/PTT.S268462
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Psoriasis (Auckl) ISSN: 2230-326X
Treatment Approval Status for Psoriasis in Children and Adolescents According to Medical Agency
| Treatment | EMA Approval Status | FDA Approval Status |
|---|---|---|
| Topical corticosteroids | Group I–II from 3 months. Group III traditionally used | Traditionally used |
| Topical calcineurin inhibitor | Not approved | Not approved |
| Topical retinoids | Not approved | Not approved |
| Vitamin-D analogs | Not approved | Not approved |
| Vitamin-D analogs + betamethasone dipropionate | Not approved | >12 years |
| Anthralin | Traditionally used | Traditionally used |
| Traditionally used | Traditionally used | |
| Traditionally used | Traditionally used | |
| Methotrexate | Not approved | Not approved |
| Retinoids | Not approved | Not approved |
| Cyclosporin | Not approved | Not approved |
| Fumaric acid esters | Not approved | Not approved |
| Apremilast | Not approved | Not approved |
| Adalimumab | >4 years | Not approved |
| Secukinumab | >6 years | Not approved |
| Ixekizumab | >6 years | >6 years |
| Etanercept | >6 years | >4 years |
| Ustekinumab | >6 years | >12 years |
Abbreviations: EMA, The European Medicines Agency; FDA, The US Food and Drug Administration.
Figure 1Mixed plaque and guttate psoriasis on the back of a 9-year-old boy.
Figure 2Plaque psoriasis on the back of a 4-year-old boy.
Characteristics of the Included Studies (n = 50)
| Study Reference | Study Design, No. of Patients | Age (Years) | Type of Psoriasis | Treatment Regimen | Main Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kimball et al | Randomized clinical trial, n=9 | 12–18 | Plaque (mild-moderate) | Group A: Clobetasol emollient foam x2/day for 14 days (50g/wk). Group B: vehicle foam x2/day for 14 days | Group A: Clear or almost clear psoriasis achieved in 25% according to ISGA. Group B: 0% effect (p<0.0001) |
| Herz et al | Clinical trial, n=11 | 5–15 | Plaque | Halobetasol propionate x2/day for 14 days (40g/wk) | 10/11 had healed or marked improvement of psoriasis according to PGA |
| Brune et al | Clinical trial, n=11 | 6–15 | Inverse or facial (mild-severe) | Tacrolimus 0.1% x2/day for 180 days | All patients who completed had clear or almost clear psoriasis according to PGA by day 30. (p<0.0001) |
| Steele et al | Retrospective review, n=13 | 22 months −16 years | Inverse | Tacrolimus 0.1% x2/day in 12 patients and 0.03% x2/day in 1 patient. Unknown duration | 12/13 patients had complete clearance within 2 weeks. AEs were burning and irritation. Assessment score was not specified |
| Oostveen et al | Clinical trial, n=34 | 3–17 | Plaque (moderate-severe) | Dithranol cream 0.01–4% x1/day in increasing doses. Mean duration 11.4 weeks | All patients achieved PASI score −69.3% |
| de Jager et al | Retrospective review, n=60 | 3–17 | Plaque | Dithranol cream 0.01–4% x1/day in increasing doses. Mean duration 9.3 weeks | 73,2% had clear or almost clear psoriasis. Assessment was not objective |
| Oranje et al | Randomized clinical trial, n=77 | 2–14 | Plaque (mild-moderate) | Group A: Calcipotriol ointment 50 μg/g x2/day (n=43). Group B: Vehicle ointment x2/day (n=34) for 8 weeks. Mean 15.2 g/week | PASI reduction 52% (group A) and 37.1% (group B) at week 8. Statistically insignificant (p<0.14) |
| Saggese et al | Randomized clinical trial, n=10 | 5–17 | Plaque | Calcitriol 3 μg/g on one side of the body and petrolatum (vehicle) on the other side x1/day. Mean amount 21ug/week | All patients had complete clearance on calcitriol treated side at week 4 according to an objective score. No effect on vehicle side |
