Saija M Hyvonen1, Jouni J Lohi2, Leena A Rasanen3, Tuula Heinonen4, Marika Mannerstrom4, Kirsi Vaali5, Tamara Tuuminen6. 1. Medical Faculty, Turku University Finland. 2. Department of Pathology, Lapland Central Hospital Rovaniemi, Ounasrinteentie 22, Rovaniemi 84100, Finland. 3. Co-op Bionautit Viikinkaari 9, Helsinki 00790, Finland. 4. FICAM, The Faculty of Medicine and Health Technology, Arvo Ylpön katu 1, University of Tampere Tampere 33014, Finland. 5. SelexLab Kalevankatu 20, Helsinki 00100, Finland. 6. Kruunuhaka Medical Center Kaisaniemenkatu 1 B, Helsinki 00100, Finland.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: There is an on-going debate on how best to test toxic indoor air. Toxicological methods based on condensed water samples and cell culture technique are newly introduced research tools which were tested in this study. METHODS: Pupils (n=47) from a water-damaged and (n=56) healthy schools were interviewed using a questionnaire. Indoor air was collected with a novel condensed water sampling technique and human THP-1 macrophages were exposed to the condensate. The cytotoxicity of cotton wool swab samples was tested using human BJ fibroblasts. Conventional microbiological culture methods were also performed. RESULTS: Gastrointestinal problems (GI) were reported by 51% from the study cohort but only 4% of the control cohort, relative risk RR=14.30. For any neurological or neuropsychological symptoms, the RR was 63.04, muscular-skeletal pain RR=58.28, headache RR=31.00, respiratory symptoms RR=22.64, fatigue RR=21.45, sub febrility RR=15.49, ear infections RR=7.74, skin rash RR=5.96, all being statistically significant (P<0.001). All indoor air (n=7) and cotton wool samples (n=2) taken from the water-damaged classroom or in proximity of the problematic classrooms were toxic in cell culture assays. Low numbers of moisture-damage indicators were recovered from wall, passive air, and swab samples, namely Aspergillus ochraceus species group, Aspergillus, Eurotium species group, Fusarium, Tritirachium, Scopulariopsis genus group and Aspergillus versicolores species group. CONCLUSIONS: Indoor air toxicity and dampness-related microbiota recovered from the classrooms were associated with multi-organ morbidity of the school occupants. These results corroborated our previous reports from two adult cohorts i.e. evidence of causality. These new toxicological methods based on condensed water and cell culturing techniques seem to be superior to conventional microbiological methods in correlating with clinical symptoms. AJCEI
BACKGROUND: There is an on-going debate on how best to test toxic indoor air. Toxicological methods based on condensed water samples and cell culture technique are newly introduced research tools which were tested in this study. METHODS: Pupils (n=47) from a water-damaged and (n=56) healthy schools were interviewed using a questionnaire. Indoor air was collected with a novel condensed water sampling technique and humanTHP-1 macrophages were exposed to the condensate. The cytotoxicity of cotton wool swab samples was tested using humanBJ fibroblasts. Conventional microbiological culture methods were also performed. RESULTS: Gastrointestinal problems (GI) were reported by 51% from the study cohort but only 4% of the control cohort, relative risk RR=14.30. For any neurological or neuropsychological symptoms, the RR was 63.04, muscular-skeletal pain RR=58.28, headache RR=31.00, respiratory symptoms RR=22.64, fatigue RR=21.45, sub febrility RR=15.49, ear infections RR=7.74, skin rash RR=5.96, all being statistically significant (P<0.001). All indoor air (n=7) and cotton wool samples (n=2) taken from the water-damaged classroom or in proximity of the problematic classrooms were toxic in cell culture assays. Low numbers of moisture-damage indicators were recovered from wall, passive air, and swab samples, namely Aspergillus ochraceus species group, Aspergillus, Eurotium species group, Fusarium, Tritirachium, Scopulariopsis genus group and Aspergillus versicolores species group. CONCLUSIONS: Indoor air toxicity and dampness-related microbiota recovered from the classrooms were associated with multi-organ morbidity of the school occupants. These results corroborated our previous reports from two adult cohorts i.e. evidence of causality. These new toxicological methods based on condensed water and cell culturing techniques seem to be superior to conventional microbiological methods in correlating with clinical symptoms. AJCEI
Authors: J Peltola; M A Andersson; T Haahtela; H Mussalo-Rauhamaa; F A Rainey; R M Kroppenstedt; R A Samson; M S Salkinoja-Salonen Journal: Appl Environ Microbiol Date: 2001-07 Impact factor: 4.792
Authors: J H Jacobs; E J M Krop; A Borras-Santos; J-P Zock; M Taubel; A Hyvarinnen; J Pekkanen; G Doekes; D J J Heederik Journal: Indoor Air Date: 2013-09-23 Impact factor: 5.770
Authors: J Rosbach; E Krop; M Vonk; J van Ginkel; C Meliefste; S de Wind; U Gehring; B Brunekreef Journal: Indoor Air Date: 2015-08-04 Impact factor: 5.770
Authors: José Jacobs; Alicia Borràs-Santos; Esmeralda Krop; Martin Täubel; Hanna Leppänen; Ulla Haverinen-Shaughnessy; Juha Pekkanen; Anne Hyvärinen; Gert Doekes; Jan-Paul Zock; Dick Heederik Journal: Occup Environ Med Date: 2014-07-17 Impact factor: 4.402
Authors: K Huttunen; J Tirkkonen; M Täubel; E Krop; S Mikkonen; J Pekkanen; D Heederik; J-P Zock; A Hyvärinen; M-R Hirvonen Journal: Indoor Air Date: 2015-06-03 Impact factor: 5.770