Silver nanoparticles (Ag-NPs) adhered/inserted on textile fibers have an effective antimicrobial role. However, their release due to low adherence and their fate in the natural settings have been questioned in terms of toxicity level. In order to overcome this recurrent problem of adherence, the in situ formation of Ag-NPs in five textile fibers (cotton (untreated and chemically bleached), sheep's wool, polyamide, and polyester) was assessed. Herein, the fibers were first immersed in a silver ion solution (1 g/L of AgNO3) for ion saturation at room T for 24 h followed by draining fibers and their reimmersion this time in a strong chemical reducing solution (0.25 g/L of NaBH4) at room T for 24 h. This latter step leads to the in situ formation of Ag-NPs where size (5 nm < size < 50 nm), surface covering concentration, and aggregation degree depend on the textile fiber kind as deduced from FESEM images. This simple lab chemical method allows instantaneous in situ formation of Ag-NPs onto fibers without the requirement of additional thermal treatment. Moreover, for natural fibers, the formation of Ag-NPs inside of them is also expected as confirmed from FESEM images in cotton cross sections. In complement, all textile fibers containing Ag-NPs (sheep's wool 10 mg/g > untreated cotton 2.3 mg/g > bleached cotton 1 mg/g > polyamide 0.62 mg/g > polyester 0.28 mg/g) were submitted to interact with strong oxidants in an aqueous media (7.5% v/v of H2O2, 0.5 and 0.05 M of HNO3 and ultrapure water as the control) using flow-through reactor experiments. Here, breakthrough curves reveal that the oxidative dissolution rate (given in mol/g min) of adhered Ag-NPs (ionic release) depends strongly on fiber nature, and nature and concentration of oxidant solution. In summary, this fundamental study suggests that Ag-NPs may be successfully adhered/inserted in natural fibers (wool and cotton) in a safety-design perspective with performant biocide properties as confirmed by using Bacillus subtilis.
Silver nanoparticles (Ag-NPs) adhered/inserted on textile fibers have an effective antimicrobial role. However, their release due to low adherence and their fate in the natural settings have been questioned in terms of toxicity level. In order to overcome this recurrent problem of adherence, the in situ formation of Ag-NPs in five textile fibers (cotton (untreated and chemically bleached), sheep's wool, polyamide, and polyester) was assessed. Herein, the fibers were first immersed in a silver ion solution (1 g/L of AgNO3) for ion saturation at room T for 24 h followed by draining fibers and their reimmersion this time in a strong chemical reducing solution (0.25 g/L of NaBH4) at room T for 24 h. This latter step leads to the in situ formation of Ag-NPs where size (5 nm < size < 50 nm), surface covering concentration, and aggregation degree depend on the textile fiber kind as deduced from FESEM images. This simple lab chemical method allows instantaneous in situ formation of Ag-NPs onto fibers without the requirement of additional thermal treatment. Moreover, for natural fibers, the formation of Ag-NPs inside of them is also expected as confirmed from FESEM images in cotton cross sections. In complement, all textile fibers containing Ag-NPs (sheep's wool 10 mg/g > untreated cotton 2.3 mg/g > bleached cotton 1 mg/g > polyamide 0.62 mg/g > polyester 0.28 mg/g) were submitted to interact with strong oxidants in an aqueous media (7.5% v/v of H2O2, 0.5 and 0.05 M of HNO3 and ultrapure water as the control) using flow-through reactor experiments. Here, breakthrough curves reveal that the oxidative dissolution rate (given in mol/g min) of adhered Ag-NPs (ionic release) depends strongly on fiber nature, and nature and concentration of oxidant solution. In summary, this fundamental study suggests that Ag-NPs may be successfully adhered/inserted in natural fibers (wool and cotton) in a safety-design perspective with performant biocide properties as confirmed by using Bacillus subtilis.
