Macé M Schuurmans1,2, René Hage1,2. 1. University Hospital Zurich, Division of Pulmonology, Raemistrasse 100, 8091 Zurich, Switzerland. 2. University of Zurich, Faculty of Medicine, Raemistrasse 71, 8006 Zurich, Switzerland.
Dear Editor:We would like to congratulate the Spanish group [1], who evaluated several repurposed drugs for coronaviral disease-19 (COVID-19) in their cohort study, whereby they came to a similar conclusion as the SOLIDARITY study of the WHO [2]. Two aspects were different: They did not evaluate remdesivir, but included Cyclosporine A (CsA).None of these drugs reduced mortality significantly, with the exception of CsA, showing a 4-fould decrease in observed mortality in the Spanish study, resulting in an impressive survival curve, significantly different from all other treatments.Treatment with CsA leads to a decrease of hyperinflammation and probably to a decreased viral replication as well [3].Although CsA is a typical immunosuppressive drug in transplant medicine, its use for COVID-19 in immunocompetent patients requires adapted instructions: the study adds clear information on the dosing (cumulative dose at least 300 mg), duration (max 3 weeks) and trough drug level monitoring.Interestingly, the authors mention that CsA use moved swiftly from being a "salvage therapy in refractory cases to initial therapy at triage" based on their experience. Now the evidence for CsA in COVID-19 is clearly stronger than for tacrolimus, the other calcineurin inhibitor. The results from two interventional studies investigating these compounds are pending [4,5].CsA additionally has the advantage of the intravenous application route, which may be crucial in critically illpatients.Two important questions remain: Firstly, when should CsA be given (what disease stage)? Is the effective cumulative dose based on oral or intraveneous administration, since dosing differs by a factor 3?
Authors: Pablo Guisado-Vasco; Sofia Valderas-Ortega; Maria Maravillas Carralón-González; Ana Roda-Santacruz; Lucia González-Cortijo; Gabriel Sotres-Fernández; Eva María Martí-Ballesteros; José Manuel Luque-Pinilla; Elena Almagro-Casado; Félix J La Coma-Lanuza; Ruth Barrena-Puertas; Esteban Javier Malo-Benages; María José Monforte-Gómez; Rocío Diez-Munar; Esther Merino-Lanza; Lorena Comeche-Casanova; Margarita Remirez-de-Esparza-Otero; María Correyero-Plaza; Manuel Recio-Rodríguez; Margarita Rodríguez-López; María Dolores Sánchez-Manzano; Cristina Andreu-Vázquez; Israel John Thuissard-Vasallo; José María Echave-Sustaeta María-Tomé; Daniel Carnevali-Ruiz Journal: EClinicalMedicine Date: 2020-10-15
Authors: Christian A Devaux; Cléa Melenotte; Marie-Dominique Piercecchi-Marti; Clémence Delteil; Didier Raoult Journal: Front Med (Lausanne) Date: 2021-09-06