| Park et al | Clinical trial, n=12 | 8–15 | Plaque and guttate | Calcipotriol 50 μg/g x2/day. Mean duration 40 weeks. Mean amount 19g/week | PASI75 achieved in 66.7%. Statistical significant compared to baseline (p<0.05) |
| Darley et al | Clinical trial, n=66 | 2–14 | Plaque (mild-moderate) | Calcipotriol 50 μg/g x2/day. Duration up to 8 weeks | 65% had marked improvement or clearance according to PASI at week 8 (p<0.001) |
| Gooderham et al | Clinical trial, n=78 | 12–17 | Scalp (moderate-severe) | Calcipotriol 50 μg/g plus betamethasone dipropionate gel 0.5 mg/g gel x1/day for 8 weeks. Mean 36g/week | 85% had clear or almost clear psoriasis according to IGA at week 8 |
| van Geel et al | Clinical trial, n=73 | 3–18 | Plaque (Mild-moderate) | Group A: Calcipotriol 50 μg/g plus betamethasone dipropionate ointment 0.5 mg/g x1 daily for 4 weeks followed by x1 daily four times weekly. Group B: x1 daily four times weekly. Total 48 weeks | Group A: PASI reduction of 17.3% at week 24 and 34.6% at week 48. Group B: No change in PASI |
| Oostveen et al | Clinical trial, n=73 | 4–17 | Scalp | Calcipotriol 50 μg/g plus betamethasone dipropionate scalp formulation 0.5 mg/g x1 daily for 2 weeks followed by 3 times weekly | PSSI reduction of 32.1% at week 12 |
| Eichenfield et al | Clinical trial, n=31 | 12–17 | Scalp (moderate-severe) | Calcipotriol 50 μg/g plus betamethasone dipropionate 0.5 mg/g topical suspension x1 daily for 8 weeks. Maximum 60g/week | 55% had clear or almost clear psoriasis according to IGA at week 8 |
| Borska et al | Clinical trial, n=19 | 5–17 | Plaque | Goeckerman therapy. 3% coal tar followed by combined UVA and UVB treatment x1/day. 14–22 days | Decrease in PASI from median 20.4 to 9.4 (p<0.001) |
| Borska et al | Clinical trial, n=26 | 8–17 | - | Goeckerman therapy. 5% coal tar followed by combined UVA and UVB treatment x1/day. Mean 19 days | Decrease in PASI from median 26.2 to 5.08 (p<0.001) |
| Borska et al | Clinical trial, n=16 | 5–17 | - | Goeckerman therapy. 5% coal tar followed by combined UVA and UVB treatment x1/day. Mean 16 days | Decrease in PASI from median 15.1 to 8.7 (p<0.001) |
| Kortuem et al | Retrospective review, n=65 | 3 months - 18 yrs | Plaque, guttate and erythroderma | Goeckerman therapy. Different types of coal tar in different doses followed by UVB treatment x1/day. Mean 20 days | 80%< clearance of plaques seen in 85% according to an unspecified global score |
| Jain et al | Clinical trial, n=20 | 6–14 | Plaque and guttate | NB-UVB x2/week. Mean 24.2 treatments | PASI70% achieved in 75% at week 12 |
| Jain et al | Clinical trial, n=18 | 5–14 | Plaque and guttate | NB-UVB x2/week for 12 weeks. One side of the body was pretreated with mineral oil | Reduction of a modified PASI score on the body side pretreated with mineral oil after 3 weeks |
| Tan et el | Clinical trial, n=38 | 8–15 | - | NB-UVB x3/week. Mean 27.8 treatments | 75%< response in 90% according to an unspecified assessment score |
| Zamberk et al | Retrospective review, n=20 | 5–17 | Plaque and guttate | NB-UVB x3/week. Median 28 treatments | PASI75% achieved in 70% |
| Pasic et al | Retrospective review, n=20 | 6–14 | - | NB-UVB x3-6/week. Mean 19 treatments | PASI70% achieved in 65% |
| Pavlovsky et al | Retrospective review, n=88 | 8–16 | - | NB-UVB x3-6/week. Mean 3.1 months | 92% had clearance or good response according to an unspecified assessment score |
