Matthew C Nali1,2, Vidya Purushothaman2,3, Qing Xu1,4, Raphael E Cuomo1,2,4, Timothy K Mackey1,2,4,5. 1. Global Health Policy Institute, San Diego, United States. 2. Department of Anesthesiology, University of California San Diego School of Medicine, San Diego, United States. 3. Master's Program in Public Health, University of California San Diego School of Medicine, San Diego, United States. 4. Department of Healthcare Research and Policy, University of California San Diego - Extension, San Diego, United States. 5. Division of Infectious Diseases and Global Public Health, Department of Medicine, University of California San Diego School of Medicine, San Diego, United States.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Recent reports of lung injury associated with Electronic Nicotine Delivery System (ENDS) products precipitated by increasing vaping prevalence and interest in flavors among adolescents has led to policies that restrict the sale, distribution, and accessibility of ENDS products. This study assessed compliance of online ENDS vendors to the Massachusetts temporary sales ban. METHODS: The study involved structured web surveillance for online ENDS vendors using keyword searches on Google search engine (October to November 2019.) Once vendors were identified, we conducted simulated online purchases, defined as placing an order for an ENDS product by putting it in the website shopping cart without finalizing payment. Simulated purchases and content analysis of websites was conducted to determine compliance characteristics. Fisher's exact test was used to identify associations between compliance and website characteristics such as location and age verification requirements. RESULTS: Simulated online purchases from 50 identified ENDS vendors yielded 72% (n=36) stores that were non-compliant and allowed placement of ENDS product orders, without restrictions, to a Massachusetts address. The remaining 14 websites had processes in place to prevent orders from buyers located in Massachusetts. Other characteristics of interest, including use of age verification, location data, and web registrar/registrant data were collected and reported. CONCLUSIONS: The September 2019 Massachusetts executive order was a comprehensive ban on selling ENDS products both online and offline. However, our study found that close to three-fourths of the vendors appeared to be non-compliant, indicating that implementation and enforcement are ongoing challenges for future tobacco control efforts on the internet. Policymaking needs to be specifically tailored to address the unique challenges of online environments, particularly in the context of identifying non-compliant sites, ensuring age verification, and addressing non-US sellers.
INTRODUCTION: Recent reports of lung injury associated with Electronic Nicotine Delivery System (ENDS) products precipitated by increasing vaping prevalence and interest in flavors among adolescents has led to policies that restrict the sale, distribution, and accessibility of ENDS products. This study assessed compliance of online ENDS vendors to the Massachusetts temporary sales ban. METHODS: The study involved structured web surveillance for online ENDS vendors using keyword searches on Google search engine (October to November 2019.) Once vendors were identified, we conducted simulated online purchases, defined as placing an order for an ENDS product by putting it in the website shopping cart without finalizing payment. Simulated purchases and content analysis of websites was conducted to determine compliance characteristics. Fisher's exact test was used to identify associations between compliance and website characteristics such as location and age verification requirements. RESULTS: Simulated online purchases from 50 identified ENDS vendors yielded 72% (n=36) stores that were non-compliant and allowed placement of ENDS product orders, without restrictions, to a Massachusetts address. The remaining 14 websites had processes in place to prevent orders from buyers located in Massachusetts. Other characteristics of interest, including use of age verification, location data, and web registrar/registrant data were collected and reported. CONCLUSIONS: The September 2019 Massachusetts executive order was a comprehensive ban on selling ENDS products both online and offline. However, our study found that close to three-fourths of the vendors appeared to be non-compliant, indicating that implementation and enforcement are ongoing challenges for future tobacco control efforts on the internet. Policymaking needs to be specifically tailored to address the unique challenges of online environments, particularly in the context of identifying non-compliant sites, ensuring age verification, and addressing non-US sellers.
Authors: Jamie F Chriqui; Kurt M Ribisl; Raedell M Wallace; Rebecca S Williams; Jean C O'Connor; Regina el Arculli Journal: Nicotine Tob Res Date: 2008-02 Impact factor: 4.244
Authors: Rebecca S Williams; Jason Derrick; Aliza Kate Liebman; Kevin LaFleur; Kurt M Ribisl Journal: Tob Control Date: 2017-05-08 Impact factor: 7.552
Authors: David A Siegel; Tara C Jatlaoui; Emily H Koumans; Emily A Kiernan; Mark Layer; Jordan E Cates; Anne Kimball; David N Weissman; Emily E Petersen; Sarah Reagan-Steiner; Shana Godfred-Cato; Danielle Moulia; Erin Moritz; Jonathan D Lehnert; Jane Mitchko; Joel London; Sherif R Zaki; Brian A King; Christopher M Jones; Anita Patel; Dana Meaney Delman; Ram Koppaka Journal: MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep Date: 2019-10-18 Impact factor: 17.586
Authors: Erin D Moritz; Lauren B Zapata; Akaki Lekiachvili; Emily Glidden; Francis B Annor; Angela K Werner; Emily N Ussery; Michelle M Hughes; Anne Kimball; Carla L DeSisto; Brandon Kenemer; Mays Shamout; Macarena C Garcia; Sarah Reagan-Steiner; Emily E Petersen; Emily H Koumans; Matthew D Ritchey; Brian A King; Christopher M Jones; Peter A Briss; Lisa Delaney; Anita Patel; Kara D Polen; Katie Sives; Dana Meaney-Delman; Kevin Chatham-Stephens Journal: MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep Date: 2019-11-01 Impact factor: 17.586