With
the development of nanotechnology, silver nanoparticles (Ag-NPs)
are widely used due to their extraordinary optical, electrical, mechanical,
catalytic, and antimicrobial properties. Moreover, silver ions and/or
silver soluble compounds have been used to disinfect liquids, solids,
and human tissue for centuries.[1,2] Due to their effective
antimicrobial activity against a wide range of microorganisms including
bacteria, fungi, viruses, etc., both as colloidal suspensions and
as components, Ag-NPs have gained popularity in industrial sectors
including textiles, food, consumer products, medicine, etc.[1−4] At the present time, Ag-NPs are extensively used in healthcare products,
women’s hygiene products, the food industry, paints, cosmetics,
medical devices, sunscreen, biosensors, clothing, and electronics.[1−6] However, this increased use of Ag-NP-improved products may cause
an increase in the toxicity level, affecting both the environment
and living organisms because a significant amount as Ag-NPs or Ag+ ions may be released in natural settings,[3−7] but little is known about the diversified mechanisms
of action of the cytotoxicity of Ag-NPs, as well as their short- or
long-term exposure outcomes, on living organisms and/or human physiology.[3−5] The antimicrobial activity of silver is mainly attributed to silver
ions, which are released from silver-containing compounds and interact
with the thiol groups of enzymes and proteins that support microbial
life, thus affecting cell respiration and killing the cells. This
antimicrobial activity may be impacted/decreased by the presence of
halide ions (Cl, F, ...) that react easily with silver ions forming
precipitates.[3,4] Therefore, the antimicrobial activity
of free silver ions is very short when they are used alone. To overcome
this issue, silver nanoparticles (Ag-NPs) and Ag-NPs-containing composites
have recently been developed. From these materials, silver ions are
gradually released, thereby providing antimicrobial activity.[3−5] In this way, to prepare the antimicrobial silver-treated textile
fibers, many authors have focused their attention on the process of
preparation of silver nanoparticles with controlled size and on developing
methods to attach the Ag-NPs not only on the surface of fibers but
also inside them.[8−15] Generally, Ag-NPs have low energetic adherence onto fibers when
they are produced ex situ and inserted physically or by using conventional
physicochemical methods (e.g., pad-dry cure method). In order to overcome
this recurrent problem of adherence, the in situ formation of Ag-NPs
in textile fibers is also being developed.[8,9,12] Many other studies have been focused on
the surface examination using the modern instrumental methods and
compared to conventional antibacterial efficacy as well as to its
durability against multiple washings in the alkaline bath (detergents
with or without oxidants).[5,6,16−22] The current study reports more fundamental research on the in situ
formation of silver nanoparticles (Ag-NPs) onto/into five textile
fibers (cotton (untreated and chemically bleached), sheep’s
wool, polyamide, and polyester) with different surface properties,
such as hydrophobicity, roughness, and porosity. Herein, two sequential
reaction steps were performed: first, the fibers were immersed in
a silver ion solution (1 g/L of AgNO3) for ion saturation
followed by draining fibers and their reimmersion this time in a strong
chemical reducing solution (0.25 g/L of NaBH4). This latter
step leads to the in situ formation of Ag-NPs (<50 nm), average
size and surface covering concentration depend on the fiber kind as
deduced from FESEM images. NaBH4 have strong reduction
potential, and then it allows instantaneous in situ formation of Ag-NPs
onto/into fibers at room temperature without the requirement of additional
thermal treatment as documented in the literature, but several other
reducing agents exist and have been investigated.[2,23,24] In complement, all textile fibers containing
Ag-NPs were submitted to interact with strong oxidants in an aqueous
media (7.5% v/v of H2O2 and 0.5 M of HNO3) using flow-through reactor experiments in order to determine
if textile fiber kind plays a significant role on the oxidation rate
of adhered Ag-NPs under extreme conditions. This unconventional method
allows then a fast assessment of the oxidative dissolution rate of
Ag-NPs adhered/inserted by the same in situ chemical reduction method
in different textile fibers. Moreover, under these extreme oxidative
conditions, the surface of fibers is expected to be rapidly altered
similarly to multiple washing cycles. Concentration of Ag in textile
fibers and in sampled solutions during flow-through reactor experiments
was quantified by ICP-AES analysis. Conventional biotests using the Bacillus subtilis strain for all textile fibers containing
Ag-NPs were also performed.
Results and Discussion
In situ formation
of Ag-NPs was investigated by chemical reduction
of silver ions initially saturating five different textile fibers
(see overall reduction of reaction in the Materials and Methods section). As expected, average size of Ag-NPs, aggregation degree,
and surface covering concentration depend strongly on the textile
fiber nature as revealed here by FESEM images.