| Eustace et al | Retrospective review, n=15 | 3–17 | - | NB-UVB x2/week. Mean 29.9 treatments | PASI75% achieved in 86% |
| Sen et al | Retrospective review, n=30 | 5–16 | - | NB-UVB x3/week. Mean 32.4 treatments | 75%< response in 73% according to an unspecified assessment score |
| Ersoy-Evans et al | Retrospective review, n=68 | 5–17 | Plaque and guttate | UVB (n=30), NB-UVB (n=28), PUVA (n=7) x1-3/week. Mean 3–27 months | 75%< response in 93% (NB-UVB), 83% (PUVA), 93% (UVB) according to an unspecified assessment score |
| Wong et al | Retrospective review, n=12 | 6–13 | - | NB-UVB x2-3/week. Mean 57.3 treatments | 70%< response in 90% according to an unspecified assessment score |
| Jury et al | Retrospective review, n=35 | 4–16 | - | NB-UVB. Median 17.5 treatments | 63% had clearance or minimal residual disease at the end of treatment according to an unspecified assessment score |
| Papp et al | Randomised clinical trial, n=37 | 6–17 | Plaque (severe) | Group A: MTX oral treatment 0.1–0.4 mg/kg per week + placebo injection for 16 weeks. Group B and C: See adalimumab | PASI75 achieved in 32% at week 16 (p<0.027) |
| van Geel et al | Clinical trial, n=25 | 6–17 | Plaque (moderate-severe) | Oral treatment (76%), subcutaneous (24%). 0.14–0.63 mg/kg per week. Mean duration 60 weeks | PASI75 achieved in 40% at week 36 |
| Ergun et al | Clinical trial, n=85 | 9–14 | - | Route of administration not reported. 0.3–0.7 mg/kg per week. Mean duration 6.5 months | PASI75 achieved in 34% |
| Charbit et al | Retrospective review, n=48 | - | Plaque, pustular, guttate, nail | Route of administration and doses not reported. Mean duration 13.9 months | PASI75 achieved in 38% at week 12. 73.9% of patients used topical treatment |
| Bronckers et al | Retrospective review, n=163 | Mean 11.6 years | Plaque (moderate-severe) | Route of administration not reported. Mean dosage 0.29 mg/kg per week. Mean duration 1.6 years | PASI75 achieved in 40% (MTX) and 71.4% (biological treatment) |
| Kaur et al | Retrospective review, n=24 | 2–14 | Plaque, pustular and erythroderma | Oral treatment, 0.2–0.4 mg/kg per week. Mean duration 5 months | PASI75 achieved in 91% after 3–10 weeks. PASI50 achieved at mean 5 weeks |
| Klufas et al | Case series, n=14 | 7–18 | Plaque (moderate-severe) | Oral treatment (n=13) subcutaneous (n=1). Mean 12.8 mg/week. 4–100 weeks | PGA reduced from 2.4 to 1.4 after 5–7 months and to 1.5 after 1 year |
| Collin et al | Case series, n=13 | 3–15 | Plaque (severe) | Oral treatment, 0.03–0.41 mg/kg per week. Mean duration 71 weeks | 11/13 patients had clearance leaving small residual plaques. Assessment was not objective |
| Ergun et al | Clinical trial, n=61 | 9–14 | - | Acitretin 0.3–0.5 mg/kg/day. Mean duration 9.1 months | PASI75 achieved in 47.5% |
| Charbit et al | Retrospective review, n=142 | - | Plaque, pustular, guttate, nail | Acitretin. Dosis not reported. Mean duration 11.5 months | PASI75 achieved in 33% at week 12. 73.9% of patients used topical treatment |
| Di Lernia et al | Retrospective review, n=18 | 2–14 | Plaque (moderate-severe) | Acitretin 0.2–0.6 mg/kg/day. Mean duration 22.7 months | PASI75 achieved in 44.4% at week 16 |
| Chen et al | Retrospective review, n=15 | 5 months - 9 yrs | Pustular | Acitretin 0.2–1.0 mg/kg/day. Unknown duration | PASI75 achieved in 93.3% at week 6 |
| Ergun et al | Clinical trial, n=80 | 9–14 | - | 3–5 mg/kg/day. Mean duration 6.5 months | PASI75 achieved in 40% |
