Dominika Benkowska-Biernacka1, Ivan I Smalyukh2, Katarzyna Matczyszyn1. 1. Advanced Materials Engineering and Modelling Group, Faculty of Chemistry, Wroclaw University of Science and Technology, Wyb. Wyspianskiego 27, 50-370 Wroclaw, Poland. 2. Department of Physics and Materials Science and Engineering Program, University of Colorado Boulder, Boulder, Colorado 80309, United States.
Abstract
Lyotropic myelin figures (MFs), i.e., long cylindrical structures formed by certain surfactants, owe their name to their resemblance to the biological membrane that covers nerve fibers. Herein, we used a strong bilayer-forming zwitterionic phospholipid stained by the Nile Red dye to study lamellar mesophases. Polarized optical microscopy and fluorescence confocal microscopy allowed us to investigate the morphology of myelin structures and determine the orientational order of amphiphilic molecules. The cross-sectional views reveal significant differences in the configurations of MFs within the liquid crystalline cell, as well as the details of a spontaneous and stimulated formation of branched lipid tubes. Our results provide insights into small-scale morphology and out-of-equilibrium structural changes in the multilamellar structures.
Lyotropic myelin figures (MFs), i.e., long cylindrical structures formed by certain surfactants, owe their name to their resemblance to the biological membrane that covers nerve fibers. Herein, we used a strong bilayer-forming zwitterionic phospholipid stained by the Nile Red dye to study lamellar mesophases. Polarized optical microscopy and fluorescence confocal microscopy allowed us to investigate the morphology of myelin structures and determine the orientational order of amphiphilic molecules. The cross-sectional views reveal significant differences in the configurations of MFs within the liquid crystalline cell, as well as the details of a spontaneous and stimulated formation of branched lipid tubes. Our results provide insights into small-scale morphology and out-of-equilibrium structural changes in the multilamellar structures.
There
has been a growing interest in the studies of lyotropic liquid
crystals (LLC) due to their essential role in diverse biological systems.[1−5] The well-known example of an LLC is myelin sheath, which is responsible
for the efficient propagation of action potential between neurons.
This structure is mainly composed of lipids that form stacked bilayers
in an aqueous medium.[6] The natural myelin
shows birefringence that is caused by the alignment of its amphiphilic
molecules, among which phospholipids constitute about 40%.[7] Since myelin is related to the most prevalent
autoimmune disease that affects the human brain and the spinal cord,[8] a possibility to mimic self-organization of this
membrane is crucial for better understanding of lipid behavior in
the lamellar phase and its biological significance.Myelin was
observed under polarized light microscope as elongated
cylindrical tubules by Virchow for the first time as early as in 1854[9] and numerous investigations on artificial analogs
of this structure were conducted since then, but there is still a
lack of comprehensive and universally accepted knowledge about the
formation of myelin structure. So far, there are several models to
explain the origin of the growth mechanism of myelin tubes. For example,
using tracking particles, Buchman confirmed that formation of a multi-bilayered
tubule is caused by swelling rather than by diffusion process.[10] Tayebi et al. indicated that myelin growth occurs
due to the presence of a driving force which is the humidity gradient.[11] According to Zou, the formation of myelin figures
(MFs) might be also attributed to shear stress.[12] Moreover, microstructures consisting of multilamellar tubules
are strongly influenced by many factors, including humidity, temperature,[11] pH,[13] and magnetic[14] and electric fields.[15] It was also shown that the morphology of MFs might be influenced
by the contact between a surfactant and a substrate. Tubes formed
from the pinned and the unpinned regions of the same sample exhibit
differences in the core-to-wall thickness ratio, which is related
to distinct membrane tensions.[16,17]Typical MFs are
formed by lyotropic lamellar mesophases, for instance,
ones built of lipids[18,19] and ionic[20] or nonionic[21] surfactants in
aqueous solution; however, MFs were also observed in systems with
thermotropic smectic-A phase of liquid crystals.[22] Here, we used phospholipids, which can self-organize into
bilayers owing to their cylindrical geometry[23] (Figure ). While
a significant amount of research has been conducted to study multilamellar
lipid tubes by fluorescence microscopy,[16,24] surprisingly
little attention has been paid to the examination of different structural
morphologies of MF by confocal fluorescence microscopy, which offers
a powerful tool to image cross-sectional views with diffraction-limited
resolution also along the microscope’s axis.