Untreated Cotton versus
Bleached Cotton
The insertion
of Ag-NPs onto cotton fibers has been widely investigated, particularly
using cotton fabrics and using various physicochemical methods.[8,12,16] Herein, the low adherence of
Ag-NPs onto cotton fibers remains the main limitation because a significant
number of Ag-NPs can be released in the first washing cycles.[18,22] In the present study, untreated cotton (initially hydrophobic fibers)
and bleached cotton (hydrophilic fibers available in pharmacies) were
preferentially used in order to determine the role of initial surface
properties. At a micrometric scale, the fibers seem very similar in
texture (shape and rugosity). Conversely, at a nanometric scale, the
bleached cotton seems porous and with higher rugosity (see Figure ). These different
surface properties have constrained the surface covering concentration
and aggregation degree of in situ formed Ag-NPs. In both cases, very
fine Ag-NPs (size < 20 nm) were in situ formed, but high aggregation
degree and higher surface covering concentration were observed for
untreated cotton from FESEM images (Figure ). Quantitative measurements by ICP-AES of
digested fibers containing Ag-NPs have confirmed a higher silver concentration
for untreated cotton (2.3 mg of Ag/g of cotton) and only 1 mg/g for
bleached cotton. This surprising result is probably related to the
lower adherence of Ag-NPs onto bleached cotton as suspected during
the washing step of fibers with ultrapure water where more washing
times were required to remove unadhered Ag-NPs with respect to all
other investigated fiber kinds (see also Figure S1). However, biotests based on Bacillus subtilis growth inhibition on agar plates reveal equivalent biocidal potential
of the impregnated fibers at 24 and 48 h, but untreated cotton had
a stronger biocidal effect than bleached cotton at 72 h as summarized
in Figure . This means
that Ag-NP concentration can play a significant role in longer durations.
Ag-NPs’ antimicrobial property is mainly mediated by released
Ag+ ions from Ag-NPs, which penetrate bacterial cells and
inhibit the cell metabolism as widely described in specialized studies.[25,26]
Figure 1
FESEM
images at three different magnifications showing size, shape,
aggregation degree, and 2D distribution of in situ formed Ag-NPs onto
untreated and bleached cotton fibers. Ag-NPs concentration was also
determined by ICP-AES in digested fibers containing Ag-NPs as explained
in the Materials and Methods section.
Figure 2
Evaluation of the biocidal properties of the fibers using
a biotest
after 24, 48, and 72 h of contact with the pellet (A, B, and C, respectively).
Representative photos of the agar plate with pellets of impregnated
polyamide and bleached cotton and their inhibition halo, and of the
agar plate with control cotton are shown.
FESEM
images at three different magnifications showing size, shape,
aggregation degree, and 2D distribution of in situ formed Ag-NPs onto
untreated and bleached cotton fibers. Ag-NPs concentration was also
determined by ICP-AES in digested fibers containing Ag-NPs as explained
in the Materials and Methods section.Evaluation of the biocidal properties of the fibers using
a biotest
after 24, 48, and 72 h of contact with the pellet (A, B, and C, respectively).
Representative photos of the agar plate with pellets of impregnated
polyamide and bleached cotton and their inhibition halo, and of the
agar plate with control cotton are shown.The developing methods to attach the Ag-NPs not only on the surface
of fibers but also inside them remain an important challenge. In this
way, cross sections of bleached cotton were prepared and observed
by FESEM, which confirms the formation of Ag-NPs inside of the fibers
(see Figure ). Here,
isolated nanoparticles with regular size (<20 nm) and spherical
shape were homogeneously inserted into the cotton fibers. Similar
results may be expected in other natural porous fibers, such as wool,
silk, and cellulose, by using our in situ formation method. However,
a deeper investigation on the Ag-NPs’ adherence and reactivity
remains to be performed in the future. In the present study, for example,
the bleached cotton allows better distribution of isolated Ag-NPs
onto and inside the fibers; however, lower adherence is suspected
because using identical chemical treatment and the same mother solutions,
the untreated cotton has sequestered a higher number of Ag-NPs as
revealed by FESEM images and quantified by ICP-AES. This means that
the conventional bleaching treatment in cotton fibers have modified
the surface functionality to bond the Ag-NPs.
Figure 3
FESEM images of a given
cross section for bleached cotton showing
that the Ag-NPs were also formed inside of the fiber.