| Di Lernia et al | Retrospective cohort study, n=38 | 5–17 | Plaque (moderate-severe) | 2.1–3.5 mg/kg/day. Mean duration 5.7 months | PASI75 achieved in 39.4% at week 12 |
| Charbit et al | Retrospective review, n=25 | - | Plaque, pustular, guttate, nail, erythroderma | Dosis not reported. Mean duration 6.5 months | PASI75 achieved in 44% at week 12. 73.9% of patients used topical treatment |
| Bulbul Baskan et al | Retrospective review, n=22 | 6–17 | Plaque and guttate | 2.5–5 mg/kg/day. Mean duration 5.7 months | PASI75 achieved in 77% after median 4 weeks |
| Dogra et al | Case series, n=10 | 3–12 | Plaque, pustular and erythroderma (severe) | 5 mg/kg/day. Unknown duration | PASI75 achieved in 70% |
| Kilic et al | Case series, n=3 | 1–10 | Pustular | 1–2 mg/kg/day for 2–12 months | All patients had skin clearance after 2–4 weeks. Assessment was not objective |
| Pereira et al | Case series, n=6 | 11 months −13 years | Plaque and pustular (severe) | 2–4 mg/kg/day. Mean duration 54 weeks | PASI100 achieved in 50% after mean 12 weeks |
| Mahé et al | Case series, n=4 | 2–10 | Plaque, pustular and erythroderma | 2.5–7.5 mg/kg/day for 3.5–6 months | Ineffective in all patients. Assessment was not objective |
| Perrett et al | Case series, n=3 | 7–11 | Plaque (severe) | 3–5 mg/kg/day for 1.5–4 months | Improvement in 2 patients. Assessment was not objective |
| Steinz et al | Retrospective review, n=6 | 6–17 | Plaque and guttate | Fumaderm 240–720 mg/day. Mean duration of treatment 17.8 months | PASI75 achieved in 100% after 12 weeks. 50% achieved PASI100 |
| van Geel et al | Case series, n=14 | 8–17 | Plaque | Dimethyl fumarate 180–1200 mg/day, mean 564 mg/day. Mean treatment duration 48.6 weeks | PASI75 achieved in 64.3% |
| Balak et al | Case series, n=14 | 8–17 | Plaque and guttate | 240–600 mg/day. Median duration of treatment 10 months | PASI75 achieved in 43% |
| Paller et al | Clinical trial, n=42 | 6–17 | Plaque (moderate-severe) | Group A: 20 mg x2/day aged 6–11. Group B: 20 mg x2/day aged 12–17. Group C: 30 mg x2/day aged 12–17 | PASI reduction of 79% (group A), 69.6% (group B) and 66.5% (group C) at week 16 |
| Papp et al | Randomized clinical trial, n=77 | 4–17 | Plaque (severe) | Group B: 0.4 mg/kg x1 every other week. Group C: 0.8 mg/kg x1 every other week. Total duration 16 weeks. Group A: See methotrexate | PASI75 achieved in 43.6% (group B) and 57.9% (group C) at week 16 (p<0.027) |
| Thaci et al | Clinical trial, n=108 | 6–18 | Plaque (severe) | Group A: MTX followed by adalimumab 0.8mg/kg. Group B: Adalimumab 0.4 mg/kg followed by 0.4 mg/kg or 0.8 mg/kg. Group C: Adalimumab 0.8 mg/kg followed by 0.8 mg/kg. Every other week for 52 weeks | PASI75 from entry to the end of study: Group A (31–86%), Group B (28–47%), Group C (50–72%) |
| Klufas et al | Case series, n=11 | 7–18 | Plaque (moderate-severe) | 40 mg x1 every other week for 4–72 weeks | PGA reduced from 2.4 to 0.7 after 5–7 months and to 2.0 after 1 year |
Note: The search on the following treatments did not provide any useful results: Topical retinoids, infliximab, brodalumab, guselkumab, secukinumab, risankizumab, tildrakizumab, and certolizumab pegol.
Abbreviations: PASI, Psoriasis Area Severity Index; PSSI, Psoriasis Scalp Severity Index; PGA, Physician’s Global Assessment; IGA, Investigator’s Global Assessment; ISGA, Investigator’s Static Global Assessment; NB-UVB, narrowband UVB; PUVA, psoralen and ultraviolet A; MTX, methotrexate.
Figure 3The number of included studies investigating off-label treatments for psoriasis in children and adolescents.