| Literature DB >> 33411143 |
Shahna Tariq1, Charmaine Van Eeden1, Jan Willem Cohen Tervaert1, Mohammed S Osman2.
Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in widespread hospitalisations and deaths around the world. As patients with rheumatic diseases generally have increased risk of infections and complications, understandably, there is significant concern of the impact of SARS-CoV-2 on these patients. However, there is a paucity of data in rheumatic patients. We review mechanisms through which SARS-CoV-2 results in infection, including ACE2 receptor, and complications (including immune dysregulation, thrombosis and complement activation). We assess these pathways in patients with rheumatic disease and those on immune modulating therapy. Although data thus far does not appear to show worse outcomes in rheumatic patients as a whole, given alterations in the underlying immune pathways in certain diseases (such as systemic lupus erythematosus), we posit that the risk is not equal in all rheumatic patients. We also discuss the benefit of underlying disease control with respect to COVID-19 risk reduction and potential increased risk of disease flares following viral infection from an immune standpoint.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 33411143 PMCID: PMC7788381 DOI: 10.1007/s10067-020-05529-y
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clin Rheumatol ISSN: 0770-3198 Impact factor: 2.980
Fig. 1a SARS-CoV-2 directly suppressed NK cell function through binding of ACE2 receptors on the cell surface. This reduces NK cell ability to kill both viral-infected cells and activated immune cells, increasing the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines and contributing to the development of hyper-inflammation. b Similarly, in rheumatic diseases, dysfunctional NK cells are not effective at clearing the immune cells which are activated by the binding of an unknown antigen (via an antigen presenting cell) to a naive T cell. Downstream, this leads to production of pro-inflammatory cytokines, which ultimately lead to organ damage
Summary of select published studies assessing SARS-CoV-2 infection in patients with rheumatic diseases
| Reference | Jurisdiction | Study type | Patient population | Outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avouac, et al 2020 [ | France/Italy | Case series | 3 patients with SSc on rituximab (including 1 with ILD) | Deaths: 0 Mechanical ventilation: 0 At reporting, 1 patient discharged, 2 on general ward All patients had complete B cell depletion |
| Favalli, Monti, et al, 2020 [ | Italy | Retrospective cohort (survey) | Baseline: 955 patients on bDMARD or tsDMARD 6 confirmed cases (3 RA, 2 SpA, 1 sarcoidosis; 5 TNF-i, 1 abatacept) 144 suspected cases | Confirmed cases: 3 Hospitalisations (supplemental oxygen): Deaths: 0 Mechanical ventilation: 0 Suspected cases: Deaths: 0 Mechanical ventilation: 0 |
| Favalli, Agape, et al, 2020 [ | Italy | Retrospective cohort (survey) | Baseline: 123 patients with CTD. 60% of patients on csDMARDs. Mean steroid dose 5.3 mg daily. bDMARDs: 18 belimumab, 5 rituximab, 2 IL-6 1 confirmed case (SSc with ILD on rituximab + HCQ) 14 suspected cases | Confirmed case: Death: 1 Suspected cases: Deaths: 0 Mechanical ventilations: 0 |
| Fredi et al, 2020 [ | Italy | Retrospective cohort + case-control study (hospitalised COVID-19 with/without COVID-19) | Baseline: 1525 rheumatic patients at single centre 65 confirmed cases: 43 on glucocorticoid (average 35 mg weekly). 27 bDMARDs (including 4 rituximab) 52 suspected cases | Confirmed cases: 72% Hospitalisations. 15% deaths (CV co-morbidities in majority) Deaths: 4% Suspected cases: 0 Case control: No difference in hospitalised patients with COVID19 with and without rheumatic diseases |
| Gianfrancesco et al, 2020 [ | Global | Retrospective cohort | 600 patients from COVID19 Global Rheumatology Alliance physician-reported registry including: rheumatic diseases: 230 RA, 85 SLE, 74 PsA, 48 SpA, 44 vasculitis Medications: 231 on bDMARDs or tsDMARDs; 11 on prednisone > 10 mg/day | Hospitalisations: 46% Deaths: 9% Hospitalisations: -No difference with rheumatic diseases -Increased with co-morbidities (HTN, lung disease, DM, CVD, CKD) -Increased OR with prednisone > 10 mg/day (OR 2.05) -Reduced with TNF-i (OR 0.40) Patients on TNF-I had reduced odds of hospitalisation (OR 0.40) Patients on prednisone > 10 mg/day had increased odds of hospitalisation (OR 2.05) No differences with other medications |
| Gisondi et al, 2020 [ | Italy | Retrospective cohort | Baseline: 5206 patients with PsO on bDMARDs 6 confirmed cases | Hospitalisations: 4 Mechanical ventilation: 1 Death: 0 -3 had co-morbidities (HTN, DM, CKD, obesity) |
| Haberman et al 2020 [ | USA | Case series | 86 patients with immune-mediated inflammatory diseases on therapy | Hospitalisations: 14 ICU: 7 Death: 1 50% hospitalised on bDMARDs/tsDMARDs. 76% ambulatory on bDMARDs/tsDMARDs Hospitalised patients more likely to have co-morbidities (HTN, DM, and obstructive lung disease) |
| Moiseev et al, 2020 [ | Russian Federation | Retrospective cohort | Baseline: 902 patients in ICU with COVID19 10 had rheumatic disease (5 RA, 1 PsA, 1 SpA, 1 SLE, 2SSc) Baseline medications not reported | Deaths: 5 (all had co-morbidities; 2 RA, 1 SpA, 2 SSc) ICU: 3 (all had co-morbidities; 2 RA, 1 SLE) Recoveries: 2 (both had HTN; 1 RA, 1 PsA) |
| Monti et al, 2020 [ | Italy | Retrospective cohort | Baseline: 320 RA/PsA patients on bDMARDs/tsDMARDs 4 confirmed cases 4 suspected cases | Confirmed cases: 1 hospitalisation (supplemental oxygen) Suspected cases: Hospitalisations: 0 Deaths:4 |
| Sanchez-Piedra et al, 2020 [ | Spain | Cohort | Baseline: 6600 rheumatic disease patients on bDMARDs/tsDMARDs in BIOBADASER database41 COVID-19 cases at 15 hospitals in the registry 31 confirmed cases 10 suspected cases | Deaths: 3 ICU: 6 Hospitalisations: 28 Deaths in: 63M RA on anakinra + pred 5 mg/day (smoker, BMI 34.6); 56F SpA on secukinumab (past smoker, BMI 28.4); 91F vasculitis on rituximab + pred 5 mg/day |
| Tomelleri et al, 2020 [ | Italy | Retrospective cohort | Baseline: 162 LVV patients (95 GCA; 67 TA)—medications: steroid, MTX, TNF-i, IL-6, JAKi 4 confirmed cases | Hospitalisations: 2 Deaths: 0 -79M GCA/HTN on prednisone 17.5 mg; 79M GCA/CVD/CKD on pred 7.5 mg |
| Wallace et al, 2020 [ | USA | Cohort | 5 SLE (80% on HCQ) vs. 31 rheumatic patients with COVID-19 | SLE: 80% hospitalised; 60% mechanical ventilation; 20% death Overall cohort: 64% Hospitalised: 19% Mechanical ventilation: 13% Death: 0 |