| Literature DB >> 33436455 |
Justin Lee1, Sergei Muratov2, Jean-Eric Tarride2, J Michael Paterson2, Kednapa Thavorn2, Lawrence Mbuagbaw2, Tara Gomes2, Wayne Khuu2, Hsien Seow2, Lehana Thabane2, Anne Holbrook2.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Health interventions and policies for high-cost health care users (HCUs) who are older adults need to be informed by a better understanding of their multimorbidity and medication use. This study aims to determine the financial contribution of medications to HCU expenditures and explore whether potentially inappropriate prescribing is associated with incident HCU development.Entities:
Year: 2021 PMID: 33436455 PMCID: PMC7843076 DOI: 10.9778/cmajo.20190196
Source DB: PubMed Journal: CMAJ Open ISSN: 2291-0026
Main research questions, hypotheses and outcome measures
| Main research questions | Hypotheses | Study design | Main outcome measures |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. What is the relative financial contribution of prescription medications to incident HCU expenditures and how do they compare with non-HCUs? |
Prescription medication costs will rank within the top 3 cost categories of HCU expenditures Average medication costs (on an individual level) and the proportion of costs attributable to medications (at a population level relative to total costs) are different in HCUs and non-HCUs In a subset of incident HCUs, prescription medication costs alone will be greater than the financial threshold for HCU status | Retrospective matched cohort analysis (HCU status treated as an “exposure”) |
Annual total prescription medication costs (co–primary outcome) Annual drug cost to total health care expenditure ratio (co–primary outcome) Frequency of patient cases in which annual drug costs alone exceeds health expenditure threshold for HCU status |
| 2. What is the relative clinical contribution of prescription medications to incident HCU status? (i.e., Does the quality of medications prescribed and used contribute to differences in health care costs and HCU development?) |
The use of “high quality” medication classes (i.e., those with a strong evidence base for primary or secondary prevention selected a priori for analysis) will be associated with a decreased odds of incident HCU status The use of “potentially inappropriate or high risk” medications selected a priori for analysis will be associated with an increased odds of incident HCU status The use of “high cost (per unit)” medications for recognized indications will be associated with an increased odds of incident HCU status | Case–control analysis (HCU status treated as an outcome) |
Odds ratio of incident HCU status |
| 3. What is the relative difference in clinical profiles of newly incident HCUs v. non-HCUs including diagnoses, medications and prognosis? |
Incident HCUs will have a significantly higher prevalence and baseline burden of chronic condition diagnoses and prescription drug use compared with non-HCUs Incident HCUs will have a significantly higher annual risk of mortality and hospital admissions compared with non-HCUs | Retrospective matched cohort analysis (HCU status treated as an “exposure”) |
Number of Johns Hopkins Adjusted Diagnosis Groups and Expanded Diagnosis Clusters Number of unique prescription drug classes dispensed All-cause mortality rate All-cause hospital admission rate |
| 4. What is the prevalent use of prescription medication classes with a strong evidence base for primary or secondary prevention of complications associated with the most common chronic conditions? |
In the pre-HCU year, the prevalent use of “high quality” prescription medication classes will be lower in HCUs compared with non-HCUs with the relevant associated indications | Retrospective matched cohort analysis (HCU status treated as an “exposure”) |
Prevalent use of “high quality” medication classes selected a priori for analysis Prevalence of relevant chronic condition based on John Hopkins Expanded Diagnosis Clusters and chart-validated ICES chronic disease cohorts |
Note: HCU = high-cost health care user.
Figure 1:Study cohort selection. Note: HCUs = high-cost health care users, LHIN = Local Health Integration Network, OHIP = Ontario Health Insurance Plan.