FESEM images of a given
cross section for bleached cotton showing
that the Ag-NPs were also formed inside of the fiber.The reactivity of adhered Ag-NPs in strong oxidant solutions
was
also investigated by using flow-through reactor experiments (see Figure S2). Herein, the oxidative dissolution
rate is directly proportional to the outlet concentration of Ag (see
eq ). The obtained breakthrough
curves for bleached cotton have revealed that the oxidative dissolution
rate of adhered Ag-NPs (ionic release) is 3–4 times higher
in oxygenated water (7.5% v/v) than in nitric acid (0.5 M) (see Figure ). In both cases,
the Ag release (outlet concentration) tends toward zero after 24 h
(Ag outlet concentration = 0.017 mg/L in nitric acid and 0.002 mg/L
in oxygenated water). This means that the initially available Ag-NPs
are almost completely dissolved in the system. Conversely, the Ag-NPs
adhered onto untreated cotton are slowly dissolved in oxygenated water
reaching a steady state (dissolution rate, r = 1.6945
× 10–6 mol/g min) after about 20 h of continuous
solution percolation; however, they are highly dissolved in nitric
acid solution reaching a maximum dissolution rate after 2 h (r = 1.5474 × 10–5 mol/g min) and
a steady state (r = 5.3750 × 10–7 mol/g min) after about 20 h of continuous solution percolation in
the system (Figure ). These interesting results have revealed that the reactivity of
in situ formed Ag-NPs onto cotton fibers depends on the initial textural
and physicochemical properties of fibers. Based on these results,
we conclude that untreated cotton fibers offer a better option to
insert Ag-NPs by in situ chemical reduction of silver ions in a safety-design
perspective. We note that the investigated oxidative conditions (extremes)
and our experimental setup have not represented realistic reactive
scenarios with respect to durability and release of Ag-NPs from textile
commercialized fabrics, but our approach allows a simple assessment
of the oxidative dissolution rate of Ag-NPs directly related to the
initial textural and physicochemical properties of textile fibers.
Based on these above results, we claim that the ionic release of Ag
and AgNPs detachment can strongly depend on surface physicochemical
properties as confirmed in the following other cases.
Figure 4
Breakthrough curves showing
the oxidative release of Ag as a function
of time obtained from flow-through reactor experiments. Inlet solutions:
ultrapure water (control), oxygenated water (7.5% v/v), and nitric
acid solution (0.5 M); Ag-NPs adhered onto bleached and untreated
cotton fibers, flow rate of 1 mL/min and Ag outlet concentration measured
by ICP-AES.
Breakthrough curves showing
the oxidative release of Ag as a function
of time obtained from flow-through reactor experiments. Inlet solutions:
ultrapure water (control), oxygenated water (7.5% v/v), and nitric
acid solution (0.5 M); Ag-NPs adhered onto bleached and untreated
cotton fibers, flow rate of 1 mL/min and Ag outlet concentration measured
by ICP-AES.
Sheep’s Wool
Commercial sheep’s wool
fibers have high rugosity and seem porous at a nanometric scale (see Figure ). These textural
surface properties have allowed an extraordinary adherence of in situ
formed Ag-NPs as revealed from FESEM images. Here, very fine spherical
Ag-NPs (size < 20 nm) were homogeneously precipitated with a low
aggregation degree and with high surface covering concentration (Figure ). The high Ag-NP
concentration was confirmed by ICP-AES analysis in digested Ag-containing
fibers (10 mg/g), i.e., 10 times more concentrated than bleached cotton
and about four times more concentrated than untreated cotton. In summary,
wool fibers have ideal surface properties to successfully insert Ag-NPs
with high physicochemical adherence by using our in situ chemical
reduction method. The high physicochemical adherence of in situ formed
Ag-NPs may be related to the strong chemical affinity of Ag ions into
wool fibers, i.e., a strong attachment with pre-existent functionalized
groups (carboxyl (−COOH), amino (−NH2), and
hydroxyl (−OH)) before its in situ chemical reduction as already
invoked by Mahmud et al.[10] In this way,
the ATR-FTIR analysis of five wool samples, pure and subject to oxidant
solutions, are shown in Figure S3 of the
Supporting Information. Results for the Ag-free wool and Ag-rich wool
are shown in Figure . Here, the ATR-FTIR spectrum of Ag-free wool shows a broad peak
around 3250 cm–1 corresponding to stretching O–H
modes of adsorbed water and a set of vibrational modes characteristic
of keratin, the main protein in wool: −CH2 and −CH3 stretching vibrations of the polypeptide backbone of the
fibers; −CH2 at 1620 cm–1 (amide
I); C–N stretching and N–H bending at 1520 cm–1 (amide II); and C–N, C–O stretching, and N–H
bending at 1230 cm–1 (amide III).[27−29] The peak at
1040 cm–1 corresponds to a stretching vibrational
mode of cysteine oxides.[27]
Figure 5
FESEM images at three
different magnifications showing size, shape,
aggregation degree, and 2D distribution of in situ formed Ag-NPs onto
commercial sheep’s wool fiber. Ag-NPs concentration was also
determined by ICP-AES in digested fibers containing Ag-NPs as explained
in the Material and Methods section.
