Marian Loveday1,2, Sindisiwe Hlangu1, Jennifer Furin3. 1. HIV Prevention Research Unit, South African Medical Research Council, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. 2. CAPRISA-MRC HIV-TB Pathogenesis and Treatment Research Unit, Doris Duke Medical Research Institute, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa. 3. Department of Global Health and Social Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: There are few data on the on the care experiences of pregnant women with rifampicin-resistant TB. OBJECTIVE: To describe the treatment journeys of pregnant women with RR-TB-including how their care experiences shape their identities-and identify areas in which tailored interventions are needed. METHODS: In this qualitative study in-depth interviews were conducted among a convenience sample from a population of pregnant women receiving treatment for RR-TB. This paper follows COREQ guidelines. A thematic network analysis using an inductive approach was performed to analyze the interview transcripts and notes. The analysis was iterative and a coding system developed which focused on the care experiences of the women and how these experiences affected their perceptions of themselves, their children, and the health care system in which treatment was received. RESULTS: Seventeen women were interviewed. The women described multiple challenges in their treatment journeys which required them to demonstrate sustained resilience (i.e. to "be brave"). Care experiences required them to negotiate seemingly contradictory identities as both new mothers-"givers of life"-and RR-TB patients facing a complicated and potentially deadly disease. In terms of their "pregnancy identity" and "RR-TB patient identity" that emerged as part of their care experiences, four key themes were identified that appeared to have elements that were contradictory to one another (contradictory areas). These included: 1) the experience of physical symptoms or changes; 2) the experience of the "mothering" and "patient" roles; 3) the experience of the care they received for their pregnancy and their RR-TB; and 4) the experience of community engagement. There were also three areas that overlapped with both roles and during which identity was negotiated/reinforced and they included: 1) faith; 2) socioeconomic issues; and 3) long-term concerns over the child's health. At times, the health care system exacerbated these challenges as the women were not given the support they needed by health care providers who were ill-informed or angry and treated the women in a discriminatory fashion. Left to negotiate this confusing time period, the women turned to faith, their own mothers, and the fathers of their unborn children. CONCLUSION: The care experiences of the women who participated in this study highlight several gaps in the current health care system that must be better addressed in both TB and perinatal services in order to improve the therapeutic journeys for pregnant women with RR-TB and their children. Suggestions for optimizing care include the provision of integrated services, including specialized counseling as well as training for health care providers; engagement of peer support networks; provision of socioeconomic support; long-term medical care/follow-up for children born to women who were treated for RR-TB; and inclusion of faith-based services in the provision of care.
BACKGROUND: There are few data on the on the care experiences of pregnant women with rifampicin-resistant TB. OBJECTIVE: To describe the treatment journeys of pregnant women with RR-TB-including how their care experiences shape their identities-and identify areas in which tailored interventions are needed. METHODS: In this qualitative study in-depth interviews were conducted among a convenience sample from a population of pregnant women receiving treatment for RR-TB. This paper follows COREQ guidelines. A thematic network analysis using an inductive approach was performed to analyze the interview transcripts and notes. The analysis was iterative and a coding system developed which focused on the care experiences of the women and how these experiences affected their perceptions of themselves, their children, and the health care system in which treatment was received. RESULTS: Seventeen women were interviewed. The women described multiple challenges in their treatment journeys which required them to demonstrate sustained resilience (i.e. to "be brave"). Care experiences required them to negotiate seemingly contradictory identities as both new mothers-"givers of life"-and RR-TBpatients facing a complicated and potentially deadly disease. In terms of their "pregnancy identity" and "RR-TBpatient identity" that emerged as part of their care experiences, four key themes were identified that appeared to have elements that were contradictory to one another (contradictory areas). These included: 1) the experience of physical symptoms or changes; 2) the experience of the "mothering" and "patient" roles; 3) the experience of the care they received for their pregnancy and their RR-TB; and 4) the experience of community engagement. There were also three areas that overlapped with both roles and during which identity was negotiated/reinforced and they included: 1) faith; 2) socioeconomic issues; and 3) long-term concerns over the child's health. At times, the health care system exacerbated these challenges as the women were not given the support they needed by health care providers who were ill-informed or angry and treated the women in a discriminatory fashion. Left to negotiate this confusing time period, the women turned to faith, their own mothers, and the fathers of their unborn children. CONCLUSION: The care experiences of the women who participated in this study highlight several gaps in the current health care system that must be better addressed in both TB and perinatal services in order to improve the therapeutic journeys for pregnant women with RR-TB and their children. Suggestions for optimizing care include the provision of integrated services, including specialized counseling as well as training for health care providers; engagement of peer support networks; provision of socioeconomic support; long-term medical care/follow-up for children born to women who were treated for RR-TB; and inclusion of faith-based services in the provision of care.
