Alok Gangaramany1, Peter Balvanz2, Margaret Waruguru Gichane2, Stephan Goetschius3, Saransh Sharma3, Krittika Sharma3, Jeff Mulhausen4, Paul Noble-Campbell4, Joyce Wamoyi5, Suzanne Maman2, Ram Prasad3. 1. Final Mile Consulting LLC, 141 W. Jackson Blvd, Suite 3302, Chicago, IL, 60604, USA. alok.gangaramany@thefinalmile.com. 2. Department of Health Behavior, Gillings School of Global Public Health, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 135 Dauer Dr, Chapel Hill, NC, 27599, USA. 3. Final Mile Consulting LLC, 141 W. Jackson Blvd, Suite 3302, Chicago, IL, 60604, USA. 4. Upstream Thinking LLC, 1400 Lavaca Street, 8th Floor, Austin, TX, 78701, USA. 5. National Institute of Medical Research, MITU, Isamilo Street, P.O. Box 11936, Mwanza, Tanzania.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Transactional sexual relationships contribute to a high incidence of HIV infection among adolescent girls and young women (AGYW) living in low-resource settings. Cash transfers (CT) are a structural approach to reduce sexual risk behaviors, but their positive economic effects frequently fade after the program ends. We aimed to understand AGYW's decision-making processes related to sexual, relationship, and financial decisions, in order to design a framework for a CT program that could lead to long-term financial independence and reduced transactional sex among AGYW. METHODS: We conducted qualitative research with AGYW participating in a CT program in Tanzania. Phase one was formative research to understand the context and experiences of AGYW regarding sexual behavior, relationships, and finances. Participants included 36 AGYW (15-23 years old), 15 influencers of AGYW (mothers and male partners) and 10 financially empowered women (FEW - women aged 20-30 with a sustained, reliable source of income independent of their partner). Decisions and decision-making contexts of AGYW that we identified in phase one informed the content of phase two. In phase two we simulated scenarios for decision-making and economic goals with 80 AGYW and 40 FEW, in order to identify key principles or intervention opportunities to guide development of a CT program framework. RESULTS: Through phases one and two of our research we identified three key themes in AGYW's vision of their desired future economic state: 1) positive social image, 2) power balance and respect, and 3) emotional and economic security. An important theme distinguishing AGYW from FEW was that AGYW lacked a vision to build self-agency. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that providing economic resources to AGYW through CT without ensuring self-agency is unlikely to be an effective long-term intervention for economic empowerment. Using these findings we developed a framework for CT programs with three key pillars for developing self-agency: 1) emotional efficacy, to increase AGYW's perception of rewards associated with developing self-agency; 2) social efficacy, to build constructive relationships and exit negative relationships that inhibit self-agency, and 3) economic efficacy, to help AGYW build a resilient stream of financial resources.
BACKGROUND: Transactional sexual relationships contribute to a high incidence of HIV infection among adolescent girls and young women (AGYW) living in low-resource settings. Cash transfers (CT) are a structural approach to reduce sexual risk behaviors, but their positive economic effects frequently fade after the program ends. We aimed to understand AGYW's decision-making processes related to sexual, relationship, and financial decisions, in order to design a framework for a CT program that could lead to long-term financial independence and reduced transactional sex among AGYW. METHODS: We conducted qualitative research with AGYW participating in a CT program in Tanzania. Phase one was formative research to understand the context and experiences of AGYW regarding sexual behavior, relationships, and finances. Participants included 36 AGYW (15-23 years old), 15 influencers of AGYW (mothers and male partners) and 10 financially empowered women (FEW - women aged 20-30 with a sustained, reliable source of income independent of their partner). Decisions and decision-making contexts of AGYW that we identified in phase one informed the content of phase two. In phase two we simulated scenarios for decision-making and economic goals with 80 AGYW and 40 FEW, in order to identify key principles or intervention opportunities to guide development of a CT program framework. RESULTS: Through phases one and two of our research we identified three key themes in AGYW's vision of their desired future economic state: 1) positive social image, 2) power balance and respect, and 3) emotional and economic security. An important theme distinguishing AGYW from FEW was that AGYW lacked a vision to build self-agency. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that providing economic resources to AGYW through CT without ensuring self-agency is unlikely to be an effective long-term intervention for economic empowerment. Using these findings we developed a framework for CT programs with three key pillars for developing self-agency: 1) emotional efficacy, to increase AGYW's perception of rewards associated with developing self-agency; 2) social efficacy, to build constructive relationships and exit negative relationships that inhibit self-agency, and 3) economic efficacy, to help AGYW build a resilient stream of financial resources.
Entities:
Keywords:
AGYW; Adolescent girls; Cash transfer; Economic empowerment; Self-agency; Sexual risk; Young women