Figure 6
ATR-FTIR spectra for Ag-free wool and wool containing
Ag-NPs. −CH2 and −CH3 stretching
bands at 2850 and 2920
cm–1; −CH2 at 1620 (amide I),
C–N stretching, and N–H bending at 1520 cm–1 (amide II); and C–N, C–O stretching, and N–H
bending at 1230 cm–1 (amide III). The peak at 1040
cm–1 corresponds to a stretching vibrational mode
of cysteine oxides.
FESEM images at three
different magnifications showing size, shape,
aggregation degree, and 2D distribution of in situ formed Ag-NPs onto
commercial sheep’s wool fiber. Ag-NPs concentration was also
determined by ICP-AES in digested fibers containing Ag-NPs as explained
in the Material and Methods section.ATR-FTIR spectra for Ag-free wool and wool containing
Ag-NPs. −CH2 and −CH3 stretching
bands at 2850 and 2920
cm–1; −CH2 at 1620 (amide I),
C–N stretching, and N–H bending at 1520 cm–1 (amide II); and C–N, C–O stretching, and N–H
bending at 1230 cm–1 (amide III). The peak at 1040
cm–1 corresponds to a stretching vibrational mode
of cysteine oxides.Upon in situ deposition
of Ag-NPs and washing with water, three
main changes are observed in the ATR-FTIR spectra:The −CH2 and −CH3 stretching bands at 2850 and 2920
cm–1 decrease
in intensity. The band at 2920 cm–1 is shifted to
2930 cm–1.The intensity of the bands at 1415
cm–1 and 1195 cm–1, corresponding
to the amide II region, decrease in intensity.The peak at 1024 cm–1 disappears. This peak has been attributed to stretching vibrations
in cysteine-s-sulphonate groups, present in keratin.[27] Other studies have also identified this group in residues
from Bunte salts that are used as coatings of the wool fibers.[30]Overall, these
results point to Ag-NPs and polypeptide interactions,
with little interaction with the amide components, suggesting noncomplexing
interactions between the nanoparticles and the keratin fibers.Additionally, flow-through reactor experiments have revealed undetected
reactivity of Ag-NPs when ultrapure water was percolated in the system
(see Figure ). This
means that Ag-NPs were successfully attached onto/into wool surfaces.
Concerning the strong oxidant solutions, the oxidative dissolution
rate of Ag-NPs depends on the concentration and chemical nature of
the oxidant solutions (see Figure ). In general, higher dissolution rates were measured
in the first 5 h of continuous percolation, reaching a steady state
after about 20 h. In chronological order, the Ag-NPs adhered/inserted
in wool fibers are most reactive in oxygenated water (2.1037 ×
10–6 mol/g min) followed by nitric acid (6.5319
× 10–7 mol/g min for 0.5 M of HNO3), and (5.3750 × 10–7 mol/g min for 0.05 M
of HNO3). This unconventional assessment suggests that
the wool fibers offer an excellent potential to adhere Ag-NPs by a
simple in situ chemical reduction method as also supported by FTIR
results in this study. This suggests that the Ag release from doped
wool fibers is related only to the silver oxidation process and the
particulate detachment will be minimized despite the physicochemical
alteration of fibers as illustrated on FESEM images obtained after
the flow-through reactor experiment (Figure ). Herein, FESEM images have revealed localized
physicochemical alteration of fibers (bleaching and cracking in oxygenated
water) and localized/zoned reactivity of Ag-NPs. This is probably
related to different bond forces that is exerted by different existent
functionalized groups, such as carboxyl (−COOH), amino (−NH2),
and hydroxyl (−OH),[10] as suspected
from FTIR measurements where alteration of wool fibers was also detected
(see Figure S3).
Figure 7
Breakthrough curves showing
the oxidative release of Ag as a function
of time obtained from flow-through reactor experiments. Inlet solutions:
ultrapure water (control), oxygenated water (7.5% v/v), and nitric
acid solutions (0.5 and 0.05 M); Ag-NPs adhered onto sheep’s
wool fibers, flow rate of 1 mL/min and Ag outlet concentration measured
by ICP-AES.
Figure 8
FESEM images at two different magnifications
showing sheep’s
wool fiber after flow-through reactor experiment with oxygenated water
(7.5% v/v). The high concentration of Ag-NPs remains still adhered
onto fiber despite the surface fiber alteration.
Breakthrough curves showing
the oxidative release of Ag as a function
of time obtained from flow-through reactor experiments. Inlet solutions:
ultrapure water (control), oxygenated water (7.5% v/v), and nitric
acid solutions (0.5 and 0.05 M); Ag-NPs adhered onto sheep’s
wool fibers, flow rate of 1 mL/min and Ag outlet concentration measured
by ICP-AES.FESEM images at two different magnifications
showing sheep’s
wool fiber after flow-through reactor experiment with oxygenated water
(7.5% v/v). The high concentration of Ag-NPs remains still adhered
onto fiber despite the surface fiber alteration.
