| Literature DB >> 33344092 |
Aline Bruna M Vaz1, Paula Luize C Fonseca1, Felipe F Silva2, Gabriel Quintanilha-Peixoto2, Inmaculada Sampedro3, Jose A Siles3, Anderson Carmo4, Rodrigo B Kato2, Vasco Azevedo4, Fernanda Badotti5, Juan A Ocampo3, Carlos A Rosa1, Aristóteles Góes-Neto1.
Abstract
The true myrtle, Myrtus communis, is a small perennial evergreen tree that occurs in Europe, Africa, and Asia with a circum-Mediterranean geographic distribution. Unfortunately, the Mediterranean Forests, where M. communis occurs, are critically endangered and are currently restricted to small fragmented areas in protected conservation units. In the present work, we performed, for the first time, a metabarcoding study on the spatial variation of fungal community structure in the foliar endophytome of this endemic plant of the Mediterranean biome, using bipartite network analysis as a model. The local bipartite network of Myrtus communis individuals and their foliar endophytic fungi is very low connected, with low nestedness, and moderately high specialization and modularity. Similar network patterns were also retrieved in both culture-dependent and amplicon metagenomics of foliar endophytes in distinct arboreal hosts in varied biomes. Furthermore, the majority of putative fungal endophytes species were basidiomycete woody saprotrophs of the orders Polyporales, Agaricales, and Hymenochaetales. Altogether, these findings suggest a possible adaptation of these wood-decaying fungi to cope with moisture limitation and spatial scarcity of their primary substrate (dead wood), which are totally consistent with the predictions of the viaphytism hypothesis that wood-decomposing fungi inhabit the internal leaf tissue of forest trees in order to enhance dispersal to substrates on the forest floor, by using leaves as vectors and as refugia, during periods of environmental stress.Entities:
Keywords: Bipartite networks; Community structure; Fungal endophytes; Metabarcoding; Myrtle
Year: 2020 PMID: 33344092 PMCID: PMC7719295 DOI: 10.7717/peerj.10487
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PeerJ ISSN: 2167-8359 Impact factor: 2.984
Summary of the number of reads in the metagenomic pipeline.
| Steps of analysis | Number of reads |
|---|---|
| Merge paired-end sequence | 212,167 |
| Shorten and/or filter the sequences | 33,364 |
| Merge strictly identical sequences | 20,538 |
| Pre-clustering the fasta sequences | 706 |
| Detect chimeras without external references (i.e., de novo) | 706 |
| Detect chimeras present with reference sequences | 599 |
| Extract all non-chimeric, non-singleton sequences, dereplicated (double-check) using Perl | 599 |
| Clustering | 599 |
Figure 1Bipartite ecological network of Myrtus communis individuals and their foliar fungal endophytes.
The bipartite ecological network: green circles (nodes: tree set) represent Myrtus communis individuals (T1-T11) (left), and blue circles (nodes: fungal set) represent putative fungal endophytes species (right). Interacting taxa are linked by lines (links), whose width is proportional to the number of interactions.
Figure 2Adjacency matrix of Myrtus communis individuals and their foliar fungal endophytes.
The adjacency matrix of bipartite ecological network with shading representing number of interactions per link, normalized by z-score.
Putative fungal endophyte species in Myrtus communis individuals.
| Putative Species | Phylum | Subphylum | Class | Order | Family | Genus | % Identity | % Coverage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ascomycota sp. | Ascomycota | Undefined | Undefined | Undefined | Undefined | Undefined | 95.25 | 98 |
| Aurantiporus sp. 1 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Meruliaceae | Aurantiporus | 99.38 | 100 |
| Aurantiporus sp. 2 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Meruliaceae | Aurantiporus | 98.70 | 94 |
| Botryobasidium sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Cantharellales | Botryobasidiaceae | Botryobasidium | 96.90 | 96 |
| Calocera sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Dacrymycetes | Dacrymycetales | Dacrymycetaceae | Calocera | 97.15 | 100 |
| Candida sp. | Ascomycota | Saccharomycotina | Saccharomycetes | Saccharomycetales | Saccharomycetales | Candida | 98.71 | 97 |
| Ceratastomella sp. | Ascomycota | Pezizomycotina | Sordariomycetes | Incertae sedis | Barbatosphaeriaceae | Ceratastomella | 98.17 | 96 |
| Ceratobasidium sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Cantharellales | Ceratobasidiaceae | Ceratobasidium | 99.12 | 94 |
| Chaetothyriales sp. | Ascomycota | Pezizomycotina | Eurotiomycetes | Chaetothyriales | Chaetothyriales | undefined | 92.86 | 93 |