Figure 1
Schematic illustration
of phospholipid bilayers (LB) separated
by the water layer (WL) stained by Nile Red and (right) the multilamellar
tube composed of stacked bilayers with the core of water (C). T denotes the thickness of the tube. (The dimensions are
not to scale.).
Schematic illustration
of phospholipid bilayers (LB) separated
by the water layer (WL) stained by Nile Red and (right) the multilamellar
tube composed of stacked bilayers with the core of water (C). T denotes the thickness of the tube. (The dimensions are
not to scale.).In the present article, we examine
the liquid crystalline phase
of MFs under a polarized light microscope equipped with a heating
stage. According to the contact method, microstructures consisting
of various forms of multilamellar tubules (e.g., looped and oval structures)
were fabricated by hydration of dried film made of phosphatidylcholines.
Most importantly, we show the first reported observation of the spontaneous
formation of side myelin structure in which the diameter and length
are significantly smaller than in a primary myelin tube. The morphology
of complicated forms of multilayered structures was studied by confocal
fluorescence microscopy. The Nile Red dye, which spontaneously self-aligns
along hydrocarbon chains of phospholipids, was used as a strongly
fluorescent probe of orientational order in the presence of lipid-rich
environment.[25,26]
Experimental Section
Materials
1,2-Dilauroyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine
(DLPC) that was used for this study was purchased Avanti Polar Lipids.
The phospholipid was dissolved in chloroform (purity >99%). 9-Diethylamino-5H-benzo[α]phenoxazine-5-one
(Nile Red), which was applied as a fluorescence dye, was purchased
from Biotium. All of these chemicals were used without further purification.
Sample Preparation
First, 0.3 mM solution of lipid
coloring agent was prepared by dissolving Nile Red in chloroform.
Then, the lipid solution was prepared by vigorous mixing of the defined
amount of DLPC with Nile Red stock solution (final concentration,
60 mg/mL). A drop of lipid solution (1 μL) was placed on microscope
glass and kept overnight to enable the evaporation of the solvent.
Further, the plaque of lipids was sandwiched between a glass substrate
and a coverslip fixed with a 30 μm spacing. After cell preparation,
Milli-Q water was injected into the lipids by capillary flow at room
temperature. Next, bilayers of amphiphilic molecules separated by
a water layer started to self-organize into elongated structures starting
from the dried lipid aggregates–water interface. Finally, the
edges of the sample were protected by epoxy glue against fast solvent
evaporation.
Myelin Figure Characterization
Polarized
light microscopy
was used to directly visualize myelin tubes. Images were taken by
an Olympus BX60 optical microscope with and without a 530 nm retardation
plate. The microscope was equipped with a temperature-controlled Linkam
LTS120 stage. The morphology of myelin tubes was determined by confocal
fluorescence microscopy. These studies were carried out using an Olympus
FV3000RS confocal microscope equipped with a 60× oil immersion
objective. A 561 nm laser was used as the fluorescence excitation
source. The fluorescence emission was recorded in the spectral region
from 580 to 655 nm. Scans along the z-axis were performed
using a stepper motor by adjusting the focal plane position within
the sample with a depth interval of 0.3 μm. Image analysis was
performed using the Olympus Fluoview software. The orientation of
phospholipids stained by anisotropic NR molecules in lamellar mesophase
was investigated by fluorescence confocal polarizing microscopy.[27] The observations were performed using an Olympus
IX81 inverted microscope equipped with a 100× oil immersion objective.
The incident excitation laser beam (488 nm Ar laser) was linearly
polarized, with its polarization controlled using a half-wave plate.
The emitted signal was epi-collected with the same objective in the
range from 560 to 600 nm selected by optical filters, with the
linear polarization direction in the detection channel matching that
of the excitation light.
