Is Experience in Hemodialysis Cannulation Related to Expertise? A Metrics-based Investigation for Skills Assessment.

Cannulation is not only one of the most common medical procedures but also fraught with complications. The skill of the clinician performing cannulation directly impacts cannulation outcomes. However, current methods of teaching this skill are deficient, relying on subjective demonstrations and unrealistic manikins that have limited utility for skills training. Furthermore, of the factors that hinders effective continuing medical education is the assumption that clinical experience results in expertise. In this work, we examine if objective metrics acquired from a novel cannulation simulator are able to distinguish between experienced clinicians and established experts, enabling the measurement of true expertise. Twenty-two healthcare professionals, who practiced cannulation with varying experience, performed a simulated arteriovenous fistula cannulation task on the simulator. Four clinicians were peer-identified as experts while the others were designated to the experienced group. The simulator tracked the motion of the needle (via an electromagnetic sensor), rendered blood flashback function (via an infrared light sensor), and recorded pinch forces exerted on the needle (via force sensing elements). Metrics were computed based on motion, force, and other sensor data. Results indicated that, with near 80% of accuracy using both logistic regression and linear discriminant analysis, the objective metrics differentiated between experts and the experienced, including identifying needle motion and finger force as two prominent features that distinguished between the groups. Furthermore, results indicated that expertise was not correlated with years of experience, validating the central hypothesis of the study. These insights contribute to structured and standardized medical skills training by enabling a meaningful definition of expertise and could potentially lead to more effective skills training methods.