| Dacrymyces sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Dacrymycetes | Dacrymycetales | Dacrymycetaceae | Dacrymyces | 99.66 | 95 |
| Filobasidium sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Tremellomycetes | Filobasidiales | Filobasidiaceae | Filobasidium | 99.73 | 100 |
| Flagelloscypha sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Agaricales | Niaceae | Flagelloscypha | 99.19 | 95 |
| Ganoderma sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Polyporaceae | Ganoderma | 97.78 | 93 |
| Gloeoporus sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Meruliaceae | Gloeoporus | 99.29 | 91 |
| Gymnopilus sp. 1 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Agaricales | Strophariaceae | Gymnopilus | 97.66 | 100 |
| Gymnopilus sp. 2 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Agaricales | Strophariaceae | Gymnopilus | 98.24 | 94 |
| Gymnopilus sp. 3 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Agaricales | Strophariaceae | Gymnopilus | 98.25 | 100 |
| Hymenochaetaceae sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Hymenochaetales | Hymenochaetaceae | undefined | 95.38 | 100 |
| Hymenochaetales sp. 1 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Hymenochaetales | undefined | undefined | 95.67 | 98 |
| Hymenochaetales sp. 2 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Hymenochaetales | undefined | undefined | 90.49 | 96 |
| Hymenochaetales sp. 3 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Hymenochaetales | undefined | undefined | 91.10 | 97 |
| Hymenochaete sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Hymenochaetales | Hymenochaetaceae | Hymenochaete | 99.37 | 97 |
| Hyphoderma sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Meruliaceae | Hyphoderma | 96.95 | 100 |
| Hyphodontia sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Hymenochaetales | Schizoporaceae | Hyphodontia | 99.68 | 96 |
| Malassezia sp. 1 | Basidiomycota | Ustilaginomycotina | Malasseziomycetes | Malasseziales | Malasseziaceae | Malassezia | 99.02 | 100 |
| Naganishia sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Tremellomycetes | Tremellales | Tremellaceae | Naganishia | 99.72 | 100 |
| Neopestalotiopsis sp. | Ascomycota | Pezizomycotina | Sordariomycetes | Xylariales | Amphisphaeriaceae | Neopestalotiopsis | 98.58 | 90 |
| Phragmidium sp. | Basidiomycota | Pucciniomycotina | Pucciniomycetes | Pucciniales | Phragmidiaceae | Phragmidium | 97.08 | 98 |
| Physisporinus sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Meripilaceae | Physisporinus | 98.51 | 100 |
| Polyporaceae sp. 1 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Polyporaceae | undefined | 95.04 | 94 |
| Polyporaceae sp. 2 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Polyporaceae | undefined | 95.29 | 94 |
| Pterulaceae sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Agaricales | Pterulaceae | undefined | 96.17 | 94 |
| Pycnoporus sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Polyporaceae | Pycnoporus | 99.09 | 100 |
| Rhodotorula sp. | Basidiomycota | Pucciniomycotina | Microbotryomycetes | Sporidiobolales | Sporidiobolaceae | Rhodotorula | 99.43 | 100 |
| Spegazzinia sp. | Ascomycota | Pezizomycotina | Dothidiomycetes | Pleosporales | Didymosphaeriaceae | Spegazzinia | 97.56 | 94 |
| Sporobolomyces sp. | Basidiomycota | Pucciniomycotina | Microbotryomycetes | Sporidiobolales | Sporidiobolaceae | Sporobolomyces | 99.12 | 100 |
| Sympodiomycopsis sp. | Basidiomycota | Ustilaginomycotina | Exobasidiomycetes | Microstromatales | Microstromataceae | Sympodiomycopsis | 99.71 | 97 |
| Thelephorales sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Thelephorales | unidentified | unidentified | 93.41 | 100 |
| Trametes sp. 1 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Polyporaceae | Trametes | 98.77 | 100 |
| Trametes sp. 2 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Polyporaceae | Trametes | 99.04 | 96 |
| Trametes sp. 3 | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Polyporaceae | Trametes | 97.84 | 100 |
| Tricholomataceae sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Agaricales | Tricholomataceae | undefined | 85.68 | 94 |
| Trichomerium sp. | Ascomycota | Pezizomycotina | Eurotiomycetes | Chaetothyriales | Trichomeriaceae | Trichomerium | 97.89 | 100 |
| Tyromyces sp. | Basidiomycota | Agaricomycotina | Agaricomycetes | Polyporales | Polyporaceae | Tyromyces | 96.98 | 100 |
Note:
Complete taxonomic classification of putative fungal endophyte species in Myrtus communis individuals and their corresponding percentage coverage and identity.