Polyamide versus Polyester
Polyamide and polyester
textile fibers are nonporous, and they have lower roughness at a nanometric
scale with respect to natural textile fibers (see Figure ). Moreover, they have typically
low hydrophilic properties (fast expelling of water). Despite these
surface properties, a significant number of Ag-NPs were adhered onto
these synthetic textile fibers by in situ chemical reduction of Ag
ions. For polyamide, the Ag-NPs were preferentially nucleated in the
continuous cavities on the fiber, leading to oriented nucleation of
Ag-NPs with spherical shape and small size (<20 nm). High surface
covering concentration was then observed on the curved longitudinal
cavities, but scarce Ag-NPs were nucleated and attached on the little
rough surfaces (see Figure ). Quantitative measurements by ICP-AES in digested Ag-containing
polyamide fibers have revealed 0.62 mg of Ag/g of fibers, this agrees
with FESEM observations. Conversely, the Ag-NPs have lower adherence
onto the surface of polyester fibers. Here, the identified surface
cavities are not necessarily reactive sites because the heterogeneous
nucleation of Ag-NPs seems to be mainly associated to roughness (see Figure ). In this case,
lower surface covering concentration was identified from FESEM images
with respect to polyamide and natural fibers. This agrees with quantitative
results from ICP-AES analysis that reveals only 0.28 mg of Ag/g of
polyester fibers. In summary, synthetic textile fibers offer poor
surface properties to insert Ag-NPs with strong adherence by in situ
chemical reduction of silver ions. For this reason, the insertion
of high concentration (>1%) of Ag-NPs in synthetic textile fibers
with antimicrobial properties is typically fabricated by using an
electrospinning production method where generally the Ag-NPs are added
into polymer solutions or polymer melts that are then injected and
subjected to an electric force.[31−34]
Figure 9
FESEM images at three different magnifications showing
size, shape,
aggregation degree, and 2D distribution of in situ formed Ag-NPs onto
polyamide and polyester fibers. Ag-NPs concentration was also determined
by ICP-AES in digested fibers containing Ag-NPs as explained in the Material and Methods section.
FESEM images at three different magnifications showing
size, shape,
aggregation degree, and 2D distribution of in situ formed Ag-NPs onto
polyamide and polyester fibers. Ag-NPs concentration was also determined
by ICP-AES in digested fibers containing Ag-NPs as explained in the Material and Methods section.Obviously, the investigated synthetic fibers have offered poor
textural properties to adhere effectively the Ag-NPs by using our
in situ chemical formation method. For example, polyamide fibers have
adhered 0.62 mg of Ag/g of polyamide fibers (see also Figure ). This represent a non-negligible
amount, but a lower adherence force between Ag-NPs and polyamide fibers
is suspected because detectable Ag concentration (0.013 mg/L) was
measured in outlet solution after 10 min when ultrapure water was
percolated; this is probably related to particulate detachment. This
disagrees with all other experiments performed with ultrapure water
concerning cotton and wool fibers where an undetected Ag signal was
measured. In addition, a fast oxidative dissolution rate (2.6077 ×
10–5 mol/g min) was also measured in the first 10
min when nitric acid solution was percolated; then, the Ag release
decreases abruptly and tends toward zero (0.029 mg/L) after 24 h (see Figure ). These results
suggest that in the first hour, the measured Ag in outlet solutions
may be a contribution of detached Ag-NPs and ionic Ag. Then, the kinetic
oxidative dissolution follows similar behavior to Ag-NPs adhered on
the bleached cotton fibers (Figure ).
Figure 10
Breakthrough curves showing the oxidative release of Ag
as a function
of time obtained from flow-through reactor experiments. Comparison
of reactivities between polyamide and bleached cotton in nitric acid.
Inlet solutions: ultrapure water (control) in a polyamide system and
nitric acid solutions (0.5 M) in polyamide and bleached cotton; flow
rate of 1 mL/min and Ag outlet concentration measured by ICP-AES.
Breakthrough curves showing the oxidative release of Ag
as a function
of time obtained from flow-through reactor experiments. Comparison
of reactivities between polyamide and bleached cotton in nitric acid.
