| Literature DB >> 33568913 |
Nur Azizah1,2, Eli Halimah1,3, Irma Melyani Puspitasari1,3, Aliya Nur Hasanah4.
Abstract
In various countries, approximately 80% of patients use herbal medicine, both in single form or in combination with antihypertensive drugs, for the treatment of hypertension. Therefore, this research summarized studies on the simultaneous use of herbal medicines and antihypertensive drugs among hypertensive patients in the community. A literature search was conducted on PubMed in April 2020, and the following keywords were used: "herbal medicines" and "antihypertensive patients." In total, 15 of 263 articles were found to be eligible in the initial research. Results showed that studies were performed in different countries worldwide including America and those in Europe, Asia, and Africa between 1960 and 2020. The factors associated with the use of herbal medicines and antihypertensive drugs were age, gender, education level, income, and residence. Herbal medicines and antihypertensive drugs are simultaneously utilized primarily due to their safety and high efficacy. Herbal medicine is frequently recommended by friends or colleagues, herbalists, advertisements, and health workers. Garlic is the most common herbal medicine used along with antihypertensive drugs. The side effects of combination therapy with herbal medicines and prescription drugs for the management of antihypertension include shortness of breath and cough, ulcers, diarrhea, knee cramps, and abdominal discomfort. The lack of communication between patients and health care workers could cause an increase in the simultaneous use of herbal medicines and antihypertensive drugs. Therefore, effective communication among health care workers and appropriate care are important in preventing the side effects and other risks of combined therapy.Entities:
Keywords: antihypertensive drug; combination use; herbal medicine; hypertensive patients
Year: 2021 PMID: 33568913 PMCID: PMC7868580 DOI: 10.2147/JMDH.S289156
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Multidiscip Healthc ISSN: 1178-2390
Figure 1Flowchart of literature search.
Use of Herbal Medicines Among Hypertensive Patients Between 1960 and 2020
| No. | Country | Number of Participants | Number of Hypertensive Patients | Number of Hypertensive Patients Who Used Herbal Medicine | Number of Patients Who Simultaneously Used Herbal Medicines and Antihypertensive Drugs | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Australia | n=260 | n=260 | n=148 | Not indicated | James |
| 2 | Palestine | n=4575 | n=3921 | n=2436 | Not indicated | Ali Shtayeh |
| 3 | Jordan | n=378 | n=32 | n=32 | Not indicated | El-Dahiyat |
| 4 | Turkey | n=343 | n=184 | n=168 | Not indicated | Aykan dan Aykan |
| 5 | Iran | n=612 | n=612 | n=169 | Not indicated | Tajadini |
| 6 | Africa | n=135 | n=135 | n=28 | Not indicated | Hughes |
| 7 | Thailand | n=1374 | n= 838 | n=272 | Not indicated | Peltzer and Pengpid |
| 8 | Iraq | n=20 | n= 20 | n=11 | Not indicated | Ibrahim |
| 9 | Nigeria | n=225 | n= 225 | n=35 | Not indicated | Amira and Okubadejo |
| 10 | South Africa | n=456 | n=124 | n=66 | 37.1% (n=46) | Hughes |
| 11 | Trinidad | n= 265 | n=74 | n=53 | 30.6% (n=81) | Clement |
| 12 | Jamaica | n=270 | n=42 | n=42 | 10% (n=27) | Picking |
| 13 | Tanzania | n=213 | n=213 | n=69 | 22.1% (n=47) | Liwa |
| 14 | West Africa | n=316 | n=142 | n=65 | 6.2% (n=4) | Diallo |
| 15 | Nigeria | n = 480 | n=480 | n=120 | 47.50% (n=57) | Olisa and Oyelola |
| (n=9466) | (n=7302) | (n= 3714) | (n=262) |
Sociodemographic Characteristics of Hypertensive Patients Who Use Herbal Medicines Combined with Antihypertensive Drugs
| No. | Number of Hypertensive Patients | Number of Hypertensive Patients Who Used Herbal Medicines | Number of Patients Who Simultaneously Used Herbal Medicines and Antihypertensive Drugs | Gender | Age | Education Level | Occupation | Income | Residence | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | n=124 | n=66 | 37.1% (n=46) | M: 20.3% | 56 years old on average | None or primary: 37.4% Secondary: 54.5% Tertiary or others: 8.1% | Employed (19.7%) Unemployed (80.3%) | 0–1999 rand: 75% 2000–5000 rand: 21.0% 5000+ rand: 4% | Urban | Hughes |
| 2 | n=74 | n=53 | 30.6% (n=81) | Not indicated | – | – | – | – | – | Clement |
| 3 | n=42 | n=42 | 10% (n=27) | Not indicated | – | – | – | – | – | Picking |
| 4 | n=213 | n=69 | 22.1% (n=47) | M: 40.4% | ≤45 years old: 21.7% 46–55 years old: 30.0% 56–65 years old: 20.1% | Did not complete primary school: 36.2% Completed primary school: 22.3% Completed secondary school: 11.8% | Farmers (32%) Small scale business owners (33.3%) Professionals, businessman or businesswoman, or students (11.1%) | – | – | Liwa |
| 5 | n=142 | n=65 | 6.2% (n=4) | M: 26.15% | 45–54 years old: 58.5% | – | – | – | Urban | Diallo |
| 6 | n=480 | n=120 | 47,50% (n=57) | Not indicated | 60–69 years old: 33.33% 70–79 years old: 41.67% | Without formal education: 42.42% Primary education: 41.67% | – | – | – | Olisa and Oyelola |
Abbreviations: n, number of patients; M, male; F, female.