Types and values of network-level indexes.
| Index | Value |
|---|---|
| Nestedness | 21.5741105 |
| NODF | 29.5555935 |
| Weighted nestedness | 0.42947246 |
| Interaction strength asymmetry | 0.35324107 |
| Mean.number.of.shared.partners.HL | 0.47777778 |
| Mean.number.of.shared.partners.LL | 2.65454545 |
| Weighted.cluster.coefficient.HL | 0.85253503 |
| Weighted.cluster.coefficient.LL | 0.33579411 |
| C.score.LL | 0.39092274 |
Note:
Bold entries represent those indexes most explored in the characterization of the bipartite network.
Types and values of higher trophic level indexes_.
| Taxon | Degree | Normalized | Species | Weighted | Effective | Proportional |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ascomycota | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.006877579 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Aurantiporus sp.1 | 10 | 0.909090909 | 6.000985121 | 0.69445883 | 4.513035865 | 0.705769113 |
| Aurantiporus sp.2 | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.001449275 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Auriculariales | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.005148005 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Botryobasidium | 2 | 0.181818182 | 0.004023278 | 0 | 1.889881575 | 0.295548292 |
| Calocera | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.01029601 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Candida | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.01346046 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Ceratastomella | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.005148005 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Ceratobasidium | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.037016265 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Chaetothyriales | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.084175084 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Dacrymyces | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.013468013 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Filobasidium | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.027510316 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Flagelloscypha | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.044414536 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Ganoderma | 4 | 0.363636364 | 0.067952092 | 0 | 3.044292689 | 0.476080362 |
| Gloeoporus | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.198541784 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Gymnopilus sp.1 | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.012870013 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Gymnopilus sp.2 | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.005148005 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Gymnopilus sp.3 | 2 | 0.181818182 | 0.008843713 | 0 | 1.754765351 | 0.274418201 |
| Hymenochaetaceae sp.1 | 4 | 0.363636364 | 0.021985178 | 0 | 3.147762106 | 0.492261381 |
| Hymenochaetales sp.1 | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.36026936 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Hymenochaetales sp.2 | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.049915872 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Hymenochaetales sp.3 | 2 | 0.181818182 | 0.038151188 | 0 | 1.676575954 | 0.262190587 |
| Hymenochaete | 3 | 0.272727273 | 0.017014422 | 0 | 1.857027729 | 0.290410458 |
| Hyphoderma | 4 | 0.363636364 | 0.19456545 | 0 | 2.410325703 | 0.376937716 |
| Hyphodontia | 2 | 0.181818182 | 0.460574461 | 0.163127913 | 1.136984769 | 0.177806859 |
| Malassezia | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.049518569 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Naganishia | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.083445491 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Neopestalotiopsis | 5 | 0.454545455 | 0.612542425 | 0.100983946 | 2.005328881 | 0.313602468 |
| Phragmidium | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.020100503 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Physisporinus | 2 | 0.181818182 | 0.090150243 | 0 | 1.999269584 | 0.312654887 |
| Polyporaceae sp.1 | 7 | 0.636363636 | 0.244426366 | 0 | 4.9200779 | 0.769424201 |
| Polyporaceae sp.2 | 9 | 0.818181818 | 0.342257352 | 0.041429311 | 6.264598218 | 0.979686415 |
| Pterulaceae | 2 | 0.181818182 | 0.139566226 | 0 | 1.865734575 | 0.291772074 |
| Pycnoporus | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.014442916 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Rhodotorula | 2 | 0.181818182 | 0.322363942 | 0 | 1.064521894 | 0.166474784 |
| Spegazzinia | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.02020202 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Sporobolomyces | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.911764706 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Sympodiomycopsis | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.067340067 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Thelephorales | 3 | 0.272727273 | 0.006123431 | 0 | 2.58640929 | 0.40447447 |
| Trametes sp.1 | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.096466629 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Trametes sp.2 | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.0625 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Trametes sp.3 | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.018508132 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Tricholomataceae | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.002751032 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Trichomerium | 1 | 0.090909091 | 0.072902338 | 0 | 1 | 0.156384557 |
| Tyromyces | 3 | 0.272727273 | 0.132824122 | 0 | 1.858120562 | 0.29058136 |
Types and values of lower trophic level indexes.