Inlet solutions: ultrapure water (control) in a polyamide system and
nitric acid solutions (0.5 M) in polyamide and bleached cotton; flow
rate of 1 mL/min and Ag outlet concentration measured by ICP-AES.In summary, natural textile fibers offer better
surface textural
and physicochemical properties to adhere/insert Ag-NPs by in situ
chemical reduction of silver ions with respect to synthetic fibers.
However, a conventional biotest based on Bacillus subtilis growth inhibition on agar plates confirmed the biocidal properties
for all impregnated fibers compared to the control (Figure . In general, at 24 and 48
h, no significant difference was observed between the fibers, whereas
at 72 h, polyester and untreated cotton had a stronger biocidal effect
than polyamide and bleached cotton was intermediate.
Conclusions
We report that the in situ formation of silver nanoparticles (Ag-NPs)
onto textile fibers by chemical reduction of sequestered Ag ions can
be a powerful chemical method to adhere/insert Ag-NPs onto/into textile
fibers in a successfully safety-design perspective. Herein, the wool
fibers offer the best effectiveness to adhere Ag-NPs (10 mg/g) followed
by the untreated cotton 2.3 mg/g > bleached cotton 1 mg/g >
polyamide
0.62 mg/g > polyester 0.28 mg/g. In all cases, spherical Ag-NPs
(size
< 20 nm) were formed when their aggregation degree and surface
covering concentration was controlled by pre-existent surface and
physicochemical properties, such as hydrophilicity, roughness, porosity,
functionality, etc. All fibers containing Ag-NPs provide biocide properties,
but the ionic Ag release and Ag nanoparticle detachment depend strongly
of the fiber nature. For example, Ag-NPs interactions with strong
oxidant solutions by using flow-through reactor experiments suggest
an effective adherence of Ag-NPs onto fibers and controlled ionic
release for natural fibers, particularly for wool and untreated cotton,
because low oxidative dissolution rates (an order of 1 × 10–7 mol/g min) were determined when the steady state
is reached under extreme oxidant conditions. This can ensure an optimized
durability and antimicrobial effectiveness of textile fibers. However,
as commented in the introduction, several unknown risks exist on the
release and fate of Ag-NPs and Ag ions in natural settings. In this
way, we suggest that the use of Ag-NPs onto/into natural and/or synthetic
fibers with antimicrobial activity should be limited to specific essential
applications, such as medical devices and healthcare worker protection
rather than an extended application to not essential applications
such as sport clothings for example.
Materials and Methods
In Situ
Formation of Ag-NPs onto Textile Fibers
Three
grams of five commercial textile fibers (untreated cotton (hydrophobic),
chemically bleached cotton (hydrophilic), sheep’s wool (hydrophobic),
polyamide (from sport socks), and polyester (from sport hat)) were
initially immersed in 250 mL of AgNO3 solution (1 g/L)
for 24 h. This simple treatment allows the silver ion saturation of
fibers. Then, the fibers are manually drained and immersed in 250
mL of NaBH4 reducing solution (250 mg/L). Instantaneous
silver reduction was attested by a color change from uncolored to
black; the overall redox reaction may be written as follows:The interaction system
was
arbitrary prolonged for 24 h at room temperature (∼20 °C)
in order to ensure a total silver reduction and equilibration of the
system (nucleation and maturation of particles). Then, the fibers
were recovered and washed various times with ultrapure water (18.2
MΩ of resistivity) in order to remove all no-adhered Ag-NPs
(Figure S1). Finally, the fibers were drained,
dried at 60 °C for 72 h, and stored for subsequent characterization
and experiments.
FESEM Observations
All fiber samples
were carefully
attached on double-sided conductive adhesive supported in aluminum
SEM supports and coated with gold–platinum (Au–Pt).
The shape and size of crystals and their 2D distribution onto fibers
were then observed by using a Zeiss Ultra 55 field emission gun scanning
electron microscope (FESEM) with a maximum spatial resolution of approximately
1 nm at 15 kV.In addition, some cotton fibers were immerged
in epoxy resin and finally sectioned and polished transversally in
order to determine if Ag-NPs are also formed inside of fibers.
Total
Ag Content in Fibers
About 30–40 mg (in
triplicate) of each fiber containing adhered Ag-NPs were digested
(total dissolution) by adding 15 mL of ultrapure HNO3 at
70% and heated at 180 °C for 20 min in a microwave system (Novawave,
SCP Sciences). Samples were then diluted by the addition of 10 mL
of ultrapure water. ICP-AES measurements were performed by using a
Varian 720ES at ISTerre, using the Ag lines at 328 and 338 nm.