Factors Correlated with the Simultaneous Usage of Herbal Medicines and Antihypertensive Drugs
| No. | Reasons for Usage | Informants | Name of Herbal Medicines | Source | Consumption Process | Antihypertensive Drugs | Perceived Side Effects | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Assuming conventional drugs was unsuccessful (31.37%) Conventional medicine was more expensive (23.08%) Sociocultural (community) habits (20.19%) Difficult access to health facilities (19.23%) Safety issues associated with conventional medicine (9.26%) Lack of attention from hospital staff (6.73%) | Salesman and friend | Market (26.52%) Friends (20.56%) Traditional medicine stores (19.79%) Pharmacists (9.09%) | Infusing the herbal material using a different solvent as vehicles, which include water, lime juice, and corn pap Steam inhalation | – | Diarrhea, stomach ulcers, abdominal discomfort, leg cramps, shortness of breath and cough | Olisa and Oyelola | ||
Family history (48.8%) Cultural beliefs (33.3%) Low cost (16.3%) Ease of obtaining herbal medicine (12.2%) Positive recommendation (22.8%) Maintaining health condition (32.5%) Drugs for specific diseases (13.0%) | Friends or colleagues (18.1%) Partners (6.0%) Family (57.8%) Traditional practitioners (6.9%) Advertisements (2.6%) Health care providers (1.7%) | – | Market (39.5%) Traditional practitioners (26.6%) Personal harvest (21%) | Tea (83.9%) Powder (9.3%) Extract (10.2%) Tablet (2.5%) Decoction (6.8%) | – | – | Hughes. | |
Belief in traditional medicines (31.9%) Convinced by others (17.4%) Pressure from family or spouse (10.2%) Indifference among hospital staff (7.3%) | Traditional medications (15%) | Garlic, ginger, honey, carrots, avocado seeds, bit roots, wood charcoal, papaya seeds, lemons, onions, and aloe vera | – | – | – | – | Liwa. | |
| Combination of herbal medicines and drugs works effectively (70.4%) | – | Garden/backyard (79.2%) Market (7.5%) | – | – | – | Clement. | ||
Simultaneous use of drugs works effectively (12.5%) Prescription of a single medicine did not work effectively (5.5%) Prescription of an expensive drug (11.1%) Many side effects from prescribed drugs (8.3%) Simultaneous use of herbal medicines and drugs was safe (8%) Do not take prescription drugs for the same condition (48.6%) | – | – | – | HCT (13.9%) Captopril (2.8%) Atenolol (4.2%) Enalapril (8.2%) Hydralazine (4.2%) Nifedipine (4.2%) Furosemide (4.2%) Carvedilol (2.8%) Bendroflumethiazide reserpine (2.8%) | – | Picking. | ||
| Culture, sociodemographic characteristics, and high cost of modern therapy | – | Hymenocardia acida Hibiscus sabdariffa | Market (54.8%) and harvest themselves (45.1%) | Decoction (73.3%) and infusion (26.6%) | Diuretic | Diallo. |
Abbreviation: HCT, hydrochlorothiazide.