Authors: Nafees Ahmad; Shama D Ahuja; Onno W Akkerman; Jan-Willem C Alffenaar; Laura F Anderson; Parvaneh Baghaei; Didi Bang; Pennan M Barry; Mayara L Bastos; Digamber Behera; Andrea Benedetti; Gregory P Bisson; Martin J Boeree; Maryline Bonnet; Sarah K Brode; James C M Brust; Ying Cai; Eric Caumes; J Peter Cegielski; Rosella Centis; Pei-Chun Chan; Edward D Chan; Kwok-Chiu Chang; Macarthur Charles; Andra Cirule; Margareth Pretti Dalcolmo; Lia D'Ambrosio; Gerard de Vries; Keertan Dheda; Aliasgar Esmail; Jennifer Flood; Gregory J Fox; Mathilde Fréchet-Jachym; Geisa Fregona; Regina Gayoso; Medea Gegia; Maria Tarcela Gler; Sue Gu; Lorenzo Guglielmetti; Timothy H Holtz; Jennifer Hughes; Petros Isaakidis; Leah Jarlsberg; Russell R Kempker; Salmaan Keshavjee; Faiz Ahmad Khan; Maia Kipiani; Serena P Koenig; Won-Jung Koh; Afranio Kritski; Liga Kuksa; Charlotte L Kvasnovsky; Nakwon Kwak; Zhiyi Lan; Christoph Lange; Rafael Laniado-Laborín; Myungsun Lee; Vaira Leimane; Chi-Chiu Leung; Eric Chung-Ching Leung; Pei Zhi Li; Phil Lowenthal; Ethel L Maciel; Suzanne M Marks; Sundari Mase; Lawrence Mbuagbaw; Giovanni B Migliori; Vladimir Milanov; Ann C Miller; Carole D Mitnick; Chawangwa Modongo; Erika Mohr; Ignacio Monedero; Payam Nahid; Norbert Ndjeka; Max R O'Donnell; Nesri Padayatchi; Domingo Palmero; Jean William Pape; Laura J Podewils; Ian Reynolds; Vija Riekstina; Jérôme Robert; Maria Rodriguez; Barbara Seaworth; Kwonjune J Seung; Kathryn Schnippel; Tae Sun Shim; Rupak Singla; Sarah E Smith; Giovanni Sotgiu; Ganzaya Sukhbaatar; Payam Tabarsi; Simon Tiberi; Anete Trajman; Lisa Trieu; Zarir F Udwadia; Tjip S van der Werf; Nicolas Veziris; Piret Viiklepp; Stalz Charles Vilbrun; Kathleen Walsh; Janice Westenhouse; Wing-Wai Yew; Jae-Joon Yim; Nicola M Zetola; Matteo Zignol; Dick Menzies Journal: Lancet Date: 2018-09-08 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Adriana Hepner; Daniel Negrini; Eliane Azeka Hase; Pedro Exman; Laura Testa; Angela F Trinconi; Jose Roberto Filassi; Rossana Pulcineli Vieira Francisco; Marcelo Zugaib; Tracey L O'Connor; Michael Gary Martin Journal: World J Oncol Date: 2019-02-26