| Tree | Degree | Normalized | Species | Weighted | Effective | Proportional |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| T1 | 14 | 0.31111111 | 7.48918425 | 0 | 2.57524028 | 0.368943722 |
| T2 | 3 | 0.06666667 | 1.0355272 | 0 | 1.42560863 | 0.204240884 |
| T3 | 6 | 0.13333333 | 0.9258364 | 0 | 2.53708048 | 0.36347673 |
| T4 | 16 | 0.35555556 | 10.8434777 | 0.15686275 | 6.44529054 | 0.923389362 |
| T5 | 4 | 0.08888889 | 1.23405498 | 0 | 2.89831062 | 0.415228635 |
| T6 | 9 | 0.2 | 4.34350996 | 0.15686275 | 1.4668374 | 0.210147556 |
| T7 | 9 | 0.2 | 6.11079302 | 0.17647059 | 5.34577583 | 0.765866566 |
| T8 | 8 | 0.17777778 | 2.56345887 | 0.23529412 | 2.24831695 | 0.322106807 |
| T9 | 16 | 0.35555556 | 9.09088067 | 0.2745098 | 5.94181194 | 0.851258124 |
| T10 | 3 | 0.06666667 | 0.11981709 | 0 | 1.7172954 | 0.246029608 |
| T11 | 6 | 0.13333333 | 1.24345983 | 0 | 1.86340415 | 0.266961987 |
Ecological guilds of putative fungal endophyte species.
| Putative Species | Trophic Mode | Guild |
|---|---|---|
| Ascomycota sp. | Pathotroph–Saprotroph–Symbiotroph | All possible guilds |
| Aurantiporus sp. 1 | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Aurantiporus sp. 2 | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Botryobasidium sp. | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Calocera sp. | Saprotroph | undefined Saprotroph |
| Candida sp. | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Ceratastomella sp. | Pathotroph–Saprotroph–Symbiotroph | Animal Pathogen-Endosymbiont-undefined Saprotroph |
| Ceratobasidium sp. | Pathotroph | Plant Pathogen |
| Chaetothyriales sp. | Pathotroph–Saprotroph–Symbiotroph | Endomycorrhizal-Plant Pathogen-undefined Saprotroph |
| Dacrymyces sp. | Pathothroph | Endosymbiont-Plant Pathogen-undefined Saprotroph |
| Filobasidium sp. | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Flagelloscypha sp. | Saprotroph | undefined Saprotroph |
| Ganoderma sp. | Saprotroph | undefined Saprotroph |
| Gloeoporus sp. | Pathotroph–Saprotroph | Plant Pathogen-Wood Saprotroph |
| Gymnopilus sp. 1 | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Gymnopilus sp. 2 | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Gymnopilus sp. 3 | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Hymenochaetaceae sp. | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Hymenochaetales sp. 1 | Saprotroph–Symbiotroph | Ectomycorrhizal-Wood Saprotroph |
| Hymenochaetales sp. 2 | Pathotroph–Saprotroph–Symbiotroph | Ectomycorrhizal-Wood Saprotroph-Plant Pathogen |
| Hymenochaetales sp. 3 | Pathotroph–Saprotroph–Symbiotroph | Ectomycorrhizal-Wood Saprotroph-Plant Pathogen |
| Hymenochaete sp. | Pathotroph–Saprotroph–Symbiotroph | Ectomycorrhizal-Wood Saprotroph-Plant Pathogen |
| Hyphoderma sp. | Saprotroph | undefined Saprotroph |
| Hyphodontia sp. | Saprotroph | undefined Saprotroph |
| Malassezia sp. 1 | Saprotroph | undefined Saprotroph |
| Naganishia sp. | Pathotroph–Saprotroph | Animal Pathogen-undefined Saprotroph |
| Neopestalotiopsis sp. | Pathotroph–Saprotroph–Symbiotroph | Animal Pathogen-Endophyte-Epiphyte-undefined Saprotroph |
| Phragmidium sp. | Pathotroph | Plant Pathogen |
| Physisporinus sp. | Saprotroph | undefined Saprotroph |
| Polyporaceae sp. 1 | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Polyporaceae sp. 2 | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Pterulaceae sp. | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Pycnoporus sp. | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Rhodotorula sp. | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Spegazzinia sp. | Pathotroph–Saprotroph | Animal Endosymbiont-Animal Pathogen-Endophyte-Plant Pathogen-undefined Saprotroph |
| Sporobolomyces sp. | Saprotroph | undefined Saprotroph |
| Sympodiomycopsis sp. | Pathotroph–Saprotroph | Fungal Parasite-Litter Saprotroph |
| Thelephorales sp. | Pathotroph | Plant Pathogen |
| Trametes sp. 1 | Symbiotroph–Saprothroph | Ectosymbiont-Wood Saprotroph |
| Trametes sp. 2 | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Trametes sp. 3 | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Tricholomataceae sp. | Saprotroph | Wood Saprotroph |
| Trichomerium sp. | Pathotroph–Symbiotroph | Ectomycorrhizal-Fungal Parasite |
| Tyromyces sp. | Symbiotroph | Endophyte |
Figure 3Trophic modes of putative foliar fungal endophyte species.
Venn diagram representing the joint and disjoint occurrences of putative endophytic fungal species of saprothrophic, pathotrophic and symbiotrophic modes of nutrition in Myrtus communis trees.