Results and Discussion
In all experiments,
myelin structures were obtained from phospholipids
doped with Nile Red using the contact experiment. As a consequence
of the preparation method, spontaneous growth of MFs was directed
toward the aqueous phase from the DPLC–water interface (Figure a). Considering the
growth rate within the first minute of hydration, the growth process
is divided into three regimes.[18]
Figure 2
(a) Bright-field
image of (II) multilamellar phase formation from
(I) the lipid reservoir. The corresponding polarized light microscopy
images of myelin figures were taken (b) without and (c) with a retardation
plate. The arrows indicate the orientations of crossed polarizers
(white double arrows) and the full-wavelength retardation plate’s
slow axis (blue double arrow). (d) Confocal fluorescent image of myelin
figures stained by Nile Red. The vertical and horizontal lines indicate
spatial locations at which the cross-sectional confocal views of myelin
tubes were obtained (displayed on the right-hand side and below the
plan view, respectively). Fluorescent images of “hollow”
and “solid” cross-sectional views are marked with “A”
and “B”, respectively. The scale bars are (a) 50 μm
and (b–d) 25 μm.
(a) Bright-field
image of (II) multilamellar phase formation from
(I) the lipid reservoir. The corresponding polarized light microscopy
images of myelin figures were taken (b) without and (c) with a retardation
plate. The arrows indicate the orientations of crossed polarizers
(white double arrows) and the full-wavelength retardation plate’s
slow axis (blue double arrow). (d) Confocal fluorescent image of myelin
figures stained by Nile Red. The vertical and horizontal lines indicate
spatial locations at which the cross-sectional confocal views of myelin
tubes were obtained (displayed on the right-hand side and below the
plan view, respectively). Fluorescent images of “hollow”
and “solid” cross-sectional views are marked with “A”
and “B”, respectively. The scale bars are (a) 50 μm
and (b–d) 25 μm.It was shown that tubes with various diameters quickly increase
in length, while maintaining a constant width of a few microns (Figures S1 and S2). After the first minute of
rapid growth, further growth is substantially slower and enables formation
of different types of multilayered microstructures.[28] Due to the strongly responsive behavior, the samples with
lyotropic lamellar phases were sensitive to external factors, such
as change of position and temperature. However, they can be clearly
observed under a polarized light microscope from several hours to
2–3 days under constant conditions.Different structural
morphologies of multilamellar tubes can be
observed under crossed polarizers (Figure b). To determine the orientation of lipids
in bilayer membrane, an additional full-wave retardation plate (530
nm) was used.[29]Figure c depicts interference colors indicating
alignment of amphiphilic molecules in multilamellar structure. The
blue second-order interference color shows regions where lipids are
oriented along the slow axis of the full retardation plate, whereas
the yellow first-order interference color marks places where the lipid
orientations within the lamellar phase are at 90° relative to
the waveplate’s slow axis.To investigate the three-dimensional
morphology of the obtained
microstructures, confocal fluorescence microscopy was used. Figure d represents the
fluorescent image of different types of lipid tubes formed 15 min
after the sample cell preparation. Consistent with a previous report,[16] we observe MFs with and without an explicit
core that are named hollow and solid tubes, respectively. The solid
cross-sectional view is noted in tubes growing from the lipid reservoir,
while the explicit water core is present in tubes forming from the
multilamellar regions. During the growth process, some tubes start
to coil.[30] We observed that the looped
structures are formed by the solid tubes, which are characterized
by higher membrane tension compared to hollow tubes. These outcomes
are pursuant to the theory of myelin coiling,[31] suggesting that multilamellar tubes characterized by substantial
membrane tension are more prone to be twisted.The orientational
ordering of phospholipids was also verified by
fluorescence confocal polarizing microscopy. In this work, DLPC was
stained by NR molecules that self-align parallel to the hydrophobic
tails of phospholipids. Therefore, by detecting the intensity of fluorescence
emitted by NR for the given polarization direction of the incident
laser beam, the orientation of DLPC could be determined. As illustrated
in Figure a–c,
the regions where the long axes of amphiphilic molecules are parallel
to the laser beam polarization manifest themselves as the brightest
part of the myelin tube. The lower-intensity regions correspond to
lipid and dye molecules oriented with a certain deviation from the
direction of the probing light’s polarization, whereas the
regions with molecules oriented orthogonally to the incident light
were observed as the darkest part of the imaged cylindrical structure.