Health administrative databases
| Health administrative database | Description | Database variables or data used |
|---|---|---|
| Ontario Registered Persons Database (RPDB) | The RPDB records vital statistics, including date of death. |
Date of death Rurality Index Ontario Score Age Sex |
| Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada Permanent Resident Database | The CIC database contains landing records for every permanent legal immigrant to Canada who arrived from 1985 onward. |
Date of landing or immigration |
| Local Health Integration Network (LHIN) database | The LHIN database contains records of the health authorities responsible for the regional administration of public health care services in the province. |
Geographic location of residence of included patients |
| Ontario Drug Benefit (ODB) database | The ODB database contains highly accurate records for outpatient prescriptions dispensed to patients aged 65 yr or older (with error rates reported to be < 1%). |
Prescription drug fill dates and costs Long-term care indicator |
| Canadian Institute for Health Information Discharge Abstract Database (CIHI-DAD) | The CIHI-DAD contains validated patient-level demographic, diagnostic, procedural and treatment information on all acute- and long-term–care hospital admissions. |
ICD-10 codes for hospital discharge diagnoses and Johns Hopkins ACGs and EDCs Hospital admissions (elective and urgent) and costs |
| CIHI — National Ambulatory Care Reporting System (NACRS) database | The CIHI-NACRS database contains patient-level demographic, diagnostic, procedural and treatment information for all hospital-and community-based ambulatory care including day surgery, outpatient and community-based clinics and emergency departments. |
ICD-10 codes for hospital discharge diagnoses and Johns Hopkins ACGs and EDCs Visits and costs |
| CIHI — Same Day Surgery (SDS) | The CIHI-SDS contains patient-level demographic, diagnostic, procedural and treatment information for all day surgeries. |
ICD-10 codes for hospital discharge diagnoses and Johns Hopkins ACGs and EDCs Visits and costs |
| CIHI — National Rehabilitation Reporting System (NRS) | The CIHI-NRS contains patient-level demographic, diagnostic, procedural and treatment information from participating adult inpatient rehabilitation facilities and programs. |
Visits and costs |
| Ontario Home Care Database (HCD) | The Ontario HCD contains patient-level demographic, diagnostic, procedural and treatment information or all home care visits. |
Home care visits Type of home care service provided Visits and costs |
| Ontario Continuing Care Reporting System (CCRS) | The Ontario CCRS contains demographic, clinical, functional and resource use information or patients receiving continuing care services in hospitals or long-term care homes in Canada. |
Visits and costs |
| Ontario Mental Health Reporting System (OMHRS) database | The OMHRS database contains patient-level demographic, diagnostic, procedural and treatment information for all psychiatric facility visits. |
Visits and costs |
| ICES Physician Database (IPDB) | The IPDB reports prescriber and specialist referral and billing data in Ontario. The physician demographic data are validated against the Ontario Physician Human Resource Data Centre database. |
Visits to primary care and specialists |
| Ontario Health Insurance Plan database (OHIP) | The OHIP database includes health claims for physician services. |
ICD-10 codes for hospital discharge diagnoses and Johns Hopkins ACGs and EDCs All health service visits and costs |
| Client Agency Program Enrolment (CAPE) database | The CAPE database contains enrolment information of an individual in a program with a specific practitioner and group. |
Primary care practitioner reimbursement model of included patients |
| ICES-derived cohorts:
Congestive Heart Failure database Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease database Ontario Crohn’s and Colitis Cohort dataset Ontario Diabetes Dataset Ontario Myocardial Infarction Database Dataset Ontario Rheumatoid Arthritis Dataset | The ICES-derived cohorts are chart-validated cohorts of patients with specific diseases and conditions. These cohorts are created using health administrative case definitions that link hospital inpatient and outpatient care, physician claims and drug benefits data over time using an anonymous unique identifier. |
Comorbidities of included patients |
Note: ACG = Adjusted Clinical Group, EDC = Expanded Diagnosis Cluster, ICD-10 = International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, 10th Revision.
Medication classes of interest for patient-level analysis
| High-quality medication use | Potentially inappropriate or high-risk medication use | High-cost drug use |
|---|---|---|
|
Statins β-blockers ACE inhibitors Angiotensin receptor blockers Antiplatelet agents (e.g., ASA, adenosine diphosphosphate inhibitors, platelet aggregation inhibitors) Anticoagulants - Vitamin K antagonists - DOACs — factor Xa inhibitors - DOACs — direct thrombin inhibitors Bisphosphonates Bone calcium regulators (e.g., denosumab) Bronchodilator and anti-inflammatory combination inhalers Long-acting anti-cholinergic inhalers (e.g., tiotropium) |
Proton pump inhibitors Benzodiazepines Narcotics (opiate agonists) Antipsychotics NSAIDs (non-ASA) Digitalis preparations (digoxin) |
Immunosuppressive agents (e.g., mycophenolic acid, natalizumab, sirolimus, tacrolimus, thalidomide) Antineoplastic agents (e.g., tocilizumab, imatinib, dasatinib) Ophthalmologics (e.g., ranibizumab) Biologic response modifying agents (e.g., adalimumab, aldesleukin, certolizumab, etanercept, glatiramer, golimumab, infliximab, interferons, levamisole) |
Note: ACE = angiotensin-converting enzyme, ARB = angiotensin receptor blocker, ASA = acetylsalicylic acid, DOAC = direct oral anticoagulant, NSAID = nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drug.