Reactivity
of Adhered Ag-NPs in Strong Oxidant Solutions
To track the
oxidation rate of adhered Ag-NPs on textile fibers under
extreme conditions, one stirred flow-through reactor was used. Herein,
0.7 g of a given fiber containing Ag-NPs were placed in the reactor
of 50 mL (internal volume), and it was first filled with ultrapure
water (18.2 MΩ). Then, flow rate calibration and washing during
10–20 min using a peristaltic pump, a given oxidant solution
(7.5% v/v of H2O2, 0.5 M of HNO3 or
ultrapure water (18.2 MΩ)) was percolated in the reactor using
a constant flow rate of 1 mL/min (Q). The interacting solution in
the reactor was continuously stirred (150 rpm) by a magnetic Teflon
bar at room temperature (∼20 °C). The outflow solution
was filtered in situ through a 0.2 μm pore size Teflon membrane
(located on the top of the reactor); the experimental setup is illustrated
in Figure S2. The filtered solutions at
various times (10, 30, 60, 120, 180, ..., 1440 min) of the experiment
were then analyzed by ICP-AES by using a Varian 720ES at ISTerre.The inlet strong oxidant solution does not contain dissolved silver
ions; in this case, the silver concentration in the outflow solution,
[Ag]out, provides a direct measure of the rate of Ag-NP
dissolution when a steady state is reached.where the rate, r, may be given in mol/g min. In
our case, the available amount of
Ag into the reactor can be a limiting factor, which means the available
number of Ag-NPs could be completely removed from the system by oxidative
dissolution when [Ag]out tends toward 0.
Characterization
of the Biocidal Properties of the Ag-Impregnated
Fibers
Biotests using the Bacillus subtilis strain (3610 strain, wild type, personal gift by Maria Laaberki)
were realized to evaluate the biocidal properties of the impregnated
fibers. The cells were grown in an LB medium: 10 g/L tryptone, 5 g/L
yeast extract, and 5 g/L NaCl. A 3610 Bacillus subtilis culture grown overnight on liquid LB at 37 °C was diluted to
A600nm = 0.1 in 10 mL of a fresh LB medium and incubated at 37 °C
and 200 rpm until the A600nm reached the exponential phase (∼0.6).
An amount of 300 μL of this culture (or 108 cells) was applied
uniformly on the surface of an LB agar plate (22 mL of LB agar). Pellets
of uniform size and weight (5 mm, 11 ± 1 mg) were pressed for
each type of fiber impregnated with Ag (four replicates per type of
fiber). The wool was not included in the test because the pellets
lost their shape and the fibers unwound on the agar plate. Hydrophilic
cotton was used as a negative control. Pellets were placed on the
agar plate, and after 24, 48, and 72 h at 30 °C, the average
diameter of the inhibition zone was measured. The biocide effect is
evaluated by the diameter of the inhibition halos, normalized with
respect to the diameter of the pellet size (5 mm). The significance
of differences between treatments was assessed using a general linear
model followed by a post hoc Tukey test using the software SPSS version
19.0.
FTIR Measurements
Five wool samples, wool without Ag-NPs
(ref), wool–Ag-NPs washed with ultrapure water, and wool–Ag-NPs
subjected to different oxidant solutions (0.05 and 0.5 M of HNO3 and 7.5% v/v of H2O2), were characterized
by FTIR. Herein, solid wool samples were analyzed using a Thermo Fisher
IS50 Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) instrument, with
a single-reflection diamond attenuated total reflection (ATR) crystal,
located at ISTerre (Grenoble, France). ATR-FTIR spectra were collected
using a resolution of 4 cm–1 and averaging 64 spectra
in the wavenumber range of 4000–400 cm–1.
Authors: Jicheng Feng; Esther Hontañón; Maria Blanes; Jörg Meyer; Xiaoai Guo; Laura Santos; Laura Paltrinieri; Nabil Ramlawi; Louis C P M de Smet; Hermann Nirschl; Frank Einar Kruis; Andreas Schmidt-Ott; George Biskos Journal: ACS Appl Mater Interfaces Date: 2016-06-03 Impact factor: 9.229
Authors: C Lorenz; L Windler; N von Goetz; R P Lehmann; M Schuppler; K Hungerbühler; M Heuberger; B Nowack Journal: Chemosphere Date: 2012-06-06 Impact factor: 7.086
Authors: Aleksandr B Stefaniak; Mathew G Duling; Robert B Lawrence; Treye A Thomas; Ryan F LeBouf; Eleanor E Wade; M Abbas Virji Journal: Int J Occup Environ Health Date: 2014 Jul-Sep