Since Nile Red is a hydrophobic molecule, consequently, the water
core running inside the myelin tube is clearly separated from the
walls composed of stained lipid bilayers. It is important to note
that these results are in good agreement with the findings obtained
by polarized light microscope equipped with the retardation plate.
Figure 3
Fluorescent
confocal polarizing images of the myelin tube labeled
with Nile Red. The white double arrows indicate the polarization of
the probing light used for the FCPM imaging. The scale bars are 10
μm.
Fluorescent
confocal polarizing images of the myelin tube labeled
with Nile Red. The white double arrows indicate the polarization of
the probing light used for the FCPM imaging. The scale bars are 10
μm.Several MFs took an oval form
at the end of tube. In contrast to
well-ordered lamellar rings obtained via the drying droplet experiment,[12,32] the myelin-like microstructures prepared by the contact experiment
could be easily observed under a polarized light microscope (Figure b,c) due to a greater
thickness of walls forming the tubes.
Figure 4
(a) Bright-field image and the corresponding
polarizing light microscopy
images of the myelin figure obtained (b) without and (c) with a retardation
plate. The arrows indicate the orientations of crossed polarizers
(white double arrows) and the full-wavelength retardation plate’s
slow axis (blue double arrow). (d,e) Fluorescent images of myelin
figures ended with an oval shape with (A, B) cross-sectional views.
(f) Z-projection of the myelin figure corresponding
to (e). The white frame limits the field of view. The scale bars are
15 μm (a–c) and 25 μm (d, e).
(a) Bright-field image and the corresponding
polarizing light microscopy
images of the myelin figure obtained (b) without and (c) with a retardation
plate. The arrows indicate the orientations of crossed polarizers
(white double arrows) and the full-wavelength retardation plate’s
slow axis (blue double arrow). (d,e) Fluorescent images of myelin
figures ended with an oval shape with (A, B) cross-sectional views.
(f) Z-projection of the myelin figure corresponding
to (e). The white frame limits the field of view. The scale bars are
15 μm (a–c) and 25 μm (d, e).Subsequently, the sample was imaged by confocal fluorescence microscopy
in two regions to investigate the morphology of myelin tubes ending
exhibiting novel shapes. As illustrated in Figure d, the cross-sectional view (A) shows the
collapsed MF in two directions. Besides, the structure contains the
lipid free volume inside the rounded part of the lamellar phase, while
its opposite walls are almost in contact with each other. This observation
is consistent with the physical phenomena of collapse of thin- and
thick-wall tubes.[12,33] Myelin-like instabilities are
formed by regularly stacked bilayers that can slide with respect to
each other; therefore, the shape of the tube may be modified. Flattening
of the structure results in a reduction of the bending energy on the
planar part, while higher bending energy cost is still localized on
the edges of the oval part.[34] In contrast, Figure e,f shows a multilamellar
structure, which is collapsed in one direction, giving the MF a spoonlike
shape. The cross-sectional view (B) depicts that there is no visible
core within this structure. It is noteworthy to mention that both
MFs (Figure d,e) are
formed from the solid tubes.The following observations at room
temperature showed the local
disorder of lamellar orientation in some MFs. Holes are mainly noted
in the bent regions of the lipid tubes. Importantly, this phenomenon
occurs around 20 min after the step of the rapid growth of elongated
lyotropic structures in systems stained by the fluorescent dye, while
it needs more time to occur in the samples without the dye. Presumably,
the organization of Nile Red molecules along lipid molecules affects
the elastic properties of lamellar phase, facilitating such disrupted
regions. A prior study has shown holes in lipid reservoir;[35] however, we observed a local disorder in some
myelin tubes along their longitudinal axis. Surprisingly, the structural
defects may lead to the formation of additional (hereafter called
side) branched tubules. Both structures differ widely in their origins
and dimensions, as shown in Figure a. First, main myelin tubes are formed at the dried
lipid–water interface, whereas side myelin tubes grow spontaneously
from the defects in stacked lipid bilayers. Besides, the primary myelin
tubes grow faster than secondary myelin tubes, which are formed at
least 20 min after water injection. This observation is in line with
the previous report, which indicated that driving stress such as gradient
of humidity has a significant impact on the rate of the growth.[11] Second, the ratio of diameter of side to primary
elongated structure is about 0.6 (average results out of 20 samples,
measured within 1 h after cell preparation). Moreover, thinner tubules
are characterized by the width-to-length ratio of about 0.4, while
the aspect ratio for main myelin tubes is significantly lower.
