OBJECTIVES: Heterogeneity of SLE patients in clinical trials remains a challenge for developing new therapies. This study used a combinatorial analysis of four molecular biomarkers to define key sources of heterogeneity. METHODS: Combinations of IFN (high/low), anti-dsDNA (+/-) and C3 and C4 (low/normal) were used to subset n = 1747 patients from two randomized phase III trials. A dichotomous classification scheme defined SLE (+) as: IFN (high), anti-dsDNA (+), C3 (low) and/or C4 (low). SLE (-) required all of the following: IFN (low), anti-dsDNA (-), C3 (normal) and C4 (normal). Additional analyses subset the data further by IFN, anti-dsDNA and complement. RESULTS: The trials enrolled n = 2262 patients of which n = 1747 patients had data for IFN, anti-dsDNA, C3 and C4 at baseline. There were n = 247 patients in the SLE (-) population and n = 1500 patients in the SLE (+) population. The SLE (-) population had more mucocutaneous and musculoskeletal disease at baseline, while SLE (+) had more haematological, renal and vascular involvement. There was lower concomitant medication use in the SLE (-) population for corticosteroids and immunosuppressants, except for MTX. Time to severe flare was significantly longer in SLE (-) vs SLE (+) (P < 0.0001) and SRI-4 response rate was significantly lower in SLE (-) vs SLE (+) (P = 0.00016). The USA had more SLE (-) patients (22%) than Mexico/Central America/South America (10%), Europe (7%) and the rest of the world (5%). CONCLUSION: Combinatorial analysis of four molecular biomarkers revealed subsets of SLE patients that discriminated by disease manifestations, concomitant medication use, geography, time to severe flare and SRI-4 response. These data may be useful for designing clinical trials and identifying subsets of patients for analysis. Rheumatology key messages SLE patients from a P3 trial were categorized by IFN, anti-dsDNA, C3 and C4 status. Patients lacking molecular markers of SLE distinguished from biomarker positive patients on multiple clinical parameters. Biomarker negative patients have distinct disease characteristics that may impact clinical trial outcomes.
OBJECTIVES: Heterogeneity of SLE patients in clinical trials remains a challenge for developing new therapies. This study used a combinatorial analysis of four molecular biomarkers to define key sources of heterogeneity. METHODS: Combinations of IFN (high/low), anti-dsDNA (+/-) and C3 and C4 (low/normal) were used to subset n = 1747 patients from two randomized phase III trials. A dichotomous classification scheme defined SLE (+) as: IFN (high), anti-dsDNA (+), C3 (low) and/or C4 (low). SLE (-) required all of the following: IFN (low), anti-dsDNA (-), C3 (normal) and C4 (normal). Additional analyses subset the data further by IFN, anti-dsDNA and complement. RESULTS: The trials enrolled n = 2262 patients of which n = 1747 patients had data for IFN, anti-dsDNA, C3 and C4 at baseline. There were n = 247 patients in the SLE (-) population and n = 1500 patients in the SLE (+) population. The SLE (-) population had more mucocutaneous and musculoskeletal disease at baseline, while SLE (+) had more haematological, renal and vascular involvement. There was lower concomitant medication use in the SLE (-) population for corticosteroids and immunosuppressants, except for MTX. Time to severe flare was significantly longer in SLE (-) vs SLE (+) (P < 0.0001) and SRI-4 response rate was significantly lower in SLE (-) vs SLE (+) (P = 0.00016). The USA had more SLE (-) patients (22%) than Mexico/Central America/South America (10%), Europe (7%) and the rest of the world (5%). CONCLUSION: Combinatorial analysis of four molecular biomarkers revealed subsets of SLE patients that discriminated by disease manifestations, concomitant medication use, geography, time to severe flare and SRI-4 response. These data may be useful for designing clinical trials and identifying subsets of patients for analysis. Rheumatology key messages SLE patients from a P3 trial were categorized by IFN, anti-dsDNA, C3 and C4 status. Patients lacking molecular markers of SLE distinguished from biomarker positive patients on multiple clinical parameters. Biomarker negative patients have distinct disease characteristics that may impact clinical trial outcomes.
Authors: Richard Furie; Michelle Petri; Omid Zamani; Ricard Cervera; Daniel J Wallace; Dana Tegzová; Jorge Sanchez-Guerrero; Andreas Schwarting; Joan T Merrill; W Winn Chatham; William Stohl; Ellen M Ginzler; Douglas R Hough; Z John Zhong; William Freimuth; Ronald F van Vollenhoven Journal: Arthritis Rheum Date: 2011-12
Authors: Joan T Merrill; William R Shanahan; Morton Scheinberg; Kenneth C Kalunian; David Wofsy; Renee S Martin Journal: Ann Rheum Dis Date: 2018-03-21 Impact factor: 19.103
Authors: D A Isenberg; M Petri; K Kalunian; Y Tanaka; M B Urowitz; R W Hoffman; M Morgan-Cox; N Iikuni; M Silk; D J Wallace Journal: Ann Rheum Dis Date: 2015-09-03 Impact factor: 19.103
Authors: Megan E B Clowse; Daniel J Wallace; Richard A Furie; Michelle A Petri; Marilyn C Pike; Piotr Leszczyński; C Michael Neuwelt; Kathryn Hobbs; Mauro Keiserman; Liliana Duca; Kenneth C Kalunian; Catrinel Galateanu; Sabine Bongardt; Christian Stach; Carolyn Beaudot; Brian Kilgallen; Caroline Gordon Journal: Arthritis Rheumatol Date: 2017-02 Impact factor: 10.995
Authors: Joan T Merrill; Susan Manzi; Cynthia Aranow; Anca Askanase; Ian Bruce; Eliza Chakravarty; Ben Chong; Karen Costenbader; Maria Dall'Era; Ellen Ginzler; Leslie Hanrahan; Ken Kalunian; Joseph Merola; Sandra Raymond; Brad Rovin; Amit Saxena; Victoria P Werth Journal: Lupus Sci Med Date: 2018-03-23
Authors: Michael A Smith; Jill Henault; Jodi L Karnell; Melissa L Parker; Jeffrey M Riggs; Dominic Sinibaldi; Devon K Taylor; Rachel Ettinger; Ethan P Grant; Miguel A Sanjuan; Roland Kolbeck; Michelle A Petri; Kerry A Casey Journal: Sci Rep Date: 2019-10-08 Impact factor: 4.379
Authors: Robert W Hoffman; Joan T Merrill; Marta M E Alarcón-Riquelme; Michelle Petri; Ernst R Dow; Eric Nantz; Laura K Nisenbaum; Krista M Schroeder; Wendy J Komocsar; Narayanan B Perumal; Matthew D Linnik; David C Airey; Yushi Liu; Guilherme V Rocha; Richard E Higgs Journal: Arthritis Rheumatol Date: 2017-03 Impact factor: 10.995
Authors: Michelle D Catalina; Prathyusha Bachali; Anthony E Yeo; Nicholas S Geraci; Michelle A Petri; Amrie C Grammer; Peter E Lipsky Journal: JCI Insight Date: 2020-08-06