Figure 5
(a) Fluorescent
image of myelin figures with side tubes. (b, d)
Bright-field images and (c, e) the corresponding polarizing light
microscopy images taken with a retardation plate at room temperature
after heating to 60 °C at heating rates of (b, c) 1 °C/min
and (d, e) 8 °C/min. The defects in the sample heated with lower
and higher process rates are marked with “A” and “B”,
respectively. The arrows indicate the orientations of crossed polarizers
(white double arrows) and the full-wavelength retardation plate’s
slow axis (blue double arrow). The scale bars are 10 μm.
(a) Fluorescent
image of myelin figures with side tubes. (b, d)
Bright-field images and (c, e) the corresponding polarizing light
microscopy images taken with a retardation plate at room temperature
after heating to 60 °C at heating rates of (b, c) 1 °C/min
and (d, e) 8 °C/min. The defects in the sample heated with lower
and higher process rates are marked with “A” and “B”,
respectively. The arrows indicate the orientations of crossed polarizers
(white double arrows) and the full-wavelength retardation plate’s
slow axis (blue double arrow). The scale bars are 10 μm.Besides experiments at room temperature, we also
investigated the
influence of heating on the MFs. Hence, the liquid crystalline cell
with MFs was heated to 90 °C without notable changes in lamellar
phase (to preclude water boiling, higher temperatures were not examined).
Further experiments were carried out up until 60 °C with distinct
process rates. The first sample was heated at a rate of 1 °C/min,
while the second sample was heated at a rate of 8 °C/min. As
illustrated in Figure b,d, a large number of defects were noted in both samples after cooling
to 20 °C. Interestingly, some short-side structures started to
grow from the holes in multilamellar tubes of the first sample, whereas
defects in the second sample remained unchanged. Besides, the surface
along the edges of the second sample is densely covered with holes,
while defect distribution of the first sample is more dispersed. In
contrast to holes causing formation of side myelin tubes at room temperature,
defects appearing after cooling down from high temperature can be
predicted and limited in size to some extent. The combination of the
heating and cooling processes affects the fluidity of the structure,
indicating the tendency to defect formation. Hypothetically, local
reorganization of phospholipid within the lamellar phase may be explained
by differences in the compositional distribution at distinct temperatures.
Conclusions
We performed a detailed investigation of the various morphologies
of lyotropic MFs. The combination of polarized light and confocal
fluorescence microscopy allowed us to study the structural changes
in lipid tubes. During the formation of lamellar mesophases composed
of zwitterionic phospholipids stained by Nile Red in excess of water,
lipid tubes showed different cross-sectional configurations due to
the region from where they grew. These observations indicated that
the explicit water core is observed only in myelin structures starting
from the preformed multilamellar regions. As a result, we noted that
looped structures growing directly from the lipid reservoir are formed
by the tubes without the explicit internal water channel. Throughout
this study, we also presented cross-sectional views of oval parts
ending chosen lipid tubes. Additionally, we reported a spontaneous
formation of side MFs from local disorder in the lamellar phase. Further
examination showed that the presence of defects along the lipid tubes
could be predicted by carrying out heat treatment. We anticipate that
this work may contribute to the research on models of myelin in the
biological system.
Authors: Louisa Reissig; David J Fairhurst; Jacques Leng; Michael E Cates; Andrew R Mount; Stefan U Egelhaaf Journal: Langmuir Date: 2010-10-05 Impact factor: 3.882
Authors: Younjin Min; Kai Kristiansen; Joan M Boggs; Cynthia Husted; Joseph A Zasadzinski; Jacob Israelachvili Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2009-02-13 